Radio propagation

Radio propagation is the behavior of radio waves as they travel, or are propagated, from one point to another in vacuum, or into various parts of the atmosphere.^[1]^: 26‑1 As a form of electromagnetic radiation, like light waves, radio waves are affected by the phenomena of reflection, refraction, diffraction, absorption, polarization, and scattering.^[2] Understanding the effects of varying conditions on radio propagation has many practical applications, from choosing frequencies for amateur radio communications, international shortwave broadcasters, to designing reliable mobile telephone systems, to radio navigation, to operation of radar systems.

Several different types of propagation are used in practical radio transmission systems. Line-of-sight propagation means radio waves which travel in a straight line from the transmitting antenna to the receiving antenna. Line of sight transmission is used for medium-distance radio transmission, such as cell phones, cordless phones, walkie-talkies, wireless networks, FM radio, television broadcasting, radar, and satellite communication (such as satellite television). Line-of-sight transmission on the surface of the Earth is limited to the distance to the visual horizon, which depends on the height of transmitting and receiving antennas. It is the only propagation method possible at microwave frequencies and above.^[a]

At lower frequencies in the MF, LF, and VLF bands, diffraction allows radio waves to bend over hills and other obstacles, and travel beyond the horizon, following the contour of the Earth. These are called surface waves or ground wave propagation. AM broadcast and amateur radio stations use ground waves to cover their listening areas. As the frequency gets lower, the attenuation with distance decreases, so very low frequency (VLF) to extremely low frequency (ELF) ground waves can be used to communicate worldwide. VLF to ELF waves can penetrate significant distances through water and earth, and these frequencies are used for mine communication and military communication with submerged submarines.

At medium wave and shortwave frequencies (MF and HF bands), radio waves can refract from the ionosphere, a layer of charged particles (ions) high in the atmosphere. This means that medium and short radio waves transmitted at an angle into the sky can be refracted back to Earth at great distances beyond the horizon – even transcontinental distances. This is called skywave propagation. It is used by amateur radio operators to communicate with operators in distant countries, and by shortwave broadcast stations to transmit internationally.^[b]

In addition, there are several less common radio propagation mechanisms, such as tropospheric scattering (troposcatter), tropospheric ducting (ducting) at VHF frequencies and near vertical incidence skywave (NVIS) which are used when HF communications are desired within a few hundred miles.

Frequency dependence

At different frequencies, radio waves travel through the atmosphere by different mechanisms or modes:^[3]

Radio frequencies and their primary mode of propagation
Band		Frequency	Wavelength	Propagation via
ELF	Extremely Low Frequency	3–30 Hz	100,000–10,000 km	Guided between the Earth and the D layer of the ionosphere.
SLF	Super Low Frequency	30–300 Hz	10,000–1,000 km	Guided between the Earth and the ionosphere.
ULF	Ultra Low Frequency	0.3–3 kHz (300–3,000 Hz)	1,000–100 km	Guided between the Earth and the ionosphere.
VLF	Very Low Frequency	3–30 kHz (3,000–30,000 Hz)	100–10 km	Guided between the Earth and the ionosphere. Ground waves.
LF	Low Frequency	30–300 kHz (30,000–300,000 Hz)	10–1 km	Guided between the Earth and the ionosphere. Ground waves.
MF	Medium Frequency	300–3,000 kHz (300,000–3,000,000 Hz)	1000–100 m	Ground waves. E, F layer ionospheric refraction at night, when D layer absorption weakens.
HF	High Frequency (Short Wave)	3–30 MHz (3,000,000–30,000,000 Hz)	100–10 m	E layer ionospheric refraction. F1, F2 layer ionospheric refraction.
VHF	Very High Frequency	30–300 MHz (30,000,000– 300,000,000 Hz)	10–1 m	Line-of-sight propagation. Infrequent E ionospheric (E_s) refraction. Uncommonly F2 layer ionospheric refraction during high sunspot activity up to 50 MHz and rarely to 80 MHz. Sometimes tropospheric ducting or meteor scatter
UHF	Ultra High Frequency	300–3,000 MHz (300,000,000– 3,000,000,000 Hz)	100–10 cm	Line-of-sight propagation. Sometimes tropospheric ducting.
SHF	Super High Frequency	3–30 GHz (3,000,000,000– 30,000,000,000 Hz)	10–1 cm	Line-of-sight propagation. Sometimes rain scatter.
EHF	Extremely High Frequency	30–300 GHz (30,000,000,000– 300,000,000,000 Hz)	10–1 mm	Line-of-sight propagation, limited by atmospheric absorption to a few kilometers (miles)
THF	Tremendously High frequency	0.3–3 THz (300,000,000,000– 3,000,000,000,000 Hz)	1–0.1 mm	Line-of-sight propagation, limited by atmospheric absorption to a few meters.^[4]^[5]
FIR	Far infrared light (overlaps radio)	0.3–20 THz (300,000,000,000– 20,000,000,000,000 Hz)	1,000–150 μみゅーm^[6]^[7]^[8]	Line-of-sight propagation, mostly limited by atmospheric absorption to a few meters.^[6]^[8]

