-
Confronting Scaling Relations of Spiral Galaxies with Hierarchical Models of Disk Formation
Authors:
Aaron A. Dutton,
Stéphane Courteau
Abstract:
The scaling relations between rotation velocity, size and luminosity form a benchmark test for any theory of disk galaxy formation. We confront recent theoretical models of disk formation to a recent large compilation of such scaling relations. We stress the importance of achieving a fair comparison between models and observations.
The scaling relations between rotation velocity, size and luminosity form a benchmark test for any theory of disk galaxy formation. We confront recent theoretical models of disk formation to a recent large compilation of such scaling relations. We stress the importance of achieving a fair comparison between models and observations.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
The Tully-Fisher Zero Point Problem
Authors:
Aaron A. Dutton,
Frank C. van den Bosch,
Stéphane Courteau
Abstract:
A long standing problem for hierarchical disk galaxy formation models has been the simultaneous matching of the zero point of the Tully-Fisher relation and the galaxy luminosity function (LF). We illustrate this problem for a typical disk galaxy and discuss three solutions: low stellar mass-to-light ratios, low initial dark halo concentrations, and no halo contraction. We speculate that halo con…
▽ More
A long standing problem for hierarchical disk galaxy formation models has been the simultaneous matching of the zero point of the Tully-Fisher relation and the galaxy luminosity function (LF). We illustrate this problem for a typical disk galaxy and discuss three solutions: low stellar mass-to-light ratios, low initial dark halo concentrations, and no halo contraction. We speculate that halo contraction may be reversed through a combination of mass ejection through feedback and angular momentum exchange brought about by dynamical friction between baryons and dark matter during the disk formation process.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Scaling Relations of Spiral Galaxies
Authors:
S. Courteau,
A. A. Dutton,
F. van den Bosch,
L. A. MacArthur,
A. Dekel,
D. H. McIntosh,
D. A. Dale
Abstract:
We construct a large data set of global structural parameters for 1300 field and cluster spiral galaxies and explore the joint distribution of luminosity L, optical rotation velocity V, and disk size R at I- and 2MASS K-bands. The I- and K-band velocity-luminosity (VL) relations have log-slopes of 0.29 and 0.27, respectively with sigma_ln(VL)~0.13, and show a small dependence on color and morpho…
▽ More
We construct a large data set of global structural parameters for 1300 field and cluster spiral galaxies and explore the joint distribution of luminosity L, optical rotation velocity V, and disk size R at I- and 2MASS K-bands. The I- and K-band velocity-luminosity (VL) relations have log-slopes of 0.29 and 0.27, respectively with sigma_ln(VL)~0.13, and show a small dependence on color and morphological type in the sense that redder, early-type disk galaxies rotate faster than bluer, later-type disk galaxies for most luminosities. The VL relation at I- and K-bands is independent of surface brightness, size and light concentration. The log-slope of the I- and K-band RL relations is a strong function of morphology and varies from 0.25 to 0.5. The average dispersion sigma_ln(RL) decreases from 0.33 at I-band to 0.29 at K, likely due to the 2MASS selection bias against lower surface brightness galaxies. Measurement uncertainties are sigma_ln(V)~0.09, sigma_ln(L)~0.14 and somewhat larger and harder to estimate for ln(R). The color dependence of the VL relation is consistent with expectations from stellar population synthesis models. The VL and RL residuals are largely uncorrelated with each other; the RV-RL residuals show only a weak positive correlation. These correlations suggest that scatter in luminosity is not a significant source of the scatter in the VL and RL relations. The observed scaling relations can be understood in the context of a model of disk galaxies embedded in dark matter halos that invokes low mean spin parameters and dark halo expansion, as we describe in our companion paper (Dutton et al. 2007). We discuss in two appendices various pitfalls of standard analytical derivations of galaxy scaling relations, including the Tully-Fisher relation with different slopes. (Abridged).
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2007;
originally announced August 2007.
