-
Comprehensive Review and New Analysis Software for Single-file Pedestrian Experiments
Authors:
Rudina Subaih,
Antoine Tordeux,
Mohcine Chraibi
Abstract:
This paper offers a comprehensive examination of single-file experiments within the field of pedestrian dynamics, providing a thorough review from both theoretical and analytical perspectives. It begins by tracing the historical context of single-file movement studies in pedestrian dynamics. Then, the significance of understanding the fundamental relationships among density, speed, and flow in ped…
▽ More
This paper offers a comprehensive examination of single-file experiments within the field of pedestrian dynamics, providing a thorough review from both theoretical and analytical perspectives. It begins by tracing the historical context of single-file movement studies in pedestrian dynamics. Then, the significance of understanding the fundamental relationships among density, speed, and flow in pedestrian dynamics through the lens of simple single-file systems is explored in depth. Furthermore, we investigate various traffic systems involving human or non-human entities such as ants, mice, bicycles, and cars, and provide insights. We explore the types of experimental setups, data collection methods, and influential factors that affect pedestrian movement. We also define and explain the common concepts concerning single-file movement, particularly in experimental research. Finally, we present a Python tool named ``SingleFileMovementAnalysis'' designed for analyzing single-file experimental data, specifically head trajectories. This tool provides a cohesive approach to preparing and calculating movement metrics like speed, density, and headway. The article aims to stimulate further research and underscore the areas where future researchers can contribute to advancing and enhancing single-file studies.
△ Less
Submitted 18 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
A Novel Voronoi-based Convolutional Neural Network Framework for Pushing Person Detection in Crowd Videos
Authors:
Ahmed Alia,
Mohammed Maree,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
Analyzing the microscopic dynamics of pushing behavior within crowds can offer valuable insights into crowd patterns and interactions. By identifying instances of pushing in crowd videos, a deeper understanding of when, where, and why such behavior occurs can be achieved. This knowledge is crucial to creating more effective crowd management strategies, optimizing crowd flow, and enhancing overall…
▽ More
Analyzing the microscopic dynamics of pushing behavior within crowds can offer valuable insights into crowd patterns and interactions. By identifying instances of pushing in crowd videos, a deeper understanding of when, where, and why such behavior occurs can be achieved. This knowledge is crucial to creating more effective crowd management strategies, optimizing crowd flow, and enhancing overall crowd experiences. However, manually identifying pushing behavior at the microscopic level is challenging, and the existing automatic approaches cannot detect such microscopic behavior. Thus, this article introduces a novel automatic framework for identifying pushing in videos of crowds on a microscopic level. The framework comprises two main components: i) Feature extraction and ii) Video labeling. In the feature extraction component, a new Voronoi-based method is developed for determining the local regions associated with each person in the input video. Subsequently, these regions are fed into EfficientNetV1B0 Convolutional Neural Network to extract the deep features of each person over time. In the second component, a combination of a fully connected layer with a Sigmoid activation function is employed to analyze these deep features and annotate the individuals involved in pushing within the video. The framework is trained and evaluated on a new dataset created using six real-world experiments, including their corresponding ground truths. The experimental findings indicate that the suggested framework outperforms seven baseline methods that are employed for comparative analysis purposes.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Single-file pedestrian dynamics: a review of agent-following models
Authors:
Jakob Cordes,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Antoine Tordeux,
Andreas Schadschneider
Abstract:
Single-file dynamics has been studied intensively, both experimentally and theoretically. It shows interesting collective effects, such as stop-and-go waves, which are validation cornerstones for any agent-based modeling approach of traffic systems. Many models have been proposed, e.g. in the form of car-following models for vehicular traffic. These approaches can be adapted for pedestrian streams…
▽ More
Single-file dynamics has been studied intensively, both experimentally and theoretically. It shows interesting collective effects, such as stop-and-go waves, which are validation cornerstones for any agent-based modeling approach of traffic systems. Many models have been proposed, e.g. in the form of car-following models for vehicular traffic. These approaches can be adapted for pedestrian streams. In this study, we delve deeper into these models, with particular attention on their interconnections. We do this by scrutinizing the influence of different parameters, including relaxation times, anticipation time, and reaction time. Specifically, we analyze the inherent fundamental problems with force-based models, a classical approach in pedestrian dynamics. Furthermore, we categorize car-following models into stimulus-response and optimal velocity models, highlighting their historical and conceptual differences. These classes can further be subdivided considering the conceptual definitions of the models, e.g. first-order vs. second-order models, or stochastic vs. deterministic models with and without noise. Our analysis shows how car-following models originally developed for vehicular traffic can provide new insights into pedestrian behavior. The focus on single-file motion, which is similar to single-lane vehicular traffic, allows for a detailed examination of the relevant interactions between pedestrians.
