-
Effects of fabrication routes and material parameters on the control of superconducting currents by gate voltage
Authors:
Leon Ruf,
Tosson Elalaily,
Claudio Puglia,
Yurii P. Ivanov,
Francois Joint,
Martin Berke,
Andrea Iorio,
Peter Makk,
Giorgio De Simoni,
Simone Gasparinetti,
Giorgio Divitini,
Szabolcs Csonka,
Francesco Giazotto,
Elke Scheer,
Angelo Di Bernardo
Abstract:
The control of a superconducting current via the application of a gate voltage has been recently demonstrated in a variety of superconducting devices. Although the mechanism underlying this gate-controlled supercurrent (GCS) effect remains under debate, the GCS effect has raised great interest for the development of the superconducting equivalent of conventional metaloxide semiconductor electronic…
▽ More
The control of a superconducting current via the application of a gate voltage has been recently demonstrated in a variety of superconducting devices. Although the mechanism underlying this gate-controlled supercurrent (GCS) effect remains under debate, the GCS effect has raised great interest for the development of the superconducting equivalent of conventional metaloxide semiconductor electronics. To date, however, the GCS effect has been mostly observed in superconducting devices made by additive patterning. Here, we show that devices made by subtractive patterning show a systematic absence of the GCS effect. Doing a microstructural analysis of these devices and comparing them to devices made by additive patterning, where we observe a GCS, we identify some material and physical parameters that are crucial for the observation of a GCS. We also show that some of the mechanisms proposed to explain the origin of the GCS effect are not universally relevant.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2023; v1 submitted 14 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Gate-control of superconducting current: mechanisms, parameters and technological potential
Authors:
Leon Ruf,
Claudio Puglia,
Tosson Elalaily,
Giorgio De Simoni,
Francois Joint,
Martin Berke,
Jennifer Koch,
Andrea Iorio,
Sara Khorshidian,
Peter Makk,
Simone Gasparinetti,
Szabolcs Csonka,
Wolfgang Belzig,
Mario Cuoco,
Francesco Giazotto,
Elke Scheer,
Angelo Di Bernardo
Abstract:
In conventional metal-oxide semiconductor (CMOS) electronics, the logic state of a device is set by a gate voltage (VG). The superconducting equivalent of such effect had remained unknown until it was recently shown that a VG can tune the superconducting current (supercurrent) flowing through a nanoconstriction in a superconductor. This gate-controlled supercurrent (GCS) effect can lead to superco…
▽ More
In conventional metal-oxide semiconductor (CMOS) electronics, the logic state of a device is set by a gate voltage (VG). The superconducting equivalent of such effect had remained unknown until it was recently shown that a VG can tune the superconducting current (supercurrent) flowing through a nanoconstriction in a superconductor. This gate-controlled supercurrent (GCS) effect can lead to superconducting logics like CMOS logics, but with lower energy dissipation. The physical mechanism underlying the GCS effect, however, remains under debate. In this review article, we illustrate the main mechanisms proposed for the GCS effect, and the material and device parameters that mostly affect it based on the evidence reported. We will come to the conclusion that different mechanisms are at play in the different studies reported so far. We then outline studies that can help answer open questions on the effect and achieve control over it, which is key for applications. We finally give insights into the impact that the GCS effect can have towards high-performance computing with low-energy dissipation and quantum technologies.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2024; v1 submitted 27 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Electrostatic field-driven supercurrent suppression in ionic-gated metallic Josephson nanotransistors
Authors:
Federico Paolucci,
Francesco Crisà,
Giorgio De Simoni,
Lennart Bours,
Claudio Puglia,
Elia Strambini,
Stefano Roddaro,
Francesco Giazotto
Abstract:
Recent experiments have shown the possibility to tune the electron transport properties of metallic nanosized superconductors through a gate voltage. These results renewed the longstanding debate on the interaction between intense electrostatic fields and superconductivity. Indeed, different works suggested competing mechanisms as the cause of the effect: unconventional electric field-effect or qu…
▽ More
Recent experiments have shown the possibility to tune the electron transport properties of metallic nanosized superconductors through a gate voltage. These results renewed the longstanding debate on the interaction between intense electrostatic fields and superconductivity. Indeed, different works suggested competing mechanisms as the cause of the effect: unconventional electric field-effect or quasiparticle injection. By realizing ionic-gated Josephson field-effect nanotransistors (IJoFETs), we provide the conclusive evidence of electrostatic field-driven control of the supercurrent in metallic nanosized superconductors. Our Nb IJoFETs show bipolar giant suppression of the superconducting critical current up to $\sim45\%$ with negligible variation of both the critical temperature and the normal-state resistance, in a setup where both overheating and charge injection are impossible. The microscopic explanation of these results calls upon a novel theory able to describe the non-trivial interaction of static electric fields with conventional superconductivity.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2021; v1 submitted 2 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Phase slips dynamics in gated Ti and V all-metallic supercurrent nano-transistors: a review
