-
Validation of hydrodynamic and kinetic simulations with a plasma interpenetration ICF hohlraum experiment
Authors:
Steven E. Anderson,
Luis Chacón,
Andrei N. Simakov,
Brian M. Haines,
David S. Montgomery
Abstract:
We report on simulations of counter-propagating laser-produced plasmas in an inertial confinement fusion (ICF) hohlraum surrogate, aiming to replicate observations reported by Le Pape et. al in recent work. The conditions of the colliding plasmas are relevant to ICF hohlraums used for indirect-drive ignition, and are obtained both with and without low-density He-gas fill. We compare experimental d…
▽ More
We report on simulations of counter-propagating laser-produced plasmas in an inertial confinement fusion (ICF) hohlraum surrogate, aiming to replicate observations reported by Le Pape et. al in recent work. The conditions of the colliding plasmas are relevant to ICF hohlraums used for indirect-drive ignition, and are obtained both with and without low-density He-gas fill. We compare experimental diagnostics to outputs from simulations using the 1D-2V Vlasov-Fokker-Planck kinetic code iFP and the xRAGE radiation-hydrodynamics code. These include the inferred radial lineouts of inferred ion number fraction and ion and electron temperatures, as well as the reported experimental Thomson-scattering (TS) spectra (compared via synthetic TS diagnostics). We observe that 1D kinetic simulations capture the plasma states reported in the experimental diagnostics quite well. Counter-intuitively, the kinetic simulations capture the gas-fill experiment (expected to be more `hydro-like') better than the vacuum experiment, while the reverse is observed for hydrodynamic simulations. This is attributed to the presence of non-trivial multi-dimensional hydrodynamic effects which are more dominant in the vacuum experiment. These effects are somewhat inhibited in the gas-fill experiment, permitting quasi-1D kinetic plasma transport to play more of a role in producing plasma interpenetration. Differences between the effects of Maxwellian vs. non-Maxwellian (`full f') synthetic TS diagnostics are investigated for the kinetic simulations. We find non-Maxwellian TS spectra differ non-trivially from Maxwellian spectra, which suggests caution may be warranted when applying Maxwellian TS models to infer plasma conditions via backward modeling when kinetic effects may be present.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Radiation and Heat Transport in Divergent Shock-Bubble Interactions
Authors:
Kelin Kurzer-Ogul,
Brian M. Haines,
David S. Montgomery,
Silvia Pandolfi,
Joshua P. Sauppe,
Andrew F. T. Leong,
Daniel Hodge,
Pawel M. Kozlowski,
Stefano Marchesini,
Eric Cunningham,
Eric Galtier,
Dimitri Khaghani,
Hae Ja Lee,
Bob Nagler,
Richard L. Sandberg,
Arianna E. Gleason,
Hussein Aluie,
Jessica K. Shang
Abstract:
Shock-bubble interactions (SBI) are important across a wide range of physical systems. In inertial confinement fusion, interactions between laser-driven shocks and micro-voids in both ablators and foam targets generate instabilities that are a major obstacle in achieving ignition. Experiments imaging the collapse of such voids at high energy densities (HED) are constrained by spatial and temporal…
▽ More
Shock-bubble interactions (SBI) are important across a wide range of physical systems. In inertial confinement fusion, interactions between laser-driven shocks and micro-voids in both ablators and foam targets generate instabilities that are a major obstacle in achieving ignition. Experiments imaging the collapse of such voids at high energy densities (HED) are constrained by spatial and temporal resolution, making simulations a vital tool in understanding these systems. In this study, we benchmark several radiation and thermal transport models in the xRAGE hydrodynamic code against experimental images of a collapsing mesoscale void during the passage of a 300 GPa shock. We also quantitatively examine the role of transport physics in the evolution of the SBI. This allows us to understand the dynamics of the interaction at timescales shorter than experimental imaging framerates. We find that all radiation models examined reproduce empirical shock velocities within experimental error. Radiation transport is found to reduce shock pressures by providing an additional energy pathway in the ablation region, but this effect is small ($\sim$1\% of total shock pressure). Employing a flux-limited Spitzer model for heat conduction, we find that flux limiters between 0.03 and 0.10 produce agreement with experimental velocities, suggesting that the system is well-within the Spitzer regime. Higher heat conduction is found to lower temperatures in the ablated plasma and to prevent secondary shocks at the ablation front, resulting in weaker primary shocks. Finally, we confirm that the SBI-driven instabilities observed in the HED regime are baroclinically driven, as in the low energy case.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
DT fusion through the $^5$He $3/2+$ "Bretscher state" accounts for $\ge 25\%$ of our existence via nucleosynthesis and for the possibility of fusion energy
Authors:
Mark B. Chadwick,
Mark W. Paris,
Brian M. Haines
Abstract:
In big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN), the deuterium-tritium (DT) fusion reaction, D(T,n)$α$, enhanced by the 3/2$^+$ resonance, is responsible for 99% of primordial $^4$He. This has been known for decades and has been well documented in the scientific literature. However, following the tradition adopted by authors of learned articles, it was stated in a matter-of-fact manner and not emphasized; for m…
▽ More
In big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN), the deuterium-tritium (DT) fusion reaction, D(T,n)$α$, enhanced by the 3/2$^+$ resonance, is responsible for 99% of primordial $^4$He. This has been known for decades and has been well documented in the scientific literature. However, following the tradition adopted by authors of learned articles, it was stated in a matter-of-fact manner and not emphasized; for most people, it has remained unknown. This helium became a source for the subsequent creation of $\geq$25% of the carbon and other heavier elements and, thus, a substantial fraction of our human bodies. (To be more precise than $\geq$25% will require future simulation studies on stellar nucleosynthesis.)
Also, without this resonance, controlled fusion energy would be beyond reach. For example, for inertial confinement fusion (ICF), laser energy delivery for the National Ignition Facility (NIF) would have to be approximately 70 times larger for ignition.
Because the resonance enhances the DT fusion cross section a hundredfold, we propose that the 3/2$^+$ $^5$He excited state be referred to as the "Bretscher state" in honor of the Manhattan Project scientist who discovered it, in analogy with the well-known 7.6 MeV "Hoyle state" in $^{12}$C that allows for the resonant 3$α$ formation.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2023; v1 submitted 1 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Infuence of mass ablation on ignition and burn propagation in layered fusion capsules
Authors:
W. Daughton,
B. J. Albright,
S. M. Finnegan,
Brian M. Haines,
J. L. Kline,
J. P. Sauppe,
J. M. Smidt
Abstract:
After decades of research, recent laser-driven inertial fusion experiments have demonstrated rapid progress toward achieving thermonuclear ignition using capsule designs with cryogenic fuel layers. The ignition physics for these layered capsules involves a complex interplay between the dynamically forming hot spot and the dense surrounding fuel. Using analytic theory and numerical simulations, we…
▽ More
After decades of research, recent laser-driven inertial fusion experiments have demonstrated rapid progress toward achieving thermonuclear ignition using capsule designs with cryogenic fuel layers. The ignition physics for these layered capsules involves a complex interplay between the dynamically forming hot spot and the dense surrounding fuel. Using analytic theory and numerical simulations, we demonstrate that the mass ablation rate into the hot spot depends sensitively upon the temperature of the dense fuel, resulting in ablative inflows up to ~4x faster than previous estimates. This produces an enthalpy flux into the hot spot that plays a critical role in controlling the hot spot temperature, the ignition threshold, and the subsequent burn propagation. The net influence of mass ablation on the ignition threshold is regulated by a dimensionless parameter that depends upon the temperature of the dense fuel. As a consequence, the ignition threshold is sensitive to any mechanism that heats the dense fuel, such as neutrons or radiation emitted from the hot spot. These predictions are confirmed using radiation hydrodynamic simulations for a series of capsules near ignition conditions. This analysis may have relevance for understanding the variable performance of recent experiments and for guiding new capsule designs toward higher fusion yields.
△ Less
Submitted 3 January, 2023; v1 submitted 30 June, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Magnetization around mix jets entering inertial confinement fusion fuel
Authors:
James D. Sadler,
Hui Li,
Brian M. Haines
Abstract:
Engineering features are known to cause jets of ablator material to enter the fuel hot-spot in inertial confinement fusion implosions. The Biermann battery mechanism wraps them in self-generated magnetic field. We show that higher-Z jets have an additional thermoelectric magnetic source term that is not present for hydrogen jets, verified here through a kinetic simulation. It has similar magnitude…
▽ More
Engineering features are known to cause jets of ablator material to enter the fuel hot-spot in inertial confinement fusion implosions. The Biermann battery mechanism wraps them in self-generated magnetic field. We show that higher-Z jets have an additional thermoelectric magnetic source term that is not present for hydrogen jets, verified here through a kinetic simulation. It has similar magnitude to the Biermann term. We then include this in an extended magneto-hydrodynamics approach to post-process an xRAGE radiation-hydrodynamic implosion simulation. The simulation includes an accurate model for the capsule fill tube, producing a dense carbon jet that becomes wrapped in a 4000T magnetic field. A simple spherical carbon mix model shows that this insulates the electron heat conduction enough to cause contraction of the jet to an optically thick equilibrium. The denser magnetized jet hydrodynamics could change its core penetration and therefore the final mix mass, which is known to be well correlated with fusion yield degradation. Fully exploring this will require self-consistent magneto-hydrodynamic simulations. Experimental signatures of this self-magnetization may emerge in the high energy neutron spectrum.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Effective Viscosity of Dilute Bacterial Suspensions: A Two-Dimensional Model
Authors:
Brian M. Haines,
Igor S. Aranson,
Leonid Berlyand,
Dmitry A. Karpeev
Abstract:
Suspensions of self-propelled particles are studied in the framework of two-dimensional (2D) Stokesean hydrodynamics. A formula is obtained for the effective viscosity of such suspensions in the limit of small concentrations. This formula includes the two terms that are found in the 2D version of Einstein's classical result for passive suspensions. To this, the main result of the paper is added,…
▽ More
Suspensions of self-propelled particles are studied in the framework of two-dimensional (2D) Stokesean hydrodynamics. A formula is obtained for the effective viscosity of such suspensions in the limit of small concentrations. This formula includes the two terms that are found in the 2D version of Einstein's classical result for passive suspensions. To this, the main result of the paper is added, an additional term due to self-propulsion which depends on the physical and geometric properties of the active suspension. This term explains the experimental observation of a decrease in effective viscosity in active suspensions.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2008;
originally announced April 2008.
