(Translated by https://www.hiragana.jp/)
CJR Daily: NY Post's Circ Surge: Fuzzy Math or Election Weather Vane?
The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20070205164440/http://www.cjrdaily.org:80/behind_the_news/ny_posts_circ_surge_fraud_aler.php

Search CJR Daily.





Tips & Ideas.

Seen something we should be writing about? Email Us


Most Recent Articles.

Nov. 27, 2006

All About the Benjamins

» K Street Switches Sides -- and the Press Notices

Blog Report

» As Iraq Study Group Meets, Bloggers Uniformly Cynical

Nov. 22, 2006

Cable World, Real World

» More Evidence That Non-Stop News Is Win-Win

Blog Report

» Bloggers Revel in New Legal Immunity

Money Rules

» "Envy Malaise" Grips Awestruck Journalists

Nov. 21, 2006

» CNN Goes Full-Court Press Over a Non-Story


The Archives.


Read CJR.


CJR Cover

Oct. 31, 2006 - 1:14 PM
Blog Report

NY Post's Circ Surge: Fuzzy Math or Election Weather Vane?

When the Audit Bureau of Circulations released the latest circulation figures for U.S. daily newspapers yesterday, a surprising statistic emerged: Rupert Murdoch's New York Post has catapulted in front of the (New York) Daily News in daily circulation while also displacing the Washington Post and jumping to fifth in the rankings of U.S. daily papers.


In light of the news, the Post offers this self-adulation on Page Six: "The New York Post made newspaper history yesterday, leapfrogging the Daily News and The Washington Post to become the fifth-largest paper in the country -- and it's all thanks to you...The new circulation figures...prove what savvy New Yorkers have known for years -- the Daily News is yesterday's news."


"We have created a newspaper with a unique voice that reflects the heart and soul of New York, and today's publisher's statement, which for the first time places us ahead of the Daily News and in the top five newspapers in the country, is a testament to the vitality of the paper and the cherished role it plays in the life of this city," Rupert Murdoch added.


Bloggers' reactions to the Post's victory were mixed.


"When it was announced yesterday that the Post had finally overtaken the News in circulation, we expressed our fervent hopes that the [Post] would celebrate its victory in a gracious, restrained manner; those hopes were quickly dashed," writes Gawker. "Comes today's Post, which, in addition to a two-page opening spread full of charts and graphs and gleeful cackling from Ed Koch, includes a four-page 'souvenir pullout,' featuring some of the paper's finest wood and an embarrassing encomium by Steve Cuozzo which actually compares the Post to the United States during the Cold War and ends with the line, 'The good guys won again.'"


Some were skeptical of circulation fraud.


"The only paper to buck the wave in a remarkable way was the, yes, New York Post," writes Will Divide at Huck and Jim. "So remarkable that I am sure this morning there is at least one fraud prosecutor, maybe a whole office full, interested in looking into practices of a circulation department that has long been suspected of ties to, ahem, certain people. The first thing you need to do when cheating on a test is to make sure you don't do too well. Maybe the loss of revenue after the breakup of the Page Six extortion racket sent Rupe's kids in pursuit of less-than-modest gains elsewhere." Continuing in this vein, Jossip wags a finger at the Daily News' editorial retort: "Why should the Daily News feel like the bastard child of New York when it, too, can spin the numbers in its favor? Mort Zuckerman's daily is playing defense this morning, reminding readers it's still the No. 1 paper in the metro area."


Other bloggers, though, attributed the Post's triumph to its conservative editorial leanings. "I did the research after noticing an anomaly in the data: the conservative New York Post was the only major paper to record any significant rise in circulation this year, and it was quite large," writes Baruk at Iris blog. "I then looked at the trend over a number of years and detected an extraordinary trend: every newspaper consistently lost subscribers, except for four which experienced solid growth. Three of those four are the nation's only conservative dailies, while the fourth is arguably the least partisan paper, USA Today."


Perhaps, according to one blogger, we can extract from all of this a forecast for next week's midterm elections. "The rise in popularity of Rupert Murdoch's New York Post would come as no surprise if the Post were competing somewhere besides the most liberal-oriented news market on the planet," writes Tom Bowler at Libertarian Leanings. "But like Fox News, another Murdoch venture, its conservative stance hasn't hurt the Post at all. In fact it may be the thing that drives those numbers. While pundits and pollsters predict a Democratic takeover in the November, Post circulation numbers suggest something else may be going on. If Republicans hold on in both Houses of Congress or if they make gains, Post circulation will have been the more accurate weather vane."


Post a comment

CJR Daily generally does not edit or remove comments, but we reserve the right to do so if a post is obscene, unlawful, or otherwise contrary to the terms of use set forth in our full legal disclaimer. We also ask users to please keep posts to the topic at hand; those wandering far afield or appearing to be spam may be deleted.


Editor's Picks.

Nov. 22, 2006

"Envy Malaise" Grips Awestruck Journalists

Today we give thanks for something that American journalism is doing well of late: allocating resources to examining jealousy in the economic stratosphere.

Nov. 20, 2006

Kristof Becomes Own Worst Enemy

Responding to an unhappy reader, Nick Kristof lets his fangs show.



Blog Report.

Nov. 27, 2006

As Iraq Study Group Meets, Bloggers Uniformly Cynical

Bloggers of all stripes seemed to come together to express cynicism and unease at the prospects of the commission's upcoming recommendations.

Nov. 22, 2006

Bloggers Revel in New Legal Immunity

A California Supreme Court ruling grants immunity to those who repost defamatory material on the Internet, giving bloggers around the country a sense of both relevance and security.

Nov. 21, 2006

Bloggers Doubt TVNewser's Abilities as Trade Columnist

The New York Times prints a gushy profile of Brian Stelter, and bloggers respond to his success with admiration and jealousy.


The Water Cooler.

Nov. 21, 2006

A Syndicated Column Preaches Beyond the Green Choir

Doug Moss, editor of E -- The Environment Magazine, talks about how to present environmental and scientific issues to the public, and promoting his magazine.


Magazine Report.

Sep. 26, 2006

Sports Illustrated Makes a Big Bet on Fantasy Sports

The venerable sports magazine extends its coverage in order to snare that number-crunching, sports-loving demographic who can't get enough.