△ Less
Submitted 14 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Social distancing and the future of pedestrian dynamics
Authors:
Mohcine Chraibi,
Andreas Schadschneider,
Antoine Tordeux
Abstract:
Many countries have introduced social distancing rules during the COVID-19 pandemic in order to reduce spreading of the virus in public spaces. This has inspired research on pedestrian dynamics in more ways than just one. Many studies have been performed, not only to determine the effectiveness of such measures, but also in order to understand its effects on crowd dynamics in general. In this Pers…
▽ More
Many countries have introduced social distancing rules during the COVID-19 pandemic in order to reduce spreading of the virus in public spaces. This has inspired research on pedestrian dynamics in more ways than just one. Many studies have been performed, not only to determine the effectiveness of such measures, but also in order to understand its effects on crowd dynamics in general. In this Perspective article, we reflect on the insights derived from these investigations and their relevance for future advancements in the field of pedestrian dynamics. This includes impacts on safety regulations and the potential for new theoretical and experimental approaches which may hold relevance even beyond applied restrictions.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Pedestrian Crowd Management Experiments: A Data Guidance Paper
Authors:
Ann Katrin Boomers,
Maik Boltes,
Juliane Adrian,
Mira Beermann,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Sina Feldmann,
Frank Fiedrich,
Niklas Frings,
Arne Graf,
Alica Kandler,
Deniz Kilic,
Krisztina Konya,
Mira Küpper,
Andreas Lotter,
Helena Lügering,
Francesca Müller,
Sarah Paetzke,
Anna-Katharina Raytarowski,
Olga Sablik,
Tobias Schrödter,
Armin Seyfried,
Anna Sieben,
Ezel Üsten
Abstract:
Understanding pedestrian dynamics and the interaction of pedestrians with their environment is crucial to the safe and comfortable design of pedestrian facilities. Experiments offer the opportunity to explore the influence of individual factors. In the context of the project CroMa (Crowd Management in transport infrastructures), experiments were conducted with about 1000 participants to test vario…
▽ More
Understanding pedestrian dynamics and the interaction of pedestrians with their environment is crucial to the safe and comfortable design of pedestrian facilities. Experiments offer the opportunity to explore the influence of individual factors. In the context of the project CroMa (Crowd Management in transport infrastructures), experiments were conducted with about 1000 participants to test various physical and social psychological hypotheses focusing on people's behaviour at railway stations and crowd management measures. The following experiments were performed: i) Train Platform Experiment, ii) Crowd Management Experiment, iii) Single-File Experiment, iv) Personal Space Experiment, v) Boarding and Alighting Experiment, vi) Bottleneck Experiment and vii) Tiny Box Experiment. This paper describes the basic planning and implementation steps, outlines all experiments with parameters, geometries, applied sensor technologies and pre- and post-processing steps. All data can be found in the pedestrian dynamics data archive.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2023; v1 submitted 3 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
A Cloud-based Deep Learning Framework for Early Detection of Pushing at Crowded Event Entrances
Authors:
Ahmed Alia,
Mohammed Maree,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Anas Toma,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
Crowding at the entrances of large events may lead to critical and life-threatening situations, particularly when people start pushing each other to reach the event faster. Automatic and timely identification of pushing behavior would help organizers and security forces to intervene early and mitigate dangerous situations. In this paper, we propose a cloud-based deep learning framework for automat…
▽ More
Crowding at the entrances of large events may lead to critical and life-threatening situations, particularly when people start pushing each other to reach the event faster. Automatic and timely identification of pushing behavior would help organizers and security forces to intervene early and mitigate dangerous situations. In this paper, we propose a cloud-based deep learning framework for automatic early detection of pushing in crowded event entrances. The proposed framework initially modifies and trains the EfficientNetV2B0 Convolutional Neural Network model. Subsequently, it integrates the adapted model with an accurate and fast pre-trained deep optical flow model with the color wheel method to analyze video streams and identify pushing patches in real-time. Moreover, the framework uses live capturing technology and a cloud-based environment to collect video streams of crowds in real-time and provide early-stage results. A novel dataset is generated based on five real-world experiments and their associated ground truth data to train the adapted EfficientNetV2B0 model. The experimental setups simulated a crowded event entrance, while the ground truths for each video experiment was generated manually by social psychologists. Several experiments on the videos and the generated dataset are carried out to evaluate the accuracy and annotation delay time of the proposed framework. The experimental results show that the proposed framework identified pushing behaviors with an accuracy rate of 87% within a reasonable delay time.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2023; v1 submitted 16 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Anticipation in a velocity-based model for pedestrian dynamics
