-
Precision is not limited by the second law of thermodynamics
Authors:
Florian Meier,
Yuri Minoguchi,
Simon Sundelin,
Tony J. G. Apollaro,
Paul Erker,
Simone Gasparinetti,
Marcus Huber
Abstract:
Physical devices operating out of equilibrium are inherently affected by thermal fluctuations, limiting their operational precision. This issue is pronounced at microscopic and especially quantum scales and can only be mitigated by incurring additional entropy dissipation. Understanding this constraint is crucial for both fundamental physics and technological design. For instance, clocks are inher…
▽ More
Physical devices operating out of equilibrium are inherently affected by thermal fluctuations, limiting their operational precision. This issue is pronounced at microscopic and especially quantum scales and can only be mitigated by incurring additional entropy dissipation. Understanding this constraint is crucial for both fundamental physics and technological design. For instance, clocks are inherently governed by the second law of thermodynamics and need a thermodynamic flux towards equilibrium to measure time, which results in a minimum entropy dissipation per clock tick. Classical and quantum models and experiments often show a linear relationship between precision and dissipation, but the ultimate bounds on this relationship are unknown. Our theoretical discovery presents an extensible quantum many-body system that achieves clock precision scaling exponentially with entropy dissipation. This finding demonstrates that coherent quantum dynamics can surpass the traditional thermodynamic precision limits, potentially guiding the development of future high-precision, low-dissipation quantum devices.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Autonomous Quantum Processing Unit: What does it take to construct a self-contained model for quantum computation?
Authors:
Florian Meier,
Marcus Huber,
Paul Erker,
Jake Xuereb
Abstract:
Computation is an input-output process, where a program encoding a problem to be solved is inserted into a machine that outputs a solution. Whilst a formalism for quantum Turing machines which lifts this input-output feature into the quantum domain has been developed, this is not how quantum computation is physically conceived. Usually, such a quantum computation is enacted by the manipulation of…
▽ More
Computation is an input-output process, where a program encoding a problem to be solved is inserted into a machine that outputs a solution. Whilst a formalism for quantum Turing machines which lifts this input-output feature into the quantum domain has been developed, this is not how quantum computation is physically conceived. Usually, such a quantum computation is enacted by the manipulation of macroscopic control interactions according to a program executed by a classical system. To understand the fundamental limits of computation, especially in relation to the resources required, it is pivotal to work with a fully self-contained description of a quantum computation where computational and thermodynamic resources are not be obscured by the classical control. To this end, we answer the question; "Can we build a physical model for quantum computation that is fully autonomous?", i.e., where the program to be executed as well as the control are both quantum. We do so by developing a framework that we dub the autonomous Quantum Processing Unit (aQPU). This machine, consisting of a timekeeping mechanism, instruction register and computational system allows an agent to input their problem and receive the solution as an output, autonomously. Using the theory of open quantum systems and results from the field of quantum clocks we are able to use the aQPU as a formalism to investigate relationships between the thermodynamics, complexity, speed and fidelity of a desired quantum computation.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Quantum Coding with Finite Thermodynamic Resources
Authors:
Jake Xuereb,
Tiago Debarba,
Marcus Huber,
Paul Erker
Abstract:
Quantum direct coding or Schumacher compression generalised the ideas of Shannon theory, gave an operational meaning to the von Neumann entropy and established the term qubit. But remembering that information processing is carried out by physical processes prompts one to wonder what thermodynamic resources are required to compress quantum information and how they constrain one's ability to perform…
▽ More
Quantum direct coding or Schumacher compression generalised the ideas of Shannon theory, gave an operational meaning to the von Neumann entropy and established the term qubit. But remembering that information processing is carried out by physical processes prompts one to wonder what thermodynamic resources are required to compress quantum information and how they constrain one's ability to perform this task. That is, if Alice and Bob only have access to thermal quantum states and clocks with finite accuracy, how well can they measure, encode and decode pure quantum state messages? In this work we examine these questions by modelling Alice's typical measurement as a unitary involving a measurement probe, investigating imperfect timekeeping on encoding and decoding and considering the role of temperature in Bob's appended qubits. In doing so, we derive fidelity bounds for this protocol involving the correlations Alice can form with their measurement probe, the variance of the clock's ticks and the temperature of Bob's qubits. Finally, we give an insight into the entropy produced by these two agents throughout the compression protocol by relating the resources they use to a quantum thermodynamic cooling protocol.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2024; v1 submitted 24 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Experimental high-dimensional entanglement certification and quantum steering with time-energy measurements
Authors:
Kai-Chi Chang,
Murat Can Sarihan,
Xiang Cheng,
Paul Erker,
Andrew Mueller,
Maria Spiropulu,
Matthew D. Shaw,
Boris Korzh,
Marcus Huber,
Chee Wei Wong
Abstract:
High-dimensional entanglement provides unique ways of transcending the limitations of current approaches in quantum information processing, quantum communications based on qubits. The generation of time-frequency qudit states offer significantly increased quantum capacities while keeping the number of photons constant, but pose significant challenges regarding the possible measurements for certifi…
▽ More
High-dimensional entanglement provides unique ways of transcending the limitations of current approaches in quantum information processing, quantum communications based on qubits. The generation of time-frequency qudit states offer significantly increased quantum capacities while keeping the number of photons constant, but pose significant challenges regarding the possible measurements for certification of entanglement. Here, we develop a new scheme and experimentally demonstrate the certification of 24-dimensional entanglement and a 9-dimensional quantum steering. We then subject our photon-pairs to dispersion conditions equivalent to the transmission through 600-km of fiber and still certify 21-dimensional entanglement. Furthermore, we use a steering inequality to prove 7-dimensional entanglement in a semi-device independent manner, proving that large chromatic dispersion is not an obstacle in distributing and certifying high-dimensional entanglement and quantum steering. Our highly scalable scheme is based on commercial telecommunication optical fiber components and recently developed low-jitter high-efficiency single-photon detectors, thus opening new pathways towards advanced large-scale quantum information processing and high-performance, noise-tolerant quantum communications with time-energy measurements
△ Less
Submitted 31 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Useful autonomous quantum machines
Authors:
José Antonio Marín Guzmán,
Paul Erker,
Simone Gasparinetti,
Marcus Huber,
Nicole Yunger Halpern
Abstract:
Controlled quantum machines have matured significantly. A natural next step is to increasingly grant them autonomy, freeing them from time-dependent external control. For example, autonomy could pare down the classical control wires that heat and decohere quantum circuits; and an autonomous quantum refrigerator recently reset superconducting qubits to near their ground states, as is necessary befo…
▽ More
Controlled quantum machines have matured significantly. A natural next step is to increasingly grant them autonomy, freeing them from time-dependent external control. For example, autonomy could pare down the classical control wires that heat and decohere quantum circuits; and an autonomous quantum refrigerator recently reset superconducting qubits to near their ground states, as is necessary before a computation. Which fundamental conditions are necessary for realizing useful autonomous quantum machines? Inspired by recent quantum thermodynamics and chemistry, we posit conditions analogous to DiVincenzo's criteria for quantum computing. Furthermore, we illustrate the criteria with multiple autonomous quantum machines (refrigerators, circuits, clocks, etc.) and multiple candidate platforms (neutral atoms, molecules, superconducting qubits, etc.). Our criteria are intended to foment and guide the development of useful autonomous quantum machines.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2024; v1 submitted 17 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
The Impact of Imperfect Timekeeping on Quantum Control
Authors:
Jake Xuereb,
Florian Meier,
Paul Erker,
Mark T. Mitchison,
Marcus Huber
Abstract:
In order to unitarily evolve a quantum system, an agent requires knowledge of time, a parameter which no physical clock can ever perfectly characterise. In this letter, we study how limitations on acquiring knowledge of time impact controlled quantum operations in different paradigms. We show that the quality of timekeeping an agent has access to limits the circuit complexity they are able to achi…
▽ More
In order to unitarily evolve a quantum system, an agent requires knowledge of time, a parameter which no physical clock can ever perfectly characterise. In this letter, we study how limitations on acquiring knowledge of time impact controlled quantum operations in different paradigms. We show that the quality of timekeeping an agent has access to limits the circuit complexity they are able to achieve within circuit-based quantum computation. We do this by deriving an upper bound on the average gate fidelity achievable under imperfect timekeeping for a general class of random circuits. Another area where quantum control is relevant is quantum thermodynamics. In that context, we show that cooling a qubit can be achieved using a timer of arbitrary quality for control: timekeeping error only impacts the rate of cooling and not the achievable temperature. Our analysis combines techniques from the study of autonomous quantum clocks and the theory of quantum channels to understand the effect of imperfect timekeeping on controlled quantum dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2023; v1 submitted 25 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Fundamental accuracy-resolution trade-off for timekeeping devices
