Subscription Deals
Today's Sun
New round of budget cuts needed: de Jong
The B.C. government will immediately launch a new round of major cuts because of...
Latest News
Let's label this depravity for what it is: misogyny
Rapper Kanye West's monstrous new video is out of the bag, and it's time to say enough to degradation and victimization of women
Daphne Bramham, Vancouver Sun
Published:Â Saturday, January 15, 2011What's entertaining about women in lingerie hanging by their necks on chains? What's artful about images of drugged, unconscious women about to be sexually assaulted?
Nothing.
It's misogyny, graphic and simple.
Instead of artistic expression, political and social commentator Zerlina Maxwell described Kanye West's music video for Monster as "a rape scenario set to a soundtrack."
Yet that's not what many commentators are saying about the gruesome and degrading images in the rapper's video, which has yet to be officially released even though it's all over the Internet either in full or in part.
West has suggested that the video's necrophilia and brutality are aimed at generating controversy and sales. Still, there's a profusion of intellectualizing and rationalizing about the video.
Much of that commentary includes attempts to absolve African-American men from criticism of their misogynist lyrics and the grotesque images of violence perpetrated on white women because of the history of slavery and colonialism.
Among the most inflated and convoluted praise for depravity as art comes from progressives. Salon.com's
Tracy Clark-Flory
deliberately set aside the question of misogyny and wrote that the video "offers a fascinating Rorschach test of our current sexual culture."
Writing on The Atlantic's blog, Chris Jackson deflected the question of misogyny saying he couldn't answer it given all the other examples in popular culture.
Instead he fatuously wrote: "Kanye is like [French Renaissance writer] Montaigne, who said of himself that he doesn't record being, but passing ... The most difficult and most intriguing aspect of Kanye as a rapper is that you never know whether he's celebrating or satirizing an idea or doing both at the same time."
However, it's worth noting that Jackson's Atlantic colleague Ta-Nehisi Coates disagrees.
Coates described the video as "boring racism, boring sexism that hearkens back to the black power macho of Amiri Baraka and Eldridge Cleaver at their worst ... the work of a failed provocateur boorishly brandishing his ancient affects."
Of course, Jackson was not wrong when he pointed out that degradation of women is nothing new in North American pop culture.
Twenty years ago, high fashion was awash with so-called heroin chic.
In 2005, contestants on the reality TV show America's Next Top Model were forced to pose as victims of poisoning, drowning, stabbing, electrocution, organ harvesting and other kinds of violence.
The judges' comments about how beautiful and wonderful the young women looked was almost more chilling than the photos.
Around the same time, shoemaker Jimmy Choo's print ad showed a dead, white woman lying in a car trunk with legendary music producer Quincy Jones digging her grave in the desert.
Far from breaking new ground, West's video only sinks to a deeper level of depravity, bringing the mainstream closer to what's come to be known as torture porn.
It's part of a growing social tolerance or numbness to violence against women. Kathleen Lahey describes it as "the remapping of male primacy onto contemporary culture."