-
Assessing the residual biases in high-resolution transit absorption spectra correction
Authors:
W. Dethier,
B. Tessore
Abstract:
In recent years it has become common practice to divide observed transit absorption spectra by synthetic absorption spectra computed for the transit of an atmosphere-less planet. This action supposedly corrects the observed absorption spectrum, leaving the sole atmospheric absorption signature free from the biases induced by stellar rotation and centre-to-limb variations. We aim to show that while…
▽ More
In recent years it has become common practice to divide observed transit absorption spectra by synthetic absorption spectra computed for the transit of an atmosphere-less planet. This action supposedly corrects the observed absorption spectrum, leaving the sole atmospheric absorption signature free from the biases induced by stellar rotation and centre-to-limb variations. We aim to show that while this practice is beneficial, it does not completely correct the absorption spectrum from the stellar distortions and that some residual biases remain, leaving a possibly altered atmospheric signature. By reducing the problem to its most basic form, we show that dividing the observed absorption spectrum by a synthetic absorption spectrum of the planet does not isolate the pure atmospheric absorption signature. We also used simulated synthetic transit observations to assess the magnitude of these residual biases in typical transit observations. We show that dividing the observed absorption spectrum by the planetary absorption spectrum results in an atmospheric signature modulated by the ratio of the flux behind the atmosphere and the flux behind the planet. Depending on the non-homogeneity of the stellar spectrum, this leads to distorted atmospheric signatures. Eventually, directly analysing these biased signatures will lead to wrong estimates of planetary atmosphere properties.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
The ANTARESS workflow I. Optimal extraction of spatially resolved stellar spectra with high-resolution transit spectroscopy
Authors:
V. Bourrier,
J. -B. Delisle,
C. Lovis,
H. M. Cegla,
M. Cretignier,
R. Allart,
K. Al Moulla,
S. Tavella,
O. Attia,
D. Mounzer,
V. Vaulato,
M. Steiner,
T. Vrignaud,
S. Mercier,
X. Dumusque,
D. Ehrenreich,
J. V. Seidel,
A. Wyttenbach,
W. Dethier,
F. Pepe
Abstract:
High-resolution spectrographs open a detailed window onto the atmospheres of stars and planets. As the number of systems observed with different instruments grows, it is crucial to develop a standard in analyzing spectral time series of exoplanet transits and occultations, for the benefit of reproducibility. Here, we introduce the ANTARESS workflow, a set of methods aimed at processing high-resolu…
▽ More
High-resolution spectrographs open a detailed window onto the atmospheres of stars and planets. As the number of systems observed with different instruments grows, it is crucial to develop a standard in analyzing spectral time series of exoplanet transits and occultations, for the benefit of reproducibility. Here, we introduce the ANTARESS workflow, a set of methods aimed at processing high-resolution spectroscopy datasets in a robust way and extracting accurate exoplanetary and stellar spectra. While a fast preliminary analysis can be run on order-merged 1D spectra and cross-correlation functions (CCFs), the workflow was optimally designed for extracted 2D echelle spectra to remain close to the original detector counts, limit the spectral resampling, and propagate the correlated noise. Input data from multiple instruments and epochs were corrected for relevant environmental and instrumental effects, processed homogeneously, and analyzed independently or jointly. In this first paper, we show how planet-occulted stellar spectra extracted along the transit chord and cleaned from planetary contamination provide a direct comparison with theoretical stellar models and enable a spectral and spatial mapping of the photosphere. We illustrate this application of the workflow to archival ESPRESSO data, using the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect Revolutions (RMR) technique to confirm the spin-orbit alignment of HD\,209458b and unveil biases in WASP-76b's published orbital architecture. Because the workflow is modular and its concepts are general, it can support new methods and be extended to additional spectrographs to find a range of applications beyond the proposed scope. In a companion paper, we will present how planet-occulted spectra can be processed further to extract and analyze planetary spectra decontaminated from the star, providing clean and direct measurements of atmospheric properties.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Probing atmospheric escape through metastable He I triplet lines in 15 exoplanets observed with SPIRou
Authors:
A. Masson,
S. Vinatier,
B. Bézard,
M. López-Puertas,
M. Lampón,
F. Debras,
A. Carmona,
B. Klein,
E. Artigau,
W. Dethier,
S. Pelletier,
T. Hood,
R. Allart,
V. Bourrier,
C. Cadieux,
B. Charnay,
N. B. Cowan,
N. J. Cook,
X. Delfosse,
J. -F. Donati,
P. -G. Gu,
G. Hébrard,
E. Martioli,
C. Moutou,
O. Venot
, et al. (1 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
For several years, the metastable helium triplet line has been successfully used as a tracer to probe atmospheric escape in transiting exoplanets. This absorption in the near-infrared (1083.3 nm) can be observed from the ground using high-resolution spectroscopy, providing new constraints on the mass-loss rate and the temperature characterizing the upper atmosphere of close-in exoplanets.
