Wikipedia:Lyrics and poetry: Difference between revisions

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Duncharris (talk | contribs)
 
(111 intermediate revisions by 67 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{redirect|WP:LYRICS|the guideline that states Wikipedia is not a lyrics database|WP:NOTLYRICS|the poetry Wikiproject|Wikipedia:WikiProject Poetry}}
{{Shortcut|[[WP:L&P]]}}
{{guideline}}


{{supplement|interprets=Wikipedia:Manual of Style/Music|shortcut=WP:LYRICS}}
[[20th century|20th]] and [[21st century]] '''[[lyrics]] and [[poetry]]''' should not generally be submitted to [[Wikipedia:Wikipedia|Wikipedia]]. This is primarily because most songwriters and poets have not released their lyrics under an [[open content]] license and therefore their inclusion violates their [[copyright]].
{{style}}
A Wikipedia article on '''lyrics''' or '''poetry''' should have an analytical framework that describes the song and its cultural impact. This page discusses how they should be written. For how lyrics and poetry should be displayed, see: [[Wikipedia:WikiProject Poetry#Style for quoting from poems]].


Foremost, [[WP:COPYRIGHT|copyrights]] should be respected. In addition, any interpretation of lyrics requires a [[Wikipedia:Identifying reliable sources|reliable]] [[Wikipedia:No original research#Primary, secondary_and_tertiary_sources|secondary source]] for that interpretation. Do not analyze, synthesize, interpret, or evaluate lyrics yourself; instead, refer to reliable secondary sources that do so.
== Don'ts ==
In addition to the main point of not violating copyright, do not write an article that consists only of lyrics. This would be considered a [[primary source]]. It may if it is [[GFDL]]-compatible [[free content]], be [[m:transwiki|transwikied]] to [[Wikisource:Main Page|Wikisource]], but it could also be [[wikipedia:Speedy deletion|speedy deleted]] for lack of context.


To be included, works ought to fit into the framework of [[Wikipedia:notability|notability]]. In general, a song from a [[b-side]] to a minor band shouldn't be included (see also [[Wikipedia:Notability (music)]] and [[Wikipedia:Deletion policy|deletion policy]]).
== Dos ==
An encyclopedic article should have an analytical framework that describes the song and its cultural impact.


== Points to avoid ==
First you should bear in mind some important points to avoid:
* Most modern songwriters and poets have not released their works under an [[open content]] license and therefore their inclusion in Wikipedia [[Wikipedia:Copyright violation|violates their copyright]]. Copyright usually expires 70 years after the author's death (see below).
* [[Wikipedia:External links|External links]] to copyright violations should also be avoided. Many archives and collections of lyrics on the Internet are ''not'' licensed and are likely to involve copyright violations.
* In addition to the main point of not violating copyright, do not write an article that consists only of lyrics. This would be considered a [[Wikipedia:No original research#Primary, secondary_and_tertiary_sources|primary source]]. It may, if it is [[GFDL]]-compatible [[free content]], be [[m:transwiki|transwikied]] to [[Wikisource:Main Page|Wikisource]], but it could also be [[wikipedia:Speedy deletion|speedy deleted]] by an admin for lack of context.

== License considerations ==
=== Copyrighted works ===
=== Copyrighted works ===
[[Quotation]]s of the work within the analytical framework can fall into the [[fair use]] provisions within [[copyright law]] (and to a lesser extent [[fair dealing]] and related concepts within other jurisdictions). However, how much of a song you can quote is open to interpretation, but you should [[Wikipedia:Avoid copyright paranoia|avoid copyright paranoia]]. Examples of [[featured articles]] that of works still under copyright, which should be used as guidelines, are:
[[Quotation]]s of the work within the analytical framework can fall into the [[fair use]] provisions within [[US copyright law]] (and to a lesser extent [[fair dealing]] and related concepts within other jurisdictions). Such quotations can be done through inline text, block quotes, or (in the case of a song) inclusion of an image showing part of the sheet music. However, how much of a song you can quote is open to interpretation, but you should follow the '''[[Wikipedia:Non-free content#Policy|Non-free content policy]]'''. Examples of [[WP:GA|good articles]] and [[Wikipedia:Featured articles|featured articles]] on works still under copyright that should be used as guidelines are:


* [[W. B. Yeats]] (includes block quotes from several poems)
* ''[[The Cantos]]''
* ''[[A Day in the Life]]''
* "[[A Day in the Life]]" by the Beatles (includes selected lyrics inline)
* "[[The Scientist (song)|The Scientist]]" by Coldplay (includes selected lyrics inline and audio excerpt)
* ''[[Hey Jude]]''
* "[[Love Story (Taylor Swift song)|Love Story]]" by Taylor Swift (includes selected lyrics inline and audio excerpt)
* ''[[Yesterday (song)]]''
* "[[Like a Rolling Stone]]" by Bob Dylan (includes selected lyrics in block quotes and audio excerpts)
* ''[[The Long and Winding Road]]''
* "[[Running to Stand Still]]" by U2 (includes selected lyrics inline and in blocks, and an audio excerpt)
* ''[[A Hard Day's Night (song)]]''
* "[[Last Post (poem)|Last Post]]" poem by Carol Ann Duffy (includes selected lyrics inline and in blocks)
* ''[[(I Can't Get No) Satisfaction]]''
* "[[Hey Ya!]]" by OutKast (includes inline discussion of selected lyrics)
* ''[[I Want to Hold Your Hand]]''
* ''[[Get Back]]''


=== Copyright-expired works ===
=== Copyright-expired works ===
<!-- Lyrics of copyright-expired works may be included when they... -->Generally, these expire in all countries (except [[Colombia]], [[Guatemala]], [[Mexico]], and [[Samoa]]) when all of the following conditions are satisfied:
You should include lyrics and poetry whose copyright has expired. As of 2005, there are no featured articles on these, but consider:
*The work was created and first published before [[January 1]], [[1923]], or at least 95 years before January 1 of the current year, whichever is later.
*The last surviving author died at least 70 years before January 1 of the current year.
*No [[Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works|Berne Convention]] signatory has passed a perpetual copyright on the work.


