-
Near-Landauer Reversible Skyrmion Logic with Voltage-Based Propagation
Authors:
Benjamin W. Walker,
Alexander J. Edwards,
Xuan Hu,
Michael P. Frank,
Felipe Garcia-Sanchez,
Joseph S. Friedman
Abstract:
Magnetic skyrmions are topological quasiparticles whose non-volatility, detectability, and mobility make them exciting candidates for low-energy computing. Previous works have demonstrated the feasibility and efficiency of current-driven skyrmions in cascaded logic structures inspired by reversible computing. As skyrmions can be propelled through the voltage-controlled magnetic anisotropy (VCMA) e…
▽ More
Magnetic skyrmions are topological quasiparticles whose non-volatility, detectability, and mobility make them exciting candidates for low-energy computing. Previous works have demonstrated the feasibility and efficiency of current-driven skyrmions in cascaded logic structures inspired by reversible computing. As skyrmions can be propelled through the voltage-controlled magnetic anisotropy (VCMA) effect with much greater efficiency, this work proposes a VCMA-based skyrmion propagation mechanism that drastically reduces energy dissipation. Additionally, we demonstrate the functionality of skyrmion logic gates enabled by our novel voltage-based propagation and estimate its energy efficiency relative to other logic schemes. The minimum dissipation of this VCMA-driven magnetic skyrmion logic at 0 K is found to be $\sim$6$\times$ the room-temperature Landauer limit, indicating the potential for sub-Landauer dissipation through further engineering.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Logical and Physical Reversibility of Conservative Skyrmion Logic
Authors:
Xuan Hu,
Benjamin W. Walker,
Felipe García-Sánchez,
Alexander J. Edwards,
Peng Zhou,
Jean Anne C. Incorvia,
Alexandru Paler,
Michael P. Frank,
Joseph S. Friedman
Abstract:
Magnetic skyrmions are nanoscale whirls of magnetism that can be propagated with electrical currents. The repulsion between skyrmions inspires their use for reversible computing based on the elastic billiard ball collisions proposed for conservative logic in 1982. Here we evaluate the logical and physical reversibility of this skyrmion logic paradigm, as well as the limitations that must be addres…
▽ More
Magnetic skyrmions are nanoscale whirls of magnetism that can be propagated with electrical currents. The repulsion between skyrmions inspires their use for reversible computing based on the elastic billiard ball collisions proposed for conservative logic in 1982. Here we evaluate the logical and physical reversibility of this skyrmion logic paradigm, as well as the limitations that must be addressed before dissipation-free computation can be realized.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Quantum Foundations of Classical Reversible Computing
Authors:
Michael P. Frank,
Karpur Shukla
Abstract:
The reversible computation paradigm aims to provide a new foundation for general classical digital computing that is capable of circumventing the thermodynamic limits to the energy efficiency of the conventional, non-reversible digital paradigm. However, to date, the essential rationale for and analysis of classical reversible computing (RC) has not yet been expressed in terms that leverage the mo…
▽ More
The reversible computation paradigm aims to provide a new foundation for general classical digital computing that is capable of circumventing the thermodynamic limits to the energy efficiency of the conventional, non-reversible digital paradigm. However, to date, the essential rationale for and analysis of classical reversible computing (RC) has not yet been expressed in terms that leverage the modern formal methods of non-equilibrium quantum thermodynamics (NEQT). In this paper, we begin developing an NEQT-based foundation for the physics of reversible computing. We use the framework of Gorini-Kossakowski-Sudarshan-Lindblad dynamics (a.k.a. Lindbladians) with multiple asymptotic states, incorporating recent results from resource theory, full counting statistics, and stochastic thermodynamics. Important conclusions include that, as expected: (1) Landauer's Principle indeed sets a strict lower bound on entropy generation in traditional non-reversible architectures for deterministic computing machines when we account for the loss of correlations; and (2) implementations of the alternative reversible computation paradigm can potentially avoid such losses, and thereby circumvent the Landauer limit, potentially allowing the efficiency of future digital computing technologies to continue improving indefinitely. We also outline a research plan for identifying the fundamental minimum energy dissipation of reversible computing machines as a function of speed.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2021; v1 submitted 30 April, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Reversible Computing with Fast, Fully Static, Fully Adiabatic CMOS
