In a lot of ways, Microsoft and Motorola are like the Great Bard's feuding Montagues and Capulets. Things changed early last year, when Motorola sent one of its own to Microsoft in good faith. Microsoft accepted and the future prosperity of both "families" seemed ensured. Things would be good for a time.
But then a little over a year later, there would be tragedy. Microsoft would file not one, but two different lawsuits, the latter being the focal point here: a suit filed in the western district court in Seattle today. It would allege Motorola demanded "royalties that are excessive and discriminatory" regarding its video decoding and wireless LAN tech under the hood of the Xbox 360. That's basically how Romeo & Juliet ends, word for word -- trust us, we just got you an A on that book report.
The story would not continue until Romeo & Juliet 2: QTE Courthouse, where Microsoft and Motorola meet face-to-face to wage battle to the legal death in a quick-time courtroom brawl. Actually, we'll save you the trouble: it's basically a bunch of talking until they ultimately settle their dispute in an ultra-anti-climactic exchange of cash in the back alley.
Reader Comments (27)
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/4053701_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 3:12AM ShadowXIII said
Microsoft casting lawsuit over excessive fees.....
......hmm.
Reply
......hmm.
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/2306404_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 5:07AM sonicspike41 said
@Mmmmz
Personally I'm hoping they win. If they lose and are forced to continue paying the apparently excessive fees then we're likely to see a cost increase somewhere on the consumer side to make up for it.
I don't wanna have to give Microsoft even more money just cause Motorola decided to charge them more.
Reply
Personally I'm hoping they win. If they lose and are forced to continue paying the apparently excessive fees then we're likely to see a cost increase somewhere on the consumer side to make up for it.
I don't wanna have to give Microsoft even more money just cause Motorola decided to charge them more.
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/1879510_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 3:56AM Pure Black World Tendency said
@Mach2 A long nights sleep. So we can be well rested and fight again next day.
Reply
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/3457373_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 11:26AM Mister Darcy said
@Riley Freeman
What, drawn, and talk of peace! I hate the word.
Reply
What, drawn, and talk of peace! I hate the word.
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/2445213_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 3:47AM neoXmahi said
Hm... This is really funny. And actually quite ironic. Really, this makes me laugh. So, what do we as gamers get out of this? Are we getting cheated as well? By Motorola? We deserve compensation. Oh wait! Microsoft overprices and overcharges us for everything. Great move Microsoft. This really puts you up on the pedestal doesn't it?
Reply
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/2431132_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 5:30AM glassfin said
@neoXmahi
conspiracy time: it's about android, say.. android infringes on these video encode&whatever; patents and motorola let's androids go with it since it's motos saving horse. but ms paid for those patents moto is letting others use for free, thus we end up with discrimination against ms by moto.
also quite probably moto has cross license agreements with other players, so they might not be paying cash or at all.
Reply
conspiracy time: it's about android, say.. android infringes on these video encode&whatever; patents and motorola let's androids go with it since it's motos saving horse. but ms paid for those patents moto is letting others use for free, thus we end up with discrimination against ms by moto.
also quite probably moto has cross license agreements with other players, so they might not be paying cash or at all.
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/3584863_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 8:01AM McDuckScrooged said
@glassfin Its all to do with Android..
If you dont succeed sue, its just all such underhanded rubbish tactics. I hope WP7 flops hard.
The really scummy thing is that they try leverage crappy software patents such as syncing to try and make out that the core of Android ie the Kernel ie Linux is infringing their patents, so that they can try and say hey you all should be paying us royalties all of you server owners running Linux, you need to pay us royalties..
Their greed and lies know no bounds...
Reply
If you dont succeed sue, its just all such underhanded rubbish tactics. I hope WP7 flops hard.
The really scummy thing is that they try leverage crappy software patents such as syncing to try and make out that the core of Android ie the Kernel ie Linux is infringing their patents, so that they can try and say hey you all should be paying us royalties all of you server owners running Linux, you need to pay us royalties..
Their greed and lies know no bounds...
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/434187_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 8:34AM Agies said
@McDuckScrooged You have to play ball in the field available. Currently software patents are perfectly valid so the onus is on Microsoft to protect them. It's probably also a combination of software and hardware patents.
