(Translated by https://www.hiragana.jp/)
Manga Top 10 - Anime News Network
The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20230724061006/https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/ratings-manga.php
×
  • remind me tomorrow
  • remind me next week
  • never remind me
Subscribe to the ANN Newsletter • Wake up every Sunday to a curated list of ANN's most interesting posts of the week. read more

Manga Top 10

Best Rated (bayesian estimate)
Worst Rated (bayesian estimate)
Best Rated (weighted average)
Most Popular
Most Viewed
Most Underrated
Most Overrated
Most Diverging Opinions

Top 10 Best Rated (bayesian estimate) (Top 50)
# title rating nb. votes
1 Berserk (manga) 9.24 1410
2 Monster (manga) 9.21 907
3 Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (manga) 9.11 712
4 Steel Ball Run (manga) 9.06 158
5 Vinland Saga (manga) 9.01 295
6 Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou (manga) 9.01 387
7 20th Century Boys (manga) 8.99 624
8 Fullmetal Alchemist (manga) 8.97 1625
9 Akira (manga) 8.91 598
10 Yotsuba&! (manga) 8.90 768
This rating only includes titles that have at least 4 votes. The bayesian estimate is a statistical technique used to reduce the noise due to low sample counts. In effect, the less a title has votes, the more it is pulled towards the mean (7.7074). In other words, these are the titles that many people agree are great. (formula)
bayesian rating = (v ÷ (v+m)) × R + (m ÷ (v+m)) × C
where:
R = average for the manga
v = number of votes for the manga
m = minimum votes required to be listed (currently 4)
C = the mean vote across the whole report (currently 7.7074)

Top 10 Worst Rated (bayesian estimate) (Top 50)
# title rating nb. votes
3423 Duel Masters (manga) 4.01 7
3422 Saint Seiya Episode.G: Assassin (manga) 4.20 4
3421 Eiken (manga) 4.35 25
3420 Treasure Hunter (manga) 4.39 8
3419 Deus Vitae (manga) 4.44 41
3418 Ultimate Muscle: The Kinnikuman Legacy (manga) 4.55 37
3417 Samurai Shodown (manga, Yuki Miyoshi) 4.75 7
3416 Haruka: Beyond the Stream of Time (manga) 4.79 49
3415 Mai-chan's Daily Life (manga) 4.86 14
3414 Battle Royale II: Blitz Royale (manga) 5.07 25
This rating only includes titles that have at least 4 votes. The bayesian estimate is a statistical technique used to reduce the noise due to low sample counts. In effect, the less a title has votes, the more it is pulled towards the mean (7.7074). In other words, these are the titles that many people agree are awful. (formula)
bayesian rating = (v ÷ (v+m)) × R + (m ÷ (v+m)) × C
where:
R = average for the manga
v = number of votes for the manga
m = minimum votes required to be listed (currently 4)
C = the mean vote across the whole report (currently 7.7074)

Top 10 Best Rated (weighted average) (Top 50)
# title rating nb. votes
84 Berserk (manga) 9.25 1410
88 Monster (manga) 9.22 907
94 Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (manga) 9.12 712
96 Steel Ball Run (manga) 9.09 158
97 Showa: A History of Japan (manga) 9.09 17
100 Vinland Saga (manga) 9.03 295
102 Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou (manga) 9.02 387
259 20th Century Boys (manga) 9.00 624
261 Fullmetal Alchemist (manga) 8.97 1625
263 A Drifting Life (manga) 8.96 21
The rating is an average of the scores given by voters, weighted to give less importance to users with unnatural voting patterns. Titles with less than 4 votes are removed from the list but are still counted in the ranking. This explains why there may be gaps in the "#" column.

Top 10 Most Popular (Top 50)
# title rating nb. votes
1 Death Note (manga) 8.85 2616
2 Naruto (manga) 8.10 2250
3 Bleach (manga) 8.10 1952
4 Fullmetal Alchemist (manga) 8.93 1625
5 Fruits Basket (manga) 8.71 1626
6 Berserk (manga) 9.29 1410
7 One Piece (manga) 8.68 1340
8 Love Hina (manga) 8.30 1338
9 Rurouni Kenshin (manga) 8.78 1252
10 Chobits (manga) 7.98 1253
The most popular titles are determined with a simple summation of all votes. Titles with many votes will tend to be at the top, but this is modified a little by the ratings. In other words, the popularity is the straight average score of a title (the value in the rating column) multiplied by the number of votes.