Authors:
Qiancheng Xu,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
Lane formation in bidirectional pedestrian streams is based on a stimulus-response mechanism and strategies of navigation in a fast-changing environment. Although microscopic models that only guarantee volume exclusion can qualitatively reproduce this phenomenon, they are not sufficient for a quantitative description. To quantitatively describe this phenomenon, a minimal anticipatory collision-fre…
▽ More
Lane formation in bidirectional pedestrian streams is based on a stimulus-response mechanism and strategies of navigation in a fast-changing environment. Although microscopic models that only guarantee volume exclusion can qualitatively reproduce this phenomenon, they are not sufficient for a quantitative description. To quantitatively describe this phenomenon, a minimal anticipatory collision-free velocity model is introduced. Compared to the original velocity model, the new model reduces the occurrence of gridlocks and reproduces the movement of pedestrians more realistically. For a quantitative description of the phenomenon, the definition of an order parameter is used to describe the formation of lanes at transient states and to show that the proposed model compares relatively well with experimental data. Furthermore, the model is validated by the experimental fundamental diagrams of bidirectional flows.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Prolonged Clogs in Bottleneck Simulations for Pedestrian Dynamics
Authors:
Qiancheng Xu,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
This article studies clogging phenomena using a velocity-based model for pedestrian dynamics. First, a method to identify prolonged clogs in simulations was introduced. Then bottleneck simulations were implemented with different initial and boundary conditions. The number of prolonged clogs was analyzed to investigate the decisive factors causing this phenomenon. Moreover, the time lapse between t…
▽ More
This article studies clogging phenomena using a velocity-based model for pedestrian dynamics. First, a method to identify prolonged clogs in simulations was introduced. Then bottleneck simulations were implemented with different initial and boundary conditions. The number of prolonged clogs was analyzed to investigate the decisive factors causing this phenomenon. Moreover, the time lapse between two consecutive agents passing the exit, and the trajectories of agents were analyzed. The influence of three types of factors was studied: parameters of the spatial boundaries, algorithmic factors related to the implementation of the model, and the movement model. Parameters of the spatial boundaries include the width and position of the bottleneck exit. Algorithmic factors are the update methods and the size of the time step. Model parameters cover several parameters describing the level of motivation, the strength and range of impact among agents, and the shape of agents. The results show that the occurrence of prolonged clogs is closely linked to parameters of the spatial boundaries and the movement model but has virtually no correlation with algorithmic factors.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Generalized collision-free velocity model for pedestrian dynamics
Authors:
Qiancheng Xu,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Antoine Tordeux,
Jun Zhang
Abstract:
The collision-free velocity model is a microscopic pedestrian model, which despite its simplicity, reproduces fairly well several self-organization phenomena in pedestrian dynamics. The model consists of two components: a direction sub-model that combines individual desired moving direction and neighbor's influence to imitate the process of navigating in a two-dimensional space, and an intrinsical…
▽ More
The collision-free velocity model is a microscopic pedestrian model, which despite its simplicity, reproduces fairly well several self-organization phenomena in pedestrian dynamics. The model consists of two components: a direction sub-model that combines individual desired moving direction and neighbor's influence to imitate the process of navigating in a two-dimensional space, and an intrinsically collision-free speed sub-model which controls the speed of the agents with respect to the distance to their neighbors.
In this paper we generalize the collision-free velocity model by introducing the influence of walls and extending the distance calculations to velocity-based ellipses. Besides, we introduce enhancements to the direction sub-module that smooth the direction changes of pedestrians in the simulation; a shortcoming that was not visible in the original model due to the symmetry of the circular shapes. Moreover, the introduced improvements mitigate backward movements, leading to a more realistic distribution of pedestrians especially in bottleneck scenarios.
We study by simulation the effects of the pedestrian's shape by comparing the fundamental diagram in narrow and wide corridors. Furthermore, we validate our generalized approach by investigating the flow through bottlenecks with varying exit's widths.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Automated Quality Assessment of Space-Continuous Models for Pedestrian Dynamics
Authors:
Valentina Kurtc,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Antoine Tordeux
Abstract:
In this work we propose a methodology for assessment of pedestrian models continuous in space. With respect to the Kolmogorov-Smirnov distance between two data clouds, representing for instance simulated and the corresponding empirical data, we calculate an evaluation factor between zero and one. Based on the value of the herein developed factor, we make a statement about the goodness of the model…
▽ More
In this work we propose a methodology for assessment of pedestrian models continuous in space. With respect to the Kolmogorov-Smirnov distance between two data clouds, representing for instance simulated and the corresponding empirical data, we calculate an evaluation factor between zero and one. Based on the value of the herein developed factor, we make a statement about the goodness of the model under evaluation. Moreover this process can be repeated in an automatic way in order to maximize the above mentioned factor and hence determine the optimal set of model parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Investigation of Voronoi diagram based Direction Choices Using Uni- and Bi-directional Trajectory Data
Authors:
Yao Xiao,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Yunchao Qu,
Antoine Tordeux,
Ziyou Gao
Abstract:
In a crowd, individuals make different motion choices such as "moving to destination", "following another pedestrian", and "making a detour". For the sake of convenience, the three direction choices are respectively called destination direction, following direction and detour direction in this paper. Here, it is found that the featured direction choices could be inspired by the shape characteristi…
▽ More
In a crowd, individuals make different motion choices such as "moving to destination", "following another pedestrian", and "making a detour". For the sake of convenience, the three direction choices are respectively called destination direction, following direction and detour direction in this paper. Here, it is found that the featured direction choices could be inspired by the shape characteristics of Voronoi diagram. To be specific, in the Voronoi cell of a pedestrian, the direction to a Voronoi node is regarded as a potential "detour" direction, and the direction perpendicular to a Voronoi link is regarded as a potential "following" direction. A pedestrian generally owns several alternative Voronoi nodes and Voronoi links in a Voronoi cell, and the optimal detour and following direction are determined by considering related factors such as deviation. Plus the destination direction which is directly pointing to the destination, the three basic direction choices are defined in a Voronoi cell. In order to evaluate the Voronoi diagram based basic directions, the empirical trajectory data in both uni- and bi-directional flow experiments are extracted. A time series method considering the step frequency is used to reduce the original trajectories' swaying phenomena which might disturb the recognition of actual forward direction. The deviations between the empirical velocity direction and the basic directions are investigated, and each velocity direction is classified into a basic direction or regarded as an inexplicable direction according to the deviations. The analysis results show that each basic direction could be a potential direction choice for a pedestrian. The combination of the three basic directions could cover most empirical velocity direction choices in both uni- and bi-directional flow experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Prediction of Pedestrian Speed with Artificial Neural Networks
Authors:
Antoine Tordeux,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Armin Seyfried,
Andreas Schadschneider
Abstract:
Pedestrian behaviours tend to depend on the type of facility. Therefore accurate predictions of pedestrians movements in complex geometries (including corridor, bottleneck or intersection) are difficult to achieve for classical models with few parameters. Artificial neural networks have multiple parameters and are able to identify various types of patterns. They could be a suitable alternative for…
▽ More
Pedestrian behaviours tend to depend on the type of facility. Therefore accurate predictions of pedestrians movements in complex geometries (including corridor, bottleneck or intersection) are difficult to achieve for classical models with few parameters. Artificial neural networks have multiple parameters and are able to identify various types of patterns. They could be a suitable alternative for forecasts. We aim in this paper to present first steps testing this approach. We compare estimations of pedestrian speed with a classical model and a neural network for combinations of corridor and bottleneck experiments. The results show that the neural network is able to differentiate the two geometries and to improve the estimation of pedestrian speeds when the geometries are mixed.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2018; v1 submitted 29 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
A Knowledge-based Way-Finding Framework for Pedestrian Dynamic
Authors:
Mohcine Chraibi,
David Haensel
Abstract:
We introduce a framework to navigate agents in buildings, inspired by the concept of "the cognitive map". It allows to route agents depending on their spacial knowledge. With help of an event-driven mechanism, agents acquire new information about their surroundings, which expands their individual cognitive map.
