-
Higher order spin interactions mediated by the substrate
Authors:
Szczepan Głodzik,
Rok Žitko
Abstract:
Since the seminal works in the fifties it has been known that a bath of non-interacting electrons mediates an interaction between local moments (such as nuclear spins or magnetic impurities) coupled to distant sites of the lattice. Recent efforts in simultaneous control of multi-qubit arrays rely on defining quantum dots in environments which likewise contain electrons capable of mediating effecti…
▽ More
Since the seminal works in the fifties it has been known that a bath of non-interacting electrons mediates an interaction between local moments (such as nuclear spins or magnetic impurities) coupled to distant sites of the lattice. Recent efforts in simultaneous control of multi-qubit arrays rely on defining quantum dots in environments which likewise contain electrons capable of mediating effective interactions. It is therefore interesting to analyze systems with more than two impurities in higher orders of perturbation theory. Here we derive and discuss the significance of the effective spin interactions between four impurities in fourth order of the coupling between the impurities and the substrate, mediated by conduction electrons of a two-dimensional square lattice. This effective interaction resembles the ring exchange -- a coupling of four spins appearing in perturbative treatment of the Hubbard model. Despite it being a higher-order effect, it can dramatically influence the magnetic ordering. We show that as an effective interaction between impurity spins, the ring exchange can also compete with the more familiar two-spin interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2024; v1 submitted 11 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Inelastic tunneling through normal and superconducting junctions in the presence of photonic bath within Lindbladian formalism
Authors:
Ádám Bácsi,
Rok Žitko
Abstract:
An electron tunneling across a junction integrated into an electric circuit can generate an excitation in the photonic field (electromagnetic environment) and lose energy in the process. Such inelastic tunneling of particles is commonly described using the $P(E)$ theory. In the conventional approach to this theory, the tunneling rate and the electric current through the junction are derived using…
▽ More
An electron tunneling across a junction integrated into an electric circuit can generate an excitation in the photonic field (electromagnetic environment) and lose energy in the process. Such inelastic tunneling of particles is commonly described using the $P(E)$ theory. In the conventional approach to this theory, the tunneling rate and the electric current through the junction are derived using Fermi's golden rule and by averaging over the environmental photonic degrees of freedom. In this work, we address the same problem of inelastic tunneling due to photonic environment in Lindbladian formalism and we present how the photonic degrees of freedom are traced out in quantum master equation approach. The resulting quantum master equation is parameterized by the same $P(E)$ function and enables us to obtain not only the electric current but various other quantities, for instance the heat current, in a systematic and convenient way. We also demonstrate that the Lindbladian formalism provides a comprehensive description of Bogoliubov quasiparticle tunneling through superconducting junctions and that it properly accounts for the coherence factors. The coherence factors become important if the normal-state density of states is particle-hole asymmetric.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2024; v1 submitted 7 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Generalized transmon Hamiltonian for Andreev spin qubits
Authors:
Luka Pavešić,
Rok Žitko
Abstract:
We solve the problem of an interacting quantum dot embedded in a Josephson junction between two superconductors with finite charging energy described by the transmon (Cooper pair box) Hamiltonian. The approach is based on the flat-band approximation of the Richardson model, which reduces the Hilbert space to the point where exact diagonalisation is possible while retaining all states that are nece…
▽ More
We solve the problem of an interacting quantum dot embedded in a Josephson junction between two superconductors with finite charging energy described by the transmon (Cooper pair box) Hamiltonian. The approach is based on the flat-band approximation of the Richardson model, which reduces the Hilbert space to the point where exact diagonalisation is possible while retaining all states that are necessary to describe the low energy phenomena. The presented method accounts for the physics of the quantum dot, the Josephson effect and the Coulomb repulsion (charging energy) at the same level. In particular, it captures the quantum fluctuations of the superconducting phase as well as the coupling between the superconducting phase and the quantum dot (spin) degrees of freedom. The method can be directly applied for modelling Andreev spin qubits embedded in transmon circuits in all parameter regimes, for describing time-dependent processes, and for the calculation of transition matrix elements for microwave-driven transmon, spin-flip and mixed transitions that involve coupling to charge or current degree of freedom.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Auxiliary master equation approach to the Anderson-Holstein impurity problem out of equilibrium
Authors:
D. Werner,
R. Žitko,
E. Arrigoni
Abstract:
We introduce a method based on auxiliary master equation for solving the problem of an impurity with local electron-electron and electron-phonon interaction embedded between two conduction leads with a finite bias voltage. The Anderson-Holstein Hamiltonian is transformed to a corresponding Lindblad equation with a reduced set of sites providing an optimal approximation of the hybridization functio…
▽ More
We introduce a method based on auxiliary master equation for solving the problem of an impurity with local electron-electron and electron-phonon interaction embedded between two conduction leads with a finite bias voltage. The Anderson-Holstein Hamiltonian is transformed to a corresponding Lindblad equation with a reduced set of sites providing an optimal approximation of the hybridization function. The problem is solved in the superfermion representation using configuration interaction for fermions and bosons. The phonon basis is shifted and rotated with the intention of permitting a low phonon basis cutoff even in the strong-coupling regime. We benchmark this approach with the numerical renormalization group in equilibrium, finding excellent agreement. We observe, however, that the rotation brings no advantage beyond the bare shift. This is even more apparent out of equilibrium, where issues in convergence with respect to the size of the phononic Hilbert space occur only in the rotated basis. As an application of the method, we explore the evolution of the phononic peak in the differential conductance spectra with changing phonon frequency.
△ Less
Submitted 11 December, 2023; v1 submitted 2 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Exchange interaction between two quantum dots coupled through a superconducting island
Authors:
Ádám Bácsi,
Luka Pavešić,
Rok Žitko
Abstract:
We present a theoretical study of a system consisting of a superconducting island and two quantum dots, a possible platform for building qubits and Cooper pair splitters, in the regime where each dot hosts a single electron and, hence, carries a magnetic moment. We focus on the case where the dots are coupled to overlapping superconductor states and we study whether the spins are ferromagnetically…
▽ More
We present a theoretical study of a system consisting of a superconducting island and two quantum dots, a possible platform for building qubits and Cooper pair splitters, in the regime where each dot hosts a single electron and, hence, carries a magnetic moment. We focus on the case where the dots are coupled to overlapping superconductor states and we study whether the spins are ferromagnetically or antiferromagnetically aligned. We show that if the total number of particles is even, the spins align antiferromagnetically in the flatband limit, i.e., when the bandwidth of the superconductor is negligibly small, but ferromagnetically if the bandwidth is finite and above some value. If the total number of particles is odd, the alignment is ferromagnetic independently from the bandwidth. This implies that the results of the flatband limit are applicable only within restricted parameter regime for realistic superconducting qubit systems and that some care is required in applying simplified models to devices such as Cooper pair splitters.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Richardson model with complex level structure and spin-orbit coupling for hybrid superconducting islands: stepwise suppression of pairing and magnetic pinning
Authors:
Juan Carlos Estrada Saldaña,
Luka Pavešič,
Alexandros Vekris,
Kasper Grove-Rasmussen,
Jesper Nygård,
Rok Žitko
Abstract:
An epitaxial semiconductor-superconductor nanowire is a superconducting system with a complex level structure originating from hybridization: in addition to a dense set of higher-energy states derived predominantly from the metallic superconducting shell above the bulk gap $Δ$, there is a smaller number of lower-energy proximitized states from the semiconducting core that define the induced gap…
▽ More
An epitaxial semiconductor-superconductor nanowire is a superconducting system with a complex level structure originating from hybridization: in addition to a dense set of higher-energy states derived predominantly from the metallic superconducting shell above the bulk gap $Δ$, there is a smaller number of lower-energy proximitized states from the semiconducting core that define the induced gap $Δ^*$. Nanostructures built from such nanowires can furthermore incorporate quantum dots in order to obtain localized spins for storing and manipulating quantum information. We discuss the magnetic field dependence in three devices with different combinations of embedded quantum dots and superconducting islands. For strong fields, they show pinning of excitation energies to a uniform spacing, even if for weak fields they have non-universal properties with different behaviors for even and odd number of confined electrons. We propose a quantum impurity model for hybrid devices that incorporates all relevant physical effects. We show that the model accounts for the key observations and permits unambiguous interpretation in terms of many-particle states. In particular, we study the replicas of the Yu-Shiba-Rusinov states in the hybrid gap, their collapse and oscillation around zero bias with increasing field, and the strong smoothing effect of the spin-orbit coupling (SOC) on these oscillations. We propose that the SOC-induced mixing of many-body states is a generic mechanism and that magnetic pinning is likely to be a ubiquitous feature in hybrid nanowires.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2023; v1 submitted 9 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Strong-coupling theory of quantum dot Josephson junctions: role of the residual quasiparticle
Authors:
Luka Pavešič,
Ramón Aguado,
Rok Žitko
Abstract:
We consider an interacting quantum dot strongly coupled to two superconducting leads in a Josephson junction geometry. By defining symmetry-adapted superpositions of states from the leads, we formulate an effective Hamiltonian for the strong-hybridisation regime with a single orbital directly coupled to the dot and three additional indirectly coupled orbitals. This minimal basis set allows to acco…
▽ More
We consider an interacting quantum dot strongly coupled to two superconducting leads in a Josephson junction geometry. By defining symmetry-adapted superpositions of states from the leads, we formulate an effective Hamiltonian for the strong-hybridisation regime with a single orbital directly coupled to the dot and three additional indirectly coupled orbitals. This minimal basis set allows to account for the quasiparticles in the vicinity of the dot as well as those further away in the leads, and to describe how their role evolves as a function of coupling strength and phase bias $φ$. This formulation also reveals the changing nature of the spin-doublet state for the experimentally relevant coupling strengths. The binding of a nearly decoupled quasiparticle in the vicinity of the QD explains the "doublet chimney" in the phase diagram for $φ\sim π$, in contrast to $φ\sim 0$ where the residual quasiparticle escapes to infinity and plays no active role.
