Schama, Fellowes, and the 'cultural necrophilia' row that would make Lady Grantham grimace
As Downton Abbey takes US TV by storm, its creator is under attack from America's favourite British historian
Wednesday 18 January 2012
Latest in TV & Radio
On Facebook
From the blogs
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20120118173202im_/http://blogs.independent.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/wikipedia-logo-en-big-150x150.png)
The Wikipedia blackout: A reminder we shouldn’t take internet freedom for granted
It’s striking how you can take things for granted online. Since the Wikipedia blackout commenced, I ...
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20120118173202im_/http://blogs.independent.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/135281528-150x150.jpg)
The New Muslim suffragettes of the United Kingdom
An increasing number of Muslim women activists are receiving death threats, fatwas and even hate-mai...
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20120118173202im_/http://blogs.independent.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/afro-acid-live-3-150x150.jpg)
A chat with Acid House pioneer DJ Pierre
I've always been a big fan of Acid House music - it was the soundtrack to the Summer Of Love in 1988...
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20120118173202im_/http://blogs.independent.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/pic21-150x150.jpg)
Atlantic Odyssey: The consequences of going overboard at night don’t bear thinking about
The latest news from the Atlantic Odyssey Challenge in which a team of six men are attempting to bre...
Lord Grantham would describe it as the height of bad manners. American viewers have been urged to reject Downton Abbey's "silvered tureen of snobbery" by Simon Schama, the British history professor whose populist books have made him a New York celebrity.
Schama, professor of history at Columbia University, launched a stinging attack on Julian Fellowes, creator of the hit series, accusing him of peddling derivative plot-lines and historical inaccuracies to a US audience dazzled by anything set in a British country house.
Schama's assault arrived the day after Fellowes claimed a Golden Globe for the series, which has doubled the Sunday night audience for the American PBS channel.
Downton is the most popular British drama running on US television, gaining more than four million viewers, more than for some "prestige" US dramas, such as Mad Men.
After picking up his award, Fellowes said: "It's rather thrilling the way America sticks up for me." But writing in Newsweek, his fellow Brit shattered the consensus. "Downton serves up a steaming, silvered tureen of snobbery," Schama claimed. "It's a servile soap opera that an American public desperate for something, anything, to take its mind off the perplexities of the present, seems only too happy to down in great, grateful gulps."
Schama, who presented his take on the Edwardian era in the BBC series A History Of Britain, added: "Nothing beats British television drama for servicing the instincts of cultural necrophilia. So the series is fabulously frocked, and acted, and overacted, and hyper-overacted by all the Usual Suspects in keeping with their allotted roles."
He went on to admit: "This unassuageable American craving for the British country house is bound to get on my nerves, having grown up in the 1950s and '60s with a Jacobinical rage against the moth-eaten haughtiness of the toffs."
Fellowes, he said, has "gotten this stuff down pat since writing Gosford Park, though all the main plot-lines were anticipated a long time ago by Upstairs, Downstairs".
The dramatist, once described as "the biggest snob in Britain", has dismissed his critics as "socially insecure, left-wing nitpickers". But the influential historian will be tougher to shake.
Both Schama and Fellowes relocated to the US in the early 1980s. Diplomat's son Fellowes pursued his "toff appeal" as an actor, but after a series of roles on stage and screen, he found his true calling as a screenwriter with the film Gosford Park.
Schama became a Harvard professor at 35 and relayed his passion for America through a series of award-winning books and television documentaries. Transferring the accessible prose of books, such as his study of Dutch culture The Embarrassment of Riches, to the screen, he became the highest-paid historian on television. But his current series, The American Future, broadcast on BBC America last night, has yet to match Downton Abbey's popular appeal.
Fellowes, who made no secret of his desire to write more Hollywood scripts, shares Schama's fervour for the US. He recently said: "I suppose I believe in a mobile society, which I think at the moment America has got a better version of than we have." He was unavailable for comment yesterday.
A spokeswoman for Downton Abbey said: "It is a fictional drama series set in a well documented era of recent modern history. It is not a history programme, but a drama of social satire about a time when relationships, behaviour and hierarchy were very different from those we enjoy today. American audiences are presumably enjoying the latest series of Downton for the same reason as British audiences - it is an entertainment with an intertwined mix of romantic, dramatic and comedic stories delivered by a large ensemble of different characters and indeed, as with any popular TV drama series, offers an alternative to our own life experience."
- 1 Why I want to bring down the internet – for a day
- 2 Mark Steel: A new yacht is the least she deserves
- 3 Huaxi: The socialist village where everyone is wealthy
- 4 Tory MPs go to war over gay marriage
- 5 Manchester United: Potential January transfer targets
- 6 So, what have the Scots ever done for us? Just 101 of the innovations Caledonia gave the world
- 7 The dark side of Dubai
- 8 Brian Cox: Stars in his eyes
- 9 Cheese-only restaurant opens in London (just don't expect Cheddar)
- 10 Greek rescue blocked by hedge fund greed
- 1 Greek rescue blocked by hedge fund greed
- 2 Schama, Fellowes, and the 'cultural necrophilia' row that would make Lady Grantham grimace
- 3 So, what have the Scots ever done for us? Just 101 of the innovations Caledonia gave the world
- 4 Kim Jong-un won't last, says his brother
- 5 Huaxi: The socialist village where everyone is wealthy
- 6 View from the bridge: the inside story of Italy's cruise disaster
- 7 Rafael Seligmann: 'I didn't want Hitler to have the last word'
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20120118173202im_/http://www.independent.co.uk/incoming/article6280633.ece/ALTERNATES/w300/sponsored-features-canary.jpg)
Win a Canary Island Holiday
Win a seven-night holiday for two adults to two of the Canary Islands.
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20120118173202im_/http://www.independent.co.uk/incoming/article6289125.ece/ALTERNATES/w300/atca-spons.jpg)
Win a three-week coastal jaunt
Spend three weeks exploring every nook and cranny of gorgeous Atlantic Canada.
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20120118173202im_/http://www.independent.co.uk/incoming/article6285180.ece/ALTERNATES/w300/sponsor-featured.jpg)
Win a home cinema system
Win a 40" 3D TV with a Blu-ray home cinema system to boot!
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20120118173202im_/http://www.independent.co.uk/incoming/article6279250.ece/ALTERNATES/w300/poshnosh-sfb.jpg)
Amazing restaurant offers
Three glasses of free champagne and a special menu at 46 top London restaurants.
![](https://web.archive.org/web/20120118173202im_/http://www.independent.co.uk/incoming/article6279321.ece/ALTERNATES/w300/sfb.jpg)
Commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Day In a Page
![Chicago on a plate](https://web.archive.org/web/20120118173202im_/http://www.independent.co.uk/incoming/article6290887.ece/ALTERNATES/w148/chicagoRex.jpg)
Comments