(Translated by https://www.hiragana.jp/)
BBC - Nature UK: What's in a name?
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
« Previous | Main | Next »

What's in a name?

Jeremy Torrance web producer Jeremy Torrance web producer | 10:39 UK time, Monday, 12 July 2010

Strange office that we are, much of our conversation this week has been centred around animal names. For instance, how can something be both a dogfish and a catshark? What's a sweetmart when it's at home? Is a daddy long legs different to a crane fly?

As keen naturalists we just had to investigate. So here are some of our favourite identity crises and the results of our investigations of how they came about.

First of all, let's address this cat/dog shark/fish confusion. According to the Shark Trust, dogfish are a deep sea species and have live young whereas catsharks lay eggs. You can also distinguish a dogfish by their lack of an anal fin. What was once the lesser spotted dogfish has been reclassified as the small spotted catshark by these identifying factors, but the dogfish name has been around for so long that it has stuck.

Dogfish lack the singular anal fin which is evident on catsharks

catshark and dogfish drawings showing lack of anal fin in dogfish

Just to complicate things further, the meat of some species of dogfish is sometimes referred to as rock salmon. Unfortunately, one of these species is the endangered spiny dogfish and the Shark Trust are urging people not to buy rock salmon from their local fish and chip shop.

The fish counter is also the root of another recent name change. Last year, one particular supermarket rebranded pollock (or pollack) to its French name of colin (pronounced co-lan) to make it more appealing to British shoppers. Behind this publicity stunt lies real concern over the stocks of cod and haddock. And does colin and chips sound like a nice Friday night treat?

killer whale

Beneath the waves is another master of disguise in the form of the killer whale. These phenomenal black and white predators aren't whales at all but the largest member of the dolphin family. They're perhaps more accurately referred to as orcas. Their scientific name orcinus orca comes from Orcus, the ferocious Roman god of the netherworld.

Back on land, thankfully the majority of our mammals have solid, dependable common names but there's always room for a little regional variation. Any ideas what royal hunters, red nannys or hedgepigs might be better known as?

hedgehog by tim melling

Pine martens are sometimes known as sweetmarts, possibly due to their sweet-smelling 'scats' or poo. Stoats, meanwhile, go through a complete transformation in the winter, taking up the title ermine to complement their white coats.

Whether you call them cheese bugs, roly-polys, slaters, chucky/chuggy pigs, doodle bugs, sow bugs or pill bugs, we're all familiar with woodlice but are there differences between them? According to the folks at Buglife, many of these names are related to the 'rolled up' appearance of Armadillidium woodlice, while slaters are seashore dwellers or water lice. If you're as baffled by all this as I am and want to know the official name for your woodlouse try the Natural History Museum's identifier.

woodlouse curled in a ball by paulpaul2626

With thousands of 'creepy-crawlies' it's perhaps unsurprising we use one name to describe lots of different species. Daddy long legs for example can be crane flies, harvestmen or cellar spiders in reference to their spindly limbs.

For every perfectly descriptive common name there's a very misleading one. Take for example the slow worm. Is it a worm? Is it a snake? No, it's a legless lizard! And not a particularly slow one either!

slow worm by allan price

Up in the skies, our bird populations have more aliases than James Bond. Did you know that feral pigeons are domesticated rock doves? You can still find wild rock doves in parts of Scotland but the familiar grey scavengers on our city streets are the product of centuries of breeding for domestic purposes such as carrying messages.

Another bird that's had a change of name is the dunnock, which some of you may know as the hedge sparrow. According to the RSPB, this is to save confusion as these familiar birds aren't actually members of the sparrow family, they're accentors.

dunnock by jenny jones

Hmmm. I'm as confused now as when I started. Hopefully everything is now as clear as mud for you too! What strange names baffle you? Did you grow up calling an animal one name only for you to find it had changed when you reached adulthood?

Comments

  • Comment number 1.

    Moose/elk is a bit what the hell. Bison /buffalo confused me witless as a kid. Cranefly/daddy longlegs/harvestman spiders, everyone confuses those. Then theres every instance where the australians get involved, monitor lizards of the family varanidae become "goanna's" which is confusing with iguanas of the family iguanidae, then they call every agamid lizard going a "dragon" by completely random priciples.

    Then my gf'd referred to woodlice as "johnny-pigs" , I mean seriously, where does that come from? I developed a "Herbert Lom" twitch at that one.

    Then you involve americans with the family chelonia , and tortoises, sea turtles, tortoises, terrapins, and box terrapins all become just "turtles" or at random for some freshwater species "sliders".

    Then theres more obscure ones like bear cats becoming a "binturong".

    Then with birds...hate to use the phrase, but OMG. Every captive collection i've ever been to has a different common name. You can go to zoo's up and down the country and your lucky if 40% of the common names tie up.

    Just as well latin names still hold sway. Very worth learