Showing 1–13 of 13 results for author: Manning, B

Neutron transfer reactions on the ground state and isomeric state of a 130Sn beam

Authors: K. L. Jones, A. Bey, S. Burcher, J. M. Allmond, A. Galindo-Uribarri, D. C. Radford, S. Ahn, A. Ayres, 1 D. W. Bardayan, J. A. Cizewski, R. F. Garcia Ruiz, M. E. Howard, R. L. Kozub, J. F. Liang, B. Manning, M. Matos, C. D. Nesaraja, P. D. O'Malley, E. Padilla-Rodal, S. D. Pain, S. T. Pittman, A. Ratkiewicz, K. T. Schmitt, M. S. Smith, D. W. Stracener , et al. (1 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The structure of nuclei around the neutron-rich nucleus 132Sn is of particular interest due to the vicinity of the Z = 50 and N = 82 shell closures and the r-process nucleosynthetic path. Four states in 131Sn with a strong single-particle-like component have previously been studied via the (d,p) reaction, with limited excitation energy resolution. The 130Sn(9Be,8Be)131Sn and 130Sn(13C,12C)131Sn si… ▽ More The structure of nuclei around the neutron-rich nucleus 132Sn is of particular interest due to the vicinity of the Z = 50 and N = 82 shell closures and the r-process nucleosynthetic path. Four states in 131Sn with a strong single-particle-like component have previously been studied via the (d,p) reaction, with limited excitation energy resolution. The 130Sn(9Be,8Be)131Sn and 130Sn(13C,12C)131Sn single-neutron transfer reactions were performed in inverse kinematics at the Holifield Radioactive Ion Beam Facility using particle-gamma coincidence spectroscopy. The uncertainties in the energies of the single-particle-like states have been reduced by more than an order of magnitude using the energies of gamma rays. The previous tentative Jpi values have been confirmed. Decays from high-spin states in 131Sn have been observed following transfer on the isomeric component of the 130Sn beam. The improved energies and confirmed spin-parities of the p-wave states important to the r-process lead to direct-semidirect cross-sections for neutron capture on the ground state of 130Sn at 30 keV that are in agreement with previous analyses. A similar assessment of the impact of neutron-transfer on the isomer would require significant nuclear structure and reaction theory input. There are few measurements of transfer reaction on isomers, and this is the first on an isomer in the 132Sn region. △ Less

Submitted 21 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: 7 pages, 4 figures

Measurement of the $^{239}$Pu(n,f)/$^{235}$U(n,f) Cross-Section Ratio with the NIFFTE fission Time Projection Chamber

Authors: L. Snyder, M. Anastasiou, N. S. Bowden, J. Bundgaard, R. J. Casperson, D. A. Cebra, T. Classen, D. H. Dongwi, N. Fotiades, J. Gearhart, V. Geppert-Kleinrath, U. Greife, C. Hagmann, M. Heffner, D. Hensle, D. Higgins, L. D. Isenhower, K. Kazkaz, A. Kemnitz, J. King, J. L. Klay, J. Latta, E. Leal-Cidoncha, W. Loveland, J. A. Magee , et al. (15 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The $^{239}$Pu(n,f)/$^{235}$U(n,f) cross-section ratio has been measured with the fission Time Projection Chamber (fissionTPC) from 100 keV to 100 MeV. The fissionTPC provides three-dimensional reconstruction of fission-fragment ionization profiles, allowing for a precise quantification of measurement uncertainties. The measurement was performed at the Los Alamos Neutron Science Center which provi… ▽ More The $^{239}$Pu(n,f)/$^{235}$U(n,f) cross-section ratio has been measured with the fission Time Projection Chamber (fissionTPC) from 100 keV to 100 MeV. The fissionTPC provides three-dimensional reconstruction of fission-fragment ionization profiles, allowing for a precise quantification of measurement uncertainties. The measurement was performed at the Los Alamos Neutron Science Center which provides a pulsed white source of neutrons. The data are recommended to be used as a cross-section ratio shape. A discussion of the status of the absolute normalization and comparisons to ENDF evaluations and previous measurements is included. △ Less

Submitted 6 July, 2021; originally announced July 2021.