Consider the following:
* ''[[Three Blind Mice]]''.

* ''[[And did those feet in ancient time]]''
* "[[Old Dan Tucker]]" (featured)
* ''[[Dulce Et Decorum Est]]''
* "[[Three Blind Mice]]"
* "[[And did those feet in ancient time]]"
<!-- find more -->
<!-- find more -->


=== National Anthems ===
=== National anthems ===
[[National anthem]]s are generally considered to be a special case of [[fair use]] if modern, or copyright-expired if older. Examples include:
* "[[God Save the King]]" (copyright expired)
* "[[Advance Australia Fair]]" (copyright expired)
* "[[Namibia, Land of the Brave]]" (copyrighted)


== Wikisource instructions ==
[[National anthems]]. <!-- elaborate why -->
If you are adding a new text on Wikisource, [[s:Help:Adding texts|follow the local guidelines]]. Use [[Template:wikisource-inline]] at the top of the external links section to link to works on [[Wikisource]] (see the [[Template talk:wikisource-inline|documentation]]). For example, use <code><nowiki>{{wikisource-inline|Anthem for Doomed Youth}}</nowiki></code> to link to the poem "[[Anthem for Doomed Youth]]". This produces the line below:

{{wikisource-inline|Anthem for Doomed Youth}}
== Inclusion guidelines ==

To be included, works ought to be [[Wikipedia:notability|notable]]. A song from a [[b-side]] to a minor band shouldn't be included (see also [[WP:MUSIC]], [[deletion policy]]).


== See also ==
== See also ==
* [[Help:Score]]

* [[Wikipedia:Copyrights]]
* [[Wikipedia:Copyrights]]
* {{section link|Wikipedia:Naming conventions (books)|Poems and lyrics}} for guidance on ''[[wikipedia:naming conventions|article naming]]''.
* [[Wikipedia:Avoid copyright paranoia]]



[[Category:Wikipedia guidelines|{{PAGENAME}}]]
[[Category:Culture Wikipedia administration]]

Latest revision as of 13:00, 2 February 2024

A Wikipedia article on lyrics or poetry should have an analytical framework that describes the song and its cultural impact. This page discusses how they should be written. For how lyrics and poetry should be displayed, see: Wikipedia:WikiProject Poetry#Style for quoting from poems.

Foremost, copyrights should be respected. In addition, any interpretation of lyrics requires a reliable secondary source for that interpretation. Do not analyze, synthesize, interpret, or evaluate lyrics yourself; instead, refer to reliable secondary sources that do so.

To be included, works ought to fit into the framework of notability. In general, a song from a b-side to a minor band shouldn't be included (see also Wikipedia:Notability (music) and deletion policy).

Points to avoid[edit]

First you should bear in mind some important points to avoid:

  • Most modern songwriters and poets have not released their works under an open content license and therefore their inclusion in Wikipedia violates their copyright. Copyright usually expires 70 years after the author's death (see below).
  • External links to copyright violations should also be avoided. Many archives and collections of lyrics on the Internet are not licensed and are likely to involve copyright violations.
  • In addition to the main point of not violating copyright, do not write an article that consists only of lyrics. This would be considered a primary source. It may, if it is GFDL-compatible free content, be transwikied to Wikisource, but it could also be speedy deleted by an admin for lack of context.

License considerations[edit]

Copyrighted works[edit]

Quotations of the work within the analytical framework can fall into the fair use provisions within US copyright law (and to a lesser extent fair dealing and related concepts within other jurisdictions). Such quotations can be done through inline text, block quotes, or (in the case of a song) inclusion of an image showing part of the sheet music. However, how much of a song you can quote is open to interpretation, but you should follow the Non-free content policy. Examples of good articles and featured articles on works still under copyright that should be used as guidelines are:

  • W. B. Yeats (includes block quotes from several poems)
  • "A Day in the Life" by the Beatles (includes selected lyrics inline)
  • "The Scientist" by Coldplay (includes selected lyrics inline and audio excerpt)
  • "Love Story" by Taylor Swift (includes selected lyrics inline and audio excerpt)
  • "Like a Rolling Stone" by Bob Dylan (includes selected lyrics in block quotes and audio excerpts)
  • "Running to Stand Still" by U2 (includes selected lyrics inline and in blocks, and an audio excerpt)
  • "Last Post" poem by Carol Ann Duffy (includes selected lyrics inline and in blocks)
  • "Hey Ya!" by OutKast (includes inline discussion of selected lyrics)

Copyright-expired works[edit]

Generally, these expire in all countries (except Colombia, Guatemala, Mexico, and Samoa) when all of the following conditions are satisfied:

  • The work was created and first published before January 1, 1923, or at least 95 years before January 1 of the current year, whichever is later.
  • The last surviving author died at least 70 years before January 1 of the current year.
  • No Berne Convention signatory has passed a perpetual copyright on the work.

Consider the following:

National anthems[edit]

National anthems are generally considered to be a special case of fair use if modern, or copyright-expired if older. Examples include:

Wikisource instructions[edit]

If you are adding a new text on Wikisource, follow the local guidelines. Use Template:wikisource-inline at the top of the external links section to link to works on Wikisource (see the documentation). For example, use {{wikisource-inline|Anthem for Doomed Youth}} to link to the poem "Anthem for Doomed Youth". This produces the line below: Works related to Anthem for Doomed Youth at Wikisource

See also[edit]