Authors:
Claudio Puglia,
Giorgio De Simoni,
Francesco Giazotto
Abstract:
The effect of electrostatic gating on metallic elemental superconductors was recently demonstrated in terms of modulation of the switching current and control of the current phase relation in superconducting quantum interferometers. The latter suggests the existence of a direct connection between the macroscopic quantum phase in a superconductor and the applied gate voltage. The measurement of the…
▽ More
The effect of electrostatic gating on metallic elemental superconductors was recently demonstrated in terms of modulation of the switching current and control of the current phase relation in superconducting quantum interferometers. The latter suggests the existence of a direct connection between the macroscopic quantum phase in a superconductor and the applied gate voltage. The measurement of the switching current cumulative probability distributions (SCCPD) is a convenient and powerful tool to analyze such relation. In particular, the comparison between the conventional Kurkijarvi-Fulton-Dunkleberger model and the gate-driven distributions give useful insights into the microscopic origin of the gating effect. In this review, we summarize the main results obtained in the analysis of the phase slip events in elemental gated superconducting weak-links in a wide range of temperatures between 20 mK and 3.5 K. Such a large temperature range demonstrates both that the gating effect is robust as the temperature increases, and that fluctuations induced by the electric field are not negligible in a wide temperature range.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Gate control of superconductivity in mesoscopic all-metallic devices
Authors:
Claudio Puglia,
Giorgio De Simoni,
Francesco Giazotto
Abstract:
It was recently demonstrated the possibility to tune, through the application of a control gate voltage, the superconducting properties of mesoscopic devices based on Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer metals. In spite of the several experimental evidence obtained on different materials and geometries, a description of the microscopic mechanism at the basis of such unconventional effect has not been provid…
▽ More
It was recently demonstrated the possibility to tune, through the application of a control gate voltage, the superconducting properties of mesoscopic devices based on Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer metals. In spite of the several experimental evidence obtained on different materials and geometries, a description of the microscopic mechanism at the basis of such unconventional effect has not been provided yet. This work discusses the technological potential of gate control of superconductivity in metallic superconductors and revises the experimental results which provide information regarding a possible thermal origin of the effect: in the first place, we review experiments performed on high critical temperature elemental superconductors (niobium and vanadium) and show how devices based on these materials can be exploited to realize basic electronic tools such as, e. g., a half-wave rectifier. In a second part, we discuss the origin of the gating effect by showing the gate-driven suppression of the supercurrent in a suspended titanium wire and by providing a comparison between thermal and electric switching current probability distributions. Furthermore, we discuss the cold field-emission of electrons from the gate by means of finite element simulations and compare the results with experimental data. Finally, the presented data provide a strong indication regarding the unlikelihood of thermal origin of the gating effect.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2021; v1 submitted 30 January, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Gate-controlled Suspended Titanium Nanobridge Supercurrent Transistor
Authors:
M. Rocci,
G. De Simoni,
C. Puglia,
D. Degli Esposti,
E. Strambini,
V. Zannier,
L. Sorba,
F. Giazotto
Abstract:
In a family of experiments carried on all-metallic supercurrent nano-transistors a surprising gating effect has been recently shown. These include the full suppression of the critical supercurrent, the increase of quasiparticle population, the manipulation of the superconducting phase, and the broadening of the switching current distributions. Aside from the high potential for future applications,…
▽ More
In a family of experiments carried on all-metallic supercurrent nano-transistors a surprising gating effect has been recently shown. These include the full suppression of the critical supercurrent, the increase of quasiparticle population, the manipulation of the superconducting phase, and the broadening of the switching current distributions. Aside from the high potential for future applications, these findings raised fundamental questions on the origin of these phenomena. To date, two complementary hypotheses are under debate: an electrostatically-triggered orbital polarization at the superconductor surface, or the injection of highly-energetic quasiparticles extracted from the gate. Here, we tackle this crucial issue via a fully suspended gate-controlled Ti nano-transistor. Our geometry allows to eliminate any direct injection of quasiparticles through the substrate thereby making cold electron field emission through the vacuum the only possible charge transport mechanism. With the aid of a fully numerical 3D model in combination with the observed phenomenology and thermal considerations we can rule out, with any realistic likelihood, the occurrence of cold electron field emission. Excluding these two trivial phenomena is pivotal in light of understanding the microscopic nature of gating effect in superconducting nanostructures, which represents an unsolved puzzle in contemporary superconductivity. Yet, from the technological point of view, our suspended fabrication technique provides the enabling technology to implement a variety of applications and fundamental studies combining, for instance, superconductivity with nano-mechanics.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2021; v1 submitted 12 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Vanadium gate-controlled Josephson half-wave nanorectifier
