-
Together apart: the influence of increased crowd heterogeneity on crowd dynamics at bottlenecks
Authors:
Paul Geoerg,
Ann Katrin Boomers,
Maxine Berthiaume,
Maik Boltes,
Max Kinateder
Abstract:
Individual differences in mobility (e.g., due to wheelchair use) are often ignored in the prediction of crowd movement. Consequently, engineering tools cannot fully describe the impact of vulnerable populations on egress performance. To contribute to closing this gap, we performed laboratory experiments with 25 pedestrians with varying mobility profiles. The control condition comprised only partic…
▽ More
Individual differences in mobility (e.g., due to wheelchair use) are often ignored in the prediction of crowd movement. Consequently, engineering tools cannot fully describe the impact of vulnerable populations on egress performance. To contribute to closing this gap, we performed laboratory experiments with 25 pedestrians with varying mobility profiles. The control condition comprised only participants without any additional equipment; in the luggage condition and the wheelchair condition, two participants at the center of the group either carried suitcases or used a wheelchair. We found that individuals using wheelchairs and to a lesser degree those carrying luggage needed longer to pass through the bottleneck, which also affected those walking behind them. This led to slower times to fully clear the bottleneck in the wheelchair and luggage condition compared to the control group. The results challenge the status quo in existing approaches to calculating egress performance and other key performance metrics in crowd dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Exploring Perceived Vulnerability of Pedestrians: Insights from a Forced-Choice Experiment
Authors:
Paul Geoerg,
Ann Katrin Boomers,
Maxine Berthiaume,
Maik Boltes,
Max Kinateder
Abstract:
Individual differences in mobility (e.g., due to wheelchair use) during crowd movement are not well understood. Perceived vulnerability of neighbors in a crowd could affect, for example, how much space is given to them by others. To explore how pedestrians perceive people moving in front of them, in particular, how vulnerable they believe them to be, we asked \SI{51}{} participants to complete a T…
▽ More
Individual differences in mobility (e.g., due to wheelchair use) during crowd movement are not well understood. Perceived vulnerability of neighbors in a crowd could affect, for example, how much space is given to them by others. To explore how pedestrians perceive people moving in front of them, in particular, how vulnerable they believe them to be, we asked \SI{51}{} participants to complete a Two-Alternatives-Forced Choice task (2AFC) in an internet browser. Participants were shown pairs of images, each showing a person, and then asked to select the person who appeared more vulnerable to them. For example, participants would choose between a male person in a wheelchair and a female person carrying a suitcase. In total 16 different stimuli (male vs female; no item/device, 1 suitcase, 2 suitcases, small backpack, large backpack, stroller, cane, and wheelchair), yielding n(n-1)/2 = 120 potential pairwise comparisons per participant. Results showed that wheelchair users appeared the most vulnerable and persons without any items/devices the least vulnerable. Persons carrying two suitcases were in the middle. These results informed the design of a main behavioral study (not reported here).
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Pedestrian Crowd Management Experiments: A Data Guidance Paper
Authors:
Ann Katrin Boomers,
Maik Boltes,
Juliane Adrian,
Mira Beermann,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Sina Feldmann,
Frank Fiedrich,
Niklas Frings,
Arne Graf,
Alica Kandler,
Deniz Kilic,
Krisztina Konya,
Mira Küpper,
Andreas Lotter,
Helena Lügering,
Francesca Müller,
Sarah Paetzke,
Anna-Katharina Raytarowski,
Olga Sablik,
Tobias Schrödter,
Armin Seyfried,
Anna Sieben,
Ezel Üsten
Abstract:
Understanding pedestrian dynamics and the interaction of pedestrians with their environment is crucial to the safe and comfortable design of pedestrian facilities. Experiments offer the opportunity to explore the influence of individual factors. In the context of the project CroMa (Crowd Management in transport infrastructures), experiments were conducted with about 1000 participants to test vario…
▽ More
Understanding pedestrian dynamics and the interaction of pedestrians with their environment is crucial to the safe and comfortable design of pedestrian facilities. Experiments offer the opportunity to explore the influence of individual factors. In the context of the project CroMa (Crowd Management in transport infrastructures), experiments were conducted with about 1000 participants to test various physical and social psychological hypotheses focusing on people's behaviour at railway stations and crowd management measures. The following experiments were performed: i) Train Platform Experiment, ii) Crowd Management Experiment, iii) Single-File Experiment, iv) Personal Space Experiment, v) Boarding and Alighting Experiment, vi) Bottleneck Experiment and vii) Tiny Box Experiment. This paper describes the basic planning and implementation steps, outlines all experiments with parameters, geometries, applied sensor technologies and pre- and post-processing steps. All data can be found in the pedestrian dynamics data archive.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2023; v1 submitted 3 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Influence of Gender Composition in Pedestrian Single-File Experiments
Authors:
Sarah Paetzke,
Maik Boltes,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
Various studies address the question of what factors are relevant to the course of the fundamental diagram in single-file experiments. Some indicate that there are differences due to group composition when gender is taken into account. For this reason, further single-file experiments with homogeneous and heterogeneous group compositions were conducted. A Tukey HSD test was performed to investigate…
