-
Galaxy-Classification Activity for All Ages
Authors:
Kathy L. Cooksey,
Anne J. Metevier,
Kate H. R. Rubin,
Philip I. Choi,
Lynne Raschke
Abstract:
Classification is a general tool of science; it is used to sort and categorize biological organisms, chemical elements, astronomical objects, and many other things. In scientific classification, taxonomy often reflects shared physical properties that, in turn, may indicate shared origins and/or evolution. A "hands-on" galaxy-classification activity developed and implemented by Professional Develop…
▽ More
Classification is a general tool of science; it is used to sort and categorize biological organisms, chemical elements, astronomical objects, and many other things. In scientific classification, taxonomy often reflects shared physical properties that, in turn, may indicate shared origins and/or evolution. A "hands-on" galaxy-classification activity developed and implemented by Professional Development Program (PDP) participants, for a high-school summer STEM enrichment program, has been adopted for various age groups and venues, from young (K-3) to college students. We detail the basic tools required, outline the general activity, and describe the modifications to the activity based on learners' ages and learning objectives. We describe the facilitation strategies learned through PDP training and used when implementing the activity, including prompts to motivate the students. We also discuss how we connected the classification process to astronomy and science more broadly during the concluding remarks.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Using the Big Ideas in Cosmology to Teach College Students
Authors:
Kevin M. McLin,
Lynn R. Cominsky,
Anne J. Metevier,
Kimberly Coble,
Janelle M. Bailey
Abstract:
Recent advances in our understanding of the Universe have revolutionized our view of its structure, composition and evolution. However, these new ideas have not necessarily been used to improve the teaching of introductory astronomy students. In this project, we have conducted research into student understanding of cosmological ideas so as to develop effective web-based tools to teach basic concep…
▽ More
Recent advances in our understanding of the Universe have revolutionized our view of its structure, composition and evolution. However, these new ideas have not necessarily been used to improve the teaching of introductory astronomy students. In this project, we have conducted research into student understanding of cosmological ideas so as to develop effective web-based tools to teach basic concepts important to modern cosmology. The tools are intended for use at the introductory college level. Our research uses several instruments, including open-ended and multiple choice surveys conducted at multiple institutions, as well as interviews and course artifacts at one institution, to ascertain what students know regarding modern cosmological ideas, what common misunderstandings and misconceptions they entertain, and what sorts of materials can most effectively overcome student difficulties in learning this material. These data are being used to create a suite of interactive, web-based tutorials that address the major ideas in cosmology using real data. Having students engage with real data is a powerful means to help students overcome certain misconceptions. Students master the scientific concepts and reasoning processes that lead to our current understanding of the universe through interactive tasks, prediction and reflection, experimentation, and model building.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2013;
originally announced March 2013.
-
The Epoch of Disk Settling: z~1 to Now
Authors:
Susan A. Kassin,
Benjamin J. Weiner,
S. M. Faber,
Jonathan P. Gardner,
C. N. A. Willmer,
Alison L. Coil,
Michael C. Cooper,
Julien Devriendt,
Aaron A. Dutton,
Puragra Guhathakurta,
David C. Koo,
A. J. Metevier,
Kai G. Noeske,
Joel R. Primack
Abstract:
We present evidence from a sample of 544 galaxies from the DEEP2 Survey for evolution of the internal kinematics of blue galaxies with stellar masses ranging 8.0 < log M* (M_Sun) < 10.7 over 0.2<z<1.2. DEEP2 provides galaxy spectra and Hubble imaging from which we measure emission-line kinematics and galaxy inclinations, respectively. Our large sample allows us to overcome scatter intrinsic to gal…
▽ More
We present evidence from a sample of 544 galaxies from the DEEP2 Survey for evolution of the internal kinematics of blue galaxies with stellar masses ranging 8.0 < log M* (M_Sun) < 10.7 over 0.2<z<1.2. DEEP2 provides galaxy spectra and Hubble imaging from which we measure emission-line kinematics and galaxy inclinations, respectively. Our large sample allows us to overcome scatter intrinsic to galaxy properties in order to examine trends in kinematics. We find that at a fixed stellar mass galaxies systematically decrease in disordered motions and increase in rotation velocity and potential well depth with time. Massive galaxies are the most well-ordered at all times examined, with higher rotation velocities and less disordered motions than less massive galaxies. We quantify disordered motions with an integrated gas velocity dispersion corrected for beam smearing (sigma_g). It is unlike the typical pressure-supported velocity dispersion measured for early type galaxies and galaxy bulges. Because both seeing and the width of our spectral slits comprise a significant fraction of the galaxy sizes, sigma_g integrates over velocity gradients on large scales which can correspond to non-ordered gas kinematics. We compile measurements of galaxy kinematics from the literature over 1.2<z<3.8 and do not find any trends with redshift, likely for the most part because these datasets are biased toward the most highly star-forming systems. In summary, over the last ~8 billion years since z=1.2, blue galaxies evolve from disordered to ordered systems as they settle to become the rotation-dominated disk galaxies observed in the Universe today, with the most massive galaxies being the most evolved at any time.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2012;
originally announced July 2012.