△ Less
Submitted 16 January, 2024; v1 submitted 24 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Incommensurable matter-wave jets in quasi-1D geometry
Authors:
Tadej Mežnaršič,
Rok Žitko,
Katja Gosar,
Jure Pirman,
Katja Arh,
Matevž Jug,
Erik Zupanič,
Peter Jeglič
Abstract:
Matter-wave jets are ejected from a Bose-Einstein condensate subjected to a modulation of the interaction strength. For sufficiently strong modulation additional higher harmonic matter-wave jets emerge. Here we report the first experimental observation of incommensurable "golden" $\frac{1+\sqrt{5}}{2}$ matter-wave jets in a Bose-Einstein condensate exposed to a single frequency interaction modulat…
▽ More
Matter-wave jets are ejected from a Bose-Einstein condensate subjected to a modulation of the interaction strength. For sufficiently strong modulation additional higher harmonic matter-wave jets emerge. Here we report the first experimental observation of incommensurable "golden" $\frac{1+\sqrt{5}}{2}$ matter-wave jets in a Bose-Einstein condensate exposed to a single frequency interaction modulation. We study the formation of higher-order jets and the corresponding incommensurable density waves in quasi-one-dimensional geometry with numerical one dimensional (1D) Gross-Pitaevskii equation simulation. We explore the process of jet formation experimentally and theoretically for a wide range of modulation amplitudes and frequencies and establish a phase diagram delineating different regimes of jet formation.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2024; v1 submitted 13 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Impurity Knight shift in quantum dot Josephson junctions
Authors:
Luka Pavešić,
Marta Pita-Vidal,
Arno Bargerbos,
Rok Žitko
Abstract:
Spectroscopy of a Josephson junction device with an embedded quantum dot reveals the presence of a contribution to level splitting in external magnetic field that is proportional to $\cos φ$, where $φ$ is the gauge-invariant phase difference across the junction. To elucidate the origin of this unanticipated effect, we systematically study the Zeeman splitting of spinful subgap states in the superc…
▽ More
Spectroscopy of a Josephson junction device with an embedded quantum dot reveals the presence of a contribution to level splitting in external magnetic field that is proportional to $\cos φ$, where $φ$ is the gauge-invariant phase difference across the junction. To elucidate the origin of this unanticipated effect, we systematically study the Zeeman splitting of spinful subgap states in the superconducting Anderson impurity model. The magnitude of the splitting is renormalized by the exchange interaction between the local moment and the continuum of Bogoliubov quasiparticles in a variant of the Knight shift phenomenon. The leading term in the shift is linear in the hybridisation strength $Γ$ (quadratic in electron hopping), while the subleading term is quadratic in $Γ$ (quartic in electron hopping) and depends on $φ$ due to spin-polarization-dependent corrections to the Josephson energy of the device. The amplitude of the $φ$-dependent part is largest for experimentally relevant parameters beyond the perturbative regime where it is investigated using numerical renormalization group calculations. Such magnetic-field-tunable coupling between the quantum dot spin and the Josephson current could find wide use in superconducting spintronics.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2023; v1 submitted 14 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Quantum capacitance of a superconducting subgap state in an electrostatically floating dot-island
Authors:
Filip K. Malinowski,
R. K. Rupesh,
Luka Pavešić,
Zoltán Guba,
Damaz de Jong,
Lin Han,
Christian G. Prosko,
Michael Chan,
Yu Liu,
Peter Krogstrup,
András Pályi,
Rok Žitko,
Jonne V. Koski
Abstract:
We study a hybrid device defined in an InAs nanowire with an epitaxial Al shell that consists of a quantum dot in contact with a superconducting island. The device is electrically floating, prohibiting transport measurements, but providing access to states that would otherwise be highly excited and unstable. Radio-frequency reflectometry with lumped-element resonators couples capacitatively to the…
▽ More
We study a hybrid device defined in an InAs nanowire with an epitaxial Al shell that consists of a quantum dot in contact with a superconducting island. The device is electrically floating, prohibiting transport measurements, but providing access to states that would otherwise be highly excited and unstable. Radio-frequency reflectometry with lumped-element resonators couples capacitatively to the quantum dot, and detects the presence of discrete subgap states. We perform a detailed study of the case with no island states, but with quantum-dot-induced subgap states controlled by the tunnel coupling. When the gap to the quasi-continuum of the excited states is small, the capacitance loading the resonator is strongly suppressed by thermal excitations, an effect we dub "thermal screening". The resonance frequency shift and changes in the quality factor at charge transitions can be accounted for using a single-level Anderson impurity model. The established measurement method, as well as the analysis and simulation framework, are applicable to more complex hybrid devices such as Andreev molecules or Kitaev chains.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2022; v1 submitted 4 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Direct manipulation of a superconducting spin qubit strongly coupled to a transmon qubit
Authors:
Marta Pita-Vidal,
Arno Bargerbos,
Rok Žitko,
Lukas J. Splitthoff,
Lukas Grünhaupt,
Jaap J. Wesdorp,
Yu Liu,
Leo P. Kouwenhoven,
Ramón Aguado,
Bernard van Heck,
Angela Kou,
Christian Kraglund Andersen
Abstract:
Spin qubits in semiconductors are currently one of the most promising architectures for quantum computing. However, they face challenges in realizing multi-qubit interactions over extended distances. Superconducting spin qubits provide a promising alternative by encoding a qubit in the spin degree of freedom of an Andreev level. Such an Andreev spin qubit could leverage the advantages of circuit q…
▽ More
Spin qubits in semiconductors are currently one of the most promising architectures for quantum computing. However, they face challenges in realizing multi-qubit interactions over extended distances. Superconducting spin qubits provide a promising alternative by encoding a qubit in the spin degree of freedom of an Andreev level. Such an Andreev spin qubit could leverage the advantages of circuit quantum electrodynamic, enabled by an intrinsic spin-supercurrent coupling. The first realization of an Andreev spin qubit encoded the qubit in the excited states of a semiconducting weak-link, leading to frequent decay out of the computational subspace. Additionally, rapid qubit manipulation was hindered by the need for indirect Raman transitions. Here, we exploit a different qubit subspace, using the spin-split doublet ground state of an electrostatically-defined quantum dot Josephson junction with large charging energy. Additionally, we use a magnetic field to enable direct spin manipulation over a frequency range of 10 GHz. Using an all-electric microwave drive we achieve Rabi frequencies exceeding 200 MHz. We furthermore embed the Andreev spin qubit in a superconducting transmon qubit, demonstrating strong coherent qubit-qubit coupling. These results are a crucial step towards a hybrid architecture that combines the beneficial aspects of both superconducting and semiconductor qubits.