-
Concentration, Spin and Shape of Dark Matter Haloes: Scatter and the Dependence on Mass and Environment
Authors:
Andrea V. Maccio',
Aaron A. Dutton,
Frank C. van den Bosch,
Ben Moore,
Doug Potter,
Joachim Stadel
Abstract:
We use a series of cosmological N-body simulations for a flat LCDM cosmology to investigate the properties of dark matter haloes in the mass range 3.0e9-3.0e13 Msun. These properties include the concentration parameter (c), the spin parameter (lambda) and the mean axis ratio (q). For the concentration-mass relation we find c~M^(-0.11) in agreement with the model proposed by Bullock et al. even i…
▽ More
We use a series of cosmological N-body simulations for a flat LCDM cosmology to investigate the properties of dark matter haloes in the mass range 3.0e9-3.0e13 Msun. These properties include the concentration parameter (c), the spin parameter (lambda) and the mean axis ratio (q). For the concentration-mass relation we find c~M^(-0.11) in agreement with the model proposed by Bullock et al. even if we find a lower normalization (15%). The results for lambda and q are in good agreement with previous studies, while c and lambda are anti-correlated. In an attempt to remove unrelaxed haloes, we use the offset parameter (xoff), defined as the distance between the most bound particle and the center of mass. Removing haloes with large xoff increases the c by ~10%, lowers the lambda by ~15%, and removes the most prolate haloes. In addition, it largely removes the anti-correlation between c and lambda though not entirely. We also investigate the effects of the large-scale environment. We find that more concentrated haloes live in denser environments. Note, however, that the trend is weak compared to the scatter. For the spin parameters we find no environment dependence, while there is a weak indication that the most spherical haloes reside in denser region. Finally, using a simple model for disk galaxy formation we show that haloes that host low surface brightness galaxies are expected to be hosted by a biased sub-set of haloes. Not only do these haloes have spin parameters that are larger than average, they also have c that are 15% percent lower than the average at a given halo mass. We discuss the implications of all these findings for the claimed disagreement between halo concentrations inferred from LSB rotation curves, and those expected for a LCDM cosmology. (abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2007; v1 submitted 7 August, 2006;
originally announced August 2006.
-
A Revised Model for the Formation of Disk Galaxies: Low Spin and Dark-Halo Expansion
Authors:
Aaron A. Dutton,
Frank C. van den Bosch,
Avishai Dekel,
Stephane Courteau
Abstract:
We use observed rotation velocity-luminosity (VL) and size-luminosity (RL) relations to single out a specific scenario for disk galaxy formation in the LCDM cosmology. Our model involves four independent log-normal random variables: dark-halo concentration c, disk spin lam_gal, disk mass fraction m_gal, and stellar mass-to-light ratio M/L_I. A simultaneous match of the VL and RL zero points with…
▽ More
We use observed rotation velocity-luminosity (VL) and size-luminosity (RL) relations to single out a specific scenario for disk galaxy formation in the LCDM cosmology. Our model involves four independent log-normal random variables: dark-halo concentration c, disk spin lam_gal, disk mass fraction m_gal, and stellar mass-to-light ratio M/L_I. A simultaneous match of the VL and RL zero points with adiabatic contraction requires low-c halos, but this model has V_2.2~1.8 V_vir (where V_2.2 and V_vir are the circular velocity at 2.2 disk scale lengths and the virial radius, respectively) which will be unable to match the luminosity function (LF). Similarly models without adiabatic contraction but standard c also predict high values of V_2.2/V_vir. Models in which disk formation induces an expansion rather than the commonly assumed contraction of the dark-matter halos have V_2.2~1.2 V_vir which allows a simultaneous fit of the LF. This may result from non-spherical, clumpy gas accretion, where dynamical friction transfers energy from the gas to the dark matter. This model requires low lam_gal and m_gal values, contrary to naive expectations. However, the low lam_gal is consistent with the notion that disk galaxies predominantly survive in halos with a quiet merger history, while a low m_gal is also indicated by galaxy-galaxy lensing. The smaller than expected scatter in the RL relation, and the lack of correlation between the residuals of the VL and RL relations, respectively, imply that the scatter in lam_gal and in c need to be smaller than predicted for LCDM halos, again consistent with the idea that disk galaxies preferentially reside in halos with a quiet merger history.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2007; v1 submitted 27 April, 2006;
originally announced April 2006.
-
Origin of the Joint Distribution of Structural Parameters in Disc Galaxies
Authors:
Aaron A. Dutton,
Frank C. van den Bosch,
Stephane Courteau,
Avishai Dekel
Abstract:
We use a simple model of disc-galaxy formation in the LCDM cosmology to simultaneously reproduce the slopes, zero-points, scatter and uncorrelated residuals in the observed velocity-luminosity (VL) and radius-luminosity (RL) relations. Observed I-band luminosities are converted to stellar masses using the IMF-dependent relation between stellar mass-to-light ratio, M/L, and color. The model treat…
▽ More
We use a simple model of disc-galaxy formation in the LCDM cosmology to simultaneously reproduce the slopes, zero-points, scatter and uncorrelated residuals in the observed velocity-luminosity (VL) and radius-luminosity (RL) relations. Observed I-band luminosities are converted to stellar masses using the IMF-dependent relation between stellar mass-to-light ratio, M/L, and color. The model treats halo concentration, spin parameter, and disc mass fraction as independent log-normal random variables. Our main conclusion is that the VL and RL zero-points and the uncorrelated residuals can only be reproduced simultaneously if adiabatic contraction is avoided. One or the other could be fixed by appealing to unrealistic values for M/L, halo concentration c, and spin parameter lambda, but not all together. The small VL scatter is naturally determined by the predicted scatter in c and in M/L, quite independent of the large scatter in lambda. However, the RL scatter, driven by the scatter in lambda, can be as low as observed only if sigma_lambda simeq 0.25, about half the value predicted for CDM haloes. This may indicate that discs form in a special subset of haloes. The VL slope is reproduced once star formation occurs only above a threshold surface density, and the RL slope implies that the disc mass fraction is increasing with halo mass, consistent with feedback effects. A model that incorporates the above ingredients provides a simultaneous fit to all the observed features. In particular, the elimination of adiabatic contraction allows 80% disc contribution to the observed rotation velocity of bright discs at 2.2 disc scale lengths. The lack of halo contraction may indicate that disc formation is not as smooth as typically envisioned, but instead may involve clumpy, cold streams.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2005;
originally announced January 2005.
-
Mass Modeling of Disk Galaxies: Constraints, Degeneracies and Adiabatic Contraction
Authors:
Aaron A. Dutton,
Stephane Courteau,
Roelof de Jong,
Claude Carignan
Abstract:
This paper addresses available constraints on mass models fitted to rotation curves. Mass models of disk galaxies have well-known degeneracies, that prevent a unique mass decomposition. The most notable is due to the unknown value of the stellar mass-to-light ratio (the disk-halo degeneracy); even with this known, degeneracies between the halo parameters themselves may prevent an unambiguous det…
▽ More
This paper addresses available constraints on mass models fitted to rotation curves. Mass models of disk galaxies have well-known degeneracies, that prevent a unique mass decomposition. The most notable is due to the unknown value of the stellar mass-to-light ratio (the disk-halo degeneracy); even with this known, degeneracies between the halo parameters themselves may prevent an unambiguous determination of the shape of the dark halo profile, which includes the inner density slope of the dark matter halo. The latter is often referred to as the ``cusp-core degeneracy''. We explore constraints on the disk and halo parameters and apply these to four mock and six observed disk galaxies with high resolution and extended rotation curves. Our full set of constraints consists of mass-to-light (M/L) ratios from stellar population synthesis models based on B-R colors, constraints on halo parameters from N-body simulations, and constraining the halo virial velocity to be less than the maximum observed velocity. These constraints are only partially successful in lifting the cusp-core degeneracy. The effect of adiabatic contraction of the halo by the disk is to steepen cores into cusps and reduce the best-fit halo concentration and M/L values (often significantly). We also discuss the effect of disk thickness, halo flattening, distance errors, and rotation curve error values on mass modeling. Increasing the imposed minimum rotation curve error from typically low, underestimated values to more realistic estimates decreases the chi-square substantially and makes distinguishing between a cuspy or cored halo profile even more difficult. In spite of the degeneracies and uncertainties present, our constrained mass modeling favors sub-maximal disks (i.e., a dominant halo) at 2.2 disk scale lengths, with Vdisk/Vtot < 0.6.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2005; v1 submitted 30 September, 2003;
originally announced October 2003.
