Microsoft said to offer payment for Wikipedia edits
It raises questions on the ethics of a company paying someone to edit entries
January 23, 2007 12:00 PM ETIDG News Service -
A software engineer in Australia said he was offered payment by Microsoft Corp. to edit certain entries in the Wikipedia online dictionary, opening a heated debate about the ethics of such a move.
Rick Jelliffe, chief technology officer of XML tools company Topologi Pty. Ltd., said he will probably accept a contract from Microsoft to edit Wikipedia entries on ODF (OpenDocument format) and OOXML (Microsoft Office Open XML), competing document format standards.
In a blog posting on the O'Reilly Web site, Jelliffe said he recently received an e-mail from Microsoft saying it wanted to contract someone "independent but friendly" for a couple of days to provide "more balance" on Wikipedia concerning the ODF and OOXML formats. He said he rarely uses Microsoft products and does not believe he is viewed as a Microsoft enthusiast.
Jelliffe, who lives in Sydney, wrote The XML & SGML Cookbook and describes himself as a standards enthusiast. He said he has added material to Wikipedia entries in the past, and that he doesn't consider himself as being hired to add pro-Microsoft information, just to correct errors.
His disclosure unleashed a heated debate about the ethics of a company paying someone to edit Wikipedia entries and the effect such payment has on the credibility of the site. "From now on we should take the Wikipedia entry on OpenDocument with a grain of salt," wrote Daniel Carrera, an ODF developer, in an e-mail.
Other comments on Jelliffe's blog posting weren't so kind. "Since you openly admit being paid by Microsoft you immediately destroy any credibility as a neutral commentator. End of story," one person wrote.
A representative from Microsoft's press office in the U.K. couldn't confirm that Microsoft had made the offer to Jelliffe
The matter is particularly sensitive given the Wikipedia entries in question. Microsoft created OOXML to compete with ODF, an electronic document format backed by Sun Microsystems Inc., IBM and open-source companies. ODF appeals to users interested in open-standard document formats that will ensure they can continue to access their existing files and lessen their dependence on Microsoft. While the formats are competitive, some companies, such as Corel Corp. and Novell Inc., have said they'll support both.
It's not yet clear what would happen if Jelliffe makes changes to the pages. Wikipedia "tends not to look favorably in terms of conflict of interest, and paying someone is a conflict," said David Gerard, a volunteer spokesman for Wikipedia.
Jelliffe could potentially be blocked from contributing to the site. The English language site is administered by about 1,000 volunteers who have the authority to block editors from contributing to the site, Gerard said. Public relations people who update the Wikipedia page about companies they represent routinely get blocked from the site, he said.
However, given the attention brought to this particular incident, Gerard finds it likely that readers will watch closely for changes made by Jelliffe and respond with their own updates and changes, resulting in an overall improvement to the relevant pages.
Gerard said the situation is regrettable. "We're disappointed that Microsoft thought it had to work by stealth like this," he said. The company would be better off donating the money to Wikipedia and earning the goodwill that would result, he said.
Reprinted with permission from
IDG.net
Story copyright 2009 International Data Group. All rights reserved.
Additional Resources
White Papers & Webcasts
VMware DRS: Why You Still Need Assured Application Delivery and Application Delivery Networking
(Source: F5 Networks) Explore how VMware Infrastructure products provide the next generation virtual platform for the new data center, but they don't virtualize...
Security Configuration Management
(Source: BigFix) In this web video, follow along with Jim Hansen, Senior Product Manager with Big Fix, as he explains why...
Keeping Your Head Above the Cloud: Seven Data Center Challenges to Consider Before Going Virtual
(Source: F5 Networks) In this white paper explore one of the pillars of the Virtual Data Center is virtual platform infrastructure, or the...
IDC Webcast: Linux Adoption in a Global Recession
(Source: Novell and HP) Join Al Gillen from IDC and Michael Applebaum from Novell in this on-demand webcast to see how Linux has...
Gartner Research Report: Magic Quadrant for Application Delivery Controllers, 2008
(Source: F5 Networks) This Research Report explores how vendors focused on solving enterprises' most-pressing application problems have become the top players....
What Are 'Free' Remote Support Tools Really Costing You?
(Source: LogMeIn) In this webinar from LogMeIn, discover how "next generation" remote support tools are optimized to provide advanced capabilities like scripting, system...
Load Balancing: The Evolution to Application Delivery Controllers
(Source: F5 Networks) Discover more about the continued evolution of the load balancer and explore the reasons they were originally created - producing...
Dynamic Infrastructure Worldwide Virtual Forum
(Source: IBM) The world is rapidly becoming more intelligent, more instrumented and more interconnected. It's becoming smarter. While at the Dynamic Infrastructure Worldwide...
Gartner Research Report: Load Balancers Are Dead - Time to Focus on Application Delivery
(Source: F5 Networks) This research shifts the attention from basic load-balancing features to application delivery features to aid in the deployment and delivery...
Interactive Guide: Getting Started with Data Governance
(Source: Kalido) In this online interactive guide, Andrew White, Research VP with lead analyst firm Gartner, answers these questions to help get you...