-
CATS: Optical to Near-Infrared Colors of the Bulge and Disk of Two z=0.7 Galaxies Using HST and Keck Laser Adaptive Optics Imaging
Authors:
E. Steinbring,
J. Melbourne,
A. J. Metevier,
D. C. Koo,
M. R. Chun,
L. Simard,
J. E. Larkin,
C. E. Max
Abstract:
We have employed laser guide star (LGS) adaptive optics (AO) on the Keck II telescope to obtain near-infrared (NIR) images in the Extended Groth Strip (EGS) deep galaxy survey field. This is a continuation of our Center for Adaptive Optics Treasury Survey (CATS) program of targeting 0.5<z<1 galaxies where existing images with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) are already in hand. Our AO field has…
▽ More
We have employed laser guide star (LGS) adaptive optics (AO) on the Keck II telescope to obtain near-infrared (NIR) images in the Extended Groth Strip (EGS) deep galaxy survey field. This is a continuation of our Center for Adaptive Optics Treasury Survey (CATS) program of targeting 0.5<z<1 galaxies where existing images with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) are already in hand. Our AO field has already been imaged by the Advanced Camera for Surveys (ACS) and the Near Infared Camera and Multiobject Spectrograph (NICMOS). Our AO images at 2.2 microns (K') are comparable in depth to those from HST, have Strehl ratios up to 0.4, and FWHM resolutions superior to that from NICMOS. By sampling the field with the LGS at different positions, we obtain better quality AO images than with an immovable natural guide star. As examples of the power of adding LGS AO to HST data we study the optical to NIR colors and color gradients of the bulge and disk of two galaxies in the field with z=0.7.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2008;
originally announced July 2008.
-
The Stellar Mass Tully-Fisher Relation to z=1.2 from AEGIS
Authors:
Susan A. Kassin,
Benjamin J. Weiner,
S. M. Faber,
David C. Koo,
Jennifer M. Lotz,
Jürg Diemand,
Justin J. Harker,
Kevin Bundy,
A. J. Metevier,
Andrew C. Phillips,
Michael C. Cooper,
Darren J. Croton,
Nicholas Konidaris,
Kai G. Noeske,
C. N. A. Willmer
Abstract:
We combine newly measured rotation velocities, velocity dispersions, and stellar masses to construct stellar mass Tully-Fisher relations (M*TFRs) for 544 galaxies with strong emission lines at 0.1<z<1.2 from the All Wavelength Extended Groth Strip International Survey (AEGIS) and the Deep Extragalactic Evolutionary Probe 2 Survey (DEEP2). The conventional M*TFR using only rotation velocity (Vrot…
▽ More
We combine newly measured rotation velocities, velocity dispersions, and stellar masses to construct stellar mass Tully-Fisher relations (M*TFRs) for 544 galaxies with strong emission lines at 0.1<z<1.2 from the All Wavelength Extended Groth Strip International Survey (AEGIS) and the Deep Extragalactic Evolutionary Probe 2 Survey (DEEP2). The conventional M*TFR using only rotation velocity (Vrot) shows large scatter (~1.5 dex in velocity). The scatter and residuals are correlated with morphology in the sense that disturbed, compact, and major merger galaxies have lower velocities for their masses. We construct an M*TFR using the kinematic estimator S_0.5 which is defined as sqrt(0.5Vrot^2 + sigma_g^2) and accounts for disordered or non-circular motions through the gas velocity dispersion (sigma_g). The new M*TFR, termed S_0.5/M*TFR, is remarkably tight over 0.1<z<1.2 with no detectable evolution of its intercept or slope with redshift. The average best fit relation has 0.47 dex scatter in stellar mass, corresponding to ~1.2 'magnitudes,' assuming a constant mass-to-light ratio. Interestingly, the S_0.5/M*TFR is consistent with the absorption-line based stellar mass Faber-Jackson relation for nearby elliptical galaxies in terms of slope and intercept, which might suggest a physical connection between the two relations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2007; v1 submitted 23 February, 2007;
originally announced February 2007.
-
A Survey of Galaxy Kinematics to z ~ 1 in the TKRS/GOODS-N Field. II. Evolution in the Tully-Fisher Relation
Authors:
Benjamin J. Weiner,
Christopher N. A. Willmer,
S. M. Faber,
Justin Harker,
Susan A. Kassin,
Andrew C. Phillips,
Jason Melbourne,
A. J. Metevier,
N. P. Vogt,
D. C. Koo
Abstract:
We use kinematic measurements of a large sample of galaxies from the Team Keck Redshift Survey in the GOODS-N field to measure evolution in the optical and near-IR Tully-Fisher relations to z = 1.2. We construct Tully-Fisher relations with integrated line-of-sight velocity widths of ~ 1000 galaxies in B and ~ 670 in J-band; these relations have large scatter, and we derive a maximum-likelihood l…
▽ More
We use kinematic measurements of a large sample of galaxies from the Team Keck Redshift Survey in the GOODS-N field to measure evolution in the optical and near-IR Tully-Fisher relations to z = 1.2. We construct Tully-Fisher relations with integrated line-of-sight velocity widths of ~ 1000 galaxies in B and ~ 670 in J-band; these relations have large scatter, and we derive a maximum-likelihood least squares method for fitting in the presence of scatter. The B-band Tully-Fisher relations, from z=0.4 to z=1.2, show evolution of ~ 1.0-1.5 mag internal to our sample without requiring calibration to a local TF relation. There is evolution in both Tully-Fisher intercept and slope, suggesting differential luminosity evolution. In J-band, there is evolution in slope but little evolution in overall luminosity. The slope measurements imply that bright, massive blue galaxies fade {\it more strongly} than fainter blue galaxies from z ~ 1.2 to now. This conclusion runs counter to some previous measurements and to our naive expectations, but we present a simple set of star formation histories to show that it arises naturally if massive galaxies have shorter timescales of star formation, forming most of their stars before z ~ 1, while less massive galaxies form stars at more slowly declining rates. This model predicts that the higher global star formation rate at z ~ 1 is mostly due to higher SFR in massive galaxies. The amount of fading in B-band constrains star formation timescale more strongly than redshift of formation. Tully-Fisher and color-magnitude relations can provide global constraints on the luminosity evolution and star formation history of blue galaxies.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
-
A Survey of Galaxy Kinematics to z ~ 1 in the TKRS/GOODS-N Field. I. Rotation and Dispersion Properties
Authors:
Benjamin J. Weiner,
Christopher N. A. Willmer,
S. M. Faber,
Jason Melbourne,
Susan A. Kassin,
Andrew C. Phillips,
Justin Harker,
A. J. Metevier,
N. P. Vogt,
D. C. Koo
Abstract:
We present kinematic measurements of a large sample of galaxies from the TKRS Survey in the GOODS-N field. We measure line-of-sight velocity dispersions from integrated emission for 1089 galaxies with median z=0.637, and spatially resolved kinematics for a subsample of 380 galaxies. This is the largest sample of galaxies to z ~ 1 with kinematics to date, and allows us to measure kinematic proper…
▽ More
We present kinematic measurements of a large sample of galaxies from the TKRS Survey in the GOODS-N field. We measure line-of-sight velocity dispersions from integrated emission for 1089 galaxies with median z=0.637, and spatially resolved kinematics for a subsample of 380 galaxies. This is the largest sample of galaxies to z ~ 1 with kinematics to date, and allows us to measure kinematic properties without morphological pre-selection. Emission linewidths provide kinematics for the bulk of blue galaxies. To fit the spatially resolved kinematics, we fit models with both line-of-sight rotation amplitude and velocity dispersion. Integrated linewidth correlates well with a combination of the rotation gradient and dispersion, and is a robust measure of galaxy kinematics. The spatial extents of emission and continuum are similar and there is no evidence that linewidths are affected by nuclear or clumpy emission. The measured rotation gradient depends strongly on slit PA alignment with galaxy major axis, but integrated linewidth does not. Even for galaxies with well-aligned slits, some have kinematics dominated by dispersion (V/sigma<1) rather than rotation. These are probably objects with disordered velocity fields, not dynamically hot stellar systems. About 35% of the resolved sample are dispersion dominated; galaxies that are both dispersion dominated and bright exist at high redshift but appear rare at low redshift. This kinematic morphology is linked to photometric morphology in HST/ACS images: dispersion dominated galaxies include a higher fraction of irregulars and chain galaxies, while rotation dominated galaxies are mostly disks and irregulars. Only one-third of chain/hyphen galaxies are dominated by rotation; high-z elongated objects cannot be assumed to be inclined disks. (Abridged)
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
-
The Tully-Fisher Relation in Cluster Cl0024+1654 at z=0.4
Authors:
Anne J. Metevier,
David C. Koo,
Luc Simard,
Andrew C. Phillips
Abstract:
Using moderate-resolution Keck spectra, we have examined the velocity profiles of 15 members of cluster Cl0024+1654 at z=0.4. WFPC2 images of the cluster members have been used to determine structural parameters, including disk sizes, orientations, and inclinations. We compare two methods of optical rotation curve analysis for kinematic measurements. Both methods take seeing, slit size and orien…
▽ More
Using moderate-resolution Keck spectra, we have examined the velocity profiles of 15 members of cluster Cl0024+1654 at z=0.4. WFPC2 images of the cluster members have been used to determine structural parameters, including disk sizes, orientations, and inclinations. We compare two methods of optical rotation curve analysis for kinematic measurements. Both methods take seeing, slit size and orientation, and instrumental effects into account and yield similar rotation velocity measurements. Four of the galaxies in our sample exhibit unusual kinematic signatures, such as non-circular motions. Our key result is that the Cl0024 galaxies are marginally underluminous (0.50 +/- 0.23 mag), given their rotation velocities, as compared to the local Tully-Fisher relation. In this analysis, we assume no slope evolution, and take into account systematic differences between local and distant velocity and luminosity measurements. Our result is particularly striking considering the Cl0024 members have very strong emission lines, and local galaxies with similar Halpha equivalent widths tend to be overluminous on the Tully-Fisher relation. Cl0024 Tully-Fisher residuals appear to be correlated most strongly with galaxy rotation velocities, indicating a possible change in the slope of the Tully-Fisher relation. However, we caution that this result may be strongly affected by magnitude selection and by the original slope assumed for the analysis. Cl0024 residuals also depend weakly on color, emission line strength and extent, and photometric asymmetry. In a comparison of stellar and gas motions in two Cl0024 members, we find no evidence for counter-rotating stars and gas, an expected signature of mergers.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2006;
originally announced January 2006.
