 |
|
|
Ancient Etruscans Unlikely Ancestors Of Modern Tuscans, Statistical Testing RevealsFor the first time, Stanford researchers have used novel statistical computer modeling to simulate demographic processes affecting the population of Tuscany over a 2,500-year time span. Rigorous tests used by the researchers have ruled out a genetic link between ancient Etruscans, the early inhabitants of central Italy, and the region's modern day residents. The findings suggest that something either suddenly wiped out the Etruscans or the group represented a social elite that had little in common with the people who became the true ancestors of Tuscans, said Joanna Mountain, assistant professor of anthropological sciences. ''Very often, we assume the most simple explanation for something,'' said Mountain, an expert in anthropological genetics. ''So when you find in a particular location the archeological remains of people, the simplest explanation is that those people are ancestral to whoever is living there now. How often do you get a chance to check that? Very rarely.'' The research advances the field of anthropological genetics by moving beyond simple storytelling about an ancient people to rigorous testing, using genetic data analysis, of a set of anthropological hypotheses, Mountain said. The findings are documented in ''Serial Coalescent Simulations Suggest a Weak Genealogical Relationship Between Etruscans and Modern Tuscans,'' published May 15 in the online version of Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Uma Ramakrishnan, a former Stanford postdoctoral fellow, and Elise M. S. Belle and Guido Barbujani of the University of Ferrara in Italy co-authored the paper with Mountain. As the paper details, previous extensive archeological excavations have established that Etruscan culture existed in central Italy between the eighth and second centuries B.C. Its origins are still controversial: Some ancient historians, including Herodotus (circa 430 B.C.), suggested that the Etruscans came to Italy from Asia Minor. But most modern archaeologists, along with Dionysius of Halicarnassos (circa 100 B.C.), believe that the Etruscan civilization developed locally from the 10th century B.C. Iron Age Villanovan culture. In the second century B.C., the Etruscans were given Roman citizenship, and soon afterward their language disappeared from records, the paper explains. ''The Etruscans seem to be quite different in many ways from other ancient Italians, and archaeological evidence indicates that they spoke a non-Indo-European language,'' Mountain said. ''Because of the cultural and linguistic shifts, scholars see the Etruscans as an enigma.'' The Etruscans are the only preclassical European population to date that has been genetically analyzed, Mountain said. Two years ago, Italian geneticists extracted maternally inherited mitochondrial DNA from the bones of 27 people called Etruscans found in six different necropolises (burial sites) in Tuscany. The female lineage was investigated because, unlike the male Y chromosome, many copies of mitochondrial DNA are found in each cell and thus are easier to extract, Mountain explained. The data represent one of the best collections of ancient human DNA in existence. ''If you get DNA out of one bone, you can try to say something about the past,'' Mountain said. ''But they managed to get DNA out of quite a few bones.'' The DNA of 49 people living in the region today was also sampled. Although data from the two groups revealed several differences, Mountain said, the researchers could not interpret if these were meaningful or significant. ''What we did was address the question: Do the present-day people look like they could be descendents of the Etruscan population?'' The answer surprised Mountain. ''We did the simulation study and there was nothing we could do-we couldn't tweak it enough to get the modern people to look like they descended from the people in the Etruscan burial [sites],'' she said. ''We couldn't make it fit with the simple inheritance direct lineage model.'' The Stanford researchers used recently developed software called ''Serial SimCoal'' to simulate genetic data based on different population scenarios, such as small (25,000 females) or large (300,000 females) populations of constant size, an expanding population, and scenarios involving migration and selection. Despite the range of scenarios created, the scientists could not find a match between the observed archaeological data and the simulations. Christian Anderson, a former Stanford undergraduate, developed the software while working with Elizabeth Hadly, associate professor of biological sciences. She has used the approach to analyze the ancient DNA of small mammals. ''I believe it's the first time it has been used to analyze ancient human DNA,'' Mountain said. ''It's computationally intensive and requires DNA data from many individuals.'' The finding is important because it questions the common assumption that residents of a particular place are descendants of its earlier inhabitants, Mountain said. ''Also, it raises a number of other questions-what happened to the Etruscans?'' she said. ''It's stimulating for archaeologists and other social scientists to look into what might have been the causes of this decline in the population. It may have been quite abrupt. Mostly, it's a matter of guessing.'' According to Mountain, the field of anthropological genetics is replete with such educated guesses. ''There's so much storytelling that goes on in our field where people will see a particular genetic sequence and go, 'Aha! That means these people moved here and there,''' she said. ''I tend to be fairly skeptical and say, 'That's a nice story.' Before [this study] you could tell a number of stories consistent with the data. What we've done is narrowed down these stories, which for me is a really great leap forward.'' Can't find it? Try searching ScienceDaily or the entire web with: |
Science Video News
TipVision host Charlie Stone tips us off to 1080i television with Circuit City expert Brian Travilla > watch video
TipVision host Charlie Stone plays some handheld games with Circuit City expert Brian Travilla > watch video
TipVision host Charlie Stone helps with home theatre with Circuit City expert Les Stockett > watch video
One Biloxi, Mississippi resident fears for the future of his community, on year after Hurricane... > watch video
The Army is reviewing casualty reports on American soldiers killed in Afghanistan, Iraq and... > watch video
A Colorado teacher has been suspended for displaying foreign flags in his classroom. > watch video
Related News Topics> more ...