Free space propagation

In free space, all electromagnetic waves (radio, light, X-rays, etc.) obey the inverse-square law which states that the power density $\rho \,$ of an electromagnetic wave is proportional to the inverse of the square of the distance $r\,$ from a point source^[1]^: 26‑19 or:

\rho \propto {\frac {1}{r^{2}}}~.

At typical communication distances from a transmitter, the transmitting antenna usually can be approximated by a point source. Doubling the distance of a receiver from a transmitter means that the power density of the radiated wave at that new location is reduced to one-quarter of its previous value.

The power density per surface unit is proportional to the product of the electric and magnetic field strengths. Thus, doubling the propagation path distance from the transmitter reduces each of these received field strengths over a free-space path by one-half.

Radio waves in vacuum travel at the speed of light. The Earth's atmosphere is thin enough that radio waves in the atmosphere travel very close to the speed of light, but variations in density and temperature can cause some slight refraction (bending) of waves over distances.

Direct modes (line-of-sight)

Line-of-sight refers to radio waves which travel directly in a line from the transmitting antenna to the receiving antenna, often also called direct-wave. It does not necessarily require a cleared sight path; at lower frequencies radio waves can pass through buildings, foliage and other obstructions. This is the most common propagation mode at VHF and above, and the only possible mode at microwave frequencies and above. On the surface of the Earth, line of sight propagation is limited by the visual horizon to about 40 miles (64 km). This is the method used by cell phones,^[c] cordless phones, walkie-talkies, wireless networks, point-to-point microwave radio relay links, FM and television broadcasting and radar. Satellite communication uses longer line-of-sight paths; for example home satellite dishes receive signals from communication satellites 22,000 miles (35,000 km) above the Earth, and ground stations can communicate with spacecraft billions of miles from Earth.

Ground plane reflection effects are an important factor in VHF line-of-sight propagation. The interference between the direct beam line-of-sight and the ground reflected beam often leads to an effective inverse-fourth-power (1⁄distance⁴) law for ground-plane limited radiation.^{[citation needed]}

Surface modes (groundwave)

Lower frequency (between 30 and 3,000 kHz) vertically polarized radio waves can travel as surface waves following the contour of the Earth; this is called ground wave propagation.

In this mode the radio wave propagates by interacting with the conductive surface of the Earth. The wave "clings" to the surface and thus follows the curvature of the Earth, so ground waves can travel over mountains and beyond the horizon. Ground waves propagate in vertical polarization so vertical antennas (monopoles) are required. Since the ground is not a perfect electrical conductor, ground waves are attenuated as they follow the Earth's surface. Attenuation is proportional to frequency, so ground waves are the main mode of propagation at lower frequencies, in the MF, LF and VLF bands. Ground waves are used by radio broadcasting stations in the MF and LF bands, and for time signals and radio navigation systems.

At even lower frequencies, in the VLF to ELF bands, an Earth-ionosphere waveguide mechanism allows even longer range transmission. These frequencies are used for secure military communications. They can also penetrate to a significant depth into seawater, and so are used for one-way military communication to submerged submarines.

Early long-distance radio communication (wireless telegraphy) before the mid-1920s used low frequencies in the longwave bands and relied exclusively on ground-wave propagation. Frequencies above 3 MHz were regarded as useless and were given to hobbyists (radio amateurs). The discovery around 1920 of the ionospheric reflection or skywave mechanism made the medium wave and short wave frequencies useful for long-distance communication and they were allocated to commercial and military users.^[9]

Non-line-of-sight modes

Non-line-of-sight (NLOS) radio propagation occurs outside of the typical line-of-sight (LOS) between the transmitter and receiver, such as in ground reflections. Near-line-of-sight (also NLOS) conditions refer to partial obstruction by a physical object present in the innermost Fresnel zone.

Obstacles that commonly cause NLOS propagation include buildings, trees, hills, mountains, and, in some cases, high voltage electric power lines. Some of these obstructions reflect certain radio frequencies, while some simply absorb or garble the signals; but, in either case, they limit the use of many types of radio transmissions, especially when low on power budget.

Lower power levels at a receiver reduce the chance of successfully receiving a transmission. Low levels can be caused by at least three basic reasons: low transmit level, for example Wi-Fi power levels; far-away transmitter, such as 3G more than 5 miles (8.0 km) away or TV more than 31 miles (50 km) away; and obstruction between the transmitter and the receiver, leaving no clear path.

NLOS lowers the effective received power. Near Line Of Sight can usually be dealt with using better antennas, but Non Line Of Sight usually requires alternative paths or multipath propagation methods.

How to achieve effective NLOS networking has become one of the major questions of modern computer networking. Currently, the most common method for dealing with NLOS conditions on wireless computer networks is simply to circumvent the NLOS condition and place relays at additional locations, sending the content of the radio transmission around the obstructions. Some more advanced NLOS transmission schemes now use multipath signal propagation, bouncing the radio signal off other nearby objects to get to the receiver.

Non-Line-of-Sight (NLOS) is a term often used in radio communications to describe a radio channel or link where there is no visual line of sight (LOS) between the transmitting antenna and the receiving antenna. In this context LOS is taken

Either as a straight line free of any form of visual obstruction, even if it is actually too distant to see with the unaided human eye
As a virtual LOS i.e., as a straight line through visually obstructing material, thus leaving sufficient transmission for radio waves to be detected

There are many electrical characteristics of the transmission media that affect the radio wave propagation and therefore the quality of operation of a radio channel, if it is possible at all, over an NLOS path.

The acronym NLOS has become more popular in the context of wireless local area networks (WLANs) and wireless metropolitan area networks such as WiMAX because the capability of such links to provide a reasonable level of NLOS coverage greatly improves their marketability and versatility in the typical urban environments where they are most frequently used. However NLOS contains many other subsets of radio communications.

The influence of a visual obstruction on a NLOS link may be anything from negligible to complete suppression. An example might apply to a LOS path between a television broadcast antenna and a roof mounted receiving antenna. If a cloud passed between the antennas the link could actually become NLOS but the quality of the radio channel could be virtually unaffected. If, instead, a large building was constructed in the path making it NLOS, the channel may be impossible to receive.

Beyond line-of-sight (BLOS) is a related term often used in the military to describe radio communications capabilities that link personnel or systems too distant or too fully obscured by terrain for LOS communications. These radios utilize active repeaters, groundwave propagation, tropospheric scatter links, and ionospheric propagation to extend communication ranges from a few kilometers to a few thousand kilometers.

Measuring HF propagation

HF propagation conditions can be simulated using radio propagation models, such as the Voice of America Coverage Analysis Program, and realtime measurements can be done using chirp transmitters. For radio amateurs the WSPR mode provides maps with real time propagation conditions between a network of transmitters and receivers.^[10] Even without special beacons the realtime propagation conditions can be measured: A worldwide network of receivers decodes morse code signals on amateur radio frequencies in realtime and provides sophisticated search functions and propagation maps for every station received.^[11]

Practical effects

The average person can notice the effects of changes in radio propagation in several ways.

In AM broadcasting, the dramatic ionospheric changes that occur overnight in the mediumwave band drive a unique broadcast license scheme in the United States, with entirely different transmitter power output levels and directional antenna patterns to cope with skywave propagation at night. Very few stations are allowed to run without modifications during dark hours, typically only those on clear channels in North America.^[12] Many stations have no authorization to run at all outside of daylight hours.