Authors:
Florian Meier,
Emanuel Schwarzhans,
Paul Erker,
Marcus Huber
Abstract:
From a thermodynamic point of view, all clocks are driven by irreversible processes. Additionally, one can use oscillatory systems to temporally modulate the thermodynamic flux towards equilibrium. Focusing on the most elementary thermalization events, this modulation can be thought of as a temporal probability concentration for these events. There are two fundamental factors limiting the performa…
▽ More
From a thermodynamic point of view, all clocks are driven by irreversible processes. Additionally, one can use oscillatory systems to temporally modulate the thermodynamic flux towards equilibrium. Focusing on the most elementary thermalization events, this modulation can be thought of as a temporal probability concentration for these events. There are two fundamental factors limiting the performance of clocks: On the one level, the inevitable drifts of the oscillatory system, which are addressed by finding stable atomic or nuclear transitions that lead to astounding precision of today's clocks. On the other level, there is the intrinsically stochastic nature of the irreversible events upon which the clock's operation is based. This becomes relevant when seeking to maximize a clock's resolution at high accuracy, which is ultimately limited by the number of such stochastic events per reference time unit. We address this essential trade-off between clock accuracy and resolution, proving a universal bound for all clocks whose elementary thermalization events are memoryless.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2023; v1 submitted 12 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Autonomous Temporal Probability Concentration: Clockworks and the Second Law of Thermodynamics
Authors:
Emanuel Schwarzhans,
Maximilian P. E. Lock,
Paul Erker,
Nicolai Friis,
Marcus Huber
Abstract:
According to thermodynamics, the inevitable increase of entropy allows the past to be distinguished from the future. From this perspective, any clock must incorporate an irreversible process that allows this flow of entropy to be tracked. In addition, an integral part of a clock is a clockwork, that is, a system whose purpose is to temporally concentrate the irreversible events that drive this ent…
▽ More
According to thermodynamics, the inevitable increase of entropy allows the past to be distinguished from the future. From this perspective, any clock must incorporate an irreversible process that allows this flow of entropy to be tracked. In addition, an integral part of a clock is a clockwork, that is, a system whose purpose is to temporally concentrate the irreversible events that drive this entropic flow, thereby increasing the accuracy of the resulting clock ticks compared to counting purely random equilibration events. In this article, we formalise the task of autonomous temporal probability concentration as the inherent goal of any clockwork based on thermal gradients. Within this framework, we show that a perfect clockwork can be approximated arbitrarily well by increasing its complexity. Furthermore, we combine such an idealised clockwork model, comprised of many qubits, with an irreversible decay mechanism to showcase the ultimate thermodynamic limits to the measurement of time.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2021; v1 submitted 2 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Measuring the thermodynamic cost of timekeeping
Authors:
A. N. Pearson,
Y. Guryanova,
P. Erker,
E. A. Laird,
G. A. D. Briggs,
M. Huber,
N. Ares
Abstract:
All clocks, in some form or another, use the evolution of nature towards higher entropy states to quantify the passage of time. Due to the statistical nature of the second law and corresponding entropy flows, fluctuations fundamentally limit the performance of any clock. This suggests a deep relation between the increase in entropy and the quality of clock ticks. Indeed, minimal models for autonom…
▽ More
All clocks, in some form or another, use the evolution of nature towards higher entropy states to quantify the passage of time. Due to the statistical nature of the second law and corresponding entropy flows, fluctuations fundamentally limit the performance of any clock. This suggests a deep relation between the increase in entropy and the quality of clock ticks. Indeed, minimal models for autonomous clocks in the quantum realm revealed that a linear relation can be derived, where for a limited regime every bit of entropy linearly increases the accuracy of quantum clocks. But can such a linear relation persist as we move towards a more classical system? We answer this in the affirmative by presenting the first experimental investigation of this thermodynamic relation in a nanoscale clock. We stochastically drive a nanometer-thick membrane and read out its displacement with a radio-frequency cavity, allowing us to identify the ticks of a clock. We show theoretically that the maximum possible accuracy for this classical clock is proportional to the entropy created per tick, similar to the known limit for a weakly coupled quantum clock but with a different proportionality constant. We measure both the accuracy and the entropy. Once non-thermal noise is accounted for, we find that there is a linear relation between accuracy and entropy and that the clock operates within an order of magnitude of the theoretical bound.
△ Less
Submitted 15 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Efficient generation of high-dimensional entanglement through multi-path downconversion
Authors:
Xiao-Min Hu,
Wen-Bo Xing,
Bi-Heng Liu,
Yun-Feng Huang,
Chuan-Feng Li,
Guang-Can Guo,
Paul Erker,
Marcus Huber
Abstract:
High-dimensional entanglement promises to greatly enhance the performance of quantum communication and enable quantum advantages unreachable by qubit entanglement. One of the great challenges, however, is the reliable production, distribution and local certification of high-dimensional sources of entanglement. In this article, we present an optical setup capable of producing quantum states with an…
▽ More
High-dimensional entanglement promises to greatly enhance the performance of quantum communication and enable quantum advantages unreachable by qubit entanglement. One of the great challenges, however, is the reliable production, distribution and local certification of high-dimensional sources of entanglement. In this article, we present an optical setup capable of producing quantum states with an exceptionally high-level of scalability, control and quality, that, together with novel certification techniques, achieve the highest amount of entanglement recorded so far. We showcase entanglement in $32$-spatial dimensions with record fidelity to the maximally entangled state ($F=0.933\pm0.001$) and introduce measurement efficient schemes to certify entanglement of formation ($E_{oF}=3.728\pm0.006$). Combined with the existing multi-core fibre technology, our results will lay a solid foundation for the construction of high-dimensional quantum networks.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Thermodynamically optimal creation of correlations
Authors:
Faraj Bakhshinezhad,
Fabien Clivaz,
Giuseppe Vitagliano,
Paul Erker,
Ali T. Rezakhani,
Marcus Huber,
Nicolai Friis
Abstract:
Correlations lie at the heart of almost all scientific predictions. It is therefore of interest to ask whether there exist general limitations to the amount of correlations that can be created at a finite amount of invested energy. Within quantum thermodynamics such limitations can be derived from first principles. In particular, it can be shown that establishing correlations between initially unc…
▽ More
Correlations lie at the heart of almost all scientific predictions. It is therefore of interest to ask whether there exist general limitations to the amount of correlations that can be created at a finite amount of invested energy. Within quantum thermodynamics such limitations can be derived from first principles. In particular, it can be shown that establishing correlations between initially uncorrelated systems in a thermal background has an energetic cost. This cost, which depends on the system dimension and the details of the energy-level structure, can be bounded from below but whether these bounds are achievable is an open question. Here, we put forward a framework for studying the process of optimally correlating identical (thermal) quantum systems. The framework is based on decompositions into subspaces that each support only states with diagonal (classical) marginals. Using methods from stochastic majorisation theory, we show that the creation of correlations at minimal energy cost is possible for all pairs of three- and four-dimensional quantum systems. For higher dimensions we provide sufficient conditions for the existence of such optimally correlating operations, which we conjecture to exist in all dimensions.
△ Less
Submitted 23 October, 2019; v1 submitted 16 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Measurements in two bases are sufficient for certifying high-dimensional entanglement
Authors:
Jessica Bavaresco,
Natalia Herrera Valencia,
Claude Klöckl,
Matej Pivoluska,
Paul Erker,
Nicolai Friis,
Mehul Malik,
Marcus Huber
Abstract:
High-dimensional encoding of quantum information provides a promising method of transcending current limitations in quantum communication. One of the central challenges in the pursuit of such an approach is the certification of high-dimensional entanglement. In particular, it is desirable to do so without resorting to inefficient full state tomography. Here, we show how carefully constructed measu…
▽ More
High-dimensional encoding of quantum information provides a promising method of transcending current limitations in quantum communication. One of the central challenges in the pursuit of such an approach is the certification of high-dimensional entanglement. In particular, it is desirable to do so without resorting to inefficient full state tomography. Here, we show how carefully constructed measurements in two bases (one of which is not orthonormal) can be used to faithfully and efficiently certify bipartite high-dimensional states and their entanglement for any physical platform. To showcase the practicality of this approach under realistic conditions, we put it to the test for photons entangled in their orbital angular momentum. In our experimental setup, we are able to verify 9-dimensional entanglement for a pair of photons on a 11-dimensional subspace each, at present the highest amount certified without any assumptions on the state.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2019; v1 submitted 21 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Autonomous quantum clocks: does thermodynamics limit our ability to measure time?
Authors:
Paul Erker,
Mark T. Mitchison,
Ralph Silva,
Mischa P. Woods,
Nicolas Brunner,
Marcus Huber
Abstract:
Time remains one of the least well understood concepts in physics, most notably in quantum mechanics. A central goal is to find the fundamental limits of measuring time. One of the main obstacles is the fact that time is not an observable and thus has to be measured indirectly. Here we explore these questions by introducing a model of time measurements that is complete and autonomous. Specifically…
▽ More
Time remains one of the least well understood concepts in physics, most notably in quantum mechanics. A central goal is to find the fundamental limits of measuring time. One of the main obstacles is the fact that time is not an observable and thus has to be measured indirectly. Here we explore these questions by introducing a model of time measurements that is complete and autonomous. Specifically, our autonomous quantum clock consists of a system out of thermal equilibrium --- a prerequisite for any system to function as a clock --- powered by minimal resources, namely two thermal baths at different temperatures. Through a detailed analysis of this specific clock model, we find that the laws of thermodynamics dictate a trade-off between the amount of dissipated heat and the clock's performance in terms of its accuracy and resolution. Our results furthermore imply that a fundamental entropy production is associated with the operation of any autonomous quantum clock, assuming that quantum machines cannot achieve perfect efficiency at finite power. More generally, autonomous clocks provide a natural framework for the exploration of fundamental questions about time in quantum theory and beyond.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2017; v1 submitted 21 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Heisenberg-Weyl Observables: Bloch vectors in phase space
Authors:
Ali Asadian,
Paul Erker,
Marcus Huber,
Claude Klöckl
Abstract:
We introduce a Hermitian generalization of Pauli matrices to higher dimensions which is based on Heisenberg-Weyl operators. The complete set of Heisenberg-Weyl observables allows us to identify a real-valued Bloch vector for an arbitrary density operator in discrete phase space, with a smooth transition to infinite dimensions. Furthermore, we derive bounds on the sum of expectation values of any s…
▽ More
We introduce a Hermitian generalization of Pauli matrices to higher dimensions which is based on Heisenberg-Weyl operators. The complete set of Heisenberg-Weyl observables allows us to identify a real-valued Bloch vector for an arbitrary density operator in discrete phase space, with a smooth transition to infinite dimensions. Furthermore, we derive bounds on the sum of expectation values of any set of anti-commuting observables. Such bounds can be used in entanglement detection and we show that Heisenberg-Weyl observables provide a first non-trivial example beyond the dichotomic case.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2016; v1 submitted 17 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Quantifying high dimensional entanglement with two mutually unbiased bases
Authors:
Paul Erker,
Mario Krenn,
Marcus Huber
Abstract:
We derive a framework for quantifying entanglement in multipartite and high dimensional systems using only correlations in two unbiased bases. We furthermore develop such bounds in cases where the second basis is not characterized beyond being unbiased, thus enabling entanglement quantification with minimal assumptions. Furthermore, we show that it is feasible to experimentally implement our metho…
▽ More
We derive a framework for quantifying entanglement in multipartite and high dimensional systems using only correlations in two unbiased bases. We furthermore develop such bounds in cases where the second basis is not characterized beyond being unbiased, thus enabling entanglement quantification with minimal assumptions. Furthermore, we show that it is feasible to experimentally implement our method with readily available equipment and even conservative estimates of physical parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2017; v1 submitted 16 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
How not to Rényi generalize the Quantum Conditional Mutual Information
Authors:
Paul Erker
Abstract:
We study the relation between the quantum conditional mutual information and the quantum $α$-Rényi divergences. Considering the totally antisymmetric state we show that it is not possible to attain a proper generalization of the quantum conditional mutual information by optimizing the distance in terms of quantum $α$-Rényi divergences over the set of all Markov states. The failure of the approach…
▽ More
We study the relation between the quantum conditional mutual information and the quantum $α$-Rényi divergences. Considering the totally antisymmetric state we show that it is not possible to attain a proper generalization of the quantum conditional mutual information by optimizing the distance in terms of quantum $α$-Rényi divergences over the set of all Markov states. The failure of the approach considered arises from the observation that a small quantum conditional mutual information does not imply that the state is close to a quantum Markov state.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2015; v1 submitted 14 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Experimentally feasible set of criteria detecting genuine multipartite entanglement in n-qubit Dicke states and in higher dimensional systems
Authors:
Marcus Huber,
Paul Erker,
Hans Schimpf,
Andreas Gabriel,
Beatrix C. Hiesmayr
Abstract:
We construct a set of criteria detecting genuine multipartite entanglement in arbitrary dimensional multipartite systems. These criteria are optimally suited for detecting multipartite entanglement in n-qubit Dicke states with m-excitations. In a detailed analysis we show that the criteria are also more robust to noise than any other criterion known so far, especially with increasing system size.…
▽ More
We construct a set of criteria detecting genuine multipartite entanglement in arbitrary dimensional multipartite systems. These criteria are optimally suited for detecting multipartite entanglement in n-qubit Dicke states with m-excitations. In a detailed analysis we show that the criteria are also more robust to noise than any other criterion known so far, especially with increasing system size. Furthermore it is shown that the number of required local observables scales only polynomially with size, thus making the criteria experimentally feasible.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2011; v1 submitted 20 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