Measurement of material isotopics and atom number ratio with alpha-particle spectroscopy for the NIFFTE fission Time Projection Chamber actinide target

Authors: M. Monterial, K. T. Schmitt, C. Prokop, E. Leal-Cidoncha, M. Anastasiou, N. S. Bowden, J. Bundgaard, R. J. Casperson, D. A. Cebra, T. Classen, D. H. Dongwi, N. Fotiades, J. Gearhart, V. Geppert-Kleinrath, U. Greife, C. Hagmann, M. Heffner, D. Hensle, D. Higgins, L. D. Isenhower, K. Kazkaz, A. Kemnitz, J. King, J. L. Klay, J. Latta , et al. (15 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We present the results of a measurement of isotopic concentrations and atomic number ratio of a double-sided actinide target with alpha-spectroscopy and mass spectrometry. The double-sided actinide target, with primarily Pu-239 on one side and U-235 on the other, was used in the fission Time Projection Chamber (fissionTPC) for a measurement of the neutron-induced fission cross-section ratio betwee… ▽ More We present the results of a measurement of isotopic concentrations and atomic number ratio of a double-sided actinide target with alpha-spectroscopy and mass spectrometry. The double-sided actinide target, with primarily Pu-239 on one side and U-235 on the other, was used in the fission Time Projection Chamber (fissionTPC) for a measurement of the neutron-induced fission cross-section ratio between the two isotopes. The measured atomic number ratio is intended to provide an absolute normalization of the measured fission cross-section ratio. The Pu-239/U-235 atom number ratio was measured with a combination of mass spectrometry and alpha-spectroscopy with a planar silicon detector with uncertainties of less than 1%. △ Less

Submitted 9 July, 2021; v1 submitted 10 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

Comments: 8 pages, 5 figures, 6 tables

Neutron Induced Fission Fragment Angular Distributions, Anisotropy, and Linear Momentum Transfer Measured with the NIFFTE Fission Time Projection Chamber

Authors: D. Hensle, J. T. Barker, J. S. Barrett, N. S. Bowden, K. J. Brewster, J. Bundgaard, Z. Q. Case, R. J. Casperson, D. A. Cebra, T. Classen, D. L. Duke, N. Fotiadis, J Gearhart, V. Geppert-Kleinrath, U. Greife, E. Guardincerri, C. Hagmann, M. Heffner, C. R. Hicks, D. Higgins, L. D. Isenhower, K. Kazkaz, A. Kemnitz, K. J. Kiesling, J. King , et al. (24 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The Neutron Induced Fission Fragment Tracking Experiment (NIFFTE) collaboration has performed measurements with a fission time projection chamber (fissionTPC) to study the fission process by reconstructing full three-dimensional tracks of fission fragments and other ionizing radiation. The amount of linear momentum imparted to the fissioning nucleus by the incident neutron can be inferred by measu… ▽ More The Neutron Induced Fission Fragment Tracking Experiment (NIFFTE) collaboration has performed measurements with a fission time projection chamber (fissionTPC) to study the fission process by reconstructing full three-dimensional tracks of fission fragments and other ionizing radiation. The amount of linear momentum imparted to the fissioning nucleus by the incident neutron can be inferred by measuring the opening angle between the fission fragments. Using this measured linear momentum, fission fragment angular distributions can be converted to the center-of-mass frame for anisotropy measurements. Angular anisotropy is an important experimental observable for understanding the quantum mechanical state of the fissioning nucleus and vital to determining detection efficiency for cross section measurements. Neutron linear momentum transfer to fissioning $^{235}$U, $^{238}$U, and $^{239}$Pu and fission fragment angular anisotropy of $^{235}$U and $^{238}$U as a function of neutron energies in the range 130 keV--250 MeV are presented. △ Less

Submitted 25 January, 2020; originally announced January 2020.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. C 102, 014605 (2020)

Towards Neutron Capture on Exotic Nuclei: Demonstrating $(d,pγがんま)$ as a Surrogate Reaction for $(n,γがんま)$

Authors: A. Ratkiewicz, J. A. Cizewski, J. E. Escher, G. Potel, J. T. Burke, R. J. Casperson, M. McCleskey, R. A. E. Austin, S. Burcher, R. O. Hughes, B. Manning, S. D. Pain, W. A. Peters, S. Rice, T. J. Ross, N. D. Scielzo, C. Shand, K. Smith

Abstract: The neutron-capture reaction plays a critical role in the synthesis of the elements in stars and is important for societal applications including nuclear power generation and stockpile-stewardship science. However, it is difficult - if not impossible - to directly measure neutron capture cross sections for the exotic, short-lived nuclei that participate in these processes. In this Letter we demons… ▽ More The neutron-capture reaction plays a critical role in the synthesis of the elements in stars and is important for societal applications including nuclear power generation and stockpile-stewardship science. However, it is difficult - if not impossible - to directly measure neutron capture cross sections for the exotic, short-lived nuclei that participate in these processes. In this Letter we demonstrate a new technique which can be used to indirectly determine neutron-capture cross sections for exotic systems. This technique makes use of the $(d,p)$ transfer reaction, which has long been used as a tool to study the structure of nuclei. Recent advances in reaction theory, together with data collected using this reaction, enable the determination of neutron-capture cross sections for short-lived nuclei. A benchmark study of the $^{95}$Mo$(d,p)$ reaction is presented, which illustrates the approach and provides guidance for future applications of the method with short-lived isotopes produced at rare isotope accelerators. △ Less

Submitted 20 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: 6 pages, 5 figures. Accepted by PRL

Measurement of the normalized $^{238}$U(n,f)/$^{235}$U(n,f) cross section ratio from threshold to 30 MeV with the fission Time Projection Chamber

Authors: R. J. Casperson, D. M. Asner, J. Baker, R. G. Baker, J. S. Barrett, N. S. Bowden, C. Brune, J. Bundgaard, E. Burgett, D. A. Cebra, T. Classen, M. Cunningham, J. Deaven, D. L. Duke, I. Ferguson, J. Gearhart, V. Geppert-Kleinrath, U. Greife, S. Grimes, E. Guardincerri, U. Hager, C. Hagmann, M. Heffner, D. Hensle, N. Hertel , et al. (39 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The normalized $^{238}$U(n,f)/$^{235}$U(n,f) cross section ratio has been measured using the NIFFTE fission Time Projection Chamber from the reaction threshold to $30$~MeV. The fissionTPC is a two-volume MICROMEGAS time projection chamber that allows for full three-dimensional reconstruction of fission-fragment ionization profiles from neutron-induced fission. The measurement was performed at the… ▽ More The normalized $^{238}$U(n,f)/$^{235}$U(n,f) cross section ratio has been measured using the NIFFTE fission Time Projection Chamber from the reaction threshold to $30$~MeV. The fissionTPC is a two-volume MICROMEGAS time projection chamber that allows for full three-dimensional reconstruction of fission-fragment ionization profiles from neutron-induced fission. The measurement was performed at the Los Alamos Neutron Science Center, where the neutron energy is determined from neutron time-of-flight. The $^{238}$U(n,f)/$^{235}$U(n,f) ratio reported here is the first cross section measurement made with the fissionTPC, and will provide new experimental data for evaluation of the $^{238}$U(n,f) cross section, an important standard used in neutron-flux measurements. Use of a development target in this work prevented the determination of an absolute normalization, to be addressed in future measurements. Instead, the measured cross section ratio has been normalized to ENDF/B-VIII.$βべーた$5 at 14.5 MeV. △ Less

Submitted 23 February, 2018; originally announced February 2018.

Performance of a MICROMEGAS-based TPC in a high-energy neutron beam

Authors: Lucas Snyder, Brett Manning, Nathaniel S. Bowden, Jeremy Bundgaard, Robert J. Casperson, Daniel A. Cebra, Timothy Classen, Dana L. Duke, Joshua Gearhart, Uwe Greife, Christian Hagmann, Michael Heffner, David Hensle, Daniel Higgins, Donald Isenhower, Jonathan King, Jennifer L. Klay, Verena Geppert-Kleinrath, Walter Loveland, Joshua A. Magee, Michael P. Mendenhall, Samuele Sangiorgio, Brandon Seilhan, Kyle T. Schmitt, Fredrik Tovesson , et al. (5 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The MICROMEGAS (MICRO-MEsh GAseous Structure) charge amplification structure has found wide use in many detection applications, especially as a gain stage for the charge readout of Time Projection Chambers (TPCs). Here we report on the behavior of a MICROMEGAS TPC when operated in a high-energy (up to 800 MeV) neutron beam. It is found that neutron-induced reactions can cause discharges in some dr… ▽ More The MICROMEGAS (MICRO-MEsh GAseous Structure) charge amplification structure has found wide use in many detection applications, especially as a gain stage for the charge readout of Time Projection Chambers (TPCs). Here we report on the behavior of a MICROMEGAS TPC when operated in a high-energy (up to 800 MeV) neutron beam. It is found that neutron-induced reactions can cause discharges in some drift gas mixtures that are stable in the absence of the neutron beam. The discharges result from recoil ions close to the MICROMEGAS that deposit high specific ionization density and have a limited diffusion time. For a binary drift gas, increasing the percentage of the molecular component (quench gas) relative to the noble component and operating at lower pressures generally improves stability. △ Less

Submitted 4 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Journal ref: Nuclear Inst. and Methods in Physics Research, A 881 (2018) 1-8

Fission Fragment Angular Anisotropy in Neutron-Induced Fission of $^{235}$U Measured with a Time Projection Chamber

Authors: V. Geppert-Kleinrath, F. Tovesson, J. S. Barrett, N. S. Bowden, J. Bundgaard, R. J. Casperson, D. A. Cebra, T. Classen, M. Cunningham, D. L. Duke, J. Gearhart, U. Greife, E. Guardincerri, C. Hagmann, M. Heffner, D. Hensle, D. Higgins, L. D. Isenhower, J. King, J. L. Klay, W. Loveland, J. A. Magee, B. Manning, M. P. Mendenhall, J. Ruz , et al. (11 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Fission fragment angular distributions can provide an important constraint on fission theory, improving predictive fission codes, and are a prerequisite for a precise ratio cross section measurement. Available anisotropy data is sparse, especially at neutron energies above 5 MeV. For the first time, a three-dimensional tracking detector is employed to study fragment emission angles and provide a d… ▽ More Fission fragment angular distributions can provide an important constraint on fission theory, improving predictive fission codes, and are a prerequisite for a precise ratio cross section measurement. Available anisotropy data is sparse, especially at neutron energies above 5 MeV. For the first time, a three-dimensional tracking detector is employed to study fragment emission angles and provide a direct measurement of angular anisotropy. The Neutron Induced Fission Fragment Tracking Experiment (NIFFTE) collaboration has deployed the fission time projection chamber (fissionTPC) to measure nuclear data with unprecedented precision. The fission fragment anisotropy of $^{235}$U has been measured over a wide range of incident neutron energies from 180 keV to 200 MeV; a careful study of the systematic uncertainties complement the data. △ Less

Submitted 15 August, 2019; v1 submitted 2 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 10 pages, 12 figures, accepted to Physical Review C

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. C 99, 064619 (2019)

Recent direct reaction experimental studies with radioactive tin beams

Authors: K. L. Jones, S. Ahn, J. M. Allmond, A. Ayres, D. W. Bardayan, T. Baugher, D. Bazin, J. S. Berryman, A. Bey, C. Bingham, L. Cartegni, G. Cerizza, K. Y. Chae, J. A. Cizewski, A. Gade, A. Galindo-Uribarri, R. F. Garcia-Ruiz, R. Grzywacz, M. E. Howard, R. L. Kozub, J. F. Liang, B. Manning, M. Matos, S. McDaniel, D. Miller , et al. (18 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: Direct reaction techniques are powerful tools to study the single-particle nature of nuclei. Performing direct reactions on short-lived nuclei requires radioactive ion beams produced either via fragmentation or the Isotope Separation OnLine (ISOL) method. Some of the most interesting regions to study with direct reactions are close to the magic numbers where changes in shell structure can be track… ▽ More Direct reaction techniques are powerful tools to study the single-particle nature of nuclei. Performing direct reactions on short-lived nuclei requires radioactive ion beams produced either via fragmentation or the Isotope Separation OnLine (ISOL) method. Some of the most interesting regions to study with direct reactions are close to the magic numbers where changes in shell structure can be tracked. These changes can impact the final abundances of explosive nucleosynthesis. The structure of the chain of tin isotopes is strongly influenced by the Z=50 proton shell closure, as well as the neutron shell closures lying in the neutron-rich, N=82, and neutron-deficient, N=50, regions. Here we present two examples of direct reactions on exotic tin isotopes. The first uses a one-neutron transfer reaction and a low-energy reaccelerated ISOL beam to study states in 131Sn from across the N=82 shell closure. The second example utilizes a one-neutron knockout reaction on fragmentation beams of neutron-deficient 106,108Sn. In both cases, measurements of gamma rays in coincidence with charged particles proved to be invaluable. △ Less

Submitted 26 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: 11 pages, 5 figures, Zakopane Conference on Nuclear Physics "Extremes of the Nuclear Landscape", Zakopane, Poland, August 31 - September 7, 2014

Journal ref: Acta Physica Polonica B, 46(3), 537-546 (2015)

$^{24}$Mg($p$, $αあるふぁ$)$^{21}$Na reaction study for spectroscopy of $^{21}$Na

Authors: S. M. Cha, K. Y. Chae, A. Kim, E. J. Lee, S. Ahn, D. W. Bardayan, K. A. Chipps, J. A. Cizewski, M. E. Howard, B. Manning, P. D. O'Malley, A. Ratkiewicz, S. Strauss, R. L. Kozub, M. Matos, S. D. Pain, S. T. Pittman, M. S. Smith, W. A. Peters

Abstract: The $^{24}$Mg($p$, $αあるふぁ$)$^{21}$Na reaction was measured at the Holifield Radioactive Ion Beam Facility at Oak Ridge National Laboratory in order to better constrain spins and parities of energy levels in $^{21}$Na for the astrophysically important $^{17}$F($αあるふぁ, p$)$^{20}$Ne reaction rate calculation. 31 MeV proton beams from the 25-MV tandem accelerator and enriched $^{24}$Mg solid targets were used… ▽ More The $^{24}$Mg($p$, $αあるふぁ$)$^{21}$Na reaction was measured at the Holifield Radioactive Ion Beam Facility at Oak Ridge National Laboratory in order to better constrain spins and parities of energy levels in $^{21}$Na for the astrophysically important $^{17}$F($αあるふぁ, p$)$^{20}$Ne reaction rate calculation. 31 MeV proton beams from the 25-MV tandem accelerator and enriched $^{24}$Mg solid targets were used. Recoiling $^{4}$He particles from the $^{24}$Mg($p$, $αあるふぁ$)$^{21}$Na reaction were detected by a highly segmented silicon detector array which measured the yields of $^{4}$He particles over a range of angles simultaneously. A new level at 6661 $\pm$ 5 keV was observed in the present work. The extracted angular distributions for the first four levels of $^{21}$Na and Distorted Wave Born Approximation (DWBA) calculations were compared to verify and extract angular momentum transfer. △ Less

Submitted 10 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: 11 pages, 6 figures, proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Accelerators and Beam Utilization (ICABU2014)

Elastic breakup cross sections of well-bound nucleons

Authors: K. Wimmer, D. Bazin, A. Gade, J. A. Tostevin, T. Baugher, Z. Chajecki, D. Coupland, M. A. Famiano, T. K. Ghosh, G. F. Grinyer M. E. Howard, M. Kilburn, W. G. Lynch, B. Manning, K. Meierbachtol, P. Quarterman, A. Ratkiewicz, A. Sanetullaev, R. H. Showalter, S. R. Stroberg, M. B. Tsang, D. Weisshaar, J. Winkelbauer, R. Winkler, M. Youngs

Abstract: The 9Be(28Mg,27Na) one-proton removal reaction with a large proton separation energy of Sp(28Mg)=16.79 MeV is studied at intermediate beam energy. Coincidences of the bound 27Na residues with protons and other light charged particles are measured. These data are analyzed to determine the percentage contributions to the proton removal cross section from the elastic and inelastic nucleon removal mec… ▽ More The 9Be(28Mg,27Na) one-proton removal reaction with a large proton separation energy of Sp(28Mg)=16.79 MeV is studied at intermediate beam energy. Coincidences of the bound 27Na residues with protons and other light charged particles are measured. These data are analyzed to determine the percentage contributions to the proton removal cross section from the elastic and inelastic nucleon removal mechanisms. These deduced contributions are compared with the eikonal reaction model predictions and with the previously measured data for reactions involving the re- moval of more weakly-bound protons from lighter nuclei. The role of transitions of the proton between different bound single-particle configurations upon the elastic breakup cross section is also quantified in this well-bound case. The measured and calculated elastic breakup fractions are found to be in good agreement. △ Less

Submitted 6 December, 2014; originally announced December 2014.

Comments: Phys. Rev. C 2014 (accepted)

Correlations in intermediate-energy two-proton removal reactions

Authors: K. Wimmer, D. Bazin, A. Gade, J. A. Tostevin, T. Baugher, Z. Chajecki, D. Coupland, M. A. Famiano, T. K. Ghosh, G. F. Grinyer, R. Hodges, M. E. Howard, M. Kilburn, W. G. Lynch, B. Manning, K. Meierbachtol, P. Quarterman, A. Ratkiewicz, A. Sanetullaev, E. C. Simpson, S. R. Stroberg, M. B. Tsang, D. Weisshaar, J. Winkelbauer, R. Winkler , et al. (1 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We report final-state-exclusive measurements of the light charged fragments in coincidence with 26Ne residual nuclei following the direct two-proton removal from a neutron-rich 28Mg secondary beam. A Dalitz-plot analysis and comparisons with simulations show that a majority of the triple- coincidence events with two protons display phase-space correlations consistent with the (two-body) kinematics… ▽ More We report final-state-exclusive measurements of the light charged fragments in coincidence with 26Ne residual nuclei following the direct two-proton removal from a neutron-rich 28Mg secondary beam. A Dalitz-plot analysis and comparisons with simulations show that a majority of the triple- coincidence events with two protons display phase-space correlations consistent with the (two-body) kinematics of a spatially-correlated pair-removal mechanism. The fraction of such correlated events, 56(12) %, is consistent with the fraction of the calculated cross section, 64 %, arising from spin S = 0 two-proton configurations in the entrance-channel (shell-model) 28Mg ground state wave function. This result promises access to an additional and more specific probe of the spin and spatial correlations of valence nucleon pairs in exotic nuclei produced as fast secondary beams. △ Less

Submitted 13 October, 2012; originally announced October 2012.

Comments: accepted for publication in Physical Review Letters

Probing elastic and inelastic breakup contributions to intermediate-energy two-proton removal reactions

Authors: K. Wimmer, D. Bazin, A. Gade, J. A. Tostevin, T. Baugher, Z. Chajecki, D. Coupland, M. A. Famiano, T. K. Ghosh, G. F. Grinyer, R. Hodges, M. E. Howard, M. Kilburn, W. G. Lynch, B. Manning, K. Meierbachtol, P. Quarterman, A. Ratkiewicz, A. Sanetullaev, S. R. Stroberg, M. B. Tsang, D. Weisshaar, J. Winkelbauer, R. Winkler M. Youngs

Abstract: The two-proton removal reaction from 28Mg projectiles has been studied at 93 MeV/u at the NSCL. First coincidence measurements of the heavy 26Ne projectile residues, the removed protons and other light charged particles enabled the relative cross sections from each of the three possible elastic and inelastic proton removal mechanisms to be determined. These more final-state-exclusive measurements… ▽ More The two-proton removal reaction from 28Mg projectiles has been studied at 93 MeV/u at the NSCL. First coincidence measurements of the heavy 26Ne projectile residues, the removed protons and other light charged particles enabled the relative cross sections from each of the three possible elastic and inelastic proton removal mechanisms to be determined. These more final-state-exclusive measurements are key for further interrogation of these reaction mechanisms and use of the reaction channel for quantitative spectroscopy of very neutron-rich nuclei. The relative and absolute yields of the three contributing mechanisms are compared to reaction model expectations - based on the use of eikonal dynamics and sd-shell-model structure amplitudes. △ Less

Submitted 9 May, 2012; originally announced May 2012.

Comments: Accepted for publication in Physical Review C (Rapid Communication)