▽ More
Various studies address the question of what factors are relevant to the course of the fundamental diagram in single-file experiments. Some indicate that there are differences due to group composition when gender is taken into account. For this reason, further single-file experiments with homogeneous and heterogeneous group compositions were conducted. A Tukey HSD test was performed to investigate whether there are differences between the mean of velocity in different density ranges. A comparison of different group compositions shows that the effect of gender can only be seen, if at all, in a small density interval. Regression analyses were also conducted to determine whether, at high densities, the distance between individuals depends on the gender of the neighboring pedestrians and to establish what human factors have an effect on the velocity. An analysis of the distances between individuals at high densities indicates that there is no effect of the gender of the neighboring pedestrians. Taking into account additional human factors in a regression analysis does not improve the model.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Influence of individual factors on fundamental diagrams of pedestrians
Authors:
Sarah Paetzke,
Maik Boltes,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
In recent years, numerous studies have been published dealing with the effect of individual characteristics of pedestrians on the fundamental diagram. These studies compared cumulative data on individuals in a group homogeneous in terms of one human factor such as age but heterogeneous in terms of other factors for instance gender. In order to examine the effect of all determined as well as undete…
▽ More
In recent years, numerous studies have been published dealing with the effect of individual characteristics of pedestrians on the fundamental diagram. These studies compared cumulative data on individuals in a group homogeneous in terms of one human factor such as age but heterogeneous in terms of other factors for instance gender. In order to examine the effect of all determined as well as undetermined human factors, individual fundamental diagrams are introduced and analyzed using multiple linear regression. A single-file school experiment with students of different age, gender, and height is therefore considered. Single individuals appearing in different runs are analyzed to study the effect of human factors such as height, age and gender and all other unknown individual effects such as motivation or attention to the individual speed. The analysis shows that for students age and height are strongly correlated and, consequently, age can be ignored. Furthermore, the study shows that gender has a weak effect and other nonmeasurable individual characteristics have a stronger effect than height. In a further step, a mixed model is used as well as the multiple linear model. Here, it is shown that the mixed model that considers all other unknown individual effects of each person as a random factor is preferable to the model where the individual speed only depends on the variables of headway, height, and all other unknown individual effects as fixed factors.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2022; v1 submitted 29 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
The influence of physical and mental constraints to a stream of people through a bottleneck
Authors:
Paul Geoerg,
Jette Schumann,
Maik Boltes,
Stefan Holl,
Anja Hofmann
Abstract:
Understanding movement in heterogeneous groups is important for a meaningful evaluation of evacuation prediction and for a proper design of buildings. The understanding of interactions and influencing factors in heterogeneous groups on key performance figures is fundamental for a safe design. This contribution presents results of experimental studies on movement of a crowd through a bottleneck inv…
▽ More
Understanding movement in heterogeneous groups is important for a meaningful evaluation of evacuation prediction and for a proper design of buildings. The understanding of interactions and influencing factors in heterogeneous groups on key performance figures is fundamental for a safe design. This contribution presents results of experimental studies on movement of a crowd through a bottleneck involving participants with and without disabilities. High precise trajectories of the attendees extracted from video recordings were used to calculate density and velocity of the participants. Besides the well-established fundamental diagram new insights into the individual relation between density and velocity are discussed. A complex structure and considerate behaviour in movement implicates a strong influence of the heterogeneity on key performance values of safe movement.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Crowding and Queuing in Entrance Scenarios: Influence of Corridor Width in Front of Bottlenecks
Authors:
Juliane Adrian,
Maik Boltes,
Stefan Holl,
Anna Sieben,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
In this paper, we present results of an entrance experiment investigating the effect of the corridor width in front of a bottleneck on the density. The idea is based on a previous study suggesting that a guiding system in front of an entrance can reduce pushing of the waiting people and thus the density at the entrance. In our study we aim to find out to what extend the corridor width has an impac…
▽ More
