-
High thermoelectric power factor through topological flat bands
Authors:
Fabian Garmroudi,
Illia Serhiienko,
Simone Di Cataldo,
Michael Parzer,
Alexander Riss,
Matthias Grasser,
Simon Stockinger,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Kacper Pryga,
Bartlomiej Wiendlocha,
Karsten Held,
Takao Mori,
Ernst Bauer,
Andrej Pustogow
Abstract:
Thermoelectric (TE) materials are useful for applications such as waste heat harvesting or efficient and targeted cooling. While various strategies towards superior thermoelectrics through a reduction of the lattice thermal conductivity have been developed, a path to enhance the power factor is pressing. Here, we report large power factors up to 5 mW m$^{-1}$ K$^{-2}$ at room temperature in the ka…
▽ More
Thermoelectric (TE) materials are useful for applications such as waste heat harvesting or efficient and targeted cooling. While various strategies towards superior thermoelectrics through a reduction of the lattice thermal conductivity have been developed, a path to enhance the power factor is pressing. Here, we report large power factors up to 5 mW m$^{-1}$ K$^{-2}$ at room temperature in the kagome metal Ni$_3$In$_{1-x}$Sn$_x$. This system is predicted to feature almost dispersionless flat bands in conjunction with highly dispersive Dirac-like bands in its electronic structure around the Fermi energy $E_\text{F}$ [L. Ye et al., Nature Physics 1-5 (2024)]. Within this study, we experimentally and theoretically showcase that tuning this flat band precisely below $E_\text{F}$ by chemical doping $x$ boosts the Seebeck coefficient and power factor, as highly mobile charge carriers scatter into the flat-band states. Our work demonstrates the prospect of engineering extremely flat and highly dispersive bands towards the Fermi energy in kagome metals and introduces topological flat bands as a novel tuning knob for thermoelectrics.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Strain-driven switching between antiferromagnetic states in frustrated antiferromagnet UO2 probed by exchange bias effect
Authors:
E. A. Tereshina-Chitrova,
L. V. Pourovskii,
S. Khmelevskyi,
L. Horak,
Z. Bao,
A. Mackova,
P. Malinsky,
T. Gouder,
R. Caciuffo
Abstract:
Frustrated antiferromagnets offer a captivating platform to study the intricate relationship of magnetic interactions, geometric constraints, and emergent phenomena. By controlling spin orientations, these materials can be tailored for applications in spintronics and quantum information processing. The research focuses on the interplay of magnetic and exchange anisotropy effects in artificial hete…
▽ More
Frustrated antiferromagnets offer a captivating platform to study the intricate relationship of magnetic interactions, geometric constraints, and emergent phenomena. By controlling spin orientations, these materials can be tailored for applications in spintronics and quantum information processing. The research focuses on the interplay of magnetic and exchange anisotropy effects in artificial heterostructures based on a canonical frustrated antiferromagnet, UO2. The potential to manipulate the spin directions in this material and switch between distinct antiferromagnetic states is investigated using substrate-induced strain. The phenomenon is probed using exchange bias (EB) effects in stoichiometric UO2/Fe3O4 bilayers. By employing many-body first-principles calculations magnetic configurations in the UO2 layers are identified. Even a minor tetragonal distortion triggers a transition between antiferromagnetic states of different symmetries, driven by a robust alteration of single-ion anisotropy due to the distortion. Consequently, this change influences the arrangement of magnetic moments at the UO2/Fe3O4 interface, affecting the magnitude of exchange bias. The findings showcase how epitaxial strain can effectively manipulate the antiferromagnetic states in frustrated antiferromagnets by controlling single-site anisotropy.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Non-collinear magnetism engendered by a hidden another order
Authors:
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Leonid V. Pourovskii
Abstract:
Standard microscopic approach to magnetic orders is based on assuming a Heisenberg form for inter-atomic exchange interactions. These interactions are considered as a driving force for the ordering transition with magnetic moments serving as the primary order parameter. Any higher-rank multipoles appearing simultaneously with such magnetic order are typically treated as auxiliary order parameters…
▽ More
Standard microscopic approach to magnetic orders is based on assuming a Heisenberg form for inter-atomic exchange interactions. These interactions are considered as a driving force for the ordering transition with magnetic moments serving as the primary order parameter. Any higher-rank multipoles appearing simultaneously with such magnetic order are typically treated as auxiliary order parameters rather than a principal cause of the transition. In this study, we show that these traditional assumptions are violated in the case of PrO$_2$. Evaluating the full set of Pr-Pr superexchange interactions from a first-principles many-body technique we find that its unusual non-collinear 2k magnetic structure stems from high-rank multipolar interactions, and that the corresponding contribution of the Heisenberg interactions is negligible. The observed magnetic order in PrO$_2$ is thus auxiliary to high-rank "hidden" multipoles. Within this picture we consistently account for previously unexplained experimental observations like the magnitude of exchange splitting and the evolution of magnetic structure in external field. Our findings challenge the standard paradigm of observable magnetic moments being the driving force for magnetic transitions.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
High thermoelectric performance in metallic NiAu alloys
Authors:
Fabian Garmroudi,
Michael Parzer,
Alexander Riss,
Cédric Bourgès,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Takao Mori,
Ernst Bauer,
Andrej Pustogow
Abstract:
Thermoelectric (TE) materials seamlessly convert thermal into electrical energy and vice versa, making them promising for applications such as power generation or cooling. Although historically the TE effect was first discovered in metals, state-of-the-art research mainly focuses on doped semiconductors with large figure of merit, $zT$, that determines the conversion efficiency of TE devices. Whil…
▽ More