△ Less
Submitted 28 August, 2022; v1 submitted 22 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Spectroscopy of spin-split Andreev levels in a quantum dot with superconducting leads
Authors:
Arno Bargerbos,
Marta Pita-Vidal,
Rok Žitko,
Lukas J. Splitthoff,
Lukas Grünhaupt,
Jaap J. Wesdorp,
Yu Liu,
Leo P. Kouwenhoven,
Ramón Aguado,
Christian Kraglund Andersen,
Angela Kou,
Bernard van Heck
Abstract:
We use a hybrid superconductor-semiconductor transmon device to perform spectroscopy of a quantum dot Josephson junction tuned to be in a spin-1/2 ground state with an unpaired quasiparticle. Due to spin-orbit coupling, we resolve two flux-sensitive branches in the transmon spectrum, depending on the spin of the quasi-particle. A finite magnetic field shifts the two branches in energy, favoring on…
▽ More
We use a hybrid superconductor-semiconductor transmon device to perform spectroscopy of a quantum dot Josephson junction tuned to be in a spin-1/2 ground state with an unpaired quasiparticle. Due to spin-orbit coupling, we resolve two flux-sensitive branches in the transmon spectrum, depending on the spin of the quasi-particle. A finite magnetic field shifts the two branches in energy, favoring one spin state and resulting in the anomalous Josephson effect. We demonstrate the excitation of the direct spin-flip transition using all-electrical control. Manipulation and control of the spin-flip transition enable the future implementation of charging energy protected Andreev spin qubits.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2022; v1 submitted 19 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Topological quantum phase transition of nickelocene on Cu(100)
Authors:
G. G. Blesio,
R. Žitko,
L. O. Manuel,
A. A. Aligia
Abstract:
Local quantum phase transitions driven by Kondo correlations have been theoretically proposed in several magnetic nanosystems; however, clear experimental signatures are scant. Modeling a nickelocene molecule on a Cu(100) substrate as a two-orbital Anderson impurity with single-ion easy-plane anisotropy coupled to two conduction bands, we find that recent scanning tunneling spectra measured at dif…
▽ More
Local quantum phase transitions driven by Kondo correlations have been theoretically proposed in several magnetic nanosystems; however, clear experimental signatures are scant. Modeling a nickelocene molecule on a Cu(100) substrate as a two-orbital Anderson impurity with single-ion easy-plane anisotropy coupled to two conduction bands, we find that recent scanning tunneling spectra measured at different microscope tip heights reveal the existence of a topological quantum phase transition from the usual local Fermi liquid with high zero-bias conductance to a non-Landau Fermi liquid, characterized by a non-trivial quantized Luttinger integral, with a small conductance. The effects of intermediate valence, finite temperature, and structural relaxation of the molecule position allow us to explain the different observed behaviors.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2023; v1 submitted 20 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Yu-Shiba-Rusinov states, the BCS-BEC crossover, and the exact solution in the flat-band limit
Authors:
Rok Žitko,
Luka Pavešić
Abstract:
We study the subgap Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) states in the Richardson's model of a superconductor with a magnetic impurity for different electron pairing strengths from the weak-coupling Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) regime to the strong-coupling Bose-Einstein-condensate (BEC) regime. We observe that the effect of the increasing pairing strength on the YSR excitation spectrum as a function of hybr…
▽ More
We study the subgap Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) states in the Richardson's model of a superconductor with a magnetic impurity for different electron pairing strengths from the weak-coupling Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) regime to the strong-coupling Bose-Einstein-condensate (BEC) regime. We observe that the effect of the increasing pairing strength on the YSR excitation spectrum as a function of hybridisation strength and impurity on-site potential is only quantitative and, in fact, rather weak when the results are appropriately rescaled. We furthermore show that the problem is analytically solvable in the deep BEC limit which is equivalent to flat-band superconductivity. This exact solution can be related to a zero-bandwidth (ZBW) effective BCS mean field Hamiltonian where the superconductor is described by a single electron level with onsite pairing. The small difference between the BCS and BEC regimes of the Richardson's model explains the success of the simple ZBW calculations for BCS mean-field Hamiltonians. A ZBW model requires only a suitable parameter rescaling to become useful as a quantitative predictive tool for the full problem.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Entanglement between quasiparticles in superconducting islands mediated by a single spin
Authors:
Juan Carlos Estrada Saldaña,
Alexandros Vekris,
Luka Pavešič,
Rok Žitko,
Kasper Grove-Rasmussen,
Jesper Nygård
Abstract:
Condensed matter is composed of a small set of identical units, yet it shows an immense range of behaviour. Recently, an array of cold atoms was used to generate long-range quantum entanglement, a property of topological matter. Another approach to strong non-local correlations employs the macroscopic coherence of superconductors. Impurity spins in superconductors are thought to be unamenable to t…
▽ More
Condensed matter is composed of a small set of identical units, yet it shows an immense range of behaviour. Recently, an array of cold atoms was used to generate long-range quantum entanglement, a property of topological matter. Another approach to strong non-local correlations employs the macroscopic coherence of superconductors. Impurity spins in superconductors are thought to be unamenable to the formation of long-range spin entanglement because each spin tends to be screened by binding to a quasiparticle from the superconductor to form a local singlet. Here we demonstrate that it is possible to attach a second quasiparticle to the spin, overscreening it into a doublet state carrying ferromagnetic correlations between two quasiparticles over a micrometer distance. To demonstrate this effect, which is strongest for equal binding, we symmetrically couple the spin of a quantum dot to two ultrasmall superconducting islands. The overscreened state requires sufficiently large Coulomb repulsion and exchange binding to become well defined. We predict that this state will carry long-range correlations for an alternating chain of quantum dots and superconducting islands, opening a new route to controllable large-scale entanglement in the solid state.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2023; v1 submitted 28 February, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Singlet-doublet transitions of a quantum dot Josephson junction detected in a transmon circuit
Authors:
Arno Bargerbos,
Marta Pita-Vidal,
Rok Žitko,
Jesús Ávila,
Lukas J. Splitthoff,
Lukas Grünhaupt,
Jaap J. Wesdorp,
Christian K. Andersen,
Yu Liu,
Leo P. Kouwenhoven,
Ramón Aguado,
Angela Kou,
Bernard van Heck
Abstract:
We realize a hybrid superconductor-semiconductor transmon device in which the Josephson effect is controlled by a gate-defined quantum dot in an InAs/Al nanowire. Microwave spectroscopy of the transmon's transition spectrum allows us to probe the ground state parity of the quantum dot as a function of gate voltages, external magnetic flux, and magnetic field applied parallel to the nanowire. The m…
▽ More
We realize a hybrid superconductor-semiconductor transmon device in which the Josephson effect is controlled by a gate-defined quantum dot in an InAs/Al nanowire. Microwave spectroscopy of the transmon's transition spectrum allows us to probe the ground state parity of the quantum dot as a function of gate voltages, external magnetic flux, and magnetic field applied parallel to the nanowire. The measured parity phase diagram is in agreement with that predicted by a single-impurity Anderson model with superconducting leads. Through continuous time monitoring of the circuit we furthermore resolve the quasiparticle dynamics of the quantum dot Josephson junction across the phase boundaries. Our results can facilitate the realization of semiconductor-based $0-π$ qubits and Andreev qubits.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Qubit based on spin-singlet Yu-Shiba-Rusinov states
Authors:
Luka Pavešić,
Rok Žitko
Abstract:
The local magnetic moment of an interacting quantum dot occupied by a single electron can be screened by binding a Bogoliubov quasiparticle from a nearby superconductor. This gives rise to a long-lived discrete spin-singlet state inside the superconducting gap, known as the Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) state. We study the nature of the subgap states induced by a quantum dot embedded between two small su…
▽ More
The local magnetic moment of an interacting quantum dot occupied by a single electron can be screened by binding a Bogoliubov quasiparticle from a nearby superconductor. This gives rise to a long-lived discrete spin-singlet state inside the superconducting gap, known as the Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) state. We study the nature of the subgap states induced by a quantum dot embedded between two small superconducting islands. We show that this system has two spin-singlet subgap states with different spatial charge distributions. These states can be put in a linear superposition and coherently manipulated using electric-field pulses applied on the gate electrode. Such YSR qubit could be implemented using present-day technology.