We introduce a framework to navigate agents in buildings, inspired by the concept of "the cognitive map". It allows to route agents depending on their spacial knowledge. With help of an event-driven mechanism, agents acquire new information about their surroundings, which expands their individual cognitive map.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Influence of the number of predecessors in interaction within acceleration-based flow models
Authors:
Antoine Tordeux,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Andreas Schadschneider,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
In this paper, the stability of the uniform solutions is analysed for microscopic flow models in interaction with $K\ge1$ predecessors. We calculate general conditions for the linear stability on the ring geometry and explore the results with particular pedestrian and car-following models based on relaxation processes. The uniform solutions are stable if the relaxation times are sufficiently small…
▽ More
In this paper, the stability of the uniform solutions is analysed for microscopic flow models in interaction with $K\ge1$ predecessors. We calculate general conditions for the linear stability on the ring geometry and explore the results with particular pedestrian and car-following models based on relaxation processes. The uniform solutions are stable if the relaxation times are sufficiently small. The analysis is focused on the relevance of the number of predecessors in the dynamics. Unexpected non-monotonic relations between $K$ and the stability are presented.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2017; v1 submitted 21 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Inflow process of pedestrians to a confined space
Authors:
Takahiro Ezaki,
Kazumichi Ohtsuka,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Maik Boltes,
Daichi Yanagisawa,
Armin Seyfried,
Andreas Schadschneider,
Katsuhiro Nishinari
Abstract:
To better design safe and comfortable urban spaces, understanding the nature of human crowd movement is important. However, precise interactions among pedestrians are difficult to measure in the presence of their complex decision-making processes and many related factors. While extensive studies on pedestrian flow through bottlenecks and corridors have been conducted, the dominant mode of interact…
▽ More
To better design safe and comfortable urban spaces, understanding the nature of human crowd movement is important. However, precise interactions among pedestrians are difficult to measure in the presence of their complex decision-making processes and many related factors. While extensive studies on pedestrian flow through bottlenecks and corridors have been conducted, the dominant mode of interaction in these scenarios may not be relevant in different scenarios. Here, we attempt to decipher the factors that affect human reactions to other individuals from a different perspective. We conducted experiments employing the inflow process in which pedestrians successively enter a confined area (like an elevator) and look for a temporary position. In this process, pedestrians have a wider range of options regarding their motion than in the classical scenarios; therefore, other factors might become relevant. The preference of location is visualized by pedestrian density profiles obtained from recorded pedestrian trajectories. Non-trivial patterns of space acquisition, e.g., an apparent preference for positions near corners, were observed. This indicates the relevance of psychological and anticipative factors beyond the private sphere, which have not been deeply discussed so far in the literature on pedestrian dynamics. From the results, four major factors, which we call flow avoidance, distance cost, angle cost, and boundary preference, were suggested. We confirmed that a description of decision-making based on these factors can give a rise to realistic preference patterns, using a simple mathematical model. Our findings provide new perspectives and a baseline for considering the optimization of design and safety in crowded public areas and public transport carriers.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Wayfinding and cognitive maps for pedestrian models
Authors:
Erik Andresen,
David Haensel,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
Usually, routing models in pedestrian dynamics assume that agents have fulfilled and global knowledge about the building's structure. However, they neglect the fact that pedestrians possess no or only parts of information about their position relative to final exits and possible routes leading to them. To get a more realistic description we introduce the systematics of gathering and using spatial…
▽ More
Usually, routing models in pedestrian dynamics assume that agents have fulfilled and global knowledge about the building's structure. However, they neglect the fact that pedestrians possess no or only parts of information about their position relative to final exits and possible routes leading to them. To get a more realistic description we introduce the systematics of gathering and using spatial knowledge. A new wayfinding model for pedestrian dynamics is proposed. The model defines for every pedestrian an individual knowledge representation implying inaccuracies and uncertainties. In addition, knowledge-driven search strategies are introduced. The presented concept is tested on a fictive example scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Collision-free speed model for pedestrian dynamics