Authors:
C. Puglia,
G. De Simoni,
N. Ligato,
F. Giazotto
Abstract:
Recently, the possibility to tune the critical current of conventional metallic superconductors via electrostatic gating was shown in wires, Josephson weak-links and superconductor-normal metal-superconductor junctions. Here we exploit such a technique to demonstrate a gate-controlled vanadium-based Dayem nano-bridge operated as a \emph{half-wave} rectifier at $3$ K. Our devices exploit the gate-d…
▽ More
Recently, the possibility to tune the critical current of conventional metallic superconductors via electrostatic gating was shown in wires, Josephson weak-links and superconductor-normal metal-superconductor junctions. Here we exploit such a technique to demonstrate a gate-controlled vanadium-based Dayem nano-bridge operated as a \emph{half-wave} rectifier at $3$ K. Our devices exploit the gate-driven modulation of the critical current of the Josephson junction, and the resulting steep variation of its normal-state resistance, to convert an AC signal applied to the gate electrode into a DC one across the junction. All-metallic superconducting gated rectifiers could provide the enabling technology to realize tunable photon detectors and diodes useful for superconducting electronics circuitry.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Niobium Dayem nano-bridge Josephson field-effect transistors
Authors:
Giorgio De Simoni,
Claudio Puglia,
Francesco Giazotto
Abstract:
We report on the first realization of Nb-based \textit{all-metallic} gated Dayem nano-bridge field-effect transistors (Nb-FETs). These Josephson devices operate up to a temperature of $\sim 3$ K, and exhibit full suppression of the supercurrent thanks to the application of a control gate voltage. The dependence of the kinetic inductance and of the transconductance on gate voltage promises a perfor…
▽ More
We report on the first realization of Nb-based \textit{all-metallic} gated Dayem nano-bridge field-effect transistors (Nb-FETs). These Josephson devices operate up to a temperature of $\sim 3$ K, and exhibit full suppression of the supercurrent thanks to the application of a control gate voltage. The dependence of the kinetic inductance and of the transconductance on gate voltage promises a performance already on par with so far realized metallic Josephson transistors, and let to foresee the implementation of a superconducting digital logic based on Nb-FETs. We conclude by showing the practical realization of a scheme implementing an all-metallic gate-tunable \emph{half-wave} rectifier to be used either for superconducting electronics or for photon detection applications.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Electrostatic control of phase slips in Ti Josephson nanotransistors
Authors:
C. Puglia,
G. De Simoni,
F. Giazotto
Abstract:
The investigation of the switching current probability distribution of a Josephson junction is a conventional tool to gain information on the phase slips dynamics as a function of the temperature. Here we adopt this well-established technique to probe the impact of an external static electric field on the occurrence of phase slips in gated all-metallic titanium (Ti) Josephson weak links. We show,…
▽ More
The investigation of the switching current probability distribution of a Josephson junction is a conventional tool to gain information on the phase slips dynamics as a function of the temperature. Here we adopt this well-established technique to probe the impact of an external static electric field on the occurrence of phase slips in gated all-metallic titanium (Ti) Josephson weak links. We show, in a temperature range between 20 mK and 420 mK, that the evolution of the phase slips dynamics as a function of the electrostatic field starkly differs from that observed as a function of the temperature. This fact demonstrates, on the one hand, that the electric field suppression of the critical current is not simply related to a conventional thermal-like quasiparticle overheating in the weak-link region. On the other hand, our results may open the way to operate an electrostatic-driven manipulation of phase slips in metallic Josephson nanojunctions, which can be pivotal for the control of decoherence in superconducting nanostructures.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2020; v1 submitted 30 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Field-Effect Control of Metallic Superconducting Systems
Authors:
Federico Paolucci,
Giorgio De Simoni,
Paolo Solinas,
Elia Strambini,
Claudio Puglia,
Nadia Ligato,
Francesco Giazotto
Abstract:
Despite metals are believed to be insensitive to field-effect and conventional Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) theories predict the electric field to be ineffective on conventional superconductors, a number of gating experiments showed the possibility of modulating the conductivity of metallic thin films and the critical temperature of conventional superconductors. All these experimental features…
▽ More
Despite metals are believed to be insensitive to field-effect and conventional Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) theories predict the electric field to be ineffective on conventional superconductors, a number of gating experiments showed the possibility of modulating the conductivity of metallic thin films and the critical temperature of conventional superconductors. All these experimental features have been explained by simple charge accumulation/depletion. In 2018, electric field control of supercurrent in conventional metallic superconductors has been demonstrated in a range of electric fields where the induced variation of charge carrier concentration in metals is negligibly small. In fact, no changes of normal state resistance and superconducting critical temperature were reported. Here, we review the experimental results obtained in the realization of field-effect metallic superconducting devices exploiting this unexplained phenomenon. We will start by presenting the seminal results on superconducting BCS wires and nano-constriction Josephson junctions (Dayem bridges) made of different materials, such as titanium, aluminum and vanadium. Then, we show the mastering of the Josephson supercurrent in superconductor-normal metal-superconductor proximity transistors suggesting that the presence of induced superconducting correlations are enough to see this unconventional field-effect. Later, we present the control of the interference pattern in a superconducting quantum interference device indicating the coupling of the electric field with thesuperconducting phase. Among the possible applications of the presented phenomenology, we conclude this review by proposing some devices that may represent a breakthrough in superconducting quantum and classical computation.
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2020; v1 submitted 27 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Josephson Field-Effect Transistors Based on All-Metallic Al/Cu/Al Proximity Nanojunctions
Authors:
Giorgio De Simoni,
Federico Paolucci,
Claudio Puglia,
Francesco Giazotto
Abstract:
We demonstrate the first \textit{all-metallic} mesoscopic superconductor-normal metal-superconductor (SNS) field-effect controlled Josephson transistors (SNS-FETs) and show their full characterization from the critical temperature $T_c$ down to 50 mK in the presence of both electric and magnetic field. The ability of a static electric field -applied by mean of a lateral gate electrode- to suppress…
▽ More
We demonstrate the first \textit{all-metallic} mesoscopic superconductor-normal metal-superconductor (SNS) field-effect controlled Josephson transistors (SNS-FETs) and show their full characterization from the critical temperature $T_c$ down to 50 mK in the presence of both electric and magnetic field. The ability of a static electric field -applied by mean of a lateral gate electrode- to suppress the critical current $I_s$ in a proximity-induced superconductor is proven for both positive and negative gate voltage values. $I_s$ suppression reached typically about one third of its initial value, saturating at high gate voltages. The transconductance of our SNS-FETs obtains values as high as 100 nA/V at 100 mK. On the fundamental physics side, our results suggest that the mechanism at the basis of the observed phenomenon is quite general and does not rely on the existence of a true pairing potential, but rather the presence of superconducting correlations is enough for the effect to occur. On the technological side, our findings widen the family of materials available for the implementation of all-metallic field-effect transistors to \textit{synthetic} proximity-induced superconductors.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2019; v1 submitted 8 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Phase-tunable Josephson thermal router
Authors:
Giuliano Timossi,
Antonio Fornieri,
Federico Paolucci,
Claudio Puglia,
Francesco Giazotto
Abstract:
Since the the first studies of thermodynamics, heat transport has been a crucial element for the understanding of any thermal system. Quantum mechanics has introduced new appealing ingredients for the manipulation of heat currents, such as the long-range coherence of the superconducting condensate. The latter has been exploited by phase-coherent caloritronics, a young field of nanoscience, to real…
▽ More
Since the the first studies of thermodynamics, heat transport has been a crucial element for the understanding of any thermal system. Quantum mechanics has introduced new appealing ingredients for the manipulation of heat currents, such as the long-range coherence of the superconducting condensate. The latter has been exploited by phase-coherent caloritronics, a young field of nanoscience, to realize Josephson heat interferometers, which can control electronic thermal currents as a function of the external magnetic flux. So far, only one output temperature has been modulated, while multi-terminal devices that allow to distribute the heat flux among different reservoirs are still missing. Here, we report the experimental realization of a phase-tunable thermal router able to control the heat transferred between two terminals residing at different temperatures. Thanks to the Josephson effect, our structure allows to regulate the thermal gradient between the output electrodes until reaching its inversion. Together with interferometers, heat diodes and thermal memories, the thermal router represents a fundamental step towards the thermal conversion of non-linear electronic devices, and the realization of caloritronic logic components.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