△ Less
Submitted 1 December, 2021; v1 submitted 26 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Iron phthalocyanine on Au(111) is a "non-Landau" Fermi liquid
Authors:
R. Žitko,
G. G. Blesio,
L. O. Manuel,
A. A. Aligia
Abstract:
The paradigm of Landau's Fermi liquid theory has been challenged with the finding of a strongly interacting Fermi liquid that cannot be adiabatically connected to a non-interacting system. A spin-1 two-channel Kondo impurity with anisotropy D has a quantum phase transition between two topologically different Fermi liquids with a peak (dip) in the Fermi level for D < Dc (D > Dc). Extending this the…
▽ More
The paradigm of Landau's Fermi liquid theory has been challenged with the finding of a strongly interacting Fermi liquid that cannot be adiabatically connected to a non-interacting system. A spin-1 two-channel Kondo impurity with anisotropy D has a quantum phase transition between two topologically different Fermi liquids with a peak (dip) in the Fermi level for D < Dc (D > Dc). Extending this theory to general multi-orbital problems with finite magnetic field, we reinterpret in a unified and consistent fashion several experimental studies of iron phthalocyanine molecules on Au(111) that were previously described in disconnected and conflicting ways. The differential conductance shows a zero-bias dip that widens when the molecule is lifted from the surface (reducing the Kondo couplings) and is transformed continuously into a peak under an applied magnetic field. We reproduce all features and propose an experiment to induce the topological transition.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2021; v1 submitted 27 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Universal magnetic oscillations of DC conductivity in the incoherent regime of correlated systems
Authors:
Jaksa Vucicevic,
Rok Zitko
Abstract:
Using the dynamical mean field theory we investigate the magnetic field dependence of DC conductivity in the Hubbard model on the square lattice, fully taking into account the orbital effects of the field introduced via the Peierls substitution. In addition to the conventional Shubnikov-de Haas quantum oscillations, associated with the coherent cyclotron motion of quasiparticles and the presence o…
▽ More
Using the dynamical mean field theory we investigate the magnetic field dependence of DC conductivity in the Hubbard model on the square lattice, fully taking into account the orbital effects of the field introduced via the Peierls substitution. In addition to the conventional Shubnikov-de Haas quantum oscillations, associated with the coherent cyclotron motion of quasiparticles and the presence of a well-defined Fermi surface, we find an additional oscillatory component with a higher frequency that corresponds to the total area of the Brillouin zone. These paradigm-breaking oscillations appear at elevated temperature. This finding is in excellent qualitative agreement with the recent experiments on graphene superlattices. We elucidate the key roles of the off-diagonal elements of the current vertex and the incoherence of electronic states, and explain the trends with respect to temperature and doping.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2021; v1 submitted 29 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Electrical conductivity in the Hubbard model: orbital effects of magnetic field
Authors:
Jaksa Vucicevic,
Rok Zitko
Abstract:
Calculation of conductivity in the Hubbard model is a challenging task. Recent years have seen much progress in this respect and numerically exact solutions are now possible in certain regimes. In this paper we discuss the calculation of conductivity for the square lattice Hubbard model in the presence of a perpendicular magnetic field, focusing on orbital effects. We present the relevant formalis…
▽ More
Calculation of conductivity in the Hubbard model is a challenging task. Recent years have seen much progress in this respect and numerically exact solutions are now possible in certain regimes. In this paper we discuss the calculation of conductivity for the square lattice Hubbard model in the presence of a perpendicular magnetic field, focusing on orbital effects. We present the relevant formalism in all detail and in full generality, and then discuss the simplifications that arise at the level of the dynamical mean field theory (DMFT). We prove that the Kubo bubble preserves gauge and translational invariance, and that in the DMFT the vertex corrections cancel regardless of the magnetic field. We present the DMFT results for the spectral function and both the longitudinal and Hall conductivity in several regimes of parameters. We analyze thoroughly the quantum oscillations of the longitudinal conductivity and identify a high-frequency oscillation component, arising as a combined effect of scattering and temperature, in line with recent experimental observations in moiré systems.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2021; v1 submitted 29 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Excitations in a superconducting Coulombic energy gap
Authors:
Juan Carlos Estrada Saldaña,
Alexandros Vekris,
Luka Pavešič,
Peter Krogstrup,
Rok Žitko,
Kasper Grove-Rasmussen,
Jesper Nygård
Abstract:
Cooper pairing and Coulomb repulsion are antagonists, producing distinct energy gaps in superconductors and Mott insulators. When a superconductor exchanges unpaired electrons with a quantum dot, its gap is populated by a pair of electron-hole symmetric Yu-Shiba-Rusinov excitations between doublet and singlet many-body states. The fate of these excitations in the presence of a strong Coulomb repul…
▽ More
Cooper pairing and Coulomb repulsion are antagonists, producing distinct energy gaps in superconductors and Mott insulators. When a superconductor exchanges unpaired electrons with a quantum dot, its gap is populated by a pair of electron-hole symmetric Yu-Shiba-Rusinov excitations between doublet and singlet many-body states. The fate of these excitations in the presence of a strong Coulomb repulsion in the superconductor is unknown, but of importance in applications such as topological superconducting qubits and multi-channel impurity models. Here we couple a quantum dot to a superconducting island with a tunable Coulomb repulsion. We show that a strong Coulomb repulsion changes the singlet many-body state into a two-body state. It also breaks the electron-hole energy symmetry of the excitations, which thereby lose their Yu-Shiba-Rusinov character.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2022; v1 submitted 26 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Subgap states in superconducting islands
Authors:
Luka Pavešić,
Daniel Bauernfeind,
Rok Žitko
Abstract:
We study an interacting quantum dot in contact with a superconducting island described by the Richardson model with a Coulomb repulsion term controlling the number of electrons on the island. This Hamiltonian admits a compact matrix-product-operator representation and can be efficiently and accurately solved using the density-matrix renormalization group. We systematically explore the effects of t…
▽ More
We study an interacting quantum dot in contact with a superconducting island described by the Richardson model with a Coulomb repulsion term controlling the number of electrons on the island. This Hamiltonian admits a compact matrix-product-operator representation and can be efficiently and accurately solved using the density-matrix renormalization group. We systematically explore the effects of the charging energy $E_c$. For $E_c$ comparable to the superconducting gap $Δ$, the subgap states are stabilized by the combination of Kondo exchange coupling and charge redistribution driven by the Coulomb interaction. The subgap states exist for both even and odd superconductor ground-state occupancy, but with very distinctive excitation spectra in each case. The spectral peaks are not symmetric with respect to the chemical potential and may undergo discontinuous changes as a function of gate voltages.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2021; v1 submitted 25 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Coupled Yu-Shiba-Rusinov states induced by a many-body molecular spin on a superconductor
Authors:
Carmen Rubio-Verdú,
Javier Zaldívar,
Rok Žitko,
Jose Ignacio Pascual
Abstract:
A magnetic impurity on a superconductor induces Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) bound states, detected by tunneling spectroscopy as long-lived quasiparticle excitations inside the superconducting gap. Coupled YSR states constitute basic elements to engineer artificial superconducting states, but their substrate-mediated interactions are generally weak. In this paper, we report that intramolecular (Hund's l…
▽ More
A magnetic impurity on a superconductor induces Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) bound states, detected by tunneling spectroscopy as long-lived quasiparticle excitations inside the superconducting gap. Coupled YSR states constitute basic elements to engineer artificial superconducting states, but their substrate-mediated interactions are generally weak. In this paper, we report that intramolecular (Hund's like) exchange interactions produce coupled YSR states across a molecular platform. We measured YSR spectra along a magnetic iron-porphyrin on Pb(111) and found evidences of two orbital interaction channels, which invert their particle-hole asymmetry across the molecule. Numerical calculations show that the identical YSR asymmetry pattern of the two channels is caused by two spin-hosting orbitals with opposite potential scattering and coupled strongly. Both channels can be similarly excited by tunneling electrons into each orbital, depicting a new scenario for entangled superconducting bound states using molecular platforms.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2021; v1 submitted 23 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Anisotropic Kondo screening induced by spin-orbit coupling in quantum wires
Authors:
E. Vernek,
G. B. Martins,
R. Zitko
Abstract:
Using the numerical renormalization group (NRG) method we study a magnetic impurity coupled to a quantum wire with Rashba and Dresselhaus spin-orbit coupling (SOC) in an external magnetic field. We consider the low-filling regime with the Fermi energy close to the bottom of the band and report the results for local static and dynamic properties in the Kondo regime. In the absence of the field, loc…
▽ More
Using the numerical renormalization group (NRG) method we study a magnetic impurity coupled to a quantum wire with Rashba and Dresselhaus spin-orbit coupling (SOC) in an external magnetic field. We consider the low-filling regime with the Fermi energy close to the bottom of the band and report the results for local static and dynamic properties in the Kondo regime. In the absence of the field, local impurity properties remain isotropic in spin space despite the SOC-induced magnetic anisotropy of the conduction band. In the presence of the field, clear fingerprints of anisotropy are revealed through the strong field-direction dependence of the impurity spin polarization and spectra, in particular of the Kondo peak height. The detailed behavior depends on the relative magnitudes of the impurity and band $g$-factors. For the case of impurity $g$-factor somewhat lower than the band $g$-factor, the maximal Kondo peak suppression is found for field oriented along the effective SOC field axis, while for a field perpendicular to this direction we observe a compensation effect (``revival of the Kondo peak''): the SOC counteracts the Kondo peak splitting effects of the local Zeeman field. We demonstrate that the SOC-induced anisotropy, measurable by tunneling spectroscopy techniques, can help to determine the ratio of Rashba and Dresselhaus SOC strengths in the wire.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Charge transport in the Hubbard model at high temperatures: triangular versus square lattice
Authors:
A. Vranic,
J. Vucicevic,
J. Kokalj,
J. Skolimowski,
R. Zitko,
J. Mravlje,
D. Tanaskovic
Abstract:
High-temperature bad-metal transport has been recently studied both theoretically and in experiments as one of the key signatures of strong electronic correlations. Here we use the dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) and its cluster extensions, as well as the finite-temperature Lanczos method (FTLM) to explore the influence of lattice frustration on the thermodynamic and transport properties of the…
▽ More
High-temperature bad-metal transport has been recently studied both theoretically and in experiments as one of the key signatures of strong electronic correlations. Here we use the dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) and its cluster extensions, as well as the finite-temperature Lanczos method (FTLM) to explore the influence of lattice frustration on the thermodynamic and transport properties of the Hubbard model at high temperatures. We consider the triangular and the square lattice at half-filling and at 15\% hole-doping. We find that for $T \gtrsim 1.5t$ the self-energy becomes practically local, while the finite-size effects become small at lattice-size $4 \times 4$ for both lattice types and doping levels. The vertex corrections to optical conductivity, which are significant on the square lattice even at high temperatures, contribute less on the triangular lattice. We find approximately linear temperature dependence of dc resistivity in doped Mott insulator for both types of lattices.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2020; v1 submitted 2 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Aharonov-Bohm and Aharonov-Casher effects in double quantum dot Josephson junction
Authors:
Damian Tomaszewski,
Piotr Busz,
Rosa Lopez,
Rok Zitko,
Minchul Lee,
Jan Martinek
Abstract:
We analyze a Josephson junction between two superconductors interconnected through a normal-state nanostructure made of two parallel nanowires with embedded quantum dots. We study the influence of interference effects due to the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) and Aharonov-Casher (AC) phases for local and nonlocal (split) Cooper pairs. In the AB effect the phase of electron is affected by magnetic flux, while…
▽ More
We analyze a Josephson junction between two superconductors interconnected through a normal-state nanostructure made of two parallel nanowires with embedded quantum dots. We study the influence of interference effects due to the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) and Aharonov-Casher (AC) phases for local and nonlocal (split) Cooper pairs. In the AB effect the phase of electron is affected by magnetic flux, while in the AC effect the phase of the electron in solid state can be modified due to the Rashba spin-orbit coupling. In the low-transmission regime the AB and AC effects can be related to only local or nonlocal Cooper pair transport, respectively. We demonstrate that by the addition of the quantum dots the Cooper pair splitting can be made perfectly efficient, and that the AC phase is different for non-spin-flip and spin-flip transport processes.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Aharonov-Bohm and Aharonov-Casher effects for local and nonlocal Cooper pairs
Authors:
Damian Tomaszewski,
Piotr Busz,
Rosa Lopez,
Rok Zitko,
Minchul Lee,
Jan Martinek
Abstract:
We study combined interference effects due to the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) and Aharonov-Casher (AC) phases in a Josephson supercurrent of local and nonlocal (split) Cooper pairs. We analyze a junction between two superconductors interconnected through a normal-state nanostructure with either (i) a ring, where single-electron interference is possible, or (ii) two parallel nanowires, where the single-elec…
▽ More
We study combined interference effects due to the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) and Aharonov-Casher (AC) phases in a Josephson supercurrent of local and nonlocal (split) Cooper pairs. We analyze a junction between two superconductors interconnected through a normal-state nanostructure with either (i) a ring, where single-electron interference is possible, or (ii) two parallel nanowires, where the single-electron interference can be absent, but the cross Andreeev reflection can occur. In the low-transmission regime in both geometries the AB and AC effects can be related to only local or nonlocal Cooper pair transport, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Investigation of the Yu-Shiba-Rusinov states of a multi-impurity Kondo system
Authors:
A. Kamlapure,
L. Cornils,
R. Žitko,
M. Valentyuk,
R. Mozara,
S. Pradhan,
J. Fransson,
A. I. Lichtenstein,
J. Wiebe,
R. Wiesendanger
Abstract:
Recent studies of mutually interacting magnetic atoms coupled to a superconductor have gained enormous interest due to the potential realization of topological superconductivity. The Kondo exchange coupling J_K of such atoms with the electrons in the superconductor has a pair-breaking effect which produces so-called Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) states within the superconducting energy gap, whose energet…
▽ More
Recent studies of mutually interacting magnetic atoms coupled to a superconductor have gained enormous interest due to the potential realization of topological superconductivity. The Kondo exchange coupling J_K of such atoms with the electrons in the superconductor has a pair-breaking effect which produces so-called Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) states within the superconducting energy gap, whose energetic positions are intimately connected with the requirements for topological superconductivity. Here, using the tip of a scanning tunneling microscope, we artificially craft a multi-impurity Kondo system coupled to a superconducting host consisting of an Fe adatom interacting with an assembly of interstitial Fe atoms on an oxygen-reconstructed Ta(100) surface and we experimentally investigate the signatures of Kondo screening and the YSR states. With the help of numerical renormalization group (NRG) calculations, we show that the observed behavior can be qualitatively reproduced by a two-impurity Kondo system whose inter-impurity antiferromagnetic interaction J is adjusted by the number of interstitial Fe atoms in the assembly. When driving the system from the regime of two decoupled Kondo singlets (small J) to that of an antiferromagnetic dimer (large J), the YSR state shows a characteristic cross-over in its energetic position and particle-hole asymmetry.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Non-Fermi-liquid fixed point in multi-orbital Kondo impurity model relevant for Hund's metals
Authors:
Alen Horvat,
Rok Zitko,
Jernej Mravlje
Abstract:
Due to the separation between the spin and the orbital screening scales, the normal state of Hund's metals at ambient temperature can be loosely characterized as a partially coherent state with fluctuating spins and quenched orbital moments. With the aim to characterize this situation more precisely, we investigate the Kondo-Kanamori impurity model that describes the low-energy local physics of th…
▽ More
Due to the separation between the spin and the orbital screening scales, the normal state of Hund's metals at ambient temperature can be loosely characterized as a partially coherent state with fluctuating spins and quenched orbital moments. With the aim to characterize this situation more precisely, we investigate the Kondo-Kanamori impurity model that describes the low-energy local physics of three-orbital Hund's metals occupied by two or four electrons. Within this model one can diminish the mixed spin-orbital terms and thereby enhance the separation between the two screening scales, allowing a more precise investigation of the intermediate state. Using the numerical renormalization group we calculate the impurity entropy as well as the temperature and frequency dependence of the spin and the orbital susceptibilities. We uncover a non-Fermi-liquid two-channel overscreened SU(3) fixed point that controls the behavior in the intermediate regime. We discuss its fingerprints in the frequency dependence of local orbital susceptibility and the shape of the spectral function.
△ Less
Submitted 12 August, 2019; v1 submitted 16 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Emission of correlated jets from a driven matter-wave soliton in a quasi-one-dimensional geometry
Authors:
Tadej Mežnaršič,
Rok Žitko,
Tina Arh,
Katja Gosar,
Erik Zupanič,
Peter Jeglič
Abstract:
We demonstrate the emission of correlated atom jets from a matter-wave soliton in a quasi-one-dimensional optical trap. We characterize the dependence of jet properties on the frequency, amplitude and length of the modulation, and qualitatively reproduce the trends in the mean-field picture with a one-dimensional time-dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation simulation. High-order jets are observed for…
▽ More
We demonstrate the emission of correlated atom jets from a matter-wave soliton in a quasi-one-dimensional optical trap. We characterize the dependence of jet properties on the frequency, amplitude and length of the modulation, and qualitatively reproduce the trends in the mean-field picture with a one-dimensional time-dependent Gross-Pitaevskii equation simulation. High-order jets are observed for sufficiently long pulses. A double-pulse modulation sequence produces consecutive jets, and a multi-pulse sequence may lead to irregular 3D jets at a finite angle to the direction of the channel. In the limit of vanishing high-order jets beyond-mean-field number correlations of jet pairs are demonstrated, implying possible number squeezing.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2020; v1 submitted 24 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Kondo screening in a charge-insulating spinon metal
Authors:
M. Gomilšek,
R. Žitko,
M. Klanjšek,
M. Pregelj,
C. Baines,
Y. Li,
Q. M. Zhang,
A. Zorko
Abstract:
The Kondo effect, an eminent manifestation of many-body physics in condensed matter, is traditionally explained as exchange scattering of conduction electrons on a spinful impurity in a metal. The resulting screening of the impurity's local moment by the electron Fermi sea is characterized by a Kondo temperature $T_K$, below which the system enters a non-perturbative strongly-coupled regime. In re…
▽ More
The Kondo effect, an eminent manifestation of many-body physics in condensed matter, is traditionally explained as exchange scattering of conduction electrons on a spinful impurity in a metal. The resulting screening of the impurity's local moment by the electron Fermi sea is characterized by a Kondo temperature $T_K$, below which the system enters a non-perturbative strongly-coupled regime. In recent years, this effect has found its realizations beyond the bulk-metal paradigm in many other itinerant-electron systems, such as quantum dots in semiconductor heterostructures and in nanomaterials, quantum point contacts, and graphene. Here we report on the first experimental observation of the Kondo screening by chargeless quasiparticles. This occurs in a charge-insulating quantum spin liquid, where spinon excitations forming a Fermi surface take the role of conduction electrons. The observed impurity behaviour therefore bears a strong resemblance to the conventional case in a metal. The discovered spinon-based Kondo effect provides a prominent platform for characterising and possibly manipulating enigmatic host spin liquids.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Erasing odd-parity states in semiconductor quantum dots coupled to superconductors
Authors:
Z. Su,
R. Zitko,
P. Zhang,
H. Wu,
D. Car,
S. R. Plissard,
S. Gazibegovic,
G. H. A. Badawy,
M. Hocevar,
J. Chen,
E. P. A. M. Bakkers,
S. M. Frolov
Abstract:
Quantum dots are gate-defined within InSb nanowires, in proximity to NbTiN superconducting contacts. As the coupling between the dot and the superconductor is increased, the odd-parity occupations become non-discernible (erased) both above and below the induced superconducting gap. Above the gap, conductance in the odd Coulomb valleys increases until the valleys are lifted. Below the gap, Andreev…
▽ More
Quantum dots are gate-defined within InSb nanowires, in proximity to NbTiN superconducting contacts. As the coupling between the dot and the superconductor is increased, the odd-parity occupations become non-discernible (erased) both above and below the induced superconducting gap. Above the gap, conductance in the odd Coulomb valleys increases until the valleys are lifted. Below the gap, Andreev bound states undergo quantum phase transitions to singlet ground states at odd occupancy. We observe that the apparent erasure of odd-parity regimes coincides at low-bias and at high-bias. This observation is reproduced in numerical renormalization group simulations, and is explained qualitatively by a competition between Kondo temperature and the induced superconducting gap. In the erased odd-parity regime, the quantum dot exhibits transport features similar to a finite-size Majorana nanowire, drawing parallels between even-odd dot occupations and even-odd one-dimensional subband occupations.