Authors:
Michael P. Frank,
Robert W. Brocato,
Brian D. Tierney,
Nancy A. Missert,
Alexander H. Hsia
Abstract:
To advance the energy efficiency of general digital computing far beyond the thermodynamic limits that apply to conventional digital circuits will require utilizing the principles of reversible computing. It has been known since the early 1990s that reversible computing based on adiabatic switching is possible in CMOS, although almost all of the "adiabatic" CMOS logic families in the literature ar…
▽ More
To advance the energy efficiency of general digital computing far beyond the thermodynamic limits that apply to conventional digital circuits will require utilizing the principles of reversible computing. It has been known since the early 1990s that reversible computing based on adiabatic switching is possible in CMOS, although almost all of the "adiabatic" CMOS logic families in the literature are not actually fully adiabatic, which limits their achievable energy savings. The first CMOS logic style that achieved truly, fully adiabatic operation if leakage was negligible (CRL) is not fully static, which leads to a number of practical engineering difficulties in the presence of certain nonidealities. Later, "static" adiabatic logic families were described, but they were not actually fully adiabatic, or fully static, and were much slower.
In this paper, we describe a new logic family, Static 2-Level Adiabatic Logic (S2LAL), which is, to our knowledge, the first CMOS logic family that is both fully static, and truly, fully adiabatic (modulo leakage). In addition, S2LAL is, we think, the fastest possible such family (among fully pipelined sequential circuits), having a latency per logic stage of one "tick" (transition time), and a minimum clock period (initiation interval) of 8 ticks. S2LAL requires 8 phases of a trapezoidal power-clock waveform (plus constant power and ground references) to be supplied. We argue that, if implemented in a suitable fabrication process designed to aggressively minimize leakage, S2LAL should be capable of demonstrating a greater level of energy efficiency than any other semiconductor-based digital logic family known today.
△ Less
Submitted 2 September, 2020; v1 submitted 28 August, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Physical Foundations of Landauer's Principle
Authors:
Michael P. Frank
Abstract:
We review the physical foundations of Landauer's Principle, which relates the loss of information from a computational process to an increase in thermodynamic entropy. Despite the long history of the Principle, its fundamental rationale and proper interpretation remain frequently misunderstood. Contrary to some misinterpretations of the Principle, the mere transfer of entropy between computational…
▽ More
We review the physical foundations of Landauer's Principle, which relates the loss of information from a computational process to an increase in thermodynamic entropy. Despite the long history of the Principle, its fundamental rationale and proper interpretation remain frequently misunderstood. Contrary to some misinterpretations of the Principle, the mere transfer of entropy between computational and non-computational subsystems can occur in a thermodynamically reversible way without increasing total entropy. However, Landauer's Principle is not about general entropy transfers; rather, it more specifically concerns the ejection of (all or part of) some correlated information from a controlled, digital form (e.g., a computed bit) to an uncontrolled, non-computational form, i.e., as part of a thermal environment. Any uncontrolled thermal system will, by definition, continually re-randomize the physical information in its thermal state, from our perspective as observers who cannot predict the exact dynamical evolution of the microstates of such environments. Thus, any correlations involving information that is ejected into and subsequently thermalized by the environment will be lost from our perspective, resulting directly in an irreversible increase in total entropy. Avoiding the ejection and thermalization of correlated computational information motivates the reversible computing paradigm, although the requirements for computations to be thermodynamically reversible are less restrictive than frequently described, particularly in the case of stochastic computational operations. There are interesting possibilities for the design of computational processes that utilize stochastic, many-to-one computational operations while nevertheless avoiding net entropy increase that remain to be fully explored.