-
Keck Adaptive Optics Imaging of 0.5<z<1 Field Galaxies from the Hubble Space Telescope Archive
Authors:
Eric Steinbring,
A. J. Metevier,
Stuart A. Norton,
L. M. Raschke,
D. C. Koo,
S. M. Faber,
C. N. A Willmer,
J. E. Larkin,
T. M. Glassman
Abstract:
We have employed natural guide star adaptive optics (AO) on the Keck II telescope to obtain near-infrared (H and K') images of three field galaxies, each of redshift greater than 0.5. These are among the highest-redshift non-active disk galaxies to be imaged with AO. Each of the galaxies was chosen because it had been observed previously with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) Wide Field Planetary…
▽ More
We have employed natural guide star adaptive optics (AO) on the Keck II telescope to obtain near-infrared (H and K') images of three field galaxies, each of redshift greater than 0.5. These are among the highest-redshift non-active disk galaxies to be imaged with AO. Each of the galaxies was chosen because it had been observed previously with the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) Wide Field Planetary Camera 2 (WFPC2) by others. Our AO images in the near infrared (NIR) closely match both the depth and high spatial resolution of those optical data. Combining the archival V and I data with our new H and K' images potentially produces a long wavelength baseline at uniform resolution. The NIR data probe emission well longward of the 4000-Angstrom break at these redshifts, and provide stellar fluxes less contaminated by dust. We fit two-dimensional galaxy bulge-plus-disk models simultaneously in all bands, and compare stellar-population-synthesis modeling to the photometry of these separated components. This is an initial foray into combining HST and AO imaging to produce a high spatial-resolution multi-color dataset for a large sample of faint galaxies. Our pilot program shows that NIR AO images from large ground-based observatories, augmented by HST images in the optical, can in principle provide a powerful tool for the analysis of faint field galaxies. However, the AO data S/N will have to be increased, and AO PSFs need to be controlled more carefully than they were here.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2004;
originally announced July 2004.
-
A Deep Keck Spectral Survey of Cl0024+1654 at z=0.4
Authors:
Anne J. Metevier,
David C. Koo,
Luc Simard,
Gregory D. Wirth
Abstract:
We have undertaken a Keck spectral survey of galaxies to R~24 near the central region of Cl0024+1654 at z=0.4. The spectral resolution and slits have been selected to yield kinematics such as the velocity dispersions of early-type systems and rotation curves of disks. The spectra also provide a suite of lines that yield star formation, age, and metallicity information.
We have undertaken a Keck spectral survey of galaxies to R~24 near the central region of Cl0024+1654 at z=0.4. The spectral resolution and slits have been selected to yield kinematics such as the velocity dispersions of early-type systems and rotation curves of disks. The spectra also provide a suite of lines that yield star formation, age, and metallicity information.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2001;
originally announced October 2001.
-
A Pilot Study of the Tully-Fisher Relation in Cl0024+1654 at z=0.4
Authors:
Anne J. Metevier,
David C. Koo,
Luc Simard
Abstract:
We present the first determination of the Tully-Fisher relation (TFR) for a distant galaxy cluster. We have measured internal kinematics of seven members of Cl0024+1654 from spatially resolved emission observed in 2D Keck (LRIS) spectra. Measurements of disk structural parameters were made from HST (WFPC2) images. While we do not find evidence for a change in the slope or zeropoint of the cluste…
▽ More
We present the first determination of the Tully-Fisher relation (TFR) for a distant galaxy cluster. We have measured internal kinematics of seven members of Cl0024+1654 from spatially resolved emission observed in 2D Keck (LRIS) spectra. Measurements of disk structural parameters were made from HST (WFPC2) images. While we do not find evidence for a change in the slope or zeropoint of the cluster TFR, we do find that there was more scatter in the past. We intend to expand this study with kinematic measurements from fifteen more Cl0024 members.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2001;
originally announced October 2001.
