-
Bulk-Edge Correspondence Recovered in Incompressible Geophysical Flows
Authors:
Yohei Onuki,
Antoine Venaille,
Pierre Delplace
Abstract:
Bulk-edge correspondence is a cornerstone in topological physics, establishing a connection between the number of unidirectional edge modes in physical space and a Chern number, an integer that counts phase singularities of the eigenmodes in parameter space. In continuous media, violation of this correspondence has been reported when some of the frequency wavebands are unbounded, resulting in weak…
▽ More
Bulk-edge correspondence is a cornerstone in topological physics, establishing a connection between the number of unidirectional edge modes in physical space and a Chern number, an integer that counts phase singularities of the eigenmodes in parameter space. In continuous media, violation of this correspondence has been reported when some of the frequency wavebands are unbounded, resulting in weak topological protection of chiral edge states. Here, we propose a strategy to reestablish strong bulk-edge correspondence in incompressible rotating stratified flows, taking advantage of a natural cutoff frequency provided by density stratification. The key idea involves the introduction of an auxiliary field to handle the divergence-free constraint. This approach highlights the resilience of internal coastal Kelvin waves near vertical walls under varying boundary conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2024; v1 submitted 29 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Unidirectional modes induced by nontraditional Coriolis force in stratified fluids
Authors:
Nicolas Perez,
Pierre Delplace,
Antoine Venaille
Abstract:
Using topology, we unveil the existence of new unidirectional modes in compressible rotating stratified fluids. We relate their emergence to the breaking of time-reversal symmetry by rotation and vertical mirror symmetry by stratification and gravity. We stress the role of the Coriolis force's nontraditional part, induced by a rotation field tangent to the surface. In contrast with horizontally tr…
▽ More
Using topology, we unveil the existence of new unidirectional modes in compressible rotating stratified fluids. We relate their emergence to the breaking of time-reversal symmetry by rotation and vertical mirror symmetry by stratification and gravity. We stress the role of the Coriolis force's nontraditional part, induced by a rotation field tangent to the surface. In contrast with horizontally trapped equatorial waves induced by the traditional component of Coriolis force perpendicular to the surface, we find vertically trapped modes that are trapped along interfaces between regions with distinct stratification properties. We show that such modes are generalized atmospheric Lamb waves whose direction of propagation can be selected by the nontraditional component of the Coriolis force.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2022; v1 submitted 5 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Wave topology brought to the coast
Authors:
Antoine Venaille,
Pierre Delplace
Abstract:
Since the pioneering work of Kelvin on Laplace tidal equations, a zoology of trapped waves have been found in the context of coastal dynamics. Among them, the one originally computed by Kelvin plays a particular role, as it is an unidirectional mode filling a frequency gap between different wave bands. The existence of such Kelvin waves is robust to changes in the boundary shape and in changes of…
▽ More
Since the pioneering work of Kelvin on Laplace tidal equations, a zoology of trapped waves have been found in the context of coastal dynamics. Among them, the one originally computed by Kelvin plays a particular role, as it is an unidirectional mode filling a frequency gap between different wave bands. The existence of such Kelvin waves is robust to changes in the boundary shape and in changes of the underlying model for the coast. This suggests a topological interpretation that has yet up to now remained elusive. Here we rectify the situation, by taking advantage of a reformulation of the shallow water dynamics that highlights an analogy with the celebrated Haldane model in condensed matter physics. For any profile of bottom topography, the number of modes that transit from one wave band to another in the dispersion relation is predicted by computing a first Chern number describing the topology of complex eigenmodes in a dual, simpler wave problem.