Authors:
Antoine Tordeux,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
We propose in this paper a minimal speed-based pedestrian model for which particle dynamics are intrinsically collision-free. The speed model is an optimal velocity function depending on the agent length (i.e.\ particle diameter), maximum speed and time gap parameters. The direction model is a weighted sum of exponential repulsion from the neighbors, calibrated by the repulsion rate and distance.…
▽ More
We propose in this paper a minimal speed-based pedestrian model for which particle dynamics are intrinsically collision-free. The speed model is an optimal velocity function depending on the agent length (i.e.\ particle diameter), maximum speed and time gap parameters. The direction model is a weighted sum of exponential repulsion from the neighbors, calibrated by the repulsion rate and distance. The model's main features like the reproduction of empirical phenomena are analysed by simulation. We point out that phenomena of self-organisation observable in force-based models and field studies can be reproduced by the collision-free model with low computational effort.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
A force-based model to reproduce stop-and-go waves in pedestrian dynamics
Authors:
Mohcine Chraibi,
Antoine Tordeux,
Andreas Schadschneider
Abstract:
Stop-and-go waves in single-file movement are a phenomenon that is ob- served empirically in pedestrian dynamics. It manifests itself by the co-existence of two phases: moving and stopping pedestrians. We show analytically based on a simplified one-dimensional scenario that under some conditions the system can have instable homogeneous solutions. Hence, oscillations in the trajectories and in- sta…
▽ More
Stop-and-go waves in single-file movement are a phenomenon that is ob- served empirically in pedestrian dynamics. It manifests itself by the co-existence of two phases: moving and stopping pedestrians. We show analytically based on a simplified one-dimensional scenario that under some conditions the system can have instable homogeneous solutions. Hence, oscillations in the trajectories and in- stabilities emerge during simulations. To our knowledge there exists no force-based model which is collision- and oscillation-free and meanwhile can reproduce phase separation. We develop a new force-based model for pedestrian dynamics able to reproduce qualitatively the phenomenon of phase separation. We investigate analytically the stability condition of the model and define regimes of parameter values where phase separation can be observed. We show by means of simulations that the predefined conditions lead in fact to the expected behavior and validate our model with respect to empirical findings.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Jamming transitions in force-based models for pedestrian dynamics
Authors:
Mohcine Chraibi,
Takahiro Ezaki,
Antoine Tordeux,
Katsuhiro Nishinari,
Andreas Schadschneider,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
Force-based models describe pedestrian dynamics in analogy to classical mechanics by a system of second order ordinary differential equations. By investigating the linear stability of two main classes of forces, parameter regions with unstable homogeneous states are identified. In this unstable regime it is then checked whether phase transitions or stop-and-go waves occur. Results based on numeric…
▽ More
Force-based models describe pedestrian dynamics in analogy to classical mechanics by a system of second order ordinary differential equations. By investigating the linear stability of two main classes of forces, parameter regions with unstable homogeneous states are identified. In this unstable regime it is then checked whether phase transitions or stop-and-go waves occur. Results based on numerical simulations show, however, that the investigated models lead to unrealistic behavior in form of backwards moving pedestrians and overlapping. This is one reason why stop-and-go waves have not been observed in these models. The unrealistic behavior is not related to the numerical treatment of the dynamic equations but rather indicates an intrinsic problem of this model class. Identifying the underlying generic problems gives indications how to define models that do not show such unrealistic behavior. As an example we introduce a new force-based model which produces realistic jam dynamics without the appearance of unrealistic negative speeds for empirical desired walking speeds.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Quantitative validation of PEDFLOW for description of unidirectional pedestrian dynamics
Authors:
J. Zhang,
D. Britto,
M. Chraibi,
R. Löhner,
E. Haug,
B. Gawenat
Abstract:
The results of a systematic quantitative validation of PEDFLOW based on the experimental data from FZJ are presented. Unidirectional flow experiments, totaling 28 different combinations with varying entry, corridor and exit widths, were considered. The condition imposed on PEDFLOW was that all the cases should be run with the same input parameters. The exit times and fundamental diagrams for the m…
▽ More