Thermoelectric (TE) materials seamlessly convert thermal into electrical energy and vice versa, making them promising for applications such as power generation or cooling. Although historically the TE effect was first discovered in metals, state-of-the-art research mainly focuses on doped semiconductors with large figure of merit, $zT$, that determines the conversion efficiency of TE devices. While metallic alloys have superior functional properties, such as high ductility and mechanical strength, they have mostly been discarded from investigation in the past due to their small Seebeck effect. Here, we realize unprecedented TE performance in metals by tuning the energy-dependent electronic scattering. Based on our theoretical predictions, we identify binary NiAu alloys as promising candidate materials and experimentally discover colossal power factors up to 34 mWm$^{-1}$K$^{-2}$ (on average 30 mWm$^{-1}$K$^{-2}$ from 300 to 1100 K), which is more than twice larger than in any known bulk material above room temperature. This system reaches a $zT$ up to 0.5, setting a new world record value for metals. NiAu alloys are not only orders of magnitude more conductive than heavily doped semiconductors, but also have large Seebeck coefficients originating from an inherently different physical mechanism: within the Au s band conduction electrons are highly mobile while holes are scattered into more localized Ni d states, yielding a strongly energy-dependent carrier mobility. Our work challenges the common belief that good metals are bad thermoelectrics and presents an auspicious paradigm for achieving high TE performance in metallic alloys through engineering electron-hole selective s-d scattering.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Structure of the normal state and origin of Schottky anomaly in the correlated heavy fermion superconductor UTe2
Authors:
S. Khmelevskyi,
L. V. Pourovskii,
E. A. Tereshina-Chitrova
Abstract:
The newly discovered UTe2 superconductor is regarded as a heavy fermion mixed-valence system with very peculiar properties within the normal and superconducting states. It shows no signs of magnetic order but strong anisotropy of a magnetic susceptibility and a superconducting critical field. In addition to the heavy fermion-like behavior in the normal state, it exhibits also a distinctive Schottk…
▽ More
The newly discovered UTe2 superconductor is regarded as a heavy fermion mixed-valence system with very peculiar properties within the normal and superconducting states. It shows no signs of magnetic order but strong anisotropy of a magnetic susceptibility and a superconducting critical field. In addition to the heavy fermion-like behavior in the normal state, it exhibits also a distinctive Schottky-type anomaly at about 12 K and a characteristic excitations gap ~35-40 K. Here we show, by virtue of dynamical mean-field theory calculations with a quasi-atomic treatment of electron correlations, that ab-initio derived crystal-field splitting of the 5f2 ionic configuration yields an agreement with these experimental observations. We analyze the symmetry of magnetic and multipolar moment fluctuations that might lead to the superconducting pairing at low temperatures. A close analogy of the normal paramagnetic state of UTe2 to that of URu2Si2 in the Kondo arrest scenario is revealed.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Suppressed fluctuations as the origin of the static magnetic order in strained Sr$_2$RuO$_4$
Authors:
Bongjae Kim,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Cesare Franchini,
I. I. Mazin
Abstract:
Combining first principle density functional calculations and Moriya's self-consistent renormalization theory, we explain the recently reported counterintuitive appearance of an ordered magnetic state in uniaxially strained Sr$_2$RuO$_4$ beyond the Lifshits transition. We show that strain weakens the quantum spin fluctuations, which destroy the static order, more strongly than the tendency to magn…
▽ More
Combining first principle density functional calculations and Moriya's self-consistent renormalization theory, we explain the recently reported counterintuitive appearance of an ordered magnetic state in uniaxially strained Sr$_2$RuO$_4$ beyond the Lifshits transition. We show that strain weakens the quantum spin fluctuations, which destroy the static order, more strongly than the tendency to magnetism. A different rate of decrease of the spin fluctuations vs. magnetic stabilization energy promotes the onset of a static magnetic order beyond a critical strain.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2022; v1 submitted 28 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Interplay between multipolar spin interactions, Jahn-Teller effect and electronic correlation in a $J_{eff}=\frac{3}{2}$ insulator
Authors:
Dario Fiore Mosca,
Leonid V. Pourovskii,
Beom Hyun Kim,
Peitao Liu,
Samuele Sanna,
Federico Boscherini,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Cesare Franchini
Abstract:
In this work we study the complex entanglement between spin interactions, electron correlation and Janh-Teller structural instabilities in the 5d$^1$ $J_{eff}=\frac{3}{2}$ spin-orbit coupled double perovskite $\rm Ba_2NaOsO_6$ using first principles approaches. By combining non-collinear magnetic calculations with multipolar pseudospin Hamiltonian analysis and many-body techniques we elucidate the…
▽ More
In this work we study the complex entanglement between spin interactions, electron correlation and Janh-Teller structural instabilities in the 5d$^1$ $J_{eff}=\frac{3}{2}$ spin-orbit coupled double perovskite $\rm Ba_2NaOsO_6$ using first principles approaches. By combining non-collinear magnetic calculations with multipolar pseudospin Hamiltonian analysis and many-body techniques we elucidate the origin of the observed quadrupolar canted antifferomagnetic. We show that the non-collinear magnetic order originates from Jahn-Teller distortions due to the cooperation of Heisenberg exchange, quadrupolar spin-spin terms and both dipolar and multipolar Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interactions. We find a strong competition between ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic canted and collinear quadrupolar magnetic phases: the transition from one magnetic order to another can be controlled by the strength of the electronic correlation ($U$) and by the degree of Jahn-Teller distortions.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Hidden order and multipolar exchange striction in a correlated f-electron system
Authors:
Leonid V. Pourovskii,
Sergii Khmelevskyi
Abstract:
The nature of order in low-temperature phases of some materials is not directly seen by experiment. Such "hidden orders" (HO) may inspire decades of research to identify the mechanism underlying those exotic states of matter. In insulators, HO phases originate in degenerate many-electron states on localized f or d shells that may harbor high-rank multipole moments. Coupled by inter-site exchange,…
▽ More
The nature of order in low-temperature phases of some materials is not directly seen by experiment. Such "hidden orders" (HO) may inspire decades of research to identify the mechanism underlying those exotic states of matter. In insulators, HO phases originate in degenerate many-electron states on localized f or d shells that may harbor high-rank multipole moments. Coupled by inter-site exchange, those moments form a vast space of competing order parameters. Here, we show how the ground state order and magnetic excitations of a prototypical HO system, neptunium dioxide NpO$_2$, can be fully described by a low-energy Hamiltonian derived by a many-body ab initio force-theorem method. Superexchange interactions between the lowest crystal-field quadruplet of Np$^{4+}$ ions induce a primary non-collinear order of time-odd rank-5 (triakontadipolar) moments with a secondary quadrupole order preserving the cubic symmetry of NpO$_2$. Our study also reveals an unconventional multipolar exchange-striction mechanism behind the anomalous volume contraction of the NpO$_2$ HO phase.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2021; v1 submitted 18 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Ising superconductivity and magnetism in NbSe$_2$
Authors:
Darshana Wickramaratne,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Daniel F. Agterberg,
I. I. Mazin
Abstract:
Recent studies on superconductivity in NbSe$_2$ have demonstrated a large anisotropy in the superconducting critical field when the material is reduced to a single monolayer. Motivated by this recent discovery, we use density functional theory (DFT) calculations to quantitatively address the superconducting properties of bulk and monolayer NbSe$_2$. We demonstrate that NbSe$_2$ is close to a ferro…
▽ More
Recent studies on superconductivity in NbSe$_2$ have demonstrated a large anisotropy in the superconducting critical field when the material is reduced to a single monolayer. Motivated by this recent discovery, we use density functional theory (DFT) calculations to quantitatively address the superconducting properties of bulk and monolayer NbSe$_2$. We demonstrate that NbSe$_2$ is close to a ferromagnetic instability, and analyze our results in the context of experimental measurements of the spin susceptibility in NbSe$_2$. We show how this magnetic instability, which is pronounced in a single monolayer, can enable sizeable singlet-triplet mixing of the superconducting order parameter, contrary to contemporary considerations of the pairing symmetry in monolayer NbSe$_2$, and discuss approaches as to how this degree of mixing can be addressed quantitatively within our DFT framework. Our calculations also enable a quantitative description of the large anisotropy of the superconducting critical field, using DFT calculations of monolayer NbSe$_2$ in the normal state
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2020; v1 submitted 11 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Comparative ab initio study of the structural, electronic, magnetic, and dynamical properties of LiOsO$_3$ and NaOsO$_3$
Authors:
Peitao Liu,
Jiangang He,
Bongjae Kim,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Alessandro Toschi,
Georg Kresse,
Cesare Franchini
Abstract:
Despite similar chemical compositions, LiOsO$_3$ and NaOsO$_3$ exhibit remarkably distinct structural, electronic, magnetic, and spectroscopic properties. At low temperature, LiOsO$_3$ is a polar bad metal with a rhombohedral $R3c$ structure without the presence of long-range magnetic order, whereas NaOsO$_3$ is a $G$-type antiferromagnetic insulator with an orthorhombic $Pnma$ structure. By means…
▽ More
Despite similar chemical compositions, LiOsO$_3$ and NaOsO$_3$ exhibit remarkably distinct structural, electronic, magnetic, and spectroscopic properties. At low temperature, LiOsO$_3$ is a polar bad metal with a rhombohedral $R3c$ structure without the presence of long-range magnetic order, whereas NaOsO$_3$ is a $G$-type antiferromagnetic insulator with an orthorhombic $Pnma$ structure. By means of comparative first-principles DFT+$U$ calculations with the inclusion of the spin-orbit coupling, we ($i$) identify the origin of the different structural ($R3c$ vs. $Pnma$) properties using a symmetry-adapted soft mode analysis, ($ii$) provide evidence that all considered exchange-correlation functionals (LDA, PBE, PBEsol, SCAN, and HSE06) and the spin disordered polymorphous descriptions are unsatisfactory to accurately describe the electronic and magnetic properties of both systems simultaneously, and ($iii$) clarify that the distinct electronic (metallic vs. insulating) properties originates mainly from a cooperative steric and magnetic effect. Finally, we find that although at ambient pressure LiOsO$_3$ with a $Pnma$ symmetry and NaOsO$_3$ with a $R\bar{3}c$ symmetry are energetically unfavorable, they do not show soft phonons and therefore are dynamically stable. A pressure-induced structural phase transition from $R3c$ to $Pnma$ for LiOsO$_3$ is predicted, whereas for NaOsO$_3$ no symmetry change is discerned in the considered pressure range.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
SrRuO$_3$-SrTiO$_3$ heterostructure as a possible platform for studying unconventional superconductivity in Sr$_{2}$RuO$_{4}$
Authors:
Bongjae Kim,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Cesare Franchini,
I. I. Mazin,
Kyoo Kim
Abstract:
There is intense controversy around the unconventional superconductivity in strontium ruthenate, where the various theoretical and experimental studies suggest diverse and mutually exclusive pairing symmetries. Currently, the investigation is solely focused on only one material, Sr2RuO4, and the field suffers from the lack of comparison targets. Here, employing a density functional theory based an…
▽ More
There is intense controversy around the unconventional superconductivity in strontium ruthenate, where the various theoretical and experimental studies suggest diverse and mutually exclusive pairing symmetries. Currently, the investigation is solely focused on only one material, Sr2RuO4, and the field suffers from the lack of comparison targets. Here, employing a density functional theory based analysis, we show that the heterostructure composed of SrRuO3 and SrTiO3 is endowed with all the key characteristics of Sr2RuO4, and, in principle, can host superconductivity. Furthermore, we show that competing magnetic phases and associated frustration, naturally affecting the superconducting state, can be tuned by epitaxial strain engineering. This system thus offers an excellent platform for gaining more insight into superconductivity in ruthenates.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2020; v1 submitted 27 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Osmates on the verge of a Hund's-Mott transition: The different fates of NaOsO$_3$ and LiOsO$_3$
Authors:
Daniel Springer,
Bongjae Kim,
Peitao Liu,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Severino Adler,
Massimo Capone,
Giorgio Sangiovanni,
Cesare Franchini,
Alessandro Toschi
Abstract:
We clarify the origin of the strikingly different spectroscopic properties of the chemically similar compounds NaOsO$_3$ and LiOsO$_3$. Our first-principle many-body analysis demonstrates that the highly sensitive physics of these two materials is controlled by their proximity to an adjacent Hund's-Mott insulating phase. In mildly correlated $5d$ oxides, this physics is triggered by the {\sl coope…
▽ More
We clarify the origin of the strikingly different spectroscopic properties of the chemically similar compounds NaOsO$_3$ and LiOsO$_3$. Our first-principle many-body analysis demonstrates that the highly sensitive physics of these two materials is controlled by their proximity to an adjacent Hund's-Mott insulating phase. In mildly correlated $5d$ oxides, this physics is triggered by the {\sl cooperative} action of intraorbital repulsion and Hund's exchange in half-filled $t_{2g}$ outer-shells. Small material-specific details hence result in an extremely sharp change of the electronic mobility, explaining the surprisingly different properties of the paramagnetic high-temperature phases of the two compounds.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2020; v1 submitted 11 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Electron transport in high-entropy alloys: Al$_{x}$CrFeCoNi as a case study
