Pictures of Whitney and Jay snuggling in NYC made us hope they’d be back on for Season Two. But in a new interview, Jay tells Australia’s Daily Telegraph that the cameras “made things confusing” and he’s not necessarily ready to jump back into a reality TV romance.

“Maybe we would still be together if she wasn’t doing the show, but I wouldn’t go back into a relationship for the sake of being on TV,” he said.

So, is this Jay’s way of letting us know that IF he comes back for Season Two, it’ll be because he loves Whit (and not the attention)? Tell us what you think!