For FM broadcasting (and the few remaining low-band TV stations), weather is the primary cause for changes in VHF propagation, along with some diurnal changes when the sky is mostly without cloud cover.^[13] These changes are most obvious during temperature inversions, such as in the late-night and early-morning hours when it is clear, allowing the ground and the air near it to cool more rapidly. This not only causes dew, frost, or fog, but also causes a slight "drag" on the bottom of the radio waves, bending the signals down such that they can follow the Earth's curvature over the normal radio horizon. The result is typically several stations being heard from another media market – usually a neighboring one, but sometimes ones from a few hundred kilometers (miles) away. Ice storms are also the result of inversions, but these normally cause more scattered omnidirection propagation, resulting mainly in interference, often among weather radio stations. In late spring and early summer, a combination of other atmospheric factors can occasionally cause skips that duct high-power signals to places well over 1000 km (600 miles) away.

Non-broadcast signals are also affected. Mobile phone signals are in the UHF band, ranging from 700 to over 2600 MHz, a range which makes them even more prone to weather-induced propagation changes. In urban (and to some extent suburban) areas with a high population density, this is partly offset by the use of smaller cells, which use lower effective radiated power and beam tilt to reduce interference, and therefore increase frequency reuse and user capacity. However, since this would not be very cost-effective in more rural areas, these cells are larger and so more likely to cause interference over longer distances when propagation conditions allow.

While this is generally transparent to the user thanks to the way that cellular networks handle cell-to-cell handoffs, when cross-border signals are involved, unexpected charges for international roaming may occur despite not having left the country at all. This often occurs between southern San Diego and northern Tijuana at the western end of the U.S./Mexico border, and between eastern Detroit and western Windsor along the U.S./Canada border. Since signals can travel unobstructed over a body of water far larger than the Detroit River, and cool water temperatures also cause inversions in surface air, this "fringe roaming" sometimes occurs across the Great Lakes, and between islands in the Caribbean. Signals can skip from the Dominican Republic to a mountainside in Puerto Rico and vice versa, or between the U.S. and British Virgin Islands, among others. While unintended cross-border roaming is often automatically removed by mobile phone company billing systems, inter-island roaming is typically not.

Empirical models

A radio propagation model, also known as the radio wave propagation model or the radio frequency propagation model, is an empirical mathematical formulation for the characterization of radio wave propagation as a function of frequency, distance and other conditions. A single model is usually developed to predict the behavior of propagation for all similar links under similar constraints. Created with the goal of formalizing the way radio waves are propagated from one place to another, such models typically predict the path loss along a link or the effective coverage area of a transmitter.

The inventor of radio communication, Guglielmo Marconi, before 1900 formulated the first crude empirical rule of radio propagation: the maximum transmission distance varied as the square of the height of the antenna.

As the path loss encountered along any radio link serves as the dominant factor for characterization of propagation for the link, radio propagation models typically focus on realization of the path loss with the auxiliary task of predicting the area of coverage for a transmitter or modeling the distribution of signals over different regions.

Because each individual telecommunication link has to encounter different terrain, path, obstructions, atmospheric conditions and other phenomena, it is intractable to formulate the exact loss for all telecommunication systems in a single mathematical equation. As a result, different models exist for different types of radio links under different conditions. The models rely on computing the median path loss for a link under a certain probability that the considered conditions will occur.

Radio propagation models are empirical in nature, which means, they are developed based on large collections of data collected for the specific scenario. For any model, the collection of data has to be sufficiently large to provide enough likeliness (or enough scope) to all kind of situations that can happen in that specific scenario. Like all empirical models, radio propagation models do not point out the exact behavior of a link, rather, they predict the most likely behavior the link may exhibit under the specified conditions.

Different models have been developed to meet the needs of realizing the propagation behavior in different conditions. Types of models for radio propagation include:

Models for free space attenuation

Models for outdoor attenuation

Terrain models
City models

Models for indoor attenuation

Footnotes

^ At microwave frequencies, moisture in the atmosphere (rain fade) can degrade transmission.
^ Skywave communication is variable: It depends on conditions in the ionosphere. Long distance shortwave transmission is most reliable at night and during the winter. Since the advent of communication satellites in the 1960s, many long range communication needs that previously used skywaves now use satellites and submerged cables, to avoid dependence on the erratic performance of skywave communications.
^ Cellular networks function even without a single clear line-of-sight by relaying signals along multiple line-of-sight paths through cell towers.