The results of a systematic quantitative validation of PEDFLOW based on the experimental data from FZJ are presented. Unidirectional flow experiments, totaling 28 different combinations with varying entry, corridor and exit widths, were considered. The condition imposed on PEDFLOW was that all the cases should be run with the same input parameters. The exit times and fundamental diagrams for the measuring region were evaluated and compared. This validation process led to modifications and enhancements of the model underlying PEDFLOW. The preliminary conclusions indicate that the results agree well for densities smaller than 3 m-2 and a good agreement is observed even at high densities for the corridors with bcor = 2.4 m, and bcor = 3.0 m. For densities between 1 and 2 m-2 the specific flow and velocities are underpredicted by PEDFLOW.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Steady State of Pedestrian Flow in Bottleneck Experiments
Authors:
Weichen Liao,
Antoine Tordeux,
Armin Seyfried,
Mohcine Chraibi,
Kevin Drzycimski,
Xiaoping Zheng,
Ying Zhao
Abstract:
Experiments with pedestrians could depend strongly on initial conditions. Comparisons of the results of such experiments require to distinguish carefully between transient state and steady state. In this work, a feasible algorithm - Cumulative Sum Control Chart - is proposed and improved to automatically detect steady states from density and speed time series of bottleneck experiments. The thresho…
▽ More
Experiments with pedestrians could depend strongly on initial conditions. Comparisons of the results of such experiments require to distinguish carefully between transient state and steady state. In this work, a feasible algorithm - Cumulative Sum Control Chart - is proposed and improved to automatically detect steady states from density and speed time series of bottleneck experiments. The threshold of the detection parameter in the algorithm is calibrated using an autoregressive model. Comparing the detected steady states with previous manually selected ones, the modified algorithm gives more reproducible results. For the applications, three groups of bottleneck experiments are analysed and the steady states are detected. The study about pedestrian flow shows that the difference between the flows in all states and in steady state mainly depends on the ratio of pedestrian number to bottleneck width. When the ratio is higher than a critical value (approximately 115 persons/m), the flow in all states is almost identical with the flow in steady state. Thus we have more possibilities to compare the flows from different experiments, especially when the detection of steady states is difficult.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2015;
originally announced June 2015.
-
Assessment of Models for Pedestrian Dynamics with Functional Principal Component Analysis
Authors:
M. Chraibi,
T. Ensslen,
H. Gottschalk,
M. Saadi,
A. Seyfried
Abstract:
Many agent based simulation approaches have been proposed for pedestrian flow. As such models are applied e.g.\ in evacuation studies, the quality and reliability of such models is of vital interest. Pedestrian trajectories are functional data and thus functional principal component analysis is a natural tool to asses the quality of pedestrian flow models beyond average properties. In this article…
▽ More
Many agent based simulation approaches have been proposed for pedestrian flow. As such models are applied e.g.\ in evacuation studies, the quality and reliability of such models is of vital interest. Pedestrian trajectories are functional data and thus functional principal component analysis is a natural tool to asses the quality of pedestrian flow models beyond average properties. In this article we conduct functional PCA for the trajectories of pedestrians passing through a bottleneck. We benchmark two agent based models of pedestrian flow against the experimental data using PCA average and stochastic features. Functional PCA proves to be an efficient tool to detect deviation between simulation and experiment and to asses quality of pedestrian models.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2015; v1 submitted 2 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
Oscillating behavior within the social force model
Authors:
Mohcine Chraibi
Abstract:
The social force model belongs to a class of microscopic force-based pedestrian model for which the interaction with the neighbors solely depends on the distance spacings. Yet, distance based models can lead to unrealistic oscillating behaviors with collision and negative peed (especially in 1D scenarios. With appropriate approximations we analyze the behavior of a simplified force-based model and…
▽ More
The social force model belongs to a class of microscopic force-based pedestrian model for which the interaction with the neighbors solely depends on the distance spacings. Yet, distance based models can lead to unrealistic oscillating behaviors with collision and negative peed (especially in 1D scenarios. With appropriate approximations we analyze the behavior of a simplified force-based model and show that with "realistic" parameter values the system oscillates.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Modeling the desired direction in a force-based model for pedestrian dynamics
Authors:
Mohcine Chraibi,
Martina Freialdenhoven,
Andreas Schadschneider,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
We introduce an enhanced model based on the generalized centrifugal force model. Furthermore, the desired direction of pedestrians is investigated. A new approach leaning on the well-known concept of static and dynamic floor-fields in cellular automata is presented. Numerical results of the model are presented and compared with empirical data.