The ai…
▽ More
For several years, the metastable helium triplet line has been successfully used as a tracer to probe atmospheric escape in transiting exoplanets. This absorption in the near-infrared (1083.3 nm) can be observed from the ground using high-resolution spectroscopy, providing new constraints on the mass-loss rate and the temperature characterizing the upper atmosphere of close-in exoplanets.
The aim of this work is to search for the He triplet signature in 15 transiting exoplanets -- ranging from super-Earths to ultrahot Jupiters -- observed with SPIRou, a high-resolution (R~70 000) near-infrared spectropolarimeter at the CFHT, in order to bring new constraints or to improve existing ones regarding atmospheric escape through a homogeneous study.
We developed a full data processing and analysis pipeline to correct for the residual telluric and stellar contributions. We then used two different 1D models based on the Parker-wind equations and nonlocal thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE) radiative transfer to interpret the observational results.
We confirm published He triplet detections for HAT-P-11 b, HD 189733 b, and WASP-69 b. We tentatively detect the signature of escaping He in HD 209458 b, GJ 3470 b, and WASP-76 b. We report new constraints on the mass-loss rate and temperature for our three detections and set upper limits for the tentative and nondetections. We notably report improved constraints on the mass-loss rate and temperature of the escaping gas for TOI-1807 b, and report a nondetection for the debated atmospheric escape in GJ 1214 b. We also conducted the first search for the He signature in GJ 486 b since its discovery and report a nondetection of the He triplet. Finally, we studied the impact of important model assumptions on our retrieved parameters, notably the limitations of 1D models and the influence of the H/He ratio on the derived constraints.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
The Rossiter-McLaughlin effect and exoplanet transits: A delicate association at medium and low spectral resolution
Authors:
Yann Carteret,
Vincent Bourrier,
William Dethier
Abstract:
The characterization of exoplanetary atmospheres via transit spectroscopy is based on the comparison between the stellar spectrum filtered through the atmosphere and the unadulterated spectrum from the occulted stellar region. The disk-integrated spectrum is often used as a proxy for the occulted spectrum, yet they differ along the transit chord depending on stellar type and rotational velocity. T…
▽ More
The characterization of exoplanetary atmospheres via transit spectroscopy is based on the comparison between the stellar spectrum filtered through the atmosphere and the unadulterated spectrum from the occulted stellar region. The disk-integrated spectrum is often used as a proxy for the occulted spectrum, yet they differ along the transit chord depending on stellar type and rotational velocity. This is refereed to as the Rossiter-McLaughlin (RM) effect, which is known to bias transmission spectra at high spectral resolution when calculated with the disk-integrated stellar spectrum. Recently, it was shown that the first claimed atmospheric signal from an exoplanet cannot arise from absorption in the core of the sodium doublet, because the features observed at high resolution are well reproduced by the RM effect. However, it remains unclear as to whether the detection made at medium spectral resolution with the HST arises from the smoothed RM signature or from the wings of the planetary absorption line. More generally, the impact of the RM effect at medium and low spectral resolution remains poorly explored. To address this question, we simulated realistic transmission spectra in a variety of systems using the EVaporating Exoplanets code. We find that the RM effect should not bias broadband atmospheric features, such as hazes or molecular absorption, measured with the JWST/NIRSPEC (prism mode) at low resolution. However, absorption signatures from metastable helium or sodium measured at medium resolution with the JWST/NIRSPEC (G140H mode) or HST/STIS can be biased, especially for planets on misaligned orbits across fast rotators. In contrast, we show that the Na signature originally reported in HD209458b, an aligned system, cannot be explained by the RM effect, supporting a planetary origin.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
ATMOSPHERIX: I- An open source high resolution transmission spectroscopy pipeline for exoplanets atmospheres with SPIRou
Authors:
B. Klein,
F. Debras,
J. -F. Donati,
T. Hood,
C. Moutou,
A. Carmona,
M. Ould-elkhim,
B. Bézard,
B. Charnay,
P. Fouqué,
A. Masson,
S. Vinatier,
C. Baruteau,
I. Boisse,
X. Bonfils,
A. Chiavassa,
X. Delfosse,
W. Dethier,
G. Hebrard,
F. Kiefer,
J. Leconte,
E. Martioli,
V. Parmentier,
P. Petit,
W. Pluriel