△ Less
Submitted 10 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Cesium bright matter-wave solitons and soliton trains
Authors:
Tadej Mežnaršič,
Tina Arh,
Jure Brence,
Jaka Pišljar,
Katja Gosar,
Žiga Gosar,
Rok Žitko,
Erik Zupanič,
Peter Jeglič
Abstract:
A study of bright matter-wave solitons of a cesium Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) is presented. Production of a single soliton is demonstrated and dependence of soliton atom number on the interatomic interaction is investigated. Formation of soliton trains in the quasi one-dimensional confinement is shown. Additionally, fragmentation of a BEC has been observed outside confinement, in free space. I…
▽ More
A study of bright matter-wave solitons of a cesium Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) is presented. Production of a single soliton is demonstrated and dependence of soliton atom number on the interatomic interaction is investigated. Formation of soliton trains in the quasi one-dimensional confinement is shown. Additionally, fragmentation of a BEC has been observed outside confinement, in free space. In the end a double BEC production setup for studying soliton collisions is described.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2019; v1 submitted 8 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Superconducting quantum dot and the sub-gap states
Authors:
Rok Zitko
Abstract:
Quantum dots are nanostructures made of semiconducting materials that are engineered to hold a small amount of electric charge (a few electrons) that is controlled by external gate and may hence be considered as tunable artificial atoms. A quantum dot may be contacted by conductive leads to become the active part of a single-electron transistor, a device that is highly conductive only at very spec…
▽ More
Quantum dots are nanostructures made of semiconducting materials that are engineered to hold a small amount of electric charge (a few electrons) that is controlled by external gate and may hence be considered as tunable artificial atoms. A quantum dot may be contacted by conductive leads to become the active part of a single-electron transistor, a device that is highly conductive only at very specific gate voltages. In recent years a significant attention has been given to more complex hybrid devices, in particular superconductor-semiconductor heterostructures. Here I review the theoretical and experimental studies of small quantum-dot devices contacted by one or several superconducting leads. I focus on the research on the low-lying localized electronic excitations that exist inside the superconducting gap (Yu-Shiba-Rusinov states) and determine the transport properties of these devices. The sub-gap states can be accurately simulated using the numerical renormalization group technique, often providing full quantitative understanding of the observed phenomena.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Two-Impurity Yu-Shiba-Rusinov States in Coupled Quantum Dots
Authors:
J. C. Estrada Saldaña,
A. Vekris,
R. Žitko,
G. Steffensen,
P. Krogstrup,
J. Paaske,
K. Grove-Rasmussen,
J. Nygård
Abstract:
Using double quantum dots as the weak link of a Josephson junction, we realize the superconducting analog of the celebrated two-impurity Kondo model. The device shows a cusped current-voltage characteristic, which can be modelled by an overdamped circuit relating the observed cusp current to the Josephson critical current. The gate dependence of the cusp current and of the subgap spectra are used…
▽ More
Using double quantum dots as the weak link of a Josephson junction, we realize the superconducting analog of the celebrated two-impurity Kondo model. The device shows a cusped current-voltage characteristic, which can be modelled by an overdamped circuit relating the observed cusp current to the Josephson critical current. The gate dependence of the cusp current and of the subgap spectra are used as complementary ground-state indicators to demonstrate gate-tuned changes of the ground state from an inter-dot singlet to independently screened Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) singlets. In contrast to the two-impurity Kondo effect in normal-state systems, the crossover between these two singlets is heralded by quantum phase boundaries to nearby doublet YSR phases in which only a single spin is screened.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2020; v1 submitted 21 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Observation of Coexistence of Yu-Shiba-Rusinov States and Spin-Flip Excitations
Authors:
Shawulienu Kezilebieke,
Rok Žitko,
Marc Dvorak,
Teemu Ojanen,
Peter Liljeroth
Abstract:
We investigate the spectral evolution in different metal phthalocyanine molecules on NbSe$_2$ surface using scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) as a function of the coupling with the substrate. For manganese phthalocyanine (MnPc), we demonstrate a smooth spectral crossover from Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) bound states to spin-flip excitations. This has not been observed previously and it is in contras…
▽ More
We investigate the spectral evolution in different metal phthalocyanine molecules on NbSe$_2$ surface using scanning tunnelling microscopy (STM) as a function of the coupling with the substrate. For manganese phthalocyanine (MnPc), we demonstrate a smooth spectral crossover from Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) bound states to spin-flip excitations. This has not been observed previously and it is in contrast to simple theoretical expectations. We corroborate the experimental findings using numerical renormalization group calculations. Our results provide fundamental new insight on the behavior of atomic scale magnetic/SC hybrid systems, which is important for e.g. engineered topological superconductors and spin logic devices.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2019; v1 submitted 28 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Conductivity in the square lattice Hubbard model at high temperatures: importance of vertex corrections
Authors:
Jaksa Vucicevic,
Jure Kokalj,
Rok Zitko,
Nils Wentzell,
Darko Tanaskovic,
Jernej Mravlje
Abstract:
Recent experiments on cold atoms in optical lattices allow for a quantitative comparison of the measurements to the conductivity calculations in the square lattice Hubbard model. However, the available calculations do not give consistent results and the question of the exact solution for the conductivity in the Hubbard model remained open. In this letter we employ several complementary state-of-th…
▽ More
Recent experiments on cold atoms in optical lattices allow for a quantitative comparison of the measurements to the conductivity calculations in the square lattice Hubbard model. However, the available calculations do not give consistent results and the question of the exact solution for the conductivity in the Hubbard model remained open. In this letter we employ several complementary state-of-the-art numerical methods to disentangle various contributions to conductivity, and identify the best available result to be compared to experiment. We find that at relevant (high) temperatures, the self-energy is practically local, yet the vertex corrections remain rather important, contrary to expectations. The finite-size effects are small even at the lattice size $4\times 4$ and the corresponding Lanczos diagonalization result is therefore close to the exact result in the thermodynamic limit.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2019; v1 submitted 20 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Mottness collapse without metallisation in the domain walls of triangular-lattice Mott insulator 1T-TaS$_2$
Authors:
Jan Skolimowski,
Yaroslav Gerasimenko,
Rok Žitko
Abstract:
1T-TaS$_2$ is a charge-density-wave (CDW) compound with a Mott-insulating ground state. The metallic state obtained by doping, substitution or pulsed charge injection is characterized by an emergent CDW domain wall network, while single domain walls can be found in the pristine Mott state. Here we study whether and how the single walls become metallic. Tunneling spectroscopy reveals partial suppre…
▽ More
1T-TaS$_2$ is a charge-density-wave (CDW) compound with a Mott-insulating ground state. The metallic state obtained by doping, substitution or pulsed charge injection is characterized by an emergent CDW domain wall network, while single domain walls can be found in the pristine Mott state. Here we study whether and how the single walls become metallic. Tunneling spectroscopy reveals partial suppression of the Mott gap and the presence of in-gap states strongly localized at the domain-wall sites. Using the real-space dynamical mean field theory description of the strongly correlated quantum-paramagnet ground state we show that the local gap suppression follows from the increased hopping along the connected zig-zag chain of lattice sites forming the domain wall, and that full metallisation is preempted by the splitting of the quasiparticle band into bonding and antibonding sub-bands due to the structural dimerization of the wall, explaining the presence of the in-gap states and the low density of states at the Fermi level.