In this paper, we present results of an entrance experiment investigating the effect of the corridor width in front of a bottleneck on the density. The idea is based on a previous study suggesting that a guiding system in front of an entrance can reduce pushing of the waiting people and thus the density at the entrance. In our study we aim to find out to what extend the corridor width has an impact on crowding or queuing behavior and with that on the density. The results of the presented experiment suggest that the transition takes place between a corridor width of 1.2 m and 2.3 m. The total duration of each experimental run is not significantly influenced by the corridor width but by the width of the entrance itself, the number of participants and partly by the motivation. In general, the density in front of the gate as well as the area of high density is increased by widening the corridor and by intensifying the motivation of the participants. However, the results also suggest that also the number of participants significantly influences the occurrence of pushing and the level of density.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Inflow process of pedestrians to a confined space
Authors:
Takahiro Ezaki,
Kazumichi Ohtsuka,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Maik Boltes,
Daichi Yanagisawa,
Armin Seyfried,
Andreas Schadschneider,
Katsuhiro Nishinari
Abstract:
To better design safe and comfortable urban spaces, understanding the nature of human crowd movement is important. However, precise interactions among pedestrians are difficult to measure in the presence of their complex decision-making processes and many related factors. While extensive studies on pedestrian flow through bottlenecks and corridors have been conducted, the dominant mode of interact…
▽ More
To better design safe and comfortable urban spaces, understanding the nature of human crowd movement is important. However, precise interactions among pedestrians are difficult to measure in the presence of their complex decision-making processes and many related factors. While extensive studies on pedestrian flow through bottlenecks and corridors have been conducted, the dominant mode of interaction in these scenarios may not be relevant in different scenarios. Here, we attempt to decipher the factors that affect human reactions to other individuals from a different perspective. We conducted experiments employing the inflow process in which pedestrians successively enter a confined area (like an elevator) and look for a temporary position. In this process, pedestrians have a wider range of options regarding their motion than in the classical scenarios; therefore, other factors might become relevant. The preference of location is visualized by pedestrian density profiles obtained from recorded pedestrian trajectories. Non-trivial patterns of space acquisition, e.g., an apparent preference for positions near corners, were observed. This indicates the relevance of psychological and anticipative factors beyond the private sphere, which have not been deeply discussed so far in the literature on pedestrian dynamics. From the results, four major factors, which we call flow avoidance, distance cost, angle cost, and boundary preference, were suggested. We confirmed that a description of decision-making based on these factors can give a rise to realistic preference patterns, using a simple mathematical model. Our findings provide new perspectives and a baseline for considering the optimization of design and safety in crowded public areas and public transport carriers.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Universal flow-density relation of single-file bicycle, pedestrian and car motion
Authors:
Jun Zhang,
Wolfgang Mehner,
Stefan Holl,
Maik Boltes,
Erik Andresen,
Andreas Schadschneider,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
The relation between flow and density is an essential quantitative characteristic to describe the efficiency of traffic systems. We have performed experiments with single-file motion of bicycles and compare the results with previous studies for car and pedestrian motion in similar setups. In the space-time diagrams we observe three different states of motion (free flow state, jammed state and stop…
▽ More
The relation between flow and density is an essential quantitative characteristic to describe the efficiency of traffic systems. We have performed experiments with single-file motion of bicycles and compare the results with previous studies for car and pedestrian motion in similar setups. In the space-time diagrams we observe three different states of motion (free flow state, jammed state and stop-and-go waves) in all these systems. Despite of their obvious differences they are described by a universal fundamental diagram after proper rescaling of space and time which takes into account the size and free velocity of the three kinds of agents. This indicates that the similarities between the systems go deeper than expected.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2014; v1 submitted 10 December, 2013;
originally announced December 2013.
-
Microscopic insights into pedestrian motion through a bottleneck, resolving spatial and temporal variations
Authors:
Jack Liddle,
Armin Seyfried,
Bernhard Steffen,
Wolfram Klingsch,
Tobias Rupprecht,
Andreas Winkens,
Maik Boltes
Abstract:
The motion of pedestrians is subject to a wide range of influences and exhibits a rich phenomenology. To enable precise measurement of the density and velocity we use an alternative definition using Voronoi diagrams which exhibits smaller fluctuations than the standard definitions. This method permits examination on scales smaller than the pedestrians. We use this method to investigate the spatial…
▽ More
The motion of pedestrians is subject to a wide range of influences and exhibits a rich phenomenology. To enable precise measurement of the density and velocity we use an alternative definition using Voronoi diagrams which exhibits smaller fluctuations than the standard definitions. This method permits examination on scales smaller than the pedestrians. We use this method to investigate the spatial and temporal variation of the observables at bottlenecks. Experiments were performed with 180 test subjects and a wide range of bottleneck parameters. The anomalous flow through short bottlenecks and non-stationary states present with narrow bottlenecks are analysed.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2011;
originally announced May 2011.
