Title:Do Most Students Need In-Person Lectures? A Study of a Large Statistics Class

Abstract:Over 1100 students over four semesters were given the option of taking an introductory undergraduate statistics class either by in-person attendance in lectures or by taking exactly the same class (same instructor, recorded lectures, homework, blind grading, website, etc.) without the in-person lectures. Roughly equal numbers of students chose each option. The online lectures were available to all. Attendance by online students was rare. The online students did slightly better on computer-graded exams. The causal effect of choosing only online lectures was estimated by adjusting for measured confounders, of which the incoming ACT math scores turned out to be most important, using four standard methods. The four nearly identical point estimates remained positive but were small and not statistically significant at the 95% confidence level. Sensitivity analysis indicated that unmeasured confounding was unlikely to be large but might plausibly reduce the point estimate to zero. No statistically significant differences were found in preliminary comparisons of effects on females/males, U.S./non-U.S. citizens, freshmen/non-freshman, and lower-scoring/higher-scoring math ACT groups.