-
Revisiting the helium isotope-shift puzzle with improved uncertainties from nuclear structure corrections
Authors:
Simone Salvatore Li Muli,
Thomas R. Richardson,
Sonia Bacca
Abstract:
Measurements of the difference between the squared charge radii of the helion ($^3$He nucleus) and the $α$-particle ($^4$He nucleus) have been characterized by longstanding tensions, recently spotlighted in the 3.6 $σ$ discrepancy of the extractions from ordinary atoms versus those from muonic atoms. Here, we present a novel analysis of uncertainties in nuclear structure corrections that must be s…
▽ More
Measurements of the difference between the squared charge radii of the helion ($^3$He nucleus) and the $α$-particle ($^4$He nucleus) have been characterized by longstanding tensions, recently spotlighted in the 3.6 $σ$ discrepancy of the extractions from ordinary atoms versus those from muonic atoms. Here, we present a novel analysis of uncertainties in nuclear structure corrections that must be supplied by theory to enable the extraction of the difference in radii from spectroscopic experiments. We use modern Bayesian inference techniques to quantify uncertainties stemming from the truncation of the chiral effective field theory expansion of the nuclear force for both muonic and ordinary atoms. With the new nuclear structure input, the helium isotope-shift puzzle cannot be explained, rather it is reinforced to a 4 $σ$ discrepancy.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Comprehensive theory of the Lamb shift in light muonic atoms
Authors:
K. Pachucki,
V. Lensky,
F. Hagelstein,
S. S. Li Muli,
S. Bacca,
R. Pohl
Abstract:
A comprehensive theory of the Lamb shift in light muonic atoms such as $μ$H, $μ$D, $μ^3$He$^+$, and $μ^4$He$^+$ is presented, with all quantum electrodynamic corrections included at the precision level constrained by the uncertainty of nuclear structure effects. This analysis can be used in the global adjustment of fundamental constants and in the determination of nuclear charge radii. Further imp…
▽ More
A comprehensive theory of the Lamb shift in light muonic atoms such as $μ$H, $μ$D, $μ^3$He$^+$, and $μ^4$He$^+$ is presented, with all quantum electrodynamic corrections included at the precision level constrained by the uncertainty of nuclear structure effects. This analysis can be used in the global adjustment of fundamental constants and in the determination of nuclear charge radii. Further improvements in the understanding of electromagnetic interactions of light nuclei will allow for a promising test of fundamental interactions by comparison with ``normal" atomic spectroscopy, in particular, with H-D and $^3$He-$^4$He isotope shifts.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2024; v1 submitted 28 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Muonic-Atom Spectroscopy and Impact on Nuclear Structure and Precision QED Theory
Authors:
Aldo Antognini,
Sonia Bacca,
Andreas Fleischmann,
Loredana Gastaldo,
Franziska Hagelstein,
Paul Indelicato,
Andreas Knecht,
Vadim Lensky,
Ben Ohayon,
Vladimir Pascalutsa,
Nancy Paul,
Randolf Pohl,
Frederik Wauters
Abstract:
Recent progress in laser and x-ray spectroscopy of muonic atoms offers promising long-term possibilities at the intersection of atomic, nuclear and particle physics. In muonic hydrogen, laser spectroscopy measurements will determine the ground-state hyperfine splitting (HFS) and additionally improve the Lamb shift by a factor of 5. Precision spectroscopy with cryogenic microcalorimeters has the po…
▽ More
Recent progress in laser and x-ray spectroscopy of muonic atoms offers promising long-term possibilities at the intersection of atomic, nuclear and particle physics. In muonic hydrogen, laser spectroscopy measurements will determine the ground-state hyperfine splitting (HFS) and additionally improve the Lamb shift by a factor of 5. Precision spectroscopy with cryogenic microcalorimeters has the potential to significantly improve the charge radii of the light nuclei in the $Z=3-8$ range. Complementary progress in precision should be achieved on the theory of nucleon- and nuclear-structure effects. The impact of this muonic-atom spectroscopy program will be amplified by the upcoming results from H and He$^+$ spectroscopy, simple molecules such as HD$^+$ and Penning trap measurements. In this broader context, one can test ab-initio nuclear theories, bound-state QED for two- or three-body systems, and determine fundamental constants, such as the Rydberg ($R_\infty$) and the fine-structure ($α$) constants.
△ Less
Submitted 30 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Bayesian analysis of nuclear polarizability corrections to the Lamb shift of muonic H-atoms and He-ions
Authors:
Simone Salvatore Li Muli,
Bijaya Acharya,
Oscar Javier Hernandez,
Sonia Bacca
Abstract:
The extraction of nuclear charge radii from spectroscopy experiments in muonic atoms is currently limited by the large uncertainties associated with the theoretical evaluation of the nuclear polarizability effects. To facilitate calculations, these polarizability corrections are conventionally expressed as an expansion in a dimensionless parameter $η$, which has been argued in previous literature…
▽ More
The extraction of nuclear charge radii from spectroscopy experiments in muonic atoms is currently limited by the large uncertainties associated with the theoretical evaluation of the nuclear polarizability effects. To facilitate calculations, these polarizability corrections are conventionally expressed as an expansion in a dimensionless parameter $η$, which has been argued in previous literature to hold an approximate value of 0.33 in light-nuclear systems. In this work, we check this claim by doing a Bayesian analysis of the nuclear-polarizability corrections to the Lamb shift in $μ^2$H and $μ^3$H atoms and in $μ^3$He$^+$ and $μ^4$He$^+$ ions at various orders in the $η$-expansion. Our analysis supports the claim that $η\ll 1$ in these systems and finds truncation uncertainties that are similar to the previous estimate, the only exception being the truncation uncertainties in the $μ^3$He$^+$ ion, which are found to be larger.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2022; v1 submitted 21 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Theoretical tools for neutrino scattering: interplay between lattice QCD, EFTs, nuclear physics, phenomenology, and neutrino event generators
Authors:
L. Alvarez Ruso,
A. M. Ankowski,
S. Bacca,
A. B. Balantekin,
J. Carlson,
S. Gardiner,
R. Gonzalez-Jimenez,
R. Gupta,
T. J. Hobbs,
M. Hoferichter,
J. Isaacson,
N. Jachowicz,
W. I. Jay,
T. Katori,
F. Kling,
A. S. Kronfeld,
S. W. Li,
H. -W. Lin,
K. -F. Liu,
A. Lovato,
K. Mahn,
J. Menendez,
A. S. Meyer,
J. Morfin,
S. Pastore
, et al. (36 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Maximizing the discovery potential of increasingly precise neutrino experiments will require an improved theoretical understanding of neutrino-nucleus cross sections over a wide range of energies. Low-energy interactions are needed to reconstruct the energies of astrophysical neutrinos from supernovae bursts and search for new physics using increasingly precise measurement of coherent elastic neut…
▽ More
Maximizing the discovery potential of increasingly precise neutrino experiments will require an improved theoretical understanding of neutrino-nucleus cross sections over a wide range of energies. Low-energy interactions are needed to reconstruct the energies of astrophysical neutrinos from supernovae bursts and search for new physics using increasingly precise measurement of coherent elastic neutrino scattering. Higher-energy interactions involve a variety of reaction mechanisms including quasi-elastic scattering, resonance production, and deep inelastic scattering that must all be included to reliably predict cross sections for energies relevant to DUNE and other accelerator neutrino experiments. This white paper discusses the theoretical status, challenges, required resources, and path forward for achieving precise predictions of neutrino-nucleus scattering and emphasizes the need for a coordinated theoretical effort involved lattice QCD, nuclear effective theories, phenomenological models of the transition region, and event generators.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2022; v1 submitted 16 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Probing uncertainties of nuclear structure corrections in light muonic atoms
Authors:
Oscar Javier Hernandez,
Chen Ji,
Sonia Bacca,
Nir Barnea
Abstract:
Recent calculations of nuclear structure corrections to the Lamb shift in light muonic atoms are based on an expansion in a parameter eta, where only terms up to second order are retained. The parameter eta can be shown to be proportional to the square root of the muon/proton mass ratio, so that it is small and the expansion is expected to converge. However, practical implementations show that the…
▽ More
Recent calculations of nuclear structure corrections to the Lamb shift in light muonic atoms are based on an expansion in a parameter eta, where only terms up to second order are retained. The parameter eta can be shown to be proportional to the square root of the muon/proton mass ratio, so that it is small and the expansion is expected to converge. However, practical implementations show that the eta convergence may be slower than expected. In this work we probe the uncertainties due to this expansion using a different formalism, which is based on a multipole expansion of the longitudinal and transverse response functions and was first introduced by Leidemann and Rosenfelder. We refer to this alternative expansion as the eta-less formalism. We generalize this formalism to account for the cancellation of elastic terms such as the third Zemach moment (or Friar moment) and embed it in a computationally efficient framework. We implement and test this approach in the case of muonic deuterium. The comparison of results in the point nucleon limit for both methods achieve sub-percent agreement. When nucleon form factors are introduced we find a 4% and 2% difference in the third Zemach moment and nuclear polarizability, respectively, compared to the eta-less expansion, indicating that the nucleon form factor approximations should be improved. However, we find that the sum of these terms removes this dependence and the uncertainty due to the eta-expansion and the related second-order approximation in the nucleon form factors amounts only to 0.2% and thus is fully justified in muonic deuterium. This computationally efficient framework paves the way to further studies in light muonic systems with more than two nucleons, where controlling and reducing uncertainties in nuclear structure corrections is key to the experimental efforts of the CREMA collaboration.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Ab initio calculation of nuclear structure corrections in muonic atoms
Authors:
Chen Ji,
Sonia Bacca,
Nir Barnea,
Oscar Javier Hernandez,
Nir Nevo-Dinur
Abstract:
The measurement of the Lamb shift in muonic hydrogen and the subsequent emergence of the proton-radius puzzle have motivated an experimental campaign devoted to measuring the Lamb shift in other light muonic atoms, such as muonic deuterium and helium. For these systems it has been shown that two-photon exchange nuclear structure corrections are the largest source of uncertainty and consequently th…
▽ More
The measurement of the Lamb shift in muonic hydrogen and the subsequent emergence of the proton-radius puzzle have motivated an experimental campaign devoted to measuring the Lamb shift in other light muonic atoms, such as muonic deuterium and helium. For these systems it has been shown that two-photon exchange nuclear structure corrections are the largest source of uncertainty and consequently the bottleneck for exploiting the experimental precision to extract the nuclear charge radius. Utilizing techniques and methods developed to study electromagnetic reactions in light nuclei, recent calculations of nuclear structure corrections to the muonic Lamb shift have reached unprecedented precision, reducing the uncertainty with respect to previous estimates by a factor of 5 in certain cases. These results will be useful for shedding light on the nature of the proton-radius puzzle and other open questions pertaining to it. Here, we review and update calculations for muonic deuterium and tritium atoms, and for muonic helium-3 and helium-4 ions. We present a thorough derivation of the formalism and discuss the results in relation to other approaches where available. We also describe how to assess theoretical uncertainties, for which the language of chiral effective field theory furnishes a systematic approach that could be further exploited in the future.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Understanding the proton radius puzzle: Nuclear structure effects in light muonic atoms
Authors:
Chen Ji,
Oscar Javier Hernandez,
Nir Nevo Dinur,
Sonia Bacca,
Nir Barnea
Abstract:
We present calculations of nuclear structure effects to the Lamb shift in light muonic atoms. We adopt a modern ab-initio approach by combining state-of-the-art nuclear potentials with the hyperspherical harmonics method. Our calculations are instrumental to the determination of nuclear charge radii in the Lamb shift measurements, which will shed light on the proton radius puzzle.
We present calculations of nuclear structure effects to the Lamb shift in light muonic atoms. We adopt a modern ab-initio approach by combining state-of-the-art nuclear potentials with the hyperspherical harmonics method. Our calculations are instrumental to the determination of nuclear charge radii in the Lamb shift measurements, which will shed light on the proton radius puzzle.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2015;
originally announced September 2015.
-
Improved estimates of the nuclear structure corrections in $μ$D
Authors:
Oscar Javier Hernandez,
Chen Ji,
Sonia Bacca,
Nir Nevo Dinur,
Nir Barnea
Abstract:
We calculate the nuclear structure corrections to the Lamb shift in muonic deuterium by using state-of-the-art nucleon-nucleon potentials derived from chiral effective field theory. Our calculations complement previous theoretical work obtained from phenomenological potentials and the zero range approximation. The study of the chiral convergence order-by-order and the dependence on cutoff variatio…
▽ More
We calculate the nuclear structure corrections to the Lamb shift in muonic deuterium by using state-of-the-art nucleon-nucleon potentials derived from chiral effective field theory. Our calculations complement previous theoretical work obtained from phenomenological potentials and the zero range approximation. The study of the chiral convergence order-by-order and the dependence on cutoff variations allows us to improve the estimates on the nuclear structure corrections and the theoretical uncertainty coming from nuclear potentials. This will enter the determination of the nuclear radius from ongoing muonic deuterium experiments at PSI.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2014; v1 submitted 19 June, 2014;
originally announced June 2014.
-
An efficient method for evaluating energy-dependent sum rules
Authors:
Nir Nevo Dinur,
Chen Ji,
Sonia Bacca,
Nir Barnea
Abstract:
Energy-dependent sum rules are useful tools in many fields of physics. In nuclear physics, they typically involve an integration of the response function over the nuclear spectrum with a weight function composed of integer powers of the energy. More complicated weight functions are also encountered, e.g., in nuclear polarization corrections of atomic spectra. Using the Lorentz integral transform m…
▽ More
Energy-dependent sum rules are useful tools in many fields of physics. In nuclear physics, they typically involve an integration of the response function over the nuclear spectrum with a weight function composed of integer powers of the energy. More complicated weight functions are also encountered, e.g., in nuclear polarization corrections of atomic spectra. Using the Lorentz integral transform method and the Lanczos algorithm, we derive a computationally efficient technique for evaluating such sum rules that avoids the explicit calculation of both the continuum states and the response function itself. Our numerical results for electric dipole sum rules of the Helium-4 nucleus with various energy-dependent weights show rapid convergence with respect to the number of Lanczos steps. This demonstrates the usefulness of the method in a variety of electroweak reactions.
△ Less
Submitted 29 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Nuclear polarization effects in muonic atoms
Authors:
Chen Ji,
Nir Nevo Dinur,
Sonia Bacca,
Nir Barnea
Abstract:
We illustrate how nuclear polarization corrections in muonic atoms can be formally connected to inelastic response functions of a nucleus. We first discuss the point-nucleon approximation and then include finite-nucleon-size corrections. As an example, we compare our ab-initio calculation of the third Zemach moment in the muonic Helium-4 ion to previous phenomenological results.
We illustrate how nuclear polarization corrections in muonic atoms can be formally connected to inelastic response functions of a nucleus. We first discuss the point-nucleon approximation and then include finite-nucleon-size corrections. As an example, we compare our ab-initio calculation of the third Zemach moment in the muonic Helium-4 ion to previous phenomenological results.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
Nuclear polarization corrections in the mu-4He+ Lamb shift
Authors:
Chen Ji,
Nir Nevo Dinur,
Sonia Bacca,
Nir Barnea
Abstract:
Stimulated by the proton radius conundrum, measurements of the Lamb shift in various light muonic atoms are planned at PSI. The aim is to extract the rms charge radius with high precision, limited by the uncertainty in the nuclear polarization corrections. We present an ab-initio calculation of the nuclear polarization for mu-4He+ leading to an energy correction in the 2S-2P transitions of…
▽ More
Stimulated by the proton radius conundrum, measurements of the Lamb shift in various light muonic atoms are planned at PSI. The aim is to extract the rms charge radius with high precision, limited by the uncertainty in the nuclear polarization corrections. We present an ab-initio calculation of the nuclear polarization for mu-4He+ leading to an energy correction in the 2S-2P transitions of $δ_{pol}=-2.47$ meV $\pm$ 6%. We use two different state-of-the-art nuclear Hamiltonians and utilize the Lorentz integral transform with hyperspherical harmonics expansion as few-body methods. We take into account the leading multipole contributions, plus Coulomb, relativistic and finite-nucleon-size corrections. Our main source of uncertainty is the nuclear Hamiltonian, which currently limits the attainable accuracy. Our predictions considerably reduce the uncertainty with respect to previous estimates and should timely serve the mu-4He+ experiment planned for 2013.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2013; v1 submitted 24 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