We introduce an enhanced model based on the generalized centrifugal force model. Furthermore, the desired direction of pedestrians is investigated. A new approach leaning on the well-known concept of static and dynamic floor-fields in cellular automata is presented. Numerical results of the model are presented and compared with empirical data.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
Calculating ellipse overlap areas
Authors:
Gary B. Hughes,
Mohcine Chraibi
Abstract:
We present a general algorithm for finding the overlap area between two ellipses. The algorithm is based on finding a segment area (the area between an ellipse and a secant line) given two points on the ellipse. The Gauss-Green formula is used to determine the ellipse sector area between two points, and a triangular area is added or subtracted to give the segment area. For two ellipses, overlap ar…
▽ More
We present a general algorithm for finding the overlap area between two ellipses. The algorithm is based on finding a segment area (the area between an ellipse and a secant line) given two points on the ellipse. The Gauss-Green formula is used to determine the ellipse sector area between two points, and a triangular area is added or subtracted to give the segment area. For two ellipses, overlap area is calculated by adding the areas of appropriate sectors and polygons. Intersection points for two general ellipses are found using Ferrari's quartic formula to solve the polynomial that results from combining the two ellipse equations. All cases for the number of intersection points (0, 1, 2, 3, 4) are handled. The algorithm is implemented in c-code, and has been tested with a range of input ellipses. The code is efficient enough for use in simulations that require many overlap area calculations.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
Generalized Centrifugal Force Model for Pedestrian Dynamics
Authors:
Mohcine Chraibi,
Armin Seyfried,
Andreas Schadschneider
Abstract:
A spatially continuous force-based model for simulating pedestrian dynamics is introduced which includes an elliptical volume exclusion of pedestrians. We discuss the phenomena of oscillations and overlapping which occur for certain choices of the forces. The main intention of this work is the quantitative description of pedestrian movement in several geometries. Measurements of the fundamental di…
▽ More
A spatially continuous force-based model for simulating pedestrian dynamics is introduced which includes an elliptical volume exclusion of pedestrians. We discuss the phenomena of oscillations and overlapping which occur for certain choices of the forces. The main intention of this work is the quantitative description of pedestrian movement in several geometries. Measurements of the fundamental diagram in narrow and wide corridors are performed. The results of the proposed model show good agreement with empirical data obtained in controlled experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2010; v1 submitted 25 August, 2010;
originally announced August 2010.
-
Quantitative Verification of a Force-based Model for Pedestrian Dynamics
Authors:
Mohcine Chraibi,
Armin Seyfried,
Andreas Schadschneider,
Wolfgang Mackens
Abstract:
This paper introduces a spatially continuous force-based model for simulating pedestrian dynamics. The main intention of this work is the quantitative description of pedestrian movement through bottlenecks and in corridors. Measurements of flow and density at bottlenecks will be presented and compared with empirical data. Furthermore the fundamental diagram for the movement in a corridor is repr…
▽ More
This paper introduces a spatially continuous force-based model for simulating pedestrian dynamics. The main intention of this work is the quantitative description of pedestrian movement through bottlenecks and in corridors. Measurements of flow and density at bottlenecks will be presented and compared with empirical data. Furthermore the fundamental diagram for the movement in a corridor is reproduced. The results of the proposed model show a good agreement with empirical data.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
Quantitative Description of Pedestrian Dynamics with a Force based Model
Authors:
Mohcine Chraibi,
Armin Seyfried,
Andreas Schadschneider,
Wolfgang Mackens
Abstract:
This paper introduces a space-continuous force-based model for simulating pedestrian dynamics. The main interest of this work is the quantitative description of pedestrian movement through a bottleneck. Measurements of flow and density will be presented and compared with empirical data. The results of the proposed model show a good agreement with empirical data. Furthermore, we emphasize the imp…
▽ More
This paper introduces a space-continuous force-based model for simulating pedestrian dynamics. The main interest of this work is the quantitative description of pedestrian movement through a bottleneck. Measurements of flow and density will be presented and compared with empirical data. The results of the proposed model show a good agreement with empirical data. Furthermore, we emphasize the importance of volume exclusion in force-based models.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2009;
originally announced October 2009.
-
Pedestrian Dynamics With Event-driven Simulation
Authors:
Mohcine Chraibi,
Armin Seyfried
Abstract:
The social-force model is systematically modified to achieve a satisfying agreement with the fundamental diagram. Furthermore, our modification allows an efficient computation of the simulation. Finally, different simulation-results will be compared to empirical data.
The social-force model is systematically modified to achieve a satisfying agreement with the fundamental diagram. Furthermore, our modification allows an efficient computation of the simulation. Finally, different simulation-results will be compared to empirical data.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