, et al. (6 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Atmospheric characterisation of exoplanets from the ground is an actively growing field of research. In this context we have created the ATMOSPHERIX consortium: a research project aimed at characterizing exoplanets atmospheres using ground-based high resolution spectroscopy. This paper presents the publicly-available data analysis pipeline and demonstrates the robustness of the recovered planetary…
▽ More
Atmospheric characterisation of exoplanets from the ground is an actively growing field of research. In this context we have created the ATMOSPHERIX consortium: a research project aimed at characterizing exoplanets atmospheres using ground-based high resolution spectroscopy. This paper presents the publicly-available data analysis pipeline and demonstrates the robustness of the recovered planetary parameters from synthetic data. Simulating planetary transits using synthetic transmission spectra of a hot Jupiter that were injected into real SPIRou observations of the non-transiting system Gl 15 A, we show that our pipeline is successful at recovering the planetary signal and input atmospheric parameters. We also introduce a deep learning algorithm to optimise data reduction which proves to be a reliable, alternative tool to the commonly used principal component analysis. We estimate the level of uncertainties and possible biases when retrieving parameters such as temperature and composition and hence the level of confidence in the case of retrieval from real data. Finally, we apply our pipeline onto two real transits of HD~189733 b observed with SPIRou and obtain similar results than in the literature. In summary, we have developed a publicly available and robust pipeline for the forthcoming studies of the targets to be observed in the framework of the ATMOSPHERIX consortium, which can easily be adapted to other high resolution instruments than SPIRou (e.g. VLT-CRIRES, MAROON-X, ELT-ANDES)
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2023; v1 submitted 28 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
DREAM: III.A helium survey in exoplanets on the edge of the hot Neptune desert with GIANO-B@TNG
Authors:
G. Guilluy,
V. Bourrier,
Y. Jaziri,
W. Dethier,
D. Mounzer,
P. Giacobbe,
O. Attia,
R. Allart,
A. S. Bonomo,
L. A. Dos Santos,
M. Rainer,
A. Sozzetti
Abstract:
The population of close-in exoplanets features a desert of hot Neptunes whose origin is uncertain. These planets may have lost their atmosphere, eroding into mini-Neptunes and super-Earths. Direct observations of evaporating atmospheres are essential to derive mass-loss estimates and constrain this scenario. The metastable 1083.3nm HeI triplet represents a powerful diagnostic of atmospheric evapor…
▽ More
The population of close-in exoplanets features a desert of hot Neptunes whose origin is uncertain. These planets may have lost their atmosphere, eroding into mini-Neptunes and super-Earths. Direct observations of evaporating atmospheres are essential to derive mass-loss estimates and constrain this scenario. The metastable 1083.3nm HeI triplet represents a powerful diagnostic of atmospheric evaporation since it traces the hot gas in extended exoplanet atmospheres, is observable from the ground, and is weakly affected by interstellar medium absorption. We conducted a uniform HeI transmission spectroscopy survey, focusing on 9 planets located at the edges of the Neptunian desert, aiming to gain insights into the role of photo-evaporation in its formation. We observed one transit per planet using the high-resolution, near-infrared spectrograph GIANO-B on the Telescopio Nazionale Galileo. We focused our analysis on the HeI triplet by computing high-resolution transmission spectra. We then employed the p-winds model to interpret the observed transmission spectra. We found no sign of planetary absorption in the HeI triplet in any of the investigated targets. We thus provided 3sigma upper-limit estimations on the thermosphere absorption, temperature, and mass loss, and combined them with past measurements to search for correlations with parameters thought to be drivers in the formation of the HeI triplet. Our results strengthen the importance of performing homogeneous surveys and analyses to bring clarification in the HeI detection and hence in the Neptunian desert origin. Our findings corroborate the literature expectations that the HeI absorption signal correlates with the stellar mass and the received XUV flux. However, these trends seem to disappear in terms of mass-loss rates; further studies are essential to shed light on this aspect and to understand better the photo-evaporation process.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2023; v1 submitted 3 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Combined analysis of stellar and planetary absorption lines via global forward-transit simulations
Authors:
William Dethier,
Vincent Bourrier
Abstract:
We characterise the planet-occulted line distortions (POLDs) in absorption spectra of transiting planets, that arise from proxies used for the occulted stellar lines and investigate the impact of stellar rotation, centre-to-limb variations, and broadband limb-darkening. We used the EVaporating Exoplanets (EVE) code to generate realistic stellar spectra during the transit of exoplanets, accounting…
▽ More
We characterise the planet-occulted line distortions (POLDs) in absorption spectra of transiting planets, that arise from proxies used for the occulted stellar lines and investigate the impact of stellar rotation, centre-to-limb variations, and broadband limb-darkening. We used the EVaporating Exoplanets (EVE) code to generate realistic stellar spectra during the transit of exoplanets, accounting for the 3D geometry of the system's architecture and atmospheric transit, as well as for spectral variations over the stellar disc. The absorption spectra were calculated using approaches drawn from the literature and compared to the expected signal. The POLDs from stellar rotation are dominant for moderate to fast rotating stars, reaching amplitudes comparable to atmospheric signals, but they can be mitigated by shifting the stellar line proxies to the radial velocity of the planet-occulted region. Centre-to-limb variations become dominant for slow rotators and are more easily mitigated at the stellar limb. We re-interpret the ESPRESSO data of two iconic systems and confirm that the sodium signature from HD209458b mainly arises from POLDs. However, we unveil a possible contribution from the planetary atmosphere that warrants further observations. For MASCARA-1b, we did not find evidence for atmospheric sodium absorption and we can fully explain the observed signature by a POLD for super-solar stellar sodium abundance. We studied POLDs dependency on star and planet properties, and on the proxy used for planet-occulted lines. Distinguishing planetary absorption signatures from POLDs is challenging without access to accurate estimates of the local stellar spectrum and system orbital parameters. We propose a way to mitigate POLDs and improve atmospheric characterisation, by using simultaneous forward modelling of both the star and the planet to simulate the global observed signatures.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Hot Exoplanet Atmospheres Resolved with Transit Spectroscopy (HEARTS) VIII. Nondetection of sodium in the atmosphere of the aligned planet KELT-10b
Authors:
M. Steiner,
O. Attia,
D. Ehrenreich,
M. Lendl,
V. Bourrier,
C. Lovis,
J. V. Seidel,
S. G. Sousa,
D. Mounzer,
N. Astudillo-Defru,
X. Bonfils,
V. Bonvin,
W. Dethier,
K. Heng,
B. Lavie,
C. Melo,
G. Ottoni,
F. Pepe,
D. Ségransan,
A. Wyttenbach
Abstract:
We searched for potential atmospheric species in KELT-10b, focusing on sodium doublet lines (Na i; 589 nm) and the Balmer alpha line (H $α$; 656 nm) in the transmission spectrum. Furthermore, we measured the planet-orbital alignment with the spin of its host star. We used the Rossiter-McLaughlin Revolutions technique to analyze the local stellar lines occulted by the planet during its transit. We…
▽ More
We searched for potential atmospheric species in KELT-10b, focusing on sodium doublet lines (Na i; 589 nm) and the Balmer alpha line (H $α$; 656 nm) in the transmission spectrum. Furthermore, we measured the planet-orbital alignment with the spin of its host star. We used the Rossiter-McLaughlin Revolutions technique to analyze the local stellar lines occulted by the planet during its transit. We used the standard transmission spectroscopy method to probe the planetary atmosphere, including the correction for telluric lines and the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect on the spectra. We analyzed two new light curves jointly with the public photometry observations. We do not detect signals in the Na i and H $α$ lines within the uncertainty of our measurements. We derive the 3-sigma upper limit of excess absorption due to the planetary atmosphere corresponding to equivalent height Rp to 1.8Rp (Na i) and 1.9Rp (H $α$). The analysis of the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect yields the sky-projected spin-orbit angle of the system $λ$ = -5.2 $\pm$ 3.4 and the stellar projected equatorial velocity $v_{eq} \sin{i_\star}$ = 2.58 $\pm$ 0.12 km/s. Photometry results are compatible within 1 -sigma with previous studies. We found no evidence of Na i and H $α$, within the precision of our data, in the atmosphere of KELT-10b. Our detection limits allow us to rule out the presence of neutral sodium or excited hydrogen in an escaping extended atmosphere around KELT-10b. We cannot confirm the previous detection of Na i at lower altitudes with VLT/UVES. We note, however, that the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect impacts the transmission spectrum on a smaller scale than the previous detection with UVES. Analysis of the planet-occulted stellar lines shows the sky-projected alignment of the system, which is likely truly aligned due to tidal interactions of the planet with its cool (Teff < 6250 K) host star.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