-
The z=0 Galaxy Luminosity Function: I. Techniques for Identification of Dwarf Galaxies at ~10 Mpc
Authors:
Kathleen Flint,
Anne J. Metevier,
Michael Bolte,
Claudia Mendes de Oliveira
Abstract:
We present a program to study the galaxy luminosity function (GLF) of the Leo I and Coma I Groups at ~10 Mpc. We have surveyed over seven square degrees in Leo I and ~11 square degrees in Coma I. In this paper, we detail the method we have developed and implemented for identifying on morphological grounds low-surface-brightness, M_R < -10 dwarf galaxies at a distance of 10 Mpc. We also describe…
▽ More
We present a program to study the galaxy luminosity function (GLF) of the Leo I and Coma I Groups at ~10 Mpc. We have surveyed over seven square degrees in Leo I and ~11 square degrees in Coma I. In this paper, we detail the method we have developed and implemented for identifying on morphological grounds low-surface-brightness, M_R < -10 dwarf galaxies at a distance of 10 Mpc. We also describe extensive Montecarlo simulations of artificial galaxies which we use to tune our detection algorithms and evaluate our detection efficiency and parameter recovery as a function of mu_R(0) and R_T. We find for a sub-set of our Leo I data that at the 90% completeness level we can detect dwarfs comparable to Antlia and Sculptor. Finally, we describe preliminary follow-up observations which confirm we are detecting dwarf spheroidals in Leo I at 10 Mpc.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2001;
originally announced January 2001.
-
The Butcher-Oemler Effect at Moderate Redshift
Authors:
Anne J. Metevier,
A. Kathy Romer,
M. P. Ulmer
Abstract:
We present the results of Butcher-Oemler-style analysis of three moderate- redshift (0.1<z<0.2) clusters which have bimodal X-ray surface brightness profiles. We find that at least two of these clusters exhibit unusually high fractions of blue galaxies as compared to clusters at comparable redshifts studied by Butcher and Oemler (1984). This implies that star formation is occurring in a high fra…
▽ More
We present the results of Butcher-Oemler-style analysis of three moderate- redshift (0.1<z<0.2) clusters which have bimodal X-ray surface brightness profiles. We find that at least two of these clusters exhibit unusually high fractions of blue galaxies as compared to clusters at comparable redshifts studied by Butcher and Oemler (1984). This implies that star formation is occurring in a high fraction of the galaxies in the two clusters. Our results are consistent with hierarchical clustering models in which subcluster- subcluster mergers create shocks in the intracluster medium. The shocks, in turn, induce simultaneous starbursts in a large fraction of cluster galaxies. Our study therefore lends weight to the hypothesis that the Butcher-Oemler effect is an environmental, as well as evolutionary, phenomenon.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 1999;
originally announced November 1999.
-
The Bright SHARC Survey: The Cluster Catalog
Authors:
A. K Romer,
R. C. Nichol,
B. P. Holden,
M. P. Ulmer,
R. A. Pildis,
A. J. Merrelli,
C. Adami,
D. J. Burke,
C. A. Collins,
A. J. Metevier,
R. G. Kron,
K. Commons
Abstract:
We present the Bright SHARC (Serendipitous High-Redshift Archival ROSAT Cluster) Survey, which is an objective search for serendipitously detected extended X-ray sources in 460 deep ROSAT PSPC pointings. The Bright SHARC Survey covers an area of 178.6 sq.deg and has yielded 374 extended sources. We discuss the X-ray data reduction, the candidate selection and present results from our on-going op…
▽ More
We present the Bright SHARC (Serendipitous High-Redshift Archival ROSAT Cluster) Survey, which is an objective search for serendipitously detected extended X-ray sources in 460 deep ROSAT PSPC pointings. The Bright SHARC Survey covers an area of 178.6 sq.deg and has yielded 374 extended sources. We discuss the X-ray data reduction, the candidate selection and present results from our on-going optical follow-up campaign. The optical follow-up concentrates on the brightest 94 of the 374 extended sources and is now 97% complete. We have identified thirty-seven clusters of galaxies, for which we present redshifts and luminosities. The clusters span a redshift range of 0.0696<z<0.83 and a luminosity range of 0.065<Lx<8.3e44 erg/s [0.5-2.0 keV] (assuming Ho = 50 km/s/Mpc and qo=0.5). Twelve of the clusters have redshifts greater than z=0.3, eight of which are at luminosities brighter than Lx=3e44 erg/s. Seventeen of the 37 optically confirmed Bright SHARC clusters have not been listed in any previously published catalog. We also report the discovery of three candidate ``fossil groups'' of the kind proposed by Ponman et al. (1994).
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2000; v1 submitted 28 July, 1999;
originally announced July 1999.