References

^ ^a ^b Westman, H.P.; et al., eds. (1968). Reference Data for Radio Engineers (Fifth ed.). Howard W. Sams and Co. ISBN 0-672-20678-1. LCCN 43-14665.
^ Paris, Demetrius T. and Hurd, F. Kenneth (1969). Basic Electromagnetic Theory. New York, NY: McGraw Hill. Chapter 8. ISBN 0-07-048470-8.
^ Seybold, John S. (2005). Introduction to RF Propagation. John Wiley and Sons. pp. 3–10. ISBN 0471743682.
^ Coutaz, Jean-Louis; Garet, Frederic; Wallace, Vincent P. (2018). Principles of Terahertz Time-Domain Spectroscopy: An introductory textbook. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. p. 18. ISBN 9781351356367.
^ Siegel, Peter (2002). "Studying the Energy of the Universe". National Aeronautics and Space Administration (nasa.gov). Education materials. Retrieved 19 May 2021.
^ ^a ^b Byrnes, James (2009). Unexploded Ordnance Detection and Mitigation. Springer. pp. 21–22. ISBN 978-1-4020-9252-7.
^ Glagoleva-Arkadiewa, A. (1924). "Short electromagnetic waves of wave-length up to 82 Microns". Nature. 2844 (113). doi:10.1038/113640a0.
^ ^a ^b "Near, mid and far-infrared". Caltech Infrared Processing and Analysis Center. California Institute of Technology. Archived from the original on 29 May 2012. Retrieved 28 January 2013.
^ DeSoto, Clinton B. (1936). 200 meters & Down - The Story of Amateur Radio. Newington, CT: The American Radio Relay League. pp. 132–146. ISBN 0-87259-001-1.
^ "WSPR propagation conditions". wsprnet.org (map). Retrieved 4 December 2020.
^ "Network of CW signal decoders for realtime analysis". Reverse Beacon Network. Retrieved 4 December 2020.
^ Why AM stations must reduce power, change operations, or cease broadcasting at night (Report). U.S. Federal Communications Commission. 11 December 2015. Retrieved 11 February 2017.
^ "VHF/UHF Propagation". rsgb.org. Radio Society of Great Britain. Retrieved 11 February 2017.

External links

Solar widget Propagation widget based on NOAA data. Also available as WordPress plugin.
ARRL Propagation Page The American Radio Relay League page on radio propagation.
HF Radio and Ionospheric Prediction Service - Australia
NASA Space Weather Action Center
Online Propagation Tools, HF Solar Data, and HF Propagation Tutorials
HF ionospheric propagation several pages

[3] At microwave frequencies, moisture in the atmosphere (rain fade) can degrade transmission.

[4] Skywave communication is variable: It depends on conditions in the ionosphere. Long distance shortwave transmission is most reliable at night and during the winter. Since the advent of communication satellites in the 1960s, many long range communication needs that previously used skywaves now use satellites and submerged cables, to avoid dependence on the erratic performance of skywave communications.

[11] Cellular networks function even without a single clear line-of-sight by relaying signals along multiple line-of-sight paths through cell towers.

[Westman-1968-1] Westman, H.P.; et al., eds. (1968). Reference Data for Radio Engineers (Fifth ed.). Howard W. Sams and Co. ISBN 0-672-20678-1. LCCN 43-14665.

[2] Paris, Demetrius T. and Hurd, F. Kenneth (1969). Basic Electromagnetic Theory. New York, NY: McGraw Hill. Chapter 8. ISBN 0-07-048470-8.

[Seybold-5] Seybold, John S. (2005). Introduction to RF Propagation. John Wiley and Sons. pp. 3–10. ISBN 0471743682.

[Coutaz-6] Coutaz, Jean-Louis; Garet, Frederic; Wallace, Vincent P. (2018). Principles of Terahertz Time-Domain Spectroscopy: An introductory textbook. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. p. 18. ISBN 9781351356367.

[Siegel-7] Siegel, Peter (2002). "Studying the Energy of the Universe". National Aeronautics and Space Administration (nasa.gov). Education materials. Retrieved 19 May 2021.

[Byrnes-8] Byrnes, James (2009). Unexploded Ordnance Detection and Mitigation. Springer. pp. 21–22. ISBN 978-1-4020-9252-7.

[Glagoleva-9] Glagoleva-Arkadiewa, A. (1924). "Short electromagnetic waves of wave-length up to 82 Microns". Nature. 2844 (113). doi:10.1038/113640a0.

