B. V. Nagarathna
B. V. Nagarathna | |
|---|---|
 | |
| Judge of the Supreme Court of India | |
| Assumed office 31 August 2021 | |
| Nominated by | N. V. Ramana |
| Appointed by | Ram Nath Kovind |
| Judge of the Karnataka High Court | |
| In office 18 February 2008 – 30 August 2021 | |
| Nominated by | K. G. Balakrishnan |
| Appointed by | Pratibha Patil |
| Personal details | |
| Born | 30 October 1962 Pandavapura, Mysore State, India[1] |
| Spouse | B. N. Gopala Krishna |
| Parent | |
| Alma mater | Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan's Mehta Vidyalaya New Delhi, Jesus and Mary College (BA), Faculty of Law, University of Delhi |
Bengaluru Venkataramiah Nagarathna (born 30 October 1962) is a judge of the Supreme Court of India. She served as a judge of the Karnataka High Court from 2008 to 2021.[2] Her father, E. S. Venkataramiah, was Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of India in 1989.[3]
She gained public attention in 2009 after being forcibly detained within the Karnataka High Court premises by a group of protesting lawyers.[4] She has delivered a number of significant judgments relating to commercial and constitutional law in Karnataka. She will be the first woman Chief Justice of India in 2027. However, her tenure will span only for 36 days.[5]
Early life and education
[edit]Nagarathna's father, E.S. Venkataramiah, was the 19th Chief Justice of India.[6][7]
Nagarathna did her schooling at Sophia High School, Bangalore and Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan, New Delhi.[8] In 1984, she earned a Bachelor of Arts in history from Jesus and Mary College, New Delhi.[9] She later earned a degree in law from the Faculty of Law, University of Delhi.[10]
Career
[edit]She enrolled with the Bar Council of Karnataka in 1987 and practiced constitutional and commercial law in Bangalore before being appointed as an additional judge of the Karnataka High Court in 2008.[11] She was appointed as a permanent judge on 17 February 2010.[2]
In May 2020, B.V. Nagarathna was reported as being considered for appointment to the Supreme Court of India, leading a number of commentators to note that this would make her eligible to become the first female chief justice of the India Supreme Court.[12][6][11]
On 26 August 2021, she was appointed as a judge of the Supreme Court of India and took her oath on 31 August 2021.[13] She is in line to become first woman Chief Justice of India in year 2027.[14]
Notable judgments and opinions
[edit]Dissent in the demonetisation judgement
[edit]Nagrathna, as a part of a five judge bench consisting of Justices S Abdul Nazeer, BR Gavai, AS Bopanna, V Ramasubramanian and herself had reserved the judgement on December 7, 2022. On 2 January 2023, the same was revealed. While the 4–1 majority judgement upheld the constitutional validity of the demonetisation, J. Nagarathna dissented.
In her dissenting view held that demonetisation of the whole series of Rs 500 and Rs 1000 currency notes is a serious matter and it could not be done by the centre by merely issuing a gazette notification.
She stated that her views on each of the questions as framed by Gavai J's majority judgement differed significantly. As per her judgement the measure was well-intentioned and well thought of. It targeted evils such as blackmoney, terror funding and counterfeiting. The measure is declared unlawful purely on legal grounds and not on the basis of objects.[15]
Sensationalist news
[edit]In 2012, along with another judge, she ordered the federal government to examine the possibility of regulating broadcast media in India, noting the rise of fake news. In a concurring opinion, she also warned against the risks of allowing government control over broadcast media, calling for a statutory framework that would allow self-regulation by the broadcast industry.[16]
Vehicle taxation
[edit]In 2016, she ruled along with another judge that the Karnataka government could not require owners of vehicles bought outside the state to pay a "lifetime tax" in order to use their vehicles in Karnataka, holding the policy to be unconstitutional.[17]
Non-commercial status of temples
[edit]In 2019, along with two other judges, she ruled that temples were not commercial institutions and accordingly, that provisions of labour laws relating to the payment of gratuities did not apply to temple employees.[18]
Autonomy of private institutions
[edit]On 15 September 2020, she and another judge upheld a contested government policy to ensure the standardization of admissions into both, public and private colleges in Karnataka, citing the COVID-19 pandemic in India as a reason to limit the autonomy of private institutions.[19]
Detention by lawyers
[edit]In 2009, she and another judge, Venkate Gopala Gowda, were unlawfully detained, along with the then-Chief Justice of the Karnataka High Court, P. D. Dinakaran, by a group of protesting lawyers in the Karnataka High Court. The incident occurred following the declaration of a boycott of courts by lawyers' association, who were protesting following allegations of corruption against P. D. Dinakaran. They were later released by the protesting lawyers.[4][20][21] Following the incident, Nagarathna made a public statement, saying, "We cannot be cowed down like this. We have taken the oath of Constitution."[22]
Status of education during the COVID-19 pandemic
[edit]Nagarathna was part of the bench that rejected the Karnataka government's proposal to halt mid-day meals in COVID-affected areas. The bench also coaxed the government to bridge the digital divide and ensure children have access to online classes. Further the bench directed teachers and non-teaching staff to be treated as frontline workers.