Authors:
J. Kudrnovský,
V. Drchal,
F. Máca,
I. Turek,
S. Khmelevskyi
Abstract:
The high-entropy alloys Al$_{x}$CrFeCoNi exist over a broad range of Al concentrations ($0 < x < 2$). With increasing Al content their structure is changed from the fcc to bcc phase. We investigate the effect of such structural changes on transport properties including the residual resistivity and the anomalous Hall resistivity. We have performed a detailed comparison of the first-principles simul…
▽ More
The high-entropy alloys Al$_{x}$CrFeCoNi exist over a broad range of Al concentrations ($0 < x < 2$). With increasing Al content their structure is changed from the fcc to bcc phase. We investigate the effect of such structural changes on transport properties including the residual resistivity and the anomalous Hall resistivity. We have performed a detailed comparison of the first-principles simulations with available experimental data. We show that the calculated residual resistivities for all studied alloy compositions are in a fair agreement with available experimental data as concerns both the resistivity values and concentration trends. We emphasize that a good agreement with experiment was obtained also for the anomalous Hall resistivity. We have completed study by estimation of the anisotropic magnetoresistance, spin-disorder resistivity, and Gilbert damping. The obtained results prove that the main scattering mechanism is due to the intrinsic chemical disorder whereas the effect of spin polarization on the residual resistivity is appreciably weaker.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Nature of the magnetic moment of cobalt in ordered FeCo alloy
Authors:
Arsenii Gerasimov,
Lars Nordström,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Vladimir V. Mazurenko,
Yaroslav O. Kvashnin
Abstract:
The magnets are typically classified into Stoner and Heisenberg type, depending on the itinerant or localized nature of the constituent magnetic moments. In this work, we investigate theoretically the behaviour of the magnetic moments of iron and cobalt in their B2-ordered alloy. The results based on local spin density approximation (LSDA) for the density functional theory (DFT) suggest that the C…
▽ More
The magnets are typically classified into Stoner and Heisenberg type, depending on the itinerant or localized nature of the constituent magnetic moments. In this work, we investigate theoretically the behaviour of the magnetic moments of iron and cobalt in their B2-ordered alloy. The results based on local spin density approximation (LSDA) for the density functional theory (DFT) suggest that the Co magnetic moment strongly depends on the directions of the surrounding magnetic moments, which usually indicates the Stoner-type mechanism of magnetism. This is consistent with the disordered local moment (DLM) picture of the paramagnetic state, where the magnetic moment of cobalt gets substantially suppressed. We argue that this is due to the lack of strong on-site electron correlations, which we take into account by employing a combination of DFT and dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT). Within LDA+DMFT, we find a substantial quasiparticle mass renormalization and a non Fermi-liquid behaviour of Fe-$3d$ orbitals. The resulting spectral functions are in very good agreement with measured spin-resolved photoemission spectra. Our results suggest that local correlations play an essential role in stabilizing a robust local moment on Co in the absence of magnetic order at high temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2020; v1 submitted 15 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Doping-induced insulator-metal transition in the Lifshitz magnetic insulator NaOsO3
Authors:
Sabine Dobrovits,
Bongjae Kim,
Michele Reticcioli,
Alessandro Toschi,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Cesare Franchini
Abstract:
By means of first principles schemes based on magnetically constrained density functional theory and on the band unfolding technique we study the effect of doping on the conducting behaviour of the Lifshitz magnetic insulator NaOsO3. Electron doping is treated realistically within a supercell approach by replacing sodium with magnesium at different concentrations. Our data indicate that by increas…
▽ More
By means of first principles schemes based on magnetically constrained density functional theory and on the band unfolding technique we study the effect of doping on the conducting behaviour of the Lifshitz magnetic insulator NaOsO3. Electron doping is treated realistically within a supercell approach by replacing sodium with magnesium at different concentrations. Our data indicate that by increasing carrier concentration the system is subjected to two types of transition: (i) insulator to bad metal at low doping and low temperature and (ii) bad metal to metal at high doping and/or high-temperature. The predicted doping-induced insulator to metal transition (MIT) has similar traits with the temperature driven MIT reported in the undoped compound. Both develops in an itinerant background and exhibit a coupled electronic and magnetic behaviour characterized by the gradual quenching of the (pseudo)-gap associated with an reduction of the local spin moment. Unlike the temperature-driven MIT, chemical doping induces substantial modifications of the band structure and the MIT cannot be fully described as a Lifshitz process.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Quadrupolar Superexchange Interactions, Multipolar Order and Magnetic Phase Transition in UO$_2$
Authors:
Leonid V. Pourovskii,
Sergii Khmelevskyi
Abstract:
The origin of non-collinear magnetic order in UO$_{2}$ is studied by an ab initio dynamical-mean-field-theory framework in conjunction with a linear-response approach for evaluating inter-site superexchange interactions between U 5$f^{2}$ shells. The calculated quadrupole-quadruple superexchange interactions are found to unambiguously resolve the frustration of face-centered-cubic U sublattice tow…
▽ More
The origin of non-collinear magnetic order in UO$_{2}$ is studied by an ab initio dynamical-mean-field-theory framework in conjunction with a linear-response approach for evaluating inter-site superexchange interactions between U 5$f^{2}$ shells. The calculated quadrupole-quadruple superexchange interactions are found to unambiguously resolve the frustration of face-centered-cubic U sublattice toward stabilization of the experimentally observed non-collinear 3k-magnetic order. Therefore, the exotic 3k antiferromagnetic order in UO$_{2}$ can be accounted for by a purely electronic exchange mechanism acting in the undistorted cubic lattice structure. The quadrupolar short-range order above magnetic ordering temperature $T_N$ is found to qualitatively differ from the long-range order below $T_N$.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2019; v1 submitted 12 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Correlated excited states in the narrow gap band semiconductor FeSi and antiferromagnetic screening of local spin moments
Authors:
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Georg Kresse,
Peter Mohn
Abstract:
The physical properties of the semiconductor FeSi with very narrow band gap, anomalous behavior of the magnetic susceptibility and metal-insulator transition at elevated temperatures attract gross interest due to the still controversial theoretical understanding of their origin. On one side the purely band like mechanism of the gap formation in FeSi at low temperature is well established, on other…
▽ More
The physical properties of the semiconductor FeSi with very narrow band gap, anomalous behavior of the magnetic susceptibility and metal-insulator transition at elevated temperatures attract gross interest due to the still controversial theoretical understanding of their origin. On one side the purely band like mechanism of the gap formation in FeSi at low temperature is well established, on other side a number of experiments and their theoretical interpretation suggest a rich physics of strong correlations at finite temperature. In this work we use an ab-initio scheme based on the Random Phase Approximation and Local Spin Density Approximation (RPA@LSDA) to reveal the role of the electron correlation effects in FeSi extending it by applying a fixed spin moment constraint. In the parameter free framework we show that correlation effects essentially alter the one-electron LSDA results leading to the formation of an additional state with finite magnetic moment on Fe, whose energy is almost degenerate with the non-magnetic ground state. This explains the results of high field experiments, which found a first-order meta-magnetic phase transition into a metallic ferromagnetic state. Our results suggest a strongly correlated nature of the low-energy excitations in FeSi. From our super-cells calculations we reveal that these excitations are local and exhibit a Kondo-like behavior since a strong antiferromagnetic screening is present.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Longitudinal integration measure in classical spin space and its application to first-principle based simulations of the high temperature magnetism of Fe and Ni
Authors:
Sergii Khmelevskyi
Abstract:
The classical Heisenberg type spin Hamiltonian is widely used for simulations of finite temperature properties of magnetic metals often using parameters derived from first principles calculations. In itinerant electron systems, however, the atomic magnetic moments vary their amplitude with temperature and the spin Hamiltonian should thus be extended to incorporate the effects of longitudinal spin…
▽ More
The classical Heisenberg type spin Hamiltonian is widely used for simulations of finite temperature properties of magnetic metals often using parameters derived from first principles calculations. In itinerant electron systems, however, the atomic magnetic moments vary their amplitude with temperature and the spin Hamiltonian should thus be extended to incorporate the effects of longitudinal spin fluctuations (LSF). Although the simple phenomenological spin Hamiltonians describing LSF can be efficiently parameterized in the framework of the constrained Local Spin Density Approximation (LSDA) and its extensions, the fundamental problem concerning the integration in classical spin space remains. It is generally unknown how to integrate over the spin amplitude. Two intuitive choices of integration measure have been used up to date; the Murata-Doniach scalar measure and the simple three dimensional vector measure. Here we derive the integration measure by considering a classical limit of the quantum Heisenberg spin Hamiltonian under conditions leading to the proper classical limit of the commutation relations for all values of the classical spin amplitude and calculate the corresponding ratio of the number of quantum states. We show, that the number of quantum states corresponding to the considered classical spin amplitude is proportional to this amplitude and thus a non-trivial integration measure must be used. We apply our results to the first-principles simulation of the Curie temperatures of the two canonical ferromagnets bcc Fe and fcc Ni using a single-site LSF Hamiltonian with parameters calculated in the LSDA framework in the Disordered Local Moment approximation and a fixed spin moment constraint. In the same framework we compare our results with those obtained from the scalar and vector measures.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2018; v1 submitted 12 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Competing magnetic interactions in spin-1/2 square lattice: hidden order in Sr$_2$VO$_4$
Authors:
Bongjae Kim,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Peter Mohn,
Cesare Franchini
Abstract:
With decreasing temperature Sr$_2$VO$_4$ undergoes two structural phase transitions, tetragonal-to-orthorhombic-to-tetragonal, without long-range magnetic order. Recent experiments suggest, that only at very low temperature Sr$_{2}$VO$_{4}$ might enter some, yet unknown, phase with long-range magnetic order, but without orthorhombic distortion. By combining relativistic density functional theory w…
▽ More
With decreasing temperature Sr$_2$VO$_4$ undergoes two structural phase transitions, tetragonal-to-orthorhombic-to-tetragonal, without long-range magnetic order. Recent experiments suggest, that only at very low temperature Sr$_{2}$VO$_{4}$ might enter some, yet unknown, phase with long-range magnetic order, but without orthorhombic distortion. By combining relativistic density functional theory with an extended spin-1/2 compass-Heisenberg model we find an antiferromagnetic single-stripe ground state with highly competing exchange interactions, involving a non negligible inter-layer coupling, which places the system at the crossover between between the XY and Heisenberg picture. Most strikingly, we find a strong two-site "spin-compass" exchange anisotropy which is relieved by the orthorhombic distortion induced by the spin stripe order. Based on these results we discuss the origin of the hidden order phase and the possible formation of a spin-liquid at low temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Transport properties of iron at the Earth's core conditions: the effect of spin disorder
Authors:
V. Drchal,
J. Kudrnovský,
D. Wagenknecht,
I. Turek,
S. Khmelevskyi
Abstract:
The electronic and thermal transport properties of the Earth's core are crucial for many geophysical models such as the geodynamo model of the Earth's magnetic field and of its reversals. Here we show, by considering bcc-iron and iron-rich iron-silicon alloy as a representative of the Earth's core composition and applying the first-principles modeling that the spin disorder at the Earth's core con…
▽ More