-
The Lagrangian picture of heat transfer in convective turbulence
Authors:
Maik Boltes,
Herwig Zilken,
Joerg Schumacher
Abstract:
We present a fluid dynamics video which illustrates the Lagrangian aspects of local heat transfer in turbulent Rayleigh-Benard convection. The data are obtained from a direct numerical simulation.
We present a fluid dynamics video which illustrates the Lagrangian aspects of local heat transfer in turbulent Rayleigh-Benard convection. The data are obtained from a direct numerical simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.
-
Enhanced empirical data for the fundamental diagram and the flow through bottlenecks
Authors:
A. Seyfried,
M. Boltes,
J. Kähler,
W. Klingsch,
A. Portz,
T. Rupprecht,
A. Schadschneider,
B. Steffen,
A. Winkens
Abstract:
In recent years, several approaches for modelling pedestrian dynamics have been proposed and applied e.g. for design of egress routes. However, so far not much attention has been paid to their 'quantitative' validation. This unsatisfactory situation belongs amongst others on the uncertain and contradictory experimental data base. The fundamental diagram, i.e. the density-dependence of the flow o…
▽ More
In recent years, several approaches for modelling pedestrian dynamics have been proposed and applied e.g. for design of egress routes. However, so far not much attention has been paid to their 'quantitative' validation. This unsatisfactory situation belongs amongst others on the uncertain and contradictory experimental data base. The fundamental diagram, i.e. the density-dependence of the flow or velocity, is probably the most important relation as it connects the basic parameter to describe the dynamic of crowds. But specifications in different handbooks as well as experimental measurements differ considerably. The same is true for the bottleneck flow. After a comprehensive review of the experimental data base we give an survey of a research project, including experiments with up to 250 persons performed under well controlled laboratory conditions. The trajectories of each person are measured in high precision to analyze the fundamental diagram and the flow through bottlenecks. The trajectories allow to study how the way of measurement influences the resulting relations. Surprisingly we found large deviation amongst the methods. These may be responsible for the deviation in the literature mentioned above. The results are of particular importance for the comparison of experimental data gained in different contexts and for the validation of models.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2008;
originally announced October 2008.
-
New insights into pedestrian flow through bottlenecks
Authors:
Armin Seyfried,
Tobias Rupprecht,
Oliver Passon,
Bernhard Steffen,
Wolfram Klingsch,
Maik Boltes
Abstract:
Capacity estimation is an important tool for the design and dimensioning of pedestrian facilities. The literature contains different procedures and specifications which show considerable differences with respect to the estimated flow values. Moreover do new experimental data indicate a stepwise growing of the capacity with the width and thus challenge the validity of the specific flow concept. T…
▽ More
Capacity estimation is an important tool for the design and dimensioning of pedestrian facilities. The literature contains different procedures and specifications which show considerable differences with respect to the estimated flow values. Moreover do new experimental data indicate a stepwise growing of the capacity with the width and thus challenge the validity of the specific flow concept. To resolve these differences we have studied experimentally the unidirectional pedestrian flow through bottlenecks under laboratory conditions. The time development of quantities like individual velocities, density and individual time gaps in bottlenecks of different width is presented. The data show a linear growth of the flow with the width. The comparison of the results with experimental data of other authors indicates that the basic assumption of the capacity estimation for bottlenecks has to be revised. In contradiction with most planning guidelines our main result is, that a jam occurs even if the incoming flow does not overstep the capacity defined by the maximum of the flow according to the fundamental diagram.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2007; v1 submitted 1 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
The Fundamental Diagram of Pedestrian Movement Revisited
Authors:
Armin Seyfried,
Bernhard Steffen,
Wolfram Klingsch,
Maik Boltes
Abstract:
The empirical relation between density and velocity of pedestrian movement is not completely analyzed, particularly with regard to the `microscopic' causes which determine the relation at medium and high densities. The simplest system for the investigation of this dependency is the normal movement of pedestrians along a line (single-file movement). This article presents experimental results for…
▽ More
The empirical relation between density and velocity of pedestrian movement is not completely analyzed, particularly with regard to the `microscopic' causes which determine the relation at medium and high densities. The simplest system for the investigation of this dependency is the normal movement of pedestrians along a line (single-file movement). This article presents experimental results for this system under laboratory conditions and discusses the following observations: The data show a linear relation between the velocity and the inverse of the density, which can be regarded as the required length of one pedestrian to move. Furthermore we compare the results for the single-file movement with literature data for the movement in a plane. This comparison shows an unexpected conformance between the fundamental diagrams, indicating that lateral interference has negligible influence on the velocity-density relation at the density domain $1 m^{-2}<ρ<5 m^{-2}$. In addition we test a procedure for automatic recording of pedestrian flow characteristics. We present preliminary results on measurement range and accuracy of this method.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2005; v1 submitted 22 June, 2005;
originally announced June 2005.
