-
Systematic Absences of Optical Phonon Modes in Phonon Dispersion Measured by Electron Microscopy
Authors:
Aowen Li,
Paul Zeiger,
Zuxian He,
Mingquan Xu,
Stephen J. Pennycook,
Ján Rusz,
Wu Zhou
Abstract:
Phonon dispersion is widely used to elucidate the vibrational properties of materials. As an emerging technique, momentum-resolved vibrational spectroscopy in scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) offers an unparalleled approach to explore q-dependent phonon behavior at local structures. In this study, we systematically investigate the phonon dispersion of monolayer graphene across seve…
▽ More
Phonon dispersion is widely used to elucidate the vibrational properties of materials. As an emerging technique, momentum-resolved vibrational spectroscopy in scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) offers an unparalleled approach to explore q-dependent phonon behavior at local structures. In this study, we systematically investigate the phonon dispersion of monolayer graphene across several Brillouin zones (BZs) using momentum-resolved vibrational spectroscopy and find that the optical phonon signals vanish at the Γ points with indices (hk0) satisfying h+2k=3n (n denoted integers). Theoretical analysis reveals that the observed phenomena arise from the complete destructive interference of the scattered waves from different basis atoms. This observation, corroborated by the study of diamond, should be a general characteristic of materials composed of symmetrically equivalent pairs of the same elements. Moreover, our results emphasize the importance of multiple scattering in interpreting the vibrational signals in bulk materials. We demonstrate that the systematic absences and dynamic effects, which have not been much appreciated before, offer new insights into the experimental assessment of local vibrational properties of materials.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2024; v1 submitted 17 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Dynamical theory of angle-resolved electron energy loss and gain spectroscopies of phonons and magnons in transmission electron microscopy including multiple scattering effects
Authors:
José Ángel Castellanos-Reyes,
Paul Zeiger,
Ján Rusz
Abstract:
We present a method for computing angle-resolved electron-energy-loss and gain spectroscopies for phonon and magnon excitations in transmission electron microscopy. Fractional scattering intensities are derived from the temperature-dependent time auto-correlation of the electron beam wave function. This method captures both single and multiple scattering processes, as well as dynamical diffraction…
▽ More
We present a method for computing angle-resolved electron-energy-loss and gain spectroscopies for phonon and magnon excitations in transmission electron microscopy. Fractional scattering intensities are derived from the temperature-dependent time auto-correlation of the electron beam wave function. This method captures both single and multiple scattering processes, as well as dynamical diffraction effects. Our method remains computationally efficient, and it is easy to parallelize.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2024; v1 submitted 28 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Inelastic electron scattering at large angles: the phonon polariton contribution
Authors:
Hongbin Yang,
Paul Zeiger,
Andrea Konečná,
Lu Han,
Guangyao Miao,
Yinong Zhou,
Yifeng Huang,
Xingxu Yan,
Weihua Wang,
Jiandong Guo,
Yuefeng Nie,
Ruqian Wu,
Jan Rusz,
Xiaoqing Pan
Abstract:
We explore the inelastic electron scattering in SrTiO3, PbTiO3, and SiC in their phonon energy range, challenging the assumption that phonon polaritons are excluded at large angles in high-resolution transmission electron energy-loss spectroscopy. We demonstrate that through multiple scattering, the electron beam can excite both phonons and phonon polaritons, and the relative proportion of each va…
▽ More
We explore the inelastic electron scattering in SrTiO3, PbTiO3, and SiC in their phonon energy range, challenging the assumption that phonon polaritons are excluded at large angles in high-resolution transmission electron energy-loss spectroscopy. We demonstrate that through multiple scattering, the electron beam can excite both phonons and phonon polaritons, and the relative proportion of each varies depending on the structure factor and scattering angle. Integrating dielectric theory, density functional theory, and multi-slice simulations, we provide a comprehensive framework for understanding these interactions in materials with polar optical phonons.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2024; v1 submitted 9 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Real-Space Visualization of Frequency-Dependent Anisotropy of Atomic Vibrations
Authors:
Xingxu Yan,
Paul M. Zeiger,
Yifeng Huang,
Haoying Sun,
Jie Li,
Chaitanya A. Gadre,
Hongbin Yang,
Ri He,
Toshihiro Aoki,
Zhicheng Zhong,
Yuefeng Nie,
Ruqian Wu,
Ján Rusz,
Xiaoqing Pan
Abstract:
The underlying dielectric properties of materials, intertwined with intriguing phenomena such as topological polariton modes and anisotropic thermal conductivities, stem from the anisotropy in atomic vibrations. Conventionally, X-ray diffraction techniques have been employed to estimate thermal ellipsoids of distinct elements, albeit lacking the desired spatial and energy resolutions. Here we intr…
▽ More
The underlying dielectric properties of materials, intertwined with intriguing phenomena such as topological polariton modes and anisotropic thermal conductivities, stem from the anisotropy in atomic vibrations. Conventionally, X-ray diffraction techniques have been employed to estimate thermal ellipsoids of distinct elements, albeit lacking the desired spatial and energy resolutions. Here we introduce a novel approach utilizing the dark-field monochromated electron energy-loss spectroscopy for momentum-selective vibrational spectroscopy, enabling the cartographic delineation of variations of phonon polarization vectors. By applying this technique to centrosymmetric cubic-phase strontium titanate, we successfully discern two types of oxygen atoms exhibiting contrasting vibrational anisotropies below and above 60 meV due to their frequency-linked thermal ellipsoids. This method establishes a new pathway to visualize phonon eigenvectors at specific crystalline sites for diverse elements, thus delving into uncharted realms of dielectric, optical, and thermal property investigations with unprecedented spatial resolutions.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Lessons from the harmonic oscillator -- a reconciliation of the Frequency-Resolved Frozen Phonon Multislice Method with other theoretical approaches
Authors:
Paul M. Zeiger,
Juri Barthel,
Leslie J. Allen,
Ján Rusz
Abstract:
We compare the Frequency-Resolved Frozen Phonon Multislice (FRFPMS) method, introduced in Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 025501 (2020), with other theoretical approaches used to account for the inelastic scattering of high energy electrons, namely the first-order Born approximation and the quantum excitation of phonons model. We show, that these theories lead to similar expressions for the single inelastic…
▽ More
We compare the Frequency-Resolved Frozen Phonon Multislice (FRFPMS) method, introduced in Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 025501 (2020), with other theoretical approaches used to account for the inelastic scattering of high energy electrons, namely the first-order Born approximation and the quantum excitation of phonons model. We show, that these theories lead to similar expressions for the single inelastically scattered intensity as a function of momentum transfer for an anisotropic quantum harmonic oscillator in a weak phase object approximation of the scattered waves, except for a too small smearing of the scattering potential by the effective Debye-Waller factor (DWF) in the FRFPMS method. We propose that this issue can be fixed by including an explicit DWF smearing into the potential and demonstrate numerically, that in any realistic situation, a FRFPMS approach revised in this way, correctly accounts for the single inelastically scattered intensity and the correct elastic scattering intensity. Furthermore our simulations illustrate that the only requirement for such a revised FRFPMS method is the smallness of mean squared displacements for all atomic species in all frequency bins. The analytical considerations for the FRFPMS method also explain the $1/ω^2$-scaling of FRFPMS spectra observed in Phys. Rev. B 104, 104301 (2021) by the use of classical statistics in the molecular dynamics simulation. Moreover, we find that the FRFPMS method inherently adds the contributions of phonon loss and gain within each frequency bin. Both of these issues related to the frequency-scaling can be fixed by a system-independent post-processing step.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Control of the phonon band gap with isotopes in hexagonal boron nitride
Authors:
Paul Zeiger,
Jordan Hachtel,
Dominik Legut,
Eli Janzen,
Juri Barthel,
James H. Edgar,
Leslie J. Allen,
Ján Rusz
Abstract:
The isotopic mass of constituent elements of materials has a well-known effect on the energy of vibrational modes. By means of monochromated scanning transmission electron microscopy we have experimentally studied the phonon bandstructure of hexagonal BN, where a phonon band gap appears between in-plane optical phonon modes and the lower energy part of the phonon spectrum. The size of the phonon b…
▽ More
The isotopic mass of constituent elements of materials has a well-known effect on the energy of vibrational modes. By means of monochromated scanning transmission electron microscopy we have experimentally studied the phonon bandstructure of hexagonal BN, where a phonon band gap appears between in-plane optical phonon modes and the lower energy part of the phonon spectrum. The size of the phonon band gap can be manipulated by the isotopic mass of the boron. While in $^{11}$BN the phonon band gap is about 7 meV wide, in $^{10}$BN the gap nearly closes, being an order of magnitude smaller (below 0.5 meV). This opens exciting options for manipulating terahertz wave propagation through isotopically structured devices having otherwise no interfaces between chemically distinct components.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2023; v1 submitted 26 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Unveiling the impact of temperature on magnon diffuse scattering detection in the transmission electron microscope
Authors:
José Ángel Castellanos-Reyes,
Paul Zeiger,
Anders Bergman,
Demie Kepaptsoglou,
Quentin M. Ramasse,
Juan Carlos Idrobo,
Ján Rusz
Abstract:
Magnon diffuse scattering (MDS) signals could be studied with high spatial resolution in scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM), thanks to recent technological progress in electron energy loss spectroscopy. However, detecting MDS signals in STEM is challenging due to their overlap with stronger thermal diffuse scattering (TDS) signals. In bcc Fe at 300 K, MDS signals greater than or comp…
▽ More
Magnon diffuse scattering (MDS) signals could be studied with high spatial resolution in scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM), thanks to recent technological progress in electron energy loss spectroscopy. However, detecting MDS signals in STEM is challenging due to their overlap with stronger thermal diffuse scattering (TDS) signals. In bcc Fe at 300 K, MDS signals greater than or comparable to TDS signals occur under the central Bragg disk, into a currently inaccesible energy-loss region. Therefore, to detect MDS in STEM, it is necessary to find conditions in which TDS and MDS signals can be separated. Temperature may be a key factor due to the distinct thermal signatures of magnon and phonon signals. In this work, we present a study on the effects of temperature on MDS and TDS in bcc Fe -- considering a detector outside the central Bragg disk and a fixed convergent electron probe -- using the frozen phonon and frozen magnon multislice methods. Our study reveals that neglecting the effects of atomic vibrations causes the MDS signal to grow approximately linearly up to the Curie temperature of Fe, after which it exhibits less variation. The MDS signal displays an alternating behavior due to dynamical diffraction, instead of increasing monotonically as a function of thickness. Including the effects of atomic vibrations through a complex atomic electrostatic potential causes the linear growth of the MDS signal to change to a non-linear behavior that exhibits a predominant peak for a sample of thickness 16.072 nm at 1100 K. In contrast, the TDS signal grows more linearly than the MDS signal but still exhibits appreciable dynamical diffraction effects. An analysis of the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) shows that the MDS signal can be a statistically significant contribution to the total scattering intensity under realizable measurement conditions and acquisition times.
△ Less
Submitted 2 October, 2023; v1 submitted 22 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Simulations of magnetic Bragg scattering in transmission electron microscopy
Authors:
Justyn Snarski-Adamski,
Alexander Edström,
Paul Zeiger,
José Ángel Castellanos-Reyes,
Keenan Lyon,
Mirosław Werwiński,
Ján Rusz
Abstract:
We have simulated the magnetic Bragg scattering in transmission electron microscopy in two antiferromagnetic compounds, NiO and LaMnAsO. This weak magnetic phenomenon was experimentally observed in NiO by Loudon. We have computationally reproduced Loudon's experimental data, and for comparison we have performed calculations for the LaMnAsO compound as a more challenging case, containing lower conc…
▽ More
We have simulated the magnetic Bragg scattering in transmission electron microscopy in two antiferromagnetic compounds, NiO and LaMnAsO. This weak magnetic phenomenon was experimentally observed in NiO by Loudon. We have computationally reproduced Loudon's experimental data, and for comparison we have performed calculations for the LaMnAsO compound as a more challenging case, containing lower concentration of magnetic elements and strongly scattering heavier non-magnetic elements. We have also described thickness and voltage dependence of the intensity of the antiferromagnetic Bragg spot for both compounds. We have considered lattice vibrations within two computational approaches, one assuming a static lattice with Debye-Waller smeared potentials, and another explicitly considering the atomic vibrations within the quantum excitations of phonons model (thermal diffuse scattering). The structural analysis shows that the antiferromagnetic Bragg spot appears in between (111) and (000) reflections for NiO, while for LaMnAsO the antiferromagnetic Bragg spot appears at the position of the (010) reflection in the diffraction pattern, which corresponds to a forbidden reflection of the crystal structure. Calculations predict that the intensity of the magnetic Bragg spot in NiO is significantly stronger than thermal diffuse scattering at room temperature. For LaMnAsO, the magnetic Bragg spot is weaker than the room-temperature thermal diffuse scattering, but its detection can be facilitated at reduced temperatures.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2023; v1 submitted 10 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Magnon diffuse scattering in scanning transmission electron microscopy
Authors:
Keenan Lyon,
Anders Bergman,
Paul Zeiger,
Demie Kepaptsoglou,
Quentin M. Ramasse,
Juan Carlos Idrobo,
Ján Rusz
Abstract:
We present a theory and a simulation of thermal diffuse scattering due to the excitation of magnons in scanning transmission electron microscopy. The calculations indicate that magnons can present atomic contrast when detected by electron energy-loss spectroscopy using atomic-size electron beams. The results presented here indicate that the intensity of the magnon diffuse scattering in bcc iron at…
▽ More
We present a theory and a simulation of thermal diffuse scattering due to the excitation of magnons in scanning transmission electron microscopy. The calculations indicate that magnons can present atomic contrast when detected by electron energy-loss spectroscopy using atomic-size electron beams. The results presented here indicate that the intensity of the magnon diffuse scattering in bcc iron at 300~K is 4 orders of magnitude weaker than the intensity of thermal diffuse scattering arising from atomic vibrations. In an energy range where the phonon and magnon dispersions do not overlap, a monochromated scanning transmission electron microscope equipped with direct electron detectors for spectroscopy is expected to resolve the magnon spectral signatures.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Simulations of angle- and spatially-resolved vibrational electron energy loss spectroscopy for a system with a planar defect
Authors:
Paul M. Zeiger,
Ján Rusz
Abstract:
Recent developments in experiments with vibrational electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) have revealed spectral shape variations at spatial resolutions down to sub-atomic scale. Interpretation in terms of local phonon density of states enables their qualitative understanding, yet a more detailed analysis is calling for advances in theoretical methods. In Zeiger and Rusz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124,…
▽ More
Recent developments in experiments with vibrational electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) have revealed spectral shape variations at spatial resolutions down to sub-atomic scale. Interpretation in terms of local phonon density of states enables their qualitative understanding, yet a more detailed analysis is calling for advances in theoretical methods. In Zeiger and Rusz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 025501 (2020) we have presented a frequency resolved frozen phonon multislice method for simulations of vibrational EELS. Detailed simulations for a plane wave electron beam scattering on a vibrating hexagonal boron nitride are presented in a companion manuscript (Zeiger and Rusz, arXiv:2104.03197). Here we present simulations of vibrational EELS assuming a convergent electron probe of nanometer size and atomic size on a hexagonal boron nitride structure model with a planar defect. With a nanometer beam we observe spectral shape modifications in the presence of the defect, which are correlated with local changes of the phonon density of states. With an atomic size electron beam, we observe the same, although with better contrast. In addition, we observe atomic level contrast and sub-atomic scale spectral shape modifications, which are particularly strong for small detector collection angles.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
The frequency-resolved frozen phonon multislice method and its application to vibrational EELS using parallel illumination
Authors:
Paul M. Zeiger,
Ján Rusz
Abstract:
We explore the capabilities of the frequency-resolved frozen phonon multislice method introduced in Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 025501 (2020) to model inelastic vibrational scattering in transmission electron microscopy. We review the method in detail and discuss advantages of using a so called hotspot thermostat instead of the $δ$-thermostat used in our first report. We apply the method to simulate vib…
▽ More
We explore the capabilities of the frequency-resolved frozen phonon multislice method introduced in Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 025501 (2020) to model inelastic vibrational scattering in transmission electron microscopy. We review the method in detail and discuss advantages of using a so called hotspot thermostat instead of the $δ$-thermostat used in our first report. We apply the method to simulate vibrational electron energy loss spectra of hexagonal boron nitride under plane wave illumination. Simulated spectroscopic information well represents the theoretical phonon bandstructure of the studied material, both in terms of energies as well as polarization vectors of individual phonon modes.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Efficient and versatile model for vibrational STEM-EELS
Authors:
Paul M. Zeiger,
Ján Rusz
Abstract:
We introduce a novel method for the simulation of the impact scattering in vibrational scanning transmission electron microscopy electron energy loss spectroscopy (STEM-EELS) simulations. The phonon-loss process is modeled by a combination of molecular dynamics and elastic multislice calculations within a modified frozen phonon approximation. The key idea is thereby to use a so-called $δ$-thermost…
▽ More
We introduce a novel method for the simulation of the impact scattering in vibrational scanning transmission electron microscopy electron energy loss spectroscopy (STEM-EELS) simulations. The phonon-loss process is modeled by a combination of molecular dynamics and elastic multislice calculations within a modified frozen phonon approximation. The key idea is thereby to use a so-called $δ$-thermostat in the classical molecular dynamics simulation to generate frequency dependent configurations of the vibrating specimen's atomic structure. The method includes correlated motion of atoms and provides vibrational spectrum images at the cost comparable to standard frozen phonon calculations. We demonstrate good agreement of our method with simulations and experiments for a 15nm flake of hexagonal boron-nitride (hBN).
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