References
[edit]- ^ Yogesh, M N (26 August 2021). "B V Nagarathna: The new Supreme Court judge with roots in Mandya village". Deccan Herald. Retrieved 26 November 2022.
- ^ a b "Hon'ble Mrs. Justice B.V.Nagarathna". Karnataka High Court. Archived from the original on 2 October 2014.
- ^ "Supreme Court Official Who Took Justice BV Nagarathna To School As Child Now Senior Staff". NDTV.com. Retrieved 24 February 2023.
- ^ a b Hunasavadi, Srikanth (10 November 2009). "Karnataka CJ, two judges attacked in court". DNA India. Retrieved 6 November 2020.
- ^ "Next 8 Chief Justices of India". Supreme Court Observer. Retrieved 10 November 2024.
- ^ a b Chhibber, Maneesh (29 May 2020). "SC collegium willing, this Karnataka judge could become first woman Chief Justice of India". ThePrint. Retrieved 6 November 2020.
- ^ Mahapatra, Dhananjay (19 August 2021). "India could get 1st woman CJI in Justice Nagarathna in 6 yrs". The Times of India. Retrieved 19 August 2021.
- ^ "Supreme Court Official Who Took Justice BV Nagarathna To School As Child Now Senior Staff". NDTV.com. Retrieved 1 July 2022.
- ^ "Jesus & Mary College New Delhi".
- ^ Rajagopal, Krishnadas (28 August 2021). "B.V. Nagarathna | Beyond the glass ceiling". The Hindu. ISSN 0971-751X. Retrieved 29 August 2021.
- ^ a b "Supreme Court Collegium may clear way for country's first woman CJI". The New Indian Express. Retrieved 6 November 2020.
- ^ Singh, Ajmer. "Legal fraternity speculates on a woman CJI in future". The Economic Times. Retrieved 6 November 2020.
- ^ "Nine new judges appointed to SC, total strength moves up to 33". The Indian Express. 27 August 2021. Retrieved 29 August 2021.
- ^ "7 Next CJIs". Supreme Court Observer. 23 November 2021. Archived from the original on 28 December 2021. Retrieved 24 November 2021.
- ^ https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/demonetisation-supreme-court-uphold-reasonable-nexus-rbi-act-217846?infinitescroll=1
- ^ Staff Reporter (16 May 2012). "Work out modalities for regulation of broadcast media, Centre told". The Hindu. ISSN 0971-751X. Retrieved 6 November 2020.
- ^ "State loses battle over lifetime tax on vehicles registered outside Karnataka". The Hindu. 2 July 2016. ISSN 0971-751X. Retrieved 6 November 2020.
- ^ "Temples not commercial establishments: HC". The Hindu. 2 August 2019. ISSN 0971-751X. Retrieved 6 November 2020.
- ^ "Govt. fiat to universities on method to promote intermediate semester students upheld". The Hindu. 15 September 2020. ISSN 0971-751X. Retrieved 6 November 2020.
- ^ PTI (9 November 2009). "Dinakaran case: Chaos in Karnataka HC, 2 judges locked up". The Times of India. Archived from the original on 12 November 2009. Retrieved 6 November 2020.
- ^ Staff Reporter (9 November 2009). "Karnataka advocates disrupt proceedings". The Hindu. ISSN 0971-751X. Retrieved 6 November 2020.
- ^ "We can't be cowed down, asserts Judge". Deccan Herald. 10 November 2009. Retrieved 6 November 2020.