△ Less
Submitted 22 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
A comparative study of nonequilibrium insulator-to-metal transitions in electron-phonon systems
Authors:
Sharareh Sayyad,
Rok Zitko,
Hugo U. R. Strand,
Philipp Werner,
Denis Golez
Abstract:
We study equilibrium and nonequilibrium properties of electron-phonon systems described by the Hubbard-Holstein model using the dynamical mean-field theory. In equilibrium, we benchmark the results for impurity solvers based on the one-crossing approximation and slave-rotor approximation against non-perturbative numerical renormalization group reference data. We also examine how well the low energ…
▽ More
We study equilibrium and nonequilibrium properties of electron-phonon systems described by the Hubbard-Holstein model using the dynamical mean-field theory. In equilibrium, we benchmark the results for impurity solvers based on the one-crossing approximation and slave-rotor approximation against non-perturbative numerical renormalization group reference data. We also examine how well the low energy properties of the electron-boson coupled systems can be reproduced by an effective static electron-electron interaction. The one-crossing and slave-rotor approximations are then used to simulate insulator-to-metal transitions induced by a sudden switch-on of the electron-phonon interaction. The slave-rotor results suggest the existence of a critical electron-phonon coupling above which the system is transiently trapped in a non-thermal metallic state with coherent quasiparticles. The same quench protocol in the one-crossing approximation results in a bad metallic state.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Supercurrent in a double quantum dot
Authors:
J. C. Estrada Saldaña,
A. Vekris,
G. Steffensen,
R. Žitko,
P. Krogstrup,
J. Paaske,
K. Grove-Rasmussen,
J. Nygård
Abstract:
We demonstrate the Josephson effect in a serial double quantum dot defined in a nanowire with epitaxial superconducting leads. The supercurrent stability diagram adopts a honeycomb pattern with electron-hole and left-right reflection symmetry. We observe sharp discontinuities in the magnitude of the critical current, $I_c$, as a function of dot occupation, related to doublet to singlet ground stat…
▽ More
We demonstrate the Josephson effect in a serial double quantum dot defined in a nanowire with epitaxial superconducting leads. The supercurrent stability diagram adopts a honeycomb pattern with electron-hole and left-right reflection symmetry. We observe sharp discontinuities in the magnitude of the critical current, $I_c$, as a function of dot occupation, related to doublet to singlet ground state transitions. Detuning of the energy levels offers a tuning knob for $I_c$, which attains a maximum at zero detuning. The consistency between experiment and theory indicates that our device is a faithful realization of the two-impurity Anderson model.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2020; v1 submitted 17 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Reversal of particle-hole scattering-rate asymmetry in Anderson impurity model
Authors:
R. Zitko,
H. R. Krishnamurthy,
B. Sriram Shastry
Abstract:
We study the particle-hole asymmetry of the scattering rate in strongly correlated electron systems by examining the cubic $ω^3$ and $ωT^2$ terms in the imaginary part of the self-energy of the Anderson impurity model. We show that the sign is opposite in the weak-coupling and strong-coupling limits, explaining the differences found in theoretical approaches taking the respective limits as the sta…
▽ More
We study the particle-hole asymmetry of the scattering rate in strongly correlated electron systems by examining the cubic $ω^3$ and $ωT^2$ terms in the imaginary part of the self-energy of the Anderson impurity model. We show that the sign is opposite in the weak-coupling and strong-coupling limits, explaining the differences found in theoretical approaches taking the respective limits as the starting points. The sign change in fact precisely delineates the cross-over between the weak and strong correlation regimes of the model. For weak interaction $U$ the sign reversal occurs for small values of the doping $δ=1-n$, while for interaction of order $U \approx 2 Γ$, $Γ$ being the hybridization strength, the cross-over curve rapidly shifts to the large-doping range. This curve based on the impurity dynamics is genuinely different from other cross-over curves defined through impurity thermodynamic and static properties.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2018; v1 submitted 30 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Supercurrent through a spin-split quasi-ballistic point contact in an InAs nanowire
Authors:
J. C. Estrada Saldaña,
R. Žitko,
J. P. Cleuziou,
E. J. H. Lee,
V. Zannier,
D. Ercolani,
L. Sorba,
R. Aguado,
S. De Franceschi
Abstract:
We study the superconducting proximity effect in an InAs nanowire contacted by Ta-based superconducting electrodes. Using local bottom gates, we control the potential landscape along the nanowire, tuning its conductance to a quasi-ballistic regime. At high magnetic field ($B$), we observe approximately quantized conductance plateaus associated with the first two spin-polarized one-dimensional mode…
▽ More
We study the superconducting proximity effect in an InAs nanowire contacted by Ta-based superconducting electrodes. Using local bottom gates, we control the potential landscape along the nanowire, tuning its conductance to a quasi-ballistic regime. At high magnetic field ($B$), we observe approximately quantized conductance plateaus associated with the first two spin-polarized one-dimensional modes. For $B < 1$ T, the onset of superconductivity occurs in concomitance with the development of sizeable charge localization leading to a 0.7-type conductance anomaly. In this regime, the proximity supercurrent exhibits an unusual, non-monotonic $B$ dependence. We interpret this finding in terms of a competition between the Kondo effect, dominating near $B=0$, and the Zeeman effect, enforcing spin polarization and the emergence of a $π$ phase shift in the Josephson relation at higher $B$.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Yu-Shiba-Rusinov screening of spins in double quantum dots
Authors:
K. Grove-Rasmussen,
G. Steffensen,
A. Jellinggaard,
M. H. Madsen,
R. Žitko,
J. Paaske,
J. Nygård
Abstract:
A magnetic impurity coupled to a superconductor gives rise to a Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) state inside the superconducting energy gap. With increasing exchange coupling the excitation energy of this state eventually crosses zero and the system switches to a YSR groundstate with bound quasiparticles screening the impurity spin by $\hbar/2$. Here we explore InAs nanowire double quantum dots tunnel coup…
▽ More
A magnetic impurity coupled to a superconductor gives rise to a Yu-Shiba-Rusinov (YSR) state inside the superconducting energy gap. With increasing exchange coupling the excitation energy of this state eventually crosses zero and the system switches to a YSR groundstate with bound quasiparticles screening the impurity spin by $\hbar/2$. Here we explore InAs nanowire double quantum dots tunnel coupled to a superconductor and demonstrate YSR screening of spin-1/2 and spin-1 states. Gating the double dot through 9 different charge states, we show that the honeycomb pattern of zero-bias conductance peaks, archetypal of double dots coupled to normal leads, is replaced by lines of zero-energy YSR states. These enclose regions of YSR-screened dot spins displaying distinctive spectral features, and their characteristic shape and topology change markedly with tunnel coupling strengths. We find excellent agreement with a simple zero-bandwidth approximation, and with numerical renormalization group calculations for the two-orbital Anderson model.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
Spin-1 two-impurity Kondo problem on a lattice
Authors:
A. Allerdt,
R. Zitko,
A. E. Feiguin
Abstract:
We present an extensive study of the two-impurity Kondo problem for spin-1 adatoms on square lattice using an exact canonical transformation to map the problem onto an effective one-dimensional system that can be numerically solved using the density matrix renormalization group method. We provide a simple intuitive picture and identify the different regimes, depending on the distance between the t…
▽ More
We present an extensive study of the two-impurity Kondo problem for spin-1 adatoms on square lattice using an exact canonical transformation to map the problem onto an effective one-dimensional system that can be numerically solved using the density matrix renormalization group method. We provide a simple intuitive picture and identify the different regimes, depending on the distance between the two impurities, Kondo coupling $J_K$, longitudinal anisotropy $D$, and transverse anisotropy $E$. In the isotropic case, two impurities on opposite(same) sublattices have a singlet(triplet) ground state. However, the energy difference between the triplet ground state and the singlet excited state is very small and we expect an effectively four-fold degenerate ground state, i.e., two decoupled impurities. For large enough $J_K$ the impurities are practically uncorrelated forming two independent underscreened states with the conduction electrons, a clear non-perturbative effect. When the impurities are entangled in an RKKY-like state, Kondo correlations persists and the two effects coexist: the impurities are underscreened, and the dangling spin-$1/2$ degrees of freedom are responsible for the inter-impurity entanglement. We analyze the effects of magnetic anisotropy in the development of quasi-classical correlations.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Field-Induced Instability of a Gapless Spin Liquid with a Spinon Fermi Surface
Authors:
M. Gomilšek,
M. Klanjšek,
R. Žitko,
M. Pregelj,
F. Bert,
P. Mendels,
Y. Li,
Q. M. Zhang,
A. Zorko
Abstract:
The ground state of the quantum kagome antiferromagnet Zn-brochantite, ZnCu$_3$(OH)$_6$SO$_4$, which is one of only a few known spin-liquid (SL) realizations in two or three dimensions, has been described as a gapless SL with a spinon Fermi surface. Employing nuclear magnetic resonance in a broad magnetic-field range down to millikelvin temperatures, we show that in applied magnetic fields this en…
▽ More
