Topic on User talk:Bob08

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Pallor (talkcontribs)

Hello! Why did you delete this? I see that you deleted it from several places, but not from other places (e.g. Párizs (Q90)). What is the concept? Thanks, bye!

Bob08 (talkcontribs)

Hi, Pallor.

I have deleted the information because a capital city should not be an instance of Q5119. The right place to declare that a city is the capital of a country is the property P1376 (Property talk:P31):

None of state or insular area capital of the United States (Q21518270), state capital in Germany (Q14784328), provincial or territorial capital city in Canada (Q21507383), capital city (Q5119): value must not be any of the specified items.

Replacement property: capital of (P1376).

There is no concept explaining why I have not changed all the concerned elements. I have simply not finished. For Paris, I am going to make the change.

Otto Von Heim (talkcontribs)

Hello, do you plan on just deleting Q5119 everywhere or will you also add P1376 in its place?

Bob08 (talkcontribs)

Hello.


I have deleted the stataements P31=Q5119 for items having one statement P1376.

Pallor (talkcontribs)

Thanks for the reply, I can already see the property constraint on P31

Reply to "Capital city"