Top 10 Most Viewed (Top 50)
# title rating seen by
1 Naruto (manga) 8.05 5132
2 Death Note (manga) 8.83 4996
3 Bleach (manga) 8.01 4793
4 Fruits Basket (manga) 8.75 3749
5 Fullmetal Alchemist (manga) 8.97 3541
6 One Piece (manga) 8.49 3015
7 Chobits (manga) 7.88 2853
8 Love Hina (manga) 8.15 2643
9 Rurouni Kenshin (manga) 8.72 2587
10 Berserk (manga) 9.25 2570
The "seen by" column indicates the number of people who have added the title in MyAnime, either in "seen some", "seen all", or "will not finish" categories. The rating displayed here is the same weighted average as the Top 10 Best Rated by weighted average, but is only displayed for reference and doesn't have anything to do with the order of the titles.

Top 10 Most Underrated (Top 50)
# title rating seen by
+4778 Saikyō Densetsu Kurosawa (manga) 8.11 4
+4307 (The) Cat Proposed (manga) 7.84 4
+4295 Skip and Loafer (manga) 8.22 6
+4283 Neo Parasyte m (manga) 7.82 4
+4171 Chio's School Road (manga) 8.10 6
+4168 Swing Shell (manga) 8.09 6
+4137 I Sold My Life for Ten Thousand Yen Per Year (manga) 8.06 6
+4133 Dame na Watashi ni Koishite Kudasai (manga) 8.29 7
+4107 Baccano! (manga) 7.91 5
+3990 Our Precious Conversations (manga) 7.84 5
This is a list of the titles that deserve to be seen more. Based on the premise that titles deserve to be seen in equal proportion to how well rated they are, the value in the "#" column is the number of positions by which this title would climb in the Most Viewed list if it was seen as much as it was liked (according to bayesian rating).

Top 10 Most Overrated (Top 50)
# title rating seen by
-3220 Princess Ai (manga) 5.58 485
-3217 (The) Vision of Escaflowne (manga) 5.07 415
-3154 My-HiME (manga) 6.04 511
-3151 Tokyo Mew Mew a la Mode (manga) 5.88 411
-3137 Mai-chan's Daily Life (manga) 4.86 309
-3132 Baby & Me (manga) 5.95 400
-3130 Yu-Gi-Oh! (manga) 6.36 1074
-3123 Miyuki-chan in Wonderland (manga) 5.98 406
-3096 Cowboy Bebop Shooting Star (manga) 6.20 523
-3067 Samurai Girl Real Bout High School (manga) 6.10 361
This is a list of the titles that didn't deserve to be seen as much as they have been. Based on the premise that titles deserve to be seen in equal proportion to how well rated they are, the value in the "#" column is the number of positions by which this title would drop in the Most Viewed list if it was seen as much as it was liked (according to bayesian rating).

Top 10 Most Diverging Opinions (Top 50)
# title rating nb. votes
1 Hanaotoko (manga) 7.88 ±3.982 24
2 GTO: 14 Days in Shonan (manga) 7.17 ±3.900 30
3 Showa: A History of Japan (manga) 8.82 ±3.899 17
4 Mai-chan's Daily Life (manga) 4.86 ±3.639 14
5 Kiichi!! (manga) 8.25 ±3.621 9
6 How to Build a Dungeon: Book of the Demon King (manga) 6.96 ±3.603 7
7 Pheromomania Syndrome (manga) 7.13 ±3.586 7
8 (The) World is Mine (manga) 8.42 ±3.563 24
9 Higurashi When They Cry: Massacre Arc (manga) 8.17 ±3.559 6
10 In This Corner of the World (manga) 8.25 ±3.549 15
Only includes titles with at least 4 votes. The rating column contains the baysesian rating ± the standard deviation, with the order of the titles being determined by the standard deviation.