Related Science Stories> more ...
Related Encyclopedia Articles> more ...
Related Book Reviews
New Fossil Study Rejects "Eve Theory" And Supports Diverse Ancestry Of Modern Humans (January 12, 2001) -- The ancestors of modern humans came from many different regions of the world, not just a single area, according to a University of Michigan study published in the current (Jan. 12) issue of Science. ... > full story Scientists Use DNA Fragments To Trace The Migration Of Modern Humans (May 28, 2003) -- Human beings may have made their first journey out of Africa as recently as 70,000 years ago, according to a new study by geneticists from Stanford University and the Russian Academy of Sciences. ... > full story
Did Early Humans Mate With The Locals? Human Genome Data Cast Doubt On "Replacement Theory" Of Human Evolution (December 26, 2002) -- A new analysis of human genetic history deals a blow to the theory that early people moved out of Africa and completely replaced local populations elsewhere in the world. The findings suggest there ... > full story Earliest European Farmers Left Little Genetic Mark On Modern Europe (November 13, 2005) -- The farmers who brought agriculture to central Europe about 7,500 years ago did not contribute heavily to the genetic makeup of modern Europeans, according to the first detailed analysis of ancient ... > full story
Geography Predicts Human Genetic Diversity (March 17, 2005) -- By analyzing the relationship between the geographic location of current human populations in relation to East Africa and the genetic variability within these populations, researchers have found new ... > full story Human Migration Tracked In Stanford Computer Simulation (January 22, 2004) -- Early humans migrating from Africa carried small genetic differences like so much flotsam in an ocean current. Now researchers at the Stanford University School of Medicine have devised a model for ... > full story Multiregional hypothesis -- The multiregional origin hypothesis of human species holds that some, or all, of the genetic variation between the contemporary human races is attributable to genetic inheritance from either Homo ... > full article Computer simulation -- A computer simulation or a computer model is a computer program that attempts to simulate an abstract model of a particular system. The reliability and the trust people put in computer simulations ... > full article Archaeology -- Archaeology or archeology is the study of human cultures through the recovery, documentation and analysis of material remains and environmental data, including architecture, artifacts, biofacts, ... > full article Genetic drift -- Genetic drift is the term used in population genetics to refer to the statistical drift over time of gene frequencies in a population due to random sampling effects in the formation of successive ... > full article Anthropology -- Anthropology consists of the study of humanity. It is holistic in two senses: it is concerned with all humans at all times and with all dimensions of ... > full article Hominidae -- The hominids are the members of the biological family Hominidae (the great apes), which includes humans, chimpanzees, gorillas, and ... > full article Archaeological field survey -- Archaeological field survey is the methodological process by which archaeologists (often landscape archaeologists) collect information about the location, distribution and organisation of past human ... > full article Human migration -- Human migration denotes any movement by humans from one locality to another, often over long distances or in large groups. Humans are known to have extensively migrated throughout history. This ... > full article The Genographic Project -- The Genographic Project, launched in April 2005, is a five-year genetic anthropology study that aims to map historical human migration patterns by collecting and analyzing DNA samples from over ... > full article Iron Age -- In archaeology, the Iron Age is the stage in the development of any people where the use of iron implements as tools and weapons is prominent. The adoption of this new material coincided with other ... > full article
|