The ground state of the quantum kagome antiferromagnet Zn-brochantite, ZnCu$_3$(OH)$_6$SO$_4$, which is one of only a few known spin-liquid (SL) realizations in two or three dimensions, has been described as a gapless SL with a spinon Fermi surface. Employing nuclear magnetic resonance in a broad magnetic-field range down to millikelvin temperatures, we show that in applied magnetic fields this enigmatic state is intrinsically unstable against a SL with a full or a partial gap. A similar instability of the gapless Fermi-surface SL was previously encountered in an organic triangular-lattice antiferromagnet, suggesting a common destabilization mechanism that most likely arises from spinon pairing. A salient property of this instability is that an infinitesimal field suffices to induce it, as predicted theoretically for some other types of gapless SL's.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2017; v1 submitted 7 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Spin-orbit coupling in three-orbital Kanamori impurity model and its relevance for transition-metal oxides
Authors:
Alen Horvat,
Rok Zitko,
Jernej Mravlje
Abstract:
We investigate the effects of the spin-orbit coupling (SOC) in a three-orbital impurity model with Kanamori interaction using the numerical renormalization group method. We focus on the impurity occupancy $N_d=2$ relevant to the dynamical mean-field theory studies of Hund's metals. Depending on the strength of SOC $λ$ we identify three regimes: usual Hund's impurity for $|λ|<λ_c$, van-Vleck non-ma…
▽ More
We investigate the effects of the spin-orbit coupling (SOC) in a three-orbital impurity model with Kanamori interaction using the numerical renormalization group method. We focus on the impurity occupancy $N_d=2$ relevant to the dynamical mean-field theory studies of Hund's metals. Depending on the strength of SOC $λ$ we identify three regimes: usual Hund's impurity for $|λ|<λ_c$, van-Vleck non-magnetic impurity for $λ> λ_c$, and a $J=2$ impurity for $λ< -λ_c$. They all correspond to a Fermi liquid but with very different quasiparticle phase shifts and different physical properties. The crossover between these regimes is controlled by an emergent scale, the orbital Kondo temperature, $λ_c =T_K^\mathrm{orb}$ that drops with increasing interaction strength. This implies that oxides with strong electronic correlations are more prone to the effects of the spin-orbit coupling.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
A Strange Metal from Gutzwiller correlations in infinite dimensions II: Transverse Transport, Optical Response and Rise of Two Relaxation Rates
Authors:
Wenxin Ding,
Rok Žitko,
B Sriram Shastry
Abstract:
Using two approaches to strongly correlated systems, the extremely correlated Fermi liquid theory and the dynamical mean field theory, we compute the transverse transport coefficients, namely the Hall constants $R_H$ and Hall angles $θ_H$, and also the longitudinal and transverse optical response of the $U=\infty$ Hubbard model in the limit of infinite dimensions. We focus on two successive low-te…
▽ More
Using two approaches to strongly correlated systems, the extremely correlated Fermi liquid theory and the dynamical mean field theory, we compute the transverse transport coefficients, namely the Hall constants $R_H$ and Hall angles $θ_H$, and also the longitudinal and transverse optical response of the $U=\infty$ Hubbard model in the limit of infinite dimensions. We focus on two successive low-temperature regimes, the Gutzwiller correlated Fermi liquid (GCFL) and the Gutzwiller correlated strange metal (GCSM). We find that the Hall angles $\cot θ_H \propto T^2$ in the GCFL regime, on warming into the strange metal regime, it passes through a downward bend and continues as $T^2$. Equivalently, $R_H$ is weakly temperature dependent in the GCFL regime, and becomes strongly $T$-dependent in the GCSM regime. Drude peaks are found for both the longitudinal optical conductivity $σ_{xx}(ω)$ and the optical Hall angles $\tan θ_H(ω)$ below certain characteristic energy scales. By comparing the relaxation rates extracted from fitting to the Drude formula, we find that in the GCFL regime there is a single relaxation rate controlling both longitudinal and transverse transport, while in the GCSM regime two independent relaxation rates emerge. We trace the origin of this behavior to the dynamical particle-hole asymmetry of the Dyson self-energy, arguably a generic feature of doped Mott insulators.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2017; v1 submitted 4 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
A new high-temperature quantum spin liquid with polaron spins
Authors:
Martin Klanjsek,
Andrej Zorko,
Rok Zitko,
Jernej Mravlje,
Zvonko Jaglicic,
Pabitra Kumar Biswas,
Peter Prelovsek,
Dragan Mihailovic,
Denis Arcon
Abstract:
The existence of a quantum spin liquid (QSL) in which quantum fluctuations of spins are sufficiently strong to preclude spin ordering down to zero temperature was originally proposed theoretically more than 40 years ago, but its experimental realisation turned out to be very elusive. Here we report on an almost ideal spin liquid state that appears to be realized by atomic-cluster spins on the tria…
▽ More
The existence of a quantum spin liquid (QSL) in which quantum fluctuations of spins are sufficiently strong to preclude spin ordering down to zero temperature was originally proposed theoretically more than 40 years ago, but its experimental realisation turned out to be very elusive. Here we report on an almost ideal spin liquid state that appears to be realized by atomic-cluster spins on the triangular lattice of a charge-density wave (CDW) state of 1T-TaS$_2$. In this system, the charge excitations have a well-defined gap of $\sim 0.3$ eV, while nuclear magnetic quadrupole resonance and muon spin relaxation experiments reveal that the spins show gapless quantum spin liquid dynamics and no long range magnetic order down to 70~mK. Canonical $T^{2}$ power-law temperature dependence of the spin relaxation dynamics characteristic of a QSL is observed from 200~K to $T_f= 55$ K. Below this temperature we observe a new gapless state with reduced density of spin excitations and high degree of local disorder signifying new quantum spin order emerging from the QSL.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
A Strange Metal from Gutzwiller correlations in infinite dimensions
Authors:
Wenxin Ding,
Rok Žitko,
Peizhi Mai,
Edward Perepelitsky,
B Sriram Shastry
Abstract:
Recent progress in extremely correlated Fermi liquid theory (ECFL) and dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) enables us to compute in the $d \to \infty$ limit the resistivity of the $t-J$ model after setting $J\to0$. This is also the $U=\infty$ Hubbard model. We study three densities $n=.75,.8,.85$ that correspond to a range between the overdoped and optimally doped Mott insulating state. We delineat…
▽ More
Recent progress in extremely correlated Fermi liquid theory (ECFL) and dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) enables us to compute in the $d \to \infty$ limit the resistivity of the $t-J$ model after setting $J\to0$. This is also the $U=\infty$ Hubbard model. We study three densities $n=.75,.8,.85$ that correspond to a range between the overdoped and optimally doped Mott insulating state. We delineate four distinct regimes characterized by different behaviors of the resistivity $ρ$. We find at the lowest $T$ a Gutzwiller Correlated Fermi Liquid regime with $ρ\propto T^2$ extending up to an effective Fermi temperature that is dramatically suppressed from the non-interacting value. This is followed by a Gutzwiller Correlated Strange Metal regime with $ρ\propto (T-T_0)$, i.e. a linear resistivity extrapolating back to $ρ=0$ at a positive $T_0$. At a higher $T$ scale, this crosses over into the Bad Metal regime with $ρ\propto (T+T_1)$ extrapolating back to a finite resistivity at $T=0$, and passing through the Ioffe-Regel-Mott value where the mean free path is a few lattice constants. This regime finally gives way to the High $T$ Metal regime, where we find $ρ\propto T$. The present work emphasizes the first two, where the availability of an analytical ECFL theory is of help in identifying the changes in related variables entering the resistivity formula that accompany the onset of linear resistivity, and the numerically exact DMFT helps to validate the results. We also examine thermodynamic variables such as the magnetic susceptibility, compressibility, heat capacity and entropy, and correlate changes in these with the change in resistivity. This exercise casts valuable light on the nature of charge and spin correlations in the strange metal regime, which has features in common with the physically relevant strange metal phase seen in strongly correlated matters.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2017; v1 submitted 6 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Fine structure of the spectra of the Kondo lattice model: two-site cellular DMFT study
Authors:
Žiga Osolin,
Rok Žitko
Abstract:
We study the antiferromagnetic and the paramagnetic Kondo insulator phases of the Kondo lattice model on the cubic lattice at half-filling using the cellular dynamical mean-field theory (CDMFT) with numerical renormalization group (NRG) as the impurity solver, focusing on the fine details of the spectral function and self-energy. We find that the non-local correlations increase the gap in both the…
▽ More
We study the antiferromagnetic and the paramagnetic Kondo insulator phases of the Kondo lattice model on the cubic lattice at half-filling using the cellular dynamical mean-field theory (CDMFT) with numerical renormalization group (NRG) as the impurity solver, focusing on the fine details of the spectral function and self-energy. We find that the non-local correlations increase the gap in both the antiferromagnetic and the Kondo insulator phase and shrink the extent of the antiferromagnetic phase in the phase diagram but do not alter any properties qualitatively. The agreement between the numerical CDMFT results and those within a simple hybridization picture, which adequately describes the overall band structure of the system but neglects all effects on the inelastic-scattering processes, is similar to that of the single-site DMFT results; there are deviations that are responsible for the additional fine structure, in particular for the asymmetric spectral resonances or dips that become more pronounced in the strong-coupling regime close to the antiferromagnet-paramagnetic quantum phase transition. These features appear broader in the CDMFT mostly due to numerical artifacts linked to more aggressive state truncation required in the NRG.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.