The electronic and thermal transport properties of the Earth's core are crucial for many geophysical models such as the geodynamo model of the Earth's magnetic field and of its reversals. Here we show, by considering bcc-iron and iron-rich iron-silicon alloy as a representative of the Earth's core composition and applying the first-principles modeling that the spin disorder at the Earth's core conditions provides an essential contribution, of order 20~$μΩ$\,cm, to the electrical resistivity. This value is comparable in magnitude with the electron-phonon and with the recently estimated electron-electron scattering contributions. The origin of the spin-disorder resistivity (SDR) consists in the existence of fluctuating local moments that are stabilized at high temperatures by the magnetic entropy even at pressures at which the ground state of iron is non-magnetic. We find that electron-phonon and SDR contributions are not additive at high temperatures. We thus observe a large violation of the Matthiessen rule, not common in conventional metallic alloys at ambient conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 24 July, 2017; v1 submitted 9 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Anisotropy of magnetic interactions and symmetry of the order parameter in unconventional superconductor Sr$_{2}$RuO$_{4}$
Authors:
Bongjae Kim,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
I. I. Mazin,
D. F. Agterberg,
Cesare Franchini
Abstract:
Sr$_2$RuO$_4$ is the best candidate for spin-triplet superconductivity, an unusual and elusive superconducting state of fundamental importance. In the last three decades Sr$_2$RuO$_4$ has been very carefully studied and despite its apparent simplicity when compared with strongly correlated high-$T_{c}$ cuprates, for which the pairing symmetry is understood, there is no scenario that can explain al…
▽ More
Sr$_2$RuO$_4$ is the best candidate for spin-triplet superconductivity, an unusual and elusive superconducting state of fundamental importance. In the last three decades Sr$_2$RuO$_4$ has been very carefully studied and despite its apparent simplicity when compared with strongly correlated high-$T_{c}$ cuprates, for which the pairing symmetry is understood, there is no scenario that can explain all the major experimental observations, a conundrum that has generated tremendous interest. Here we present a density-functional based analysis of magnetic interactions in Sr$_{2}$RuO$_{4}$ and discuss the role of magnetic anisotropy in its unconventional superconductivity. Our goal is twofold. First, we access the possibility of the superconducting order parameter rotation in an external magnetic field of 200 Oe, and conclude that the spin-orbit interaction in this material is several orders of magnitude too strong to be consistent with this hypothesis. Thus, the observed invariance of the Knight shift across $T_{c}$ has no plausible explanation, and casts doubt on using the Knight shift as an ultimate litmus paper for the pairing symmetry. Second, we propose a quantitative double-exchange-like model for combining itinerant fermions with an anisotropic Heisenberg magnetic Hamiltonian. This model is complementary to the Hubbard-model-based calculations published so far, and forms an alternative framework for exploring superconducting symmetry in Sr$_{2}$RuO$_{4}.$ As an example, we use this model to analyze the degeneracy between various $p-$triplet states in the simplest mean-field approximation, and show that it splits into a single and two doublets with the ground state defined by the competition between the "Ising" and "compass" anisotropic terms.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2017; v1 submitted 13 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Lifshitz transition driven by spin fluctuations and spin-orbit renormalization in NaOsO$_3$
Authors:
Bongjae Kim,
Peitao Liu,
Zeynep Ergönenc,
Alessandro Toschi,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Cesare Franchini
Abstract:
In systems where electrons form both dispersive bands and small local spins, we show that changes of the spin configuration can tune the bands through a Lifshitz transition, resulting in a continuous metal-insulator transition associated with a progressive change of the Fermi surface topology. In contrast to a Mott-Hubbard and Slater pictures, this spin-driven Lifshitz transition appears in system…
▽ More
In systems where electrons form both dispersive bands and small local spins, we show that changes of the spin configuration can tune the bands through a Lifshitz transition, resulting in a continuous metal-insulator transition associated with a progressive change of the Fermi surface topology. In contrast to a Mott-Hubbard and Slater pictures, this spin-driven Lifshitz transition appears in systems with small electron-electron correlation and large hybridization. We show that this situation is realized in 5$d$ distorted perovskites with an half-filled $t_{2g}$ bands such as NaOsO$_3$, where the strong $p-d$ hybridization reduces the local moment, and spin-orbit coupling causes a large renormalization of the electronic mobility. This weakens the role of electronic correlations and drives the system towards an itinerant magnetic regime which enables spin-fluctuations.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2016; v1 submitted 13 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Magnetism of gadolinium: a first-principles perspective
Authors:
László Oroszlány,
András Deák,
Sergeii Khmelevskyi,
László Szunyogh
Abstract:
By calculating the spectral density of states in the ferromagnetic (FM) ground state and in the high temperature paramagnetic (PM) phase we provide the first concise study of finite temperature effects on the electronic structure of the bulk and the surface of gadolinium metal. The variation of calculated spectral properties of the Fermi surface and the density of states in the bulk and at the sur…
▽ More
By calculating the spectral density of states in the ferromagnetic (FM) ground state and in the high temperature paramagnetic (PM) phase we provide the first concise study of finite temperature effects on the electronic structure of the bulk and the surface of gadolinium metal. The variation of calculated spectral properties of the Fermi surface and the density of states in the bulk and at the surface are in good agreement with recent photoemission experiments performed in both ferromagnetic and paramagnetic phases. In the paramagnetic state we find vanishing spin splitting of the conduction band, but finite local spin moments both in bulk and at the surface. We clearly demonstrate that the formation of these local spin moments in the conduction band is due to the asymmetry of the density of states in the two spin channels, suggesting a complex, non-Stoner behavior. We, therefore, suggest that the vanishing or nearly vanishing spin splitting of spectral features cannot be used as an indicator for Stoner-like magnetism.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Anisotropic Magnetic Couplings and Structure-Driven Canted to Collinear Transitions in Spin-orbit Coupled Sr2IrO4
Authors:
Peitao Liu,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Bongjae Kim,
Martijn Marsman,
Dianzhong Li,
Xing-Qiu Chen,
D. D. Sarma,
Georg Kresse,
Cesare Franchini
Abstract:
We put forward a scheme to study the anisotropic magnetic couplings in Sr2IrO4 by mapping fully relativistic constrained noncollinear density functional theory including an on-site Hubbard U correction onto a general spin model Hamiltonian. This procedure allows for the simultaneous account and direct control of the lattice, spin and orbital interactions within a fully ab initio scheme. We compute…
▽ More
We put forward a scheme to study the anisotropic magnetic couplings in Sr2IrO4 by mapping fully relativistic constrained noncollinear density functional theory including an on-site Hubbard U correction onto a general spin model Hamiltonian. This procedure allows for the simultaneous account and direct control of the lattice, spin and orbital interactions within a fully ab initio scheme. We compute the isotropic, single site anisotropy and Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya (DM) coupling parameters, and clarify that the origin of the canted magnetic state in Sr2IrO4 arises from the interplay between structural distortions and the competition between isotropic exchange and DM interactions. A complete magnetic phase diagram with respect to the tetragonal distortion and the rotation of IrO6 octahedra is constructed, revealing the presence of two types of canted to collinear magnetic transitions: a spin-flop transition with increasing tetragonal distortion and a complete quenching of the basal weak ferromagnetic moment below a critical octahedral rotation.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2015; v1 submitted 23 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Antiferromagnetism in Ru2MnZ (Z=Sn, Sb, Ge, Si) full Heusler alloys: effects of magnetic frustration and chemical disorder
Authors:
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Eszter Simon,
Laszlo Szunyogh
Abstract:
We present systematic theoretical investigations to explore the microscopic mechanisms leading to the formation of antiferromagnetism in Ru2MnZ (Z= Sn,Sb,Ge,Si) full Heusler alloys. Our study is based on first-principles calculations of inter-atomic Mn-Mn exchange interactions to set up a suitable Heisenberg spin-model and on subsequent Monte-Carlo simulations of the magnetic properties at finite…
▽ More
We present systematic theoretical investigations to explore the microscopic mechanisms leading to the formation of antiferromagnetism in Ru2MnZ (Z= Sn,Sb,Ge,Si) full Heusler alloys. Our study is based on first-principles calculations of inter-atomic Mn-Mn exchange interactions to set up a suitable Heisenberg spin-model and on subsequent Monte-Carlo simulations of the magnetic properties at finite temperature. The exchange interactions are derived from the paramagnetic state, while a realistic account of long-range chemical disorder is made in the framework of the Coherent Potential Approximation. We find that in case of the highly ordered alloys (Z=Sn and Sb) the exchange interactions derived from the perfectly ordered L21 structure lead to Néel temperatures in excellent agreement with the experiments, whereas, in particular, in case of Si the consideration of chemical disorder is essential to reproduce the experimental Néel temperatures. Our numerical results suggest that improving a heat treatment of the samples to suppress the intermixing between the Mn and Si atoms, the Néel temperature of the Si-based alloys can potentially be increased by more than 30%. Furthermore, we show that in strongly disordered Ru2MnSi alloys a distinct change in the antiferromagnetic ordering occurs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Antiferromagnetic ground state in NpCoGe
Authors:
E. Colineau,
J. -C. Griveau,
R. Eloirdi,
P. Gaczyński,
S. Khmelevskyi,
A. B. Shick,
R. Caciuffo
Abstract:
NpCoGe, the neptunium analogue of the ferromagnetic superconductor UCoGe, has been investigated by dc-magnetization, ac-susceptibility, specific heat, electrical resistivity, Hall effect, 237Np Moessbauer spectroscopy and LSDA calculations. NpCoGe exhibits an antiferromagnetic ground state with a Neel temperature TN = 13 K and an average ordered magnetic moment <mNp> = 0.80 mB. The magnetic phase…
▽ More
NpCoGe, the neptunium analogue of the ferromagnetic superconductor UCoGe, has been investigated by dc-magnetization, ac-susceptibility, specific heat, electrical resistivity, Hall effect, 237Np Moessbauer spectroscopy and LSDA calculations. NpCoGe exhibits an antiferromagnetic ground state with a Neel temperature TN = 13 K and an average ordered magnetic moment <mNp> = 0.80 mB. The magnetic phase diagram has been determined and shows that the antiferromagnetic structure is destroyed by the application of a magnetic field (around 3 T). The value of the isomer shift suggests a Np3+ charge state (configuration 5f4). A high Sommerfeld coefficient value for NpCoGe (170 mJ mol-1K-2) is inferred from specific heat. LSDA calculations indicate strong magnetic anisotropy and easy magnetization along the c-axis. Moessbauer data and calculated exchange interactions support the possible occurrence of an elliptical spin spiral structure in NpCoGe. The comparison with NpRhGe and uranium analogues suggests the leading role of 5f-d hybridization, the rather delocalized character of 5f electrons in NpCoGe and the possible proximity of NpRuGe or NpFeGe to a magnetic quantum critical point.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2014; v1 submitted 18 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
One-dimensional magnetism in one-dimensional metallic chains in bulk MnB4
Authors:
S. Khmelevskyi,
J. Redinger,
A. B. Shick,
P. Mohn
Abstract:
We have investigated from first-principles an electronic structure and magnetism in MnB4 compound with experimentally observed orthorhombic C12/m1 structure. It is found that Mn tetra-borides (MnB4) is found to have metallic ground state with well defined local Mn magnetic moments. This conclusion was drawn from calculation within full potential Linear Augmented Plane Wave method and Korringa-Kohn…
▽ More
We have investigated from first-principles an electronic structure and magnetism in MnB4 compound with experimentally observed orthorhombic C12/m1 structure. It is found that Mn tetra-borides (MnB4) is found to have metallic ground state with well defined local Mn magnetic moments. This conclusion was drawn from calculation within full potential Linear Augmented Plane Wave method and Korringa-Kohn-Rostocker method using Disordered Local Moment Approximation. We have shown using Lichtenstein Green function method that magnetic exchange interactions between Mn moments are strongly ferromagnetic along 1D-chains of Mn atoms and they are practically vanishing between the chains. The metallic state appears to exhibit a strongly one-dimensional character since the single metallic band show dispersion only in one reciprocal lattice dimension. Thus it appears that MnB4 may be a perfect one-dimensional one-band Hubbard model system. Although LSDA predicts the magnetism in this system it may well be superconductor at low temperatures due to the correlation effects beyond mean field like approach.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Non-collinear magnetic ordering in compressed FePd$_3$ ordered alloy: a first principles study
Authors:
Y. O. Kvashnin,
S. Khmelevskyi,
J. Kudrnovský,
A. N. Yaresko,
L. Genovese,
P. Bruno
Abstract:
By means of ab initio calculations based on the density functional theory we investigated magnetic phase diagram of ordered FePd$_3$ alloy as a function of external pressure.
