1. And this will combat the resale how exactly?
I will bring 5 other people to the shop and it's 10 per shop and not to forget shop hopping especially for people who are in metro area such as NY or Chicago...

Sometimes I just don't understand these policies...

Posted at 7:14AM on Oct 27th 2007 by illutionz

2. No cash? Hmmmm, this would be highly illegal here in Australia.

Posted at 7:28AM on Oct 27th 2007 by Mike

3. An easier way would be to sell the phone unlocked at a higher cost and in other countries i.e.. Norway! :D

Posted at 7:57AM on Oct 27th 2007 by Karl Otto Henriksen

4. Yeah, I ran into this the other day. Drove to Buffalo, NY from Toronto to pick up a few phones.. I wasn't going to resell, they were for my family, but the staff at the store were quite rude.

Posted at 8:08AM on Oct 27th 2007 by Ty

5. The only reason for this is that they don't want them to be sold on eBay internationally, because that will spoil the big introduction of the iPhone in other countries, which I guess will happen somewhere in 2008.

Posted at 8:11AM on Oct 27th 2007 by 2shae

6. Is it legal here in the US to refuse to accept the legal tender?

Posted at 8:12AM on Oct 27th 2007 by John Harlow

7. Well, as far as I'm aware...In the UK, you make an offer to purchase an item, and the shop can legally refuse this "offer of purchase". I don't know what it's like in the States though..

Posted at 8:34AM on Oct 27th 2007 by Callum Lawson

8. The apple is getting rotten at the core - it may be legal (I hear in the US it's only debt payment that requires legal tender, not services) but they are definitely becoming even more elitist (as if everyone has credit cards) and alienating more and more customers.

Posted at 8:44AM on Oct 27th 2007 by bugmat

9. Yes, we must prevent people like Steve Wozniak from buying multiple iPhones as gifts.

"Wozniak says he probably purchased about 20 iPhones for himself and his friends and has not gotten a single refund back on his own although some of his friends have gotten their refunds."

http://www.itnews.com.au/News/61818,apple-legend-woz-blasts-iphone-price-drop-and-refund-policy.aspx

Apple is trying to have it both ways. They want to sell at retail, "unsubsidized" and also to get recurring revenue from AT&T.; They should either just stop selling it at Apple stores or have an AT&T; rep in their stores, and in either case, require instant activation like any cellphone.

But refusing cash sounds illegal. My wife gave me $600 cash specifically to buy my iPhone for our anniversary. I happened to choose to use my AmEx card instead, which was a great idea. AmEx refunded me $200+tax after the price drop.

Posted at 8:52AM on Oct 27th 2007 by Todd Bernhard

10. If the Apple stores are refusing cash, it won't be long before someone launches yet another lawsuit against Apple. Even if it is foud to be legal in the US (which I doubt), it will create a lot of bad press for Apple. Is Apple really that stupid? I though Apple was good at PR.

Posted at 8:53AM on Oct 27th 2007 by Rob

11. Looks like it is legal: http://www.treas.gov/education/faq/currency/legal-tender.shtml

Posted at 9:02AM on Oct 27th 2007 by mkorablin

12. Just another step in the direction increasingly totalitarian Apple is heading. They want to control you.

Also to the person who said, "the employees were rude". That's just normal for Apple store employees.

Posted at 9:32AM on Oct 27th 2007 by yacoub

13. But how are drug dealers supposed to buy iPhones now?

Posted at 9:47AM on Oct 27th 2007 by congested

14. a conspiracy with the credit card companies?

Posted at 10:00AM on Oct 27th 2007 by makesense

15. Someone's going to sue just for the purpose of bad PR. Most people would consider it crazy that you can't use cash to buy anything. Just goes to show you that Apple's a puppet to AT&T; and they'll soon become the next Sony.

Posted at 10:02AM on Oct 27th 2007 by dagamer34

16. Apple = the next evil empire

Posted at 10:26AM on Oct 27th 2007 by bugeyedearl

17. This is just beyond retardation. Will they soon expand this to the entire product line? After that, will they just outright refuse U.S. currency and create Apple Money like the MS Points?

Posted at 10:41AM on Oct 27th 2007 by Rubbinz

18. #15 has got it right with the puppet comment.

Jobs must be doing a slow burn.
Obliging ATT on this one like swallowing someone else's bile.

It leaves one wondering:
How much of ATT's stomach acid can he swallow?

We are going to find out.
I suspect Steve is near his meltdown point right now.

But hey...

Make a deal with the devil and you've got to dance when he fiddles.

Posted at 10:51AM on Oct 27th 2007 by koreyel

19. Whilst I'm not going to get into a slagging match about how eeeevul Apple is, I can say that recently they have forgotten their core policies and operate more like Redmond did a few years back.

Firstly we all know that the US telco market is the nastiest little monopoly around, besides AT&T; selling out to the NSA, they also have a pathetic network infrastructure and when countries like Kenya has a far more advanced GSM network, you have to wonder.

What happened to the "Think Different" slogan? Why the hell should I have to pay with my credit card? Cash is cash, who is Apple to determine how I should give them money?

I think we might have reached a turning point. Apple can adopt the nasty policies which alienate the customer base which made them who they are (anyone disagreeing with this, think back to when Apple's share price was a joke) but making the fat corporate cats like AT&T; happy with a mediocre iPhone offering and very damn annoying policies.

Apple, you have a good market share, don't forget how you got there and let's not act like some other hardware companies out there.

Posted at 10:58AM on Oct 27th 2007 by Daniel

20. #13 - "But how are drug dealers supposed to buy iPhones now?"

LOL. Good joke.

But they'll just use prepaid credit cards or debit cards that can't be traced back to a purchaser. The mall that my Apple Store is at sells Amex and other gift cards at a kiosk 100 feet from the Apple Store. Then of course these "drug dealers will just use a prepaid Go Phone sim card.

Apple is becoming ridiculous. This is just like DRM copy protection, software serial licenses, and door locks on glass doors in your home. The only people any of those inconvenience are honest people that you don't need the protection from in the first place. A burglar will smash a window to get in the house, a software pirate will use a keygen programmer, a music sharer will find non-DRM music, and yes, an iPhone reseller will easily find a way around this policy.

Posted at 11:03AM on Oct 27th 2007 by DistortedLoop