(Translated by https://www.hiragana.jp/)
Nomination Process for Expert Consensus Panels
The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20110819013058/http://www.psych.org/MainMenu/PsychiatricPractice/PracticeGuidelines_1/Nomination-Process-for-Expert-Consensus-Panels.aspx

Nomination Process for Expert Consensus Panels

If you have reached this page because you provided nominations for an expert consensus panel, thank you!

The American Psychiatric Association is piloting a new process for development of practice guidelines. Under this new process, expert consensus panels will be formally surveyed about interventions that may be recommended in APA guidelines. Survey data will augment findings from systematic reviews of available published evidence including from clinical trials.

Panels will be composed of two categories of individuals: clinical experts and research/scholarly experts. Both will be peer‐identified through a blind nomination process. Clinical experts are psychiatrists with substantial experience in the clinical care of patients with psychiatric disorders. Research/scholarly experts are individuals who are making substantial contributions with respect to psychiatric research and/or scholarly writing. An individual may be considered expert in both categories.

Nominations for the panels are being collected from three groups: chairs of academic departments of psychiatry, directors of psychiatric residency training programs, and voting members of the APA Assembly. Individuals in each of these groups are invited to nominate anonymously up to 10 clinical experts on specific topics. As needed, the final pool of clinical experts may be screened to obtain a predetermined number for the consensus panel.

In addition to clinical experts, academic chairs are invited to nominate research/scholarly experts on the same topics. By snowball method, other research experts will then be identified, i.e., nominated individuals will be asked to nominate other individuals. As needed, the final pool of research experts may be screened to obtain a predetermined number for the consensus panel.

FAQ

How can I participate in the nomination process?
For this pilot effort, only chairs of academic departments of psychiatry, directors of residency training programs, and voting members of the Assembly may participate.

How can I participate on an expert consensus panel?
You must be nominated as a clinical expert or a research/scholarly expert. In addition, even if you are nominated, you must be selected for a consensus survey. Depending on the number of individuals nominated, selection may be random, or specific criteria may be applied, such as number of nominations received or number of recent publications.

Can I nominate myself?
Although we understand that you may be an expert yourself, self-nomination is not permitted. You may, however, be nominated by a colleague.

Will the individuals I nominate know that I nominated them?
No, APA will keep your nominations anonymous. You may, however, inform individuals yourself that you nominated them.

Where can I find APA practice guidelines?
APA guidelines are published on PsychiatryOnline.com
. Please note that our existing guidelines were developed using a process that did not involve surveys of expert consensus panels.