Considering several magnetic configurations we concluded that the system under pressure has a tendency to non-collinear spin alignment. Analysis of the Heisenberg exchange parameters $J_{ij}$ revealed strong dependence of i…
▽ More
By means of ab initio calculations based on the density functional theory we investigated magnetic phase diagram of ordered FePd$_3$ alloy as a function of external pressure.
Considering several magnetic configurations we concluded that the system under pressure has a tendency to non-collinear spin alignment. Analysis of the Heisenberg exchange parameters $J_{ij}$ revealed strong dependence of iron-iron magnetic couplings on polarization of Pd atoms. To take into account the latter effect we built an extended Heisenberg model with higher order (biquadratic) terms. Minimizing the energy of this Hamiltonian, fully parameterized using the results of ab initio calculations, we found a candidate for a ground state of compressed FePd$_3$, which can be seen as two interpenetrating "triple-Q" phases.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2012; v1 submitted 19 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Spin-orbit coupling induced anisotropy effects in bimetallic antiferromagnets: A route towards antiferromagnetic spintronics
Authors:
Alexander B. Shick,
Sergii Khmelevskyi,
Oleg N. Mryasov,
Joerg Wunderlich,
Tomas Jungwirth
Abstract:
Magnetic anisotropy phenomena in bimetallic antiferromagnets Mn$_2$Au and MnIr are studied by first-principles density functional theory calculations. We find strong and lattice-parameter dependent magnetic anisotropies of the ground state energy, chemical potential, and density of states, and attribute these anisotropies to combined effects of large moment on the Mn 3$d$ shell and large spin-or…
▽ More
Magnetic anisotropy phenomena in bimetallic antiferromagnets Mn$_2$Au and MnIr are studied by first-principles density functional theory calculations. We find strong and lattice-parameter dependent magnetic anisotropies of the ground state energy, chemical potential, and density of states, and attribute these anisotropies to combined effects of large moment on the Mn 3$d$ shell and large spin-orbit coupling on the 5$d$ shell of the noble metal. Large magnitudes of the proposed effects can open a route towards spintronics in compensated antiferromagnets without involving ferromagnetic elements.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
-
Weak itinerant ferromagnetism in YCo9Si4
Authors:
H. Michor,
M. El-Hagary,
S. Oezcan,
A. Horyn,
E. Bauer,
M. Reissner,
G. Hilscher,
S. Khmelevskyi,
P. Mohn,
P. Rogl
Abstract:
Weak itinerant ferromagnetism in YCo9Si4 below about 25 K is studied by means of magnetisation, specific heat, and resistivity measurements. Single crystal X-ray Rietveld refinements at room temperature reveal a fully ordered distribution of Y, Co and Si atoms within the tetragonal space group I4/mcm isostructural with LaCo9Si4. The latter exhibits itinerant electron metamagnetism with an induce…
▽ More
Weak itinerant ferromagnetism in YCo9Si4 below about 25 K is studied by means of magnetisation, specific heat, and resistivity measurements. Single crystal X-ray Rietveld refinements at room temperature reveal a fully ordered distribution of Y, Co and Si atoms within the tetragonal space group I4/mcm isostructural with LaCo9Si4. The latter exhibits itinerant electron metamagnetism with an induced moment of about 1 mu_B/f.u. above 6 T, whereas YCo9Si4 exhibits a spontaneous magnetisation M0~12 Am^2/kg at 2 K which corresponds to an ordered moment of about 1.6 mu_B/f.u. indicating weak itinerant ferromagnetism.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2004;
originally announced June 2004.
-
Itinerant electron metamagnetism in LaCo$_9$Si$_4$
Authors:
H. Michor,
M. El-Hagary,
M. DellaMea,
M. W Pieper,
M. Reissner,
G. Hilscher,
S. Khmelevskyi,
P. Mohn,
G. Schneider,
G. Giester,
P. Rogl
Abstract:
The strongly exchange enhanced Pauli paramagnet LaCo$_9$Si$_4$ is found to exhibit an itinerant metamagnetic phase transition with indications for metamagnetic quantum criticality. Our investigation comprises magnetic, specific heat, and NMR measurements as well as ab-initio electronic structure calculations. The critical field is about 3.5 T for $H||c$ and 6 T for $H\bot c$, which is the lowest…
▽ More
The strongly exchange enhanced Pauli paramagnet LaCo$_9$Si$_4$ is found to exhibit an itinerant metamagnetic phase transition with indications for metamagnetic quantum criticality. Our investigation comprises magnetic, specific heat, and NMR measurements as well as ab-initio electronic structure calculations. The critical field is about 3.5 T for $H||c$ and 6 T for $H\bot c$, which is the lowest value ever found for rare earth intermetallic compounds. In the ferromagnetic state there appears a moment of about 0.2 $μ_B$/Co at the $16k$ Co-sites, but sigificantly smaller moments at the 4d and $16l$ Co-sites.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2003; v1 submitted 9 September, 2003;
originally announced September 2003.