[caltech-10] "Near, mid and far-infrared". Caltech Infrared Processing and Analysis Center. California Institute of Technology. Archived from the original on 29 May 2012. Retrieved 28 January 2013.

[12] DeSoto, Clinton B. (1936). 200 meters & Down - The Story of Amateur Radio. Newington, CT: The American Radio Relay League. pp. 132–146. ISBN 0-87259-001-1.

[13] "WSPR propagation conditions". wsprnet.org (map). Retrieved 4 December 2020.

[14] "Network of CW signal decoders for realtime analysis". Reverse Beacon Network. Retrieved 4 December 2020.

[15] Why AM stations must reduce power, change operations, or cease broadcasting at night (Report). U.S. Federal Communications Commission. 11 December 2015. Retrieved 11 February 2017.

[16] "VHF/UHF Propagation". rsgb.org. Radio Society of Great Britain. Retrieved 11 February 2017.

[1]

[2]

[a]

[b]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[c]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

v t e Electromagnetic spectrum
Gamma rays X-rays Ultraviolet Visible Infrared Microwave Radio ← higher frequencies longer wavelengths →
Gamma rays	Very-high-energy gamma ray Ultra-high-energy gamma ray
X-rays	Soft X-ray Hard X-ray
Ultraviolet	Extreme ultraviolet Vacuum ultraviolet Lyman-alpha FUV MUV NUV UVC UVB UVA
Visible (optical)	Violet Blue Cyan Green Yellow Orange Red
Infrared	NIR (Bands: J, K, H) SWIR MWIR (Bands: L, M, N) LWIR FIR
Microwaves	W band V band Q band K_a band K band K_u band X band C band S band L band
Radio	THF EHF SHF UHF VHF HF MF LF VLF ULF SLF ELF
Wavelength types	Microwave Shortwave Medium wave Longwave

v t e Analog television broadcasting topics
Systems	180-line 343-line 375-line 405-line (System A) 441-line 455-line 525-line (System M) 625-line (System B, System C, System D, System G, System H, System I, System K, System L, System N) 819-line (System E, System F)
Color systems	NTSC NTSC-J Clear-Vision PAL PAL-M PAL-S PALplus SECAM
Video	Back porch and front porch Black level Blanking level Chrominance Chrominance subcarrier Colorburst Color killer Color TV Composite video Frame (video) Horizontal scan rate Horizontal blanking interval Luma Nominal analogue blanking Overscan Raster scan Safe area Television lines Vertical blanking interval White clipper
Sound	Multichannel television sound NICAM Sound-in-Syncs Zweikanalton
Modulation	Frequency modulation Quadrature amplitude modulation Vestigial sideband modulation (VSB)
Transmission	Amplifiers Antenna (radio) Broadcast transmitter/Transmitter station Cavity amplifier Differential gain Differential phase Diplexer Dipole antenna Dummy load Frequency mixer Intercarrier method Intermediate frequency Output power of an analog TV transmitter Pre-emphasis Residual carrier Split sound system Superheterodyne transmitter Television receive-only Direct-broadcast satellite television Television transmitter Terrestrial television Transposer Digital television transition
Frequencies & bands	Frequency offset Microwave transmission Television channel frequencies UHF VHF
Propagation	Beam tilt Distortion Earth bulge Field strength in free space Noise (electronics) Null fill Path loss Radiation pattern Skew Television interference
Testing	Distortionmeter Field strength meter Vectorscope VIT signals Zero reference pulse
Artifacts	Dot crawl Ghosting Hanover bars Sparklies

v t e Radio frequency propagation models
Free space	Free-space path loss Friis transmission equation Dipole field strength in free space
Terrain	ITU terrain model Egli model Longley–Rice Irregular Terrain Model (ITM) Two-ray ground-reflection model
Foliage	Weissberger's model Early ITU model One woodland terminal model Single vegetative obstruction model
Urban	Okumura model Hata model COST Hata model Young model Six-rays model Ten-rays model
Indoor	ITU model for indoor attenuation Log-distance path loss model
Other	VOACAP (HF) Area-to-area Lee model (900 MHz) Point-to-point Lee model (900 MHz) Longley–Rice model (20 MHz - 20 GHz)