Report t3mp7st's Profile

1-10 Rating System

1. Abysmal (1)
Description: Virtually unredeemable with critical flaws. Severe issues in all aspects, including story, art, and execution. Extremely disappointing and not worth the time.

2. Terrible (2)
Description: Major problems dominate the experience. Significant issues with the story, art, or execution make it a struggle to engage. Only a few minor redeeming qualities, if any.

3. Poor (3)
Description: Largely unsatisfactory with numerous flaws. While there might be some potential or interesting ideas, they are overshadowed by major problems that hinder enjoyment.

4. Fair (4)
Description: Mediocre and inconsistent. Contains notable shortcomings but also some redeeming elements. It meets basic expectations but fails to stand out or offer a compelling experience.

5. Average (5)
Description: Adequate but unremarkable. It performs reasonably well in most areas but lacks excellence or excitement. It’s serviceable but doesn’t leave a lasting impression.

6. Good (6)
Description: Solid and enjoyable with some clear strengths. It offers a generally positive experience with minor flaws that don’t significantly detract from the overall enjoyment.

7. Very Good (7)
Description: Strong and engaging. It excels in key areas and provides a satisfying experience with only a few minor issues. Worth recommending with some enthusiasm.

8. Excellent (8)
Description: Highly impressive with strong qualities. It delivers a memorable experience with minimal flaws. The work is well-executed and offers considerable enjoyment.

9. Outstanding (9)
Description: Exceptional in most aspects. It stands out with superior quality, innovation, and impact. Very few minor issues, if any, and a highly recommended experience.

10. Perfect (10)
Description: Flawless and exemplary. Sets a high standard with no noticeable flaws. Provides an extraordinary experience that is both memorable and influential.

Criteria for Evaluation
Story/Narrative (30%): How engaging, original, and coherent is the plot? Are the characters well-developed and relatable?
Art/Visuals (25%): How visually appealing and well-executed are the illustrations or design elements? Do they effectively support the narrative?
Execution (20%): How well is the concept or genre executed? Are there technical or structural issues that affect the overall experience?
Originality (15%): How unique or innovative is the work? Does it offer new perspectives or creative approaches within its genre?
Overall Enjoyment (10%): How satisfying and enjoyable is the overall experience? Does it meet or exceed expectations?


Comics not on MAL:
1. The Beginning After The End

Shows not on MAL: