-
Lithium-ion battery degradation: using degradation mode analysis to validate lifetime prediction modelling
Authors:
Ruihe Li,
Niall D. Kirkaldy,
Fabian Oehler,
Monica Marinescu,
Gregory J. Offer,
Simon E. J. O'Kane
Abstract:
Predicting lithium-ion battery lifetime is one of the greatest unsolved problems in battery research right now. Recent years have witnessed a surge in lifetime prediction papers using physics-based, empirical, or data-driven models, most of which have been validated against the remaining capacity (capacity fade) and sometimes resistance (power fade). However, there are many different combinations…
▽ More
Predicting lithium-ion battery lifetime is one of the greatest unsolved problems in battery research right now. Recent years have witnessed a surge in lifetime prediction papers using physics-based, empirical, or data-driven models, most of which have been validated against the remaining capacity (capacity fade) and sometimes resistance (power fade). However, there are many different combinations of degradation mechanisms in lithium-ion batteries that can result in the same patterns of capacity and power fade, making it impossible to find a unique validated solution. Experimentally, degradation mode analysis involving measuring the loss of lithium inventory, loss of active material at both electrodes, and electrode drift/slippage has emerged as a state-of-the-art requirement for cell degradation studies. In this paper we coupled five degradation mechanisms together for the first time. We also showed how three models with different levels of complexity can all fit the remaining capacity and resistance well, but only the model with five coupled degradation mechanisms could also fit the degradation modes at all temperatures. This work proves that validating only against capacity and power fade is no longer sufficient, and state-of-the-art experimental and modelling degradation studies should include degradation mode analysis for validation in the future.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2024; v1 submitted 9 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Lithium-ion battery performance model including solvent segregation effects
Authors:
Ruihe Li,
Simon O'Kane,
Andrew Wang,
Taeho Jung,
Niall Kirkaldy,
Monica Marinescu,
Charles W. Monroe,
Gregory J. Offer
Abstract:
A model of a lithium-ion battery containing a cosolvent electrolyte is developed and implemented within the open-source PyBaMM platform. Lithium-ion electrolytes are essential to battery operation and normally contain at least two solvents to satisfy performance requirements. The widely used Doyle-Fuller-Newman battery model assumes that the electrolyte comprises a salt dissolved in a single effec…
▽ More
A model of a lithium-ion battery containing a cosolvent electrolyte is developed and implemented within the open-source PyBaMM platform. Lithium-ion electrolytes are essential to battery operation and normally contain at least two solvents to satisfy performance requirements. The widely used Doyle-Fuller-Newman battery model assumes that the electrolyte comprises a salt dissolved in a single effective solvent, however. This single-solvent approximation has been disproved experimentally and may hinder accurate battery modelling. Here, we present a two-solvent model that resolves the transport of ethylene carbonate (EC) and lithium salt in a background linear carbonate. EC concentration polarization opposes that of Li+ during cycling, affecting local electrolyte properties and cell-level overpotentials. Concentration gradients of Li+ can be affected by cross-diffusion, whereby EC gradients enhance or impede salt flux. A rationally parametrized model that includes EC transport predicts 6% more power loss at 4.5C discharge and ~0.32% more capacity loss after a thousand 1C cycles than its single-solvent equivalent. This work provides a tool to model more transport behaviour in the electrolyte that may affect degradation and enables the transfer of microscopic knowledge about solvation structure-dependent performance to the macroscale.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
A million cycles in a day: enabling high-throughput computing of lithium-ion battery degradation with physics-based models
Authors:
Ruihe Li,
Simon O'Kane,
Jianbo Huang,
Monica Marinescu,
Gregory J Offer
Abstract:
High-throughput computing (HTC) is a pivotal asset in many scientific fields, such as biology, material science and machine learning. Applying HTC to the complex physics-based degradation models of lithium-ion batteries enables efficient parameter identification and sensitivity analysis, which further leads to optimal battery design and operating conditions. However, running physics-based degradat…
▽ More
High-throughput computing (HTC) is a pivotal asset in many scientific fields, such as biology, material science and machine learning. Applying HTC to the complex physics-based degradation models of lithium-ion batteries enables efficient parameter identification and sensitivity analysis, which further leads to optimal battery design and operating conditions. However, running physics-based degradation models comes with pitfalls, as solvers can crash or get stuck in infinite loops due to numerical errors. Also, how to pipeline HTC for degradation models has seldom been discussed. To fill these gaps, we have created ParaSweeper, a Python script tailored for HTC, designed to streamline parameter sweeping by running as many ageing simulations as computational resources allow, each with different parameters. We have demonstrated the capability of ParaSweeper based on the open-source platform PyBaMM, and the approach can also apply to other numerical models which solve partial differential equations. ParaSweeper not only manages common solver errors, but also integrates various methods to accelerate the simulation. Using a high-performance computing platform, ParaSweeper can run millions of charge/discharge cycles within one day. ParaSweeper stands to benefit both academic researchers, through expedited model exploration, and industry professionals, by enabling rapid lifetime design, ultimately contributing to the prolonged lifetime of batteries.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2024; v1 submitted 8 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
A electrochemical-electro-thermal coupled computational framework to simulate the performance of Li-ion batteries at cell-level: Analysis on the thermal effects
Authors:
Han Yuan,
Shen Li,
Tao Zhu,
Simon O'Kane,
Carlos Garcia,
Gregory Offer,
Monica Marinescu
Abstract:
Accurately predicting the performance of Li-ion batteries is of great importance for the global electric vehicle and energy storage industries. In this research, we propose a computational framework that integrates the electrochemical DFN model, ECM parametrisation, 3D distributed ECN model to simulate the performance of Li-ion cells. Using Kokam 7.5 Ah pouch cell (ModelSLPB75106100) as an example…
▽ More
Accurately predicting the performance of Li-ion batteries is of great importance for the global electric vehicle and energy storage industries. In this research, we propose a computational framework that integrates the electrochemical DFN model, ECM parametrisation, 3D distributed ECN model to simulate the performance of Li-ion cells. Using Kokam 7.5 Ah pouch cell (ModelSLPB75106100) as an example, we demonstrate the three-step workflow of the framework that consists of the characterisation data acquisition, parametrisation with BatPar, and 3D ECN-simulation with PyECN. With this framework, we simulate constant current discharge experiments in the literature and compare the simulations with DFN model that coupled with a classical lumped thermal model. With a better consideration of thermal process and its coupling effects with electrochemistry, the computational model outperforms DFN model, especially at low-temperature and/or high C-rate scenarios. The largest predicting error of the framework at 3 C-rate &Tam = 25oC and at 1 C-rate &Tam = 0 oC is approximately 1/3 of that for DFN model. At 3 C-rate &Tam = 5oC, the difference between these two can rise to 377 mV. Further analysis reveals that the lumped DFN + thermal model is unsuitable to simulate the performance of Li-ion batteries at a scale larger than cell level, due to significant internal heat generation and large Biot number. By integrating DFN and 3D-distributed ECN together, this proposed computational framework is electrochemical-electro-thermal coupled and can be used as a toolset by cell manufacturers and pack designers to predict, analyse, and optimise the performance of Li-based energy storage systems.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Lithium-ion battery degradation: how to model it
Authors:
Simon E. J. O'Kane,
Weilong Ai,
Ganesh Madabattula,
Diego Alonso Alvarez,
Robert Timms,
Valentin Sulzer,
Jacqueline Sophie Edge,
Billy Wu,
Gregory J. Offer,
Monica Marinescu
Abstract:
Predicting lithium-ion battery degradation is worth billions to the global automotive, aviation and energy storage industries, to improve performance and safety and reduce warranty liabilities. However, very few published models of battery degradation explicitly consider the interactions between more than two degradation mechanisms, and none do so within a single electrode. In this paper, the firs…
▽ More
Predicting lithium-ion battery degradation is worth billions to the global automotive, aviation and energy storage industries, to improve performance and safety and reduce warranty liabilities. However, very few published models of battery degradation explicitly consider the interactions between more than two degradation mechanisms, and none do so within a single electrode. In this paper, the first published attempt to directly couple more than two degradation mechanisms in the negative electrode is reported. The results are used to map different pathways through the complicated path dependent and non-linear degradation space. Four degradation mechanisms are coupled in PyBaMM, an open source modelling environment uniquely developed to allow new physics to be implemented and explored quickly and easily. Crucially it is possible to see 'inside' the model and observe the consequences of the different patterns of degradation, such as loss of lithium inventory and loss of active material. For the same cell, five different pathways that can result in end-of-life have already been found, depending on how the cell is used. Such information would enable a product designer to either extend life or predict life based upon the usage pattern. However, parameterization of the degradation models remains as a major challenge, and requires the attention of the international battery community.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2022; v1 submitted 3 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Parameterising continuum level Li-ion battery models & the LiionDB database
Authors:
A. A. Wang,
S. E. J. O'Kane,
F. Brosa Planella,
J. Le Houx,
K. O'Regan,
M. Zyskin,
J. Edge,
C. W. Monroe,
S. J. Cooper,
D. A. Howey,
E. Kendrick,
J. M. Foster
Abstract:
The Doyle-Fuller-Newman framework is the most popular physics-based continuum-level description of the chemical and dynamical internal processes within operating lithium-ion-battery cells. With sufficient flexibility to model a wide range of battery designs and chemistries, the framework provides an effective balance between detail, needed to capture key microscopic mechanisms, and simplicity, nee…
▽ More
The Doyle-Fuller-Newman framework is the most popular physics-based continuum-level description of the chemical and dynamical internal processes within operating lithium-ion-battery cells. With sufficient flexibility to model a wide range of battery designs and chemistries, the framework provides an effective balance between detail, needed to capture key microscopic mechanisms, and simplicity, needed to solve the governing equations at a relatively modest computational expense. Nevertheless, implementation requires values of numerous model parameters, whose ranges of applicability, estimation, and validation pose challenges. This article provides a critical review of the methods to measure or infer parameters for use within the isothermal DFN framework, discusses their advantages or disadvantages, and clarifies limitations attached to their practical application. Accompanying this discussion we provide a searchable database, available at www.liiondb.com, which aggregates many parameters and state functions for the standard Doyle-Fuller-Newman model that have been reported in the literature.
△ Less
Submitted 19 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
DandeLiion v1: An extremely fast solver for the Newman model of lithium-ion battery (dis)charge
Authors:
Ivan Korotkin,
Smita Sahu,
Simon O'Kane,
Giles Richardson,
Jamie M. Foster
Abstract:
DandeLiion (available at dandeliion.com) is a robust and extremely fast solver for the Doyle Fuller Newman (DFN) model, the standard electrochemical model for (dis)charge of a planar lithium-ion cell. DandeLiion conserves lithium, uses a second order spatial discretisation method (enabling accurate computations using relatively coarse discretisations) and is many times faster than its competitors.…
▽ More
DandeLiion (available at dandeliion.com) is a robust and extremely fast solver for the Doyle Fuller Newman (DFN) model, the standard electrochemical model for (dis)charge of a planar lithium-ion cell. DandeLiion conserves lithium, uses a second order spatial discretisation method (enabling accurate computations using relatively coarse discretisations) and is many times faster than its competitors. The code can be used `in the cloud' and does not require installation before use. The difference in compute time between DandeLiion and its commercial counterparts is roughly a factor of 100 for the moderately-sized test case of the discharge of a single cell. Its linear scaling property means that the disparity in performance is even more pronounced for bigger systems, making it particularly suitable for applications involving multiple coupled cells. The model is characterised by a number of phenomenological parameters and functions, which may either be provided by the user or chosen from DandeLiion's library. This library contains data for the most commonly used electrolyte (LiPF6) and a number of common active material chemistries including graphite, lithium iron phosphate (LFP), nickel cobalt aluminium (NCA), and a variant of nickel cobalt manganese (NMC).
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Systematic derivation of a surface polarization model for planar perovskite solar cells
Authors:
N. E. Courtier,
J. M. Foster,
S. E. J. O'Kane,
A. B. Walker,
G. Richardson
Abstract:
Increasing evidence suggests that the presence of mobile ions in perovskite solar cells can cause a current-voltage curve hysteresis. Steady state and transient current-voltage characteristics of a planar metal halide CH$_3$NH$_3$PbI$_3$ perovskite solar cell are analysed with a drift-diffusion model that accounts for both charge transport and ion vacancy motion. The high ion vacancy density withi…
▽ More
Increasing evidence suggests that the presence of mobile ions in perovskite solar cells can cause a current-voltage curve hysteresis. Steady state and transient current-voltage characteristics of a planar metal halide CH$_3$NH$_3$PbI$_3$ perovskite solar cell are analysed with a drift-diffusion model that accounts for both charge transport and ion vacancy motion. The high ion vacancy density within the perovskite layer gives rise to narrow Debye layers (typical width $\sim$2nm), adjacent to the interfaces with the transport layers, over which large drops in the electric potential occur and in which significant charge is stored. Large disparities between (I) the width of the Debye layers and that of the perovskite layer ($\sim$600nm) and (II) the ion vacancy density and the charge carrier densities motivate an asymptotic approach to solving the model, while the stiffness of the equations renders standard solution methods unreliable. We derive a simplified surface polarisation model in which the slow ion dynamic are replaced by interfacial (nonlinear) capacitances at the perovskite interfaces. Favourable comparison is made between the results of the asymptotic approach and numerical solutions for a realistic cell over a wide range of operating conditions of practical interest.
△ Less
Submitted 30 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.