△ Less
Submitted 26 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Design Automation for Adiabatic Circuits
Authors:
Alwin Zulehner,
Michael P. Frank,
Robert Wille
Abstract:
Adiabatic circuits are heavily investigated since they allow for computations with an asymptotically close to zero energy dissipation per operation - serving as an alternative technology for many scenarios where energy efficiency is preferred over fast execution. Their concepts are motivated by the fact that the information lost from conventional circuits results in an entropy increase which cause…
▽ More
Adiabatic circuits are heavily investigated since they allow for computations with an asymptotically close to zero energy dissipation per operation - serving as an alternative technology for many scenarios where energy efficiency is preferred over fast execution. Their concepts are motivated by the fact that the information lost from conventional circuits results in an entropy increase which causes energy dissipation. To overcome this issue, computations are performed in a (conditionally) reversible fashion which, additionally, have to satisfy switching rules that are different from conventional circuitry - crying out for dedicated design automation solutions. While previous approaches either focus on their electrical realization (resulting in small, hand-crafted circuits only) or on designing fully reversible building blocks (an unnecessary overhead), this work aims for providing an automatic and dedicated design scheme that explicitly takes the recent findings in this domain into account. To this end, we review the theoretical and technical background of adiabatic circuits and present automated methods that dedicatedly realize the desired function as an adiabatic circuit. The resulting methods are further optimized - leading to an automatic and efficient design automation for this promising technology. Evaluations confirm the benefits and applicability of the proposed solution.
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2018; v1 submitted 7 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Generalized Reversible Computing
Authors:
Michael P. Frank
Abstract:
Landauer's Principle that information loss from a computation implies entropy increase can be rigorously proved from mathematical physics. However, carefully examining its detailed formulation reveals that the traditional identification of logically reversible computational operations with bijective transformations of the full digital state space is actually not the correct logical-level character…
▽ More
Landauer's Principle that information loss from a computation implies entropy increase can be rigorously proved from mathematical physics. However, carefully examining its detailed formulation reveals that the traditional identification of logically reversible computational operations with bijective transformations of the full digital state space is actually not the correct logical-level characterization of the full set of classical computational operations that can be carried out physically with asymptotically zero energy dissipation. To find the correct logical conditions for physical reversibility, we must account for initial-state probabilities when applying the Principle. The minimal logical-level requirement for the physical reversibility of deterministic computational operations is that the subset of initial states that exhibit nonzero probability in a given statistical operating context must be transformed one-to-one into final states. Thus, any computational operation is conditionally reversible relative to any sufficiently-restrictive precondition on its initial state, and the minimum dissipation required for any deterministic operation by Landauer's Principle asymptotically approaches 0 when the probability of meeting any preselected one of its suitable preconditions approaches 1. This realization facilitates simpler designs for asymptotically thermodynamically reversible computational hardware, compared to designs that are restricted to using only fully-bijective operations such as Toffoli type operations. Thus, this more general framework for reversible computing provides a more effective theoretical foundation to use for the design of practical reversible computers than does the more restrictive traditional model of reversible logic. In this paper, we formally develop the theoretical foundations of the generalized model, and briefly survey some of its applications.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Back to the Future: The Case for Reversible Computing
Authors:
Michael P. Frank
Abstract:
There is one, and only one way, consistent with fundamental physics, that the efficiency of general digital computation can continue increasing indefinitely, and that is to apply the principles of reversible computing. We need to begin intensive development work on this technology soon if we want to maintain advances in computing and the attendant economic growth.
NOTE: This paper is an extended…
▽ More
There is one, and only one way, consistent with fundamental physics, that the efficiency of general digital computation can continue increasing indefinitely, and that is to apply the principles of reversible computing. We need to begin intensive development work on this technology soon if we want to maintain advances in computing and the attendant economic growth.
NOTE: This paper is an extended author's preprint of the feature article titled "Throwing Computing Into Reverse" (print) or "The Future of Computing Depends on Making it Reversible" (online), published by IEEE Spectrum in Aug.-Sep. 2017. This preprint is based on the original draft manuscript that the author submitted to Spectrum, prior to IEEE edits and feedback from external readers.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2018; v1 submitted 7 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Relativized Separation of Reversible and Irreversible Space-Time Complexity Classes
Authors:
Michael P. Frank,
M. Josephine Ammer
Abstract:
Reversible computing can reduce the energy dissipation of computation, which can improve cost-efficiency in some contexts. But the practical applicability of this method depends sensitively on the space and time overhead required by reversible algorithms. Time and space complexity classes for reversible machines match conventional ones, but we conjecture that the joint space-time complexity classe…
▽ More
Reversible computing can reduce the energy dissipation of computation, which can improve cost-efficiency in some contexts. But the practical applicability of this method depends sensitively on the space and time overhead required by reversible algorithms. Time and space complexity classes for reversible machines match conventional ones, but we conjecture that the joint space-time complexity classes are different, and that a particular reduction by Bennett minimizes the space-time product complexity of general reversible computations. We provide an oracle-relativized proof of the separation, and of a lower bound on space for linear-time reversible simulations. A non-oracle proof applies when a read-only input is omitted from the space accounting. Both constructions model one-way function iteration, conjectured to be a problem for which Bennett's algorithm is optimal.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Field Programmable Gate Array based Front-End Data Acquisition Module for the COSMICi Astroparticle Telescope System
Authors:
Darryl W. McGowan Jr,
David R. Grosby,
Michael P. Frank,
Sachin Junnarkar,
Ray H. O'Neal Jr
Abstract:
We describe an FPGA based Front-End Data Acquisition Module (FEDAM) for implementing Time-over-Threshold (ToT) Time-to-Digital conversion (TDC) of pulses obtained from the COSMICi astroparticle telescope detector system photomultiplier tubes. The telescope system consists of a minimum of three scintillation detectors configured to detect particle airshowers likely initiated by Ultra High Energy Co…
▽ More
We describe an FPGA based Front-End Data Acquisition Module (FEDAM) for implementing Time-over-Threshold (ToT) Time-to-Digital conversion (TDC) of pulses obtained from the COSMICi astroparticle telescope detector system photomultiplier tubes. The telescope system consists of a minimum of three scintillation detectors configured to detect particle airshowers likely initiated by Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays (UHECR). The relative time delay of detection events between the detectors is used to estimate the angle of incidence of the shower. The FEDAM provides time-over-threshold measurements with a resolution of 2 ns. This allows determination of shower direction to an error of 0.035 (cos θ)-1 radians where θ is the angle between the baseline axis through a pair of detectors and the plane representing the shower front.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
-
A space-efficient quantum computer simulator suitable for high-speed FPGA implementation
Authors:
Michael P. Frank,
Liviu Oniciuc,
Uwe Meyer-Baese,
Irinel Chiorescu
Abstract:
Conventional vector-based simulators for quantum computers are quite limited in the size of the quantum circuits they can handle, due to the worst-case exponential growth of even sparse representations of the full quantum state vector as a function of the number of quantum operations applied. However, this exponential-space requirement can be avoided by using general space-time tradeoffs long kn…
▽ More
Conventional vector-based simulators for quantum computers are quite limited in the size of the quantum circuits they can handle, due to the worst-case exponential growth of even sparse representations of the full quantum state vector as a function of the number of quantum operations applied. However, this exponential-space requirement can be avoided by using general space-time tradeoffs long known to complexity theorists, which can be appropriately optimized for this particular problem in a way that also illustrates some interesting reformulations of quantum mechanics. In this paper, we describe the design and empirical space-time complexity measurements of a working software prototype of a quantum computer simulator that avoids excessive space requirements. Due to its space-efficiency, this design is well-suited to embedding in single-chip environments, permitting especially fast execution that avoids access latencies to main memory. We plan to prototype our design on a standard FPGA development board.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2009;
originally announced October 2009.
-
Space-Efficient Simulation of Quantum Computers
Authors:
Michael P. Frank,
Uwe H. Meyer-Baese,
Irinel Chiorescu,
Liviu Oniciuc,
Robert A. van Engelen
Abstract:
Traditional algorithms for simulating quantum computers on classical ones require an exponentially large amount of memory, and so typically cannot simulate general quantum circuits with more than about 30 or so qubits on a typical PC-scale platform with only a few gigabytes of main memory. However, more memory-efficient simulations are possible, requiring only polynomial or even linear space in…
▽ More
Traditional algorithms for simulating quantum computers on classical ones require an exponentially large amount of memory, and so typically cannot simulate general quantum circuits with more than about 30 or so qubits on a typical PC-scale platform with only a few gigabytes of main memory. However, more memory-efficient simulations are possible, requiring only polynomial or even linear space in the size of the quantum circuit being simulated. In this paper, we describe one such technique, which was recently implemented at FSU in the form of a C++ program called SEQCSim, which we releasing publicly. We also discuss the potential benefits of this simulation in quantum computing research and education, and outline some possible directions for further progress.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2009; v1 submitted 18 December, 2008;
originally announced December 2008.
-
The Indefinite Logarithm, Logarithmic Units, and the Nature of Entropy
Authors:
Michael P. Frank
Abstract:
We define the indefinite logarithm [log x] of a real number x>0 to be a mathematical object representing the abstract concept of the logarithm of x with an indeterminate base (i.e., not specifically e, 10, 2, or any fixed number). The resulting indefinite logarithmic quantities naturally play a mathematical role that is closely analogous to that of dimensional physical quantities (such as length…
▽ More
We define the indefinite logarithm [log x] of a real number x>0 to be a mathematical object representing the abstract concept of the logarithm of x with an indeterminate base (i.e., not specifically e, 10, 2, or any fixed number). The resulting indefinite logarithmic quantities naturally play a mathematical role that is closely analogous to that of dimensional physical quantities (such as length) in that, although these quantities have no definite interpretation as ordinary numbers, nevertheless the ratio of two of these entities is naturally well-defined as a specific, ordinary number, just like the ratio of two lengths. As a result, indefinite logarithm objects can serve as the basis for logarithmic spaces, which are natural systems of logarithmic units suitable for measuring any quantity defined on a logarithmic scale. We illustrate how logarithmic units provide a convenient language for explaining the complete conceptual unification of the disparate systems of units that are presently used for a variety of quantities that are conventionally considered distinct, such as, in particular, physical entropy and information-theoretic entropy.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2005;
originally announced June 2005.
-
On the Interpretation of Energy as the Rate of Quantum Computation
Authors:
Michael P. Frank
Abstract:
Over the last few decades, developments in the physical limits of computing and quantum computing have increasingly taught us that it can be helpful to think about physics itself in computational terms. For example, work over the last decade has shown that the energy of a quantum system limits the rate at which it can perform significant computational operations, and suggests that we might valid…
▽ More
Over the last few decades, developments in the physical limits of computing and quantum computing have increasingly taught us that it can be helpful to think about physics itself in computational terms. For example, work over the last decade has shown that the energy of a quantum system limits the rate at which it can perform significant computational operations, and suggests that we might validly interpret energy as in fact being the speed at which a physical system is "computing," in some appropriate sense of the word. In this paper, we explore the precise nature of this connection. Elementary results in quantum theory show that the Hamiltonian energy of any quantum system corresponds exactly to the angular velocity of state-vector rotation (defined in a certain natural way) in Hilbert space, and also to the rate at which the state-vector's components (in any basis) sweep out area in the complex plane. The total angle traversed (or area swept out) corresponds to the action of the Hamiltonian operator along the trajectory, and we can also consider it to be a measure of the "amount of computational effort exerted" by the system, or effort for short. For any specific quantum or classical computational operation, we can (at least in principle) calculate its difficulty, defined as the minimum effort required to perform that operation on a worst-case input state, and this in turn determines the minimum time required for quantum systems to carry out that operation on worst-case input states of a given energy. As examples, we calculate the difficulty of some basic 1-bit and n-bit quantum and classical operations in an simple unconstrained scenario.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2005; v1 submitted 9 September, 2004;
originally announced September 2004.