They aren't suing over Android, they are suing over Motorola's implementation of Android. If Microsoft was going to sue anyone over just Android they'd sue Google. And if the Linux kernel somehow violated Microsoft patents then they'd move against the major distributors.
For the record Android uses a modified Linux kernel and any suits against Android based on the kernel would probably be based on the modified parts. If there were going to be any suits over Linux they would already have happened since it's no secret as to what is in there.
Reply
They aren't suing over Android, they are suing over Motorola's implementation of Android. If Microsoft was going to sue anyone over just Android they'd sue Google. And if the Linux kernel somehow violated Microsoft patents then they'd move against the major distributors.
For the record Android uses a modified Linux kernel and any suits against Android based on the kernel would probably be based on the modified parts. If there were going to be any suits over Linux they would already have happened since it's no secret as to what is in there.
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/3584863_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 11:28AM McDuckScrooged said
@Agies software patents are a load of rubbish end of. They only exist in the US and are the stupidest idea ever. I am so glad we don't have it here in Europe.
They are suing motorola over rubbish:
"Microsoft has hit up the ITC over a total of nine alleged patent infringements by Motorola in its Android devices, specifically relating to "synchronizing email, calendars and contacts, scheduling meetings, and notifying applications of changes in signal strength and battery power."
Also Microsoft have repeatedly and wrongly claimed Linux infringes on its software patents trying to scare monger people away from Linux and it has nothing to do with Androids fork of the Linux kernel..
They again are trying the same sort of crappy tactics with Android Mobile phone manufacturers, indirectly blaming Linux and indirectly saying its the underlying Linux kernel all the while trying to hide exactly what it is they are licensing out..
http://blogs.computerworld.com/16025/microsoft_marches_on_android_and_linux
http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9005171/Ballmer_Linux_users_owe_Microsoft_
http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/2007/05/28/100033867/index.htm
Reply
They are suing motorola over rubbish:
"Microsoft has hit up the ITC over a total of nine alleged patent infringements by Motorola in its Android devices, specifically relating to "synchronizing email, calendars and contacts, scheduling meetings, and notifying applications of changes in signal strength and battery power."
Also Microsoft have repeatedly and wrongly claimed Linux infringes on its software patents trying to scare monger people away from Linux and it has nothing to do with Androids fork of the Linux kernel..
They again are trying the same sort of crappy tactics with Android Mobile phone manufacturers, indirectly blaming Linux and indirectly saying its the underlying Linux kernel all the while trying to hide exactly what it is they are licensing out..
http://blogs.computerworld.com/16025/microsoft_marches_on_android_and_linux
http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/9005171/Ballmer_Linux_users_owe_Microsoft_
http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/2007/05/28/100033867/index.htm
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/2314307_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 4:56AM SushiGummy said
Oh, the irony. What's next, Zynga suing a company for stealing their game?
Reply
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/4441135_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 7:17AM RastaPanda said
"Motorola demanded "royalties that are excessive and discriminatory" Hmm.. Doesn't this sound a lot like microsoft and their price on their products? lets rephrase this. "Microsoft demands "royalties that aren't excessive and discriminatory to the consumer, KooKooKaChoo"
Reply
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/46646_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 7:34AM Batzarro The worlds WOrst Detect said
"Actually, we'll save you the trouble: it's basically a bunch of talking until they ultimately settle their dispute in an ultra-anti-climactic exchange of cash in the back alley. "
Just like a broken marriage.
Reply
Just like a broken marriage.
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20101111151519im_/http://www.blogsmithcdn.com/avatar/images/11/4465108_50.jpg)
Posted: Nov 10th 2010 8:53AM Jack Kevorkian said
@Batzarro The worlds WOrst Detect you are one dark dude. And I kill people for a living.
Reply
Sorry, you must be logged in to leave a comment.
Featured Stories
The most popular posts
in the last 7 days
- Kinect review: The hardware and experience 262 comments
- Kinect vs. our living rooms: A survey 193 comments
- Activision's Kotick on Brutal Legend drama: 'That's not really what happened' 133 comments
- Killzone 3 has considerably less input lag than its predecessor 128 comments
- Fighters Uncaged unreview: It's unbelievably ungood 117 comments