△ Less
Submitted 22 August, 2021; v1 submitted 6 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Manifestation of Berry curvature in geophysical ray tracing
Authors:
Nicolas Perez,
Pierre Delplace,
Antoine Venaille
Abstract:
Geometrical phases, such as the Berry phase, have proven to be powerful concepts to understand numerous physical phenomena, from the precession of the Foucault pendulum to the quantum Hall effect and the existence of topological insulators. The Berry phase is generated by a quantity named Berry curvature, describing the local geometry of wave polarization relations and known to appear in the equat…
▽ More
Geometrical phases, such as the Berry phase, have proven to be powerful concepts to understand numerous physical phenomena, from the precession of the Foucault pendulum to the quantum Hall effect and the existence of topological insulators. The Berry phase is generated by a quantity named Berry curvature, describing the local geometry of wave polarization relations and known to appear in the equations of motion of multi-component wave packets. Such a geometrical contribution in ray propagation of vectorial fields has been observed in condensed matter, optics and cold atoms physics. Here, we use a variational method with a vectorial Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin (WKB) ansatz to derive ray tracing equations in geophysical waves and reveal the contribution of Berry curvature. We detail the case of shallow water wave packets and propose a new interpretation to the equatorial oscillation and the bending of rays in mid-latitude area. Our result shows a mismatch with the textbook scalar approach for ray tracing, by predicting a larger eastward velocity for Poincaré wave packets. This work enlightens the role of wave polarization's geometry in various geophysical and astrophysical fluid waves, beyond the shallow water model.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2021; v1 submitted 12 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
From the geometry of Foucault pendulum to the topology of planetary waves
Authors:
Pierre Delplace,
Antoine Venaille
Abstract:
The physics of topological insulators makes it possible to understand and predict the existence of unidirectional waves trapped along an edge or an interface. In this review, we describe how these ideas can be adapted to geophysical and astrophysical waves. We deal in particular with the case of planetary equatorial waves, which highlights the key interplay between rotation and sphericity of the p…
▽ More
The physics of topological insulators makes it possible to understand and predict the existence of unidirectional waves trapped along an edge or an interface. In this review, we describe how these ideas can be adapted to geophysical and astrophysical waves. We deal in particular with the case of planetary equatorial waves, which highlights the key interplay between rotation and sphericity of the planet, to explain the emergence of waves which propagate their energy only towards the East. These minimal ingredients are precisely those put forward in the geometric interpretation of the Foucault pendulum. We discuss this classic example of mechanics to introduce the concepts of holonomy and vector bundle which we then use to calculate the topological properties of equatorial shallow water waves.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Anomalous bulk-edge correspondence in continuous media
Authors:
Clément Tauber,
Pierre Delplace,
Antoine Venaille
Abstract:
Topology plays an increasing role in physics beyond the realm of topological insulators in condensed mater. From geophysical fluids to active matter, acoustics or photonics, a growing family of systems presents topologically protected chiral edge modes. The number of such modes should coincide with the bulk topological invariant (e.g. Chern number) defined for a sample without boundary, in agreeme…
▽ More
Topology plays an increasing role in physics beyond the realm of topological insulators in condensed mater. From geophysical fluids to active matter, acoustics or photonics, a growing family of systems presents topologically protected chiral edge modes. The number of such modes should coincide with the bulk topological invariant (e.g. Chern number) defined for a sample without boundary, in agreement with the bulk-edge correspondence. However this is not always the case when dealing with continuous media where there is no small scale cut-off. The number of edge modes actually depends on the boundary condition, even when the bulk is properly regularized, showing an apparent paradox where the bulk-edge correspondence is violated. In this paper we solve this paradox by showing that the anomaly is due to {ghost} edge modes hidden in the asymptotic part of the spectrum. We provide a general formalism based on scattering theory to detect all edge modes properly, so that the bulk-edge correspondence is restored. We illustrate this approach through the odd-viscous shallow-water model and the massive Dirac Hamiltonian, and discuss the physical consequences.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
A bulk-interface correspondence for equatorial waves
Authors:
Clément Tauber,
Pierre Delplace,
Antoine Venaille
Abstract:
Topology is bringing new tools for the study of fluid waves. The existence of unidirectional Yanai and Kelvin equatorial waves has been related to a topological invariant, the Chern number, that describes the winding of $f$-plane shallow water eigenmodes around band crossing points in parameter space. In this previous study, the topological invariant was a property of the interface between two hem…
▽ More
Topology is bringing new tools for the study of fluid waves. The existence of unidirectional Yanai and Kelvin equatorial waves has been related to a topological invariant, the Chern number, that describes the winding of $f$-plane shallow water eigenmodes around band crossing points in parameter space. In this previous study, the topological invariant was a property of the interface between two hemispheres. Here we ask whether a topological index can be assigned to each hemisphere. We show that this can be done if the shallow water model in $f$-plane geometry is regularized by an additional odd-viscous term. We then compute the spectrum of a shallow water model with a sharp equator separating two flat hemispheres, and recover the Kelvin and Yanai waves as two exponentially trapped waves along the equator, with all the other modes delocalized into the bulk. This model provides an exactly solvable example of bulk-interface correspondence in a flow with a sharp interface, and offers a topological interpretation for some of the transition modes described by [Iga, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 1995]. It also paves the way towards a topological interpretation of coastal Kelvin waves along a boundary, and more generally, to an understanding of bulk-boundary correspondence in continuous media.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2019; v1 submitted 13 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Topological transition in stratified fluids
Authors:
Manolis Perrot,
Pierre Delplace,
Antoine Venaille
Abstract:
Lamb waves are trapped acoustic-gravity waves that propagate energy over great distances along a solid boundary in density stratified, compressible fluids. They constitute useful indicators of explosions in planetary atmospheres. When the density stratification exceeds a threshold, or when the impermeability condition at the boundary is relaxed, atmospheric Lamb waves suddenly disappear. Here we u…
▽ More
Lamb waves are trapped acoustic-gravity waves that propagate energy over great distances along a solid boundary in density stratified, compressible fluids. They constitute useful indicators of explosions in planetary atmospheres. When the density stratification exceeds a threshold, or when the impermeability condition at the boundary is relaxed, atmospheric Lamb waves suddenly disappear. Here we use topological arguments to predict the possible existence of new trapped Lamb-like waves in the absence of a solid boundary, depending on the stratification profile. The topological origin of the Lamb-like waves is emphasized by relating their existence to two-band crossing points carrying opposite Chern numbers. The existence of these band crossings coincides with a restoration of the vertical mirror symmetry that is in general broken by gravity. From this perspective, Lamb-like waves also bear strong similarities with boundary modes encountered in quantum valley Hall effect. Our study shows that the presence of Lamb-like waves encode essential information on the underlying stratification profile in astrophysical and geophysical flows, which is often poorly constrained by observations.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2019; v1 submitted 8 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Topological Origin of Equatorial Waves
Authors:
Pierre Delplace,
J. B. Marston,
Antoine Venaille
Abstract:
Topology sheds new light on the emergence of unidirectional edge waves in a variety of physical systems, from condensed matter to artificial lattices. Waves observed in geophysical flows are also robust to perturbations, which suggests a role for topology. We show a topological origin for two celebrated equatorially trapped waves known as Kelvin and Yanai modes, due to the Earth's rotation that br…
▽ More
Topology sheds new light on the emergence of unidirectional edge waves in a variety of physical systems, from condensed matter to artificial lattices. Waves observed in geophysical flows are also robust to perturbations, which suggests a role for topology. We show a topological origin for two celebrated equatorially trapped waves known as Kelvin and Yanai modes, due to the Earth's rotation that breaks time-reversal symmetry. The non-trivial structure of the bulk Poincaré wave modes encoded through the first Chern number of value $2$ guarantees existence for these waves. This invariant demonstrates that ocean and atmospheric waves share fundamental properties with topological insulators, and that topology plays an unexpected role in the Earth climate system.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2017; v1 submitted 24 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Zonal flows as statistical equilibria
Authors:
F Bouchet,
Antoine Venaille
Abstract:
Zonal jets are striking and beautiful examples of the propensity for geophysical turbulent flows to spontaneously self-organize into robust, large scale coherent structures. There exist many dynamical mechanisms for the formation of zonal jets: statistical theories (kinetic approaches, second order or larger oder closures), deterministic approaches (modulational instability, $β$-plumes, radiating…
▽ More
Zonal jets are striking and beautiful examples of the propensity for geophysical turbulent flows to spontaneously self-organize into robust, large scale coherent structures. There exist many dynamical mechanisms for the formation of zonal jets: statistical theories (kinetic approaches, second order or larger oder closures), deterministic approaches (modulational instability, $β$-plumes, radiating instability, zonostrophic turbulence, and so on). A striking remark is that all these different dynamical approaches, each of them possibly relevant in some specific regimes, lead to the same kind of final jet structures. Is it then possible to have a more general explanation of why all these different dynamical regimes, from fully turbulent flows to gentle quasilinear regime, consistently lead to the same jet attractors ? Equilibrium statistical mechanics provides an answer to this general question. Here we we present the salient features of this theory and review applications of this approach to the description of zonal jets. We show that equilibrium states on a beta plane or a sphere are usually zonal or quasi-zonal, and that increasing the energy leads to bifurcations breaking the zonal symmetry.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Equilibrium statistical mechanics and energy partition for the shallow water model
Authors:
Antoine Renaud,
Antoine Venaille,
Freddy Bouchet
Abstract:
The aim of this paper is to use large deviation theory in order to compute the entropy of macrostates for the microcanonical measure of the shallow water system. The main prediction of this full statistical mechanics computation is the energy partition between a large scale vortical flow and small scale fluctuations related to inertia-gravity waves. We introduce for that purpose a discretized mode…
▽ More
The aim of this paper is to use large deviation theory in order to compute the entropy of macrostates for the microcanonical measure of the shallow water system. The main prediction of this full statistical mechanics computation is the energy partition between a large scale vortical flow and small scale fluctuations related to inertia-gravity waves. We introduce for that purpose a discretized model of the continuous shallow water system, and compute the corresponding statistical equilibria. We argue that microcanonical equilibrium states of the discretized model in the continuous limit are equilibrium states of the actual shallow water system. We show that the presence of small scale fluctuations selects a subclass of equilibria among the states that were previously computed by phenomenological approaches that were neglecting such fluctuations. In the limit of weak height fluctuations, the equilibrium state can be interpreted as two subsystems in thermal contact: one subsystem corresponds to the large scale vortical flow, the other subsystem corresponds to small scale height and velocity fluctuations. It is shown that either a non-zero circulation or rotation and bottom topography are required to sustain a non-zero large scale flow at equilibrium. Explicit computation of the equilibria and their energy partition is presented in the quasi-geostrophic limit for the energy-enstrophy ensemble. The possible role of small scale dissipation and shocks is discussed. A geophysical application to the Zapiola anticyclone is presented.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2016; v1 submitted 6 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Violent relaxation in two-dimensional flows with varying interaction range
Authors:
A Venaille,
T Dauxois,
S Ruffo
Abstract:
Understanding the relaxation of a system towards equilibrium is a longstanding problem in statistical mechanics. Here we address the role of long-range interactions in this process by considering a class of two-dimensional or geophysical flows where the interaction between fluid particles varies with the distance as $\sim$ r^($α$--2) with $α$ \textgreater{} 0. Previous studies in the Euler case…
▽ More
Understanding the relaxation of a system towards equilibrium is a longstanding problem in statistical mechanics. Here we address the role of long-range interactions in this process by considering a class of two-dimensional or geophysical flows where the interaction between fluid particles varies with the distance as $\sim$ r^($α$--2) with $α$ \textgreater{} 0. Previous studies in the Euler case $α$ = 2 had shown convergence towards a variety of quasi-stationary states by changing the initial state. Unexpectedly, all those regimes are recovered by changing $α$ with a prescribed initial state. For small $α$, a coarsening process leads to the formation of a sharp interface between two regions of homogenized $α$-vorticity; for large $α$, the flow is attracted to a stable dipolar structure through a filamentation process.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2015; v1 submitted 26 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Bottom-trapped currents as statistical equilibrium states above topographic anomalies
Authors:
Antoine Venaille
Abstract:
Oceanic geostrophic turbulence is mostly forced at the surface, yet strong bottom-trapped flows are commonly observed along topographic anomalies. Here we consider the case of a freely evolving, initially surface-intensified velocity field above a topographic bump, and show that the self-organization into a bottom-trapped current can result from its turbulent dynamics. Using equilibrium statistica…
▽ More
Oceanic geostrophic turbulence is mostly forced at the surface, yet strong bottom-trapped flows are commonly observed along topographic anomalies. Here we consider the case of a freely evolving, initially surface-intensified velocity field above a topographic bump, and show that the self-organization into a bottom-trapped current can result from its turbulent dynamics. Using equilibrium statistical mechanics, we explain this phenomenon as the most probable outcome of turbulent stirring. We compute explicitly a class of solutions characterized by a linear relation between potential vorticity and streamfunction, and predict when the bottom intensification is expected. Using direct numerical simulations, we provide an illustration of this phenomenon that agrees qualitatively with theory, although the ergodicity hypothesis is not strictly fulfilled.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Equilibrium and out of equilibrium phase transitions in systems with long range interactions and in 2D flows
Authors:
Freddy Bouchet,
Julien Barré,
Antoine Venaille
Abstract:
In self-gravitating stars, two dimensional or geophysical flows and in plasmas, long range interactions imply a lack of additivity for the energy; as a consequence, the usual thermodynamic limit is not appropriate. However, by contrast with many claims, the equilibrium statistical mechanics of such systems is a well understood subject. In this proceeding, we explain briefly the classical approac…
▽ More
In self-gravitating stars, two dimensional or geophysical flows and in plasmas, long range interactions imply a lack of additivity for the energy; as a consequence, the usual thermodynamic limit is not appropriate. However, by contrast with many claims, the equilibrium statistical mechanics of such systems is a well understood subject. In this proceeding, we explain briefly the classical approach to equilibrium and non equilibrium statistical mechanics for these systems, starting from first principles. We emphasize recent and new results, mainly a classification of equilibrium phase transitions, new unobserved equilibrium phase transition, and out of equilibrium phase transitions. We briefly discuss what we consider as challenges in this field.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2008;
originally announced February 2008.
-
Ensemble inequivalence, bicritical points and azeotropy for generalized Fofonoff flows
Authors:
Antoine Venaille,
Freddy Bouchet
Abstract:
We present a theoretical description for the equilibrium states of a large class of models of two-dimensional and geophysical flows, in arbitrary domains. We account for the existence of ensemble inequivalence and negative specific heat in those models, for the first time using explicit computations. We give exact theoretical computation of a criteria to determine phase transition location and t…
▽ More
We present a theoretical description for the equilibrium states of a large class of models of two-dimensional and geophysical flows, in arbitrary domains. We account for the existence of ensemble inequivalence and negative specific heat in those models, for the first time using explicit computations. We give exact theoretical computation of a criteria to determine phase transition location and type. Strikingly, this criteria does not depend on the model, but only on the domain geometry. We report the first example of bicritical points and second order azeotropy in the context of systems with long range interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2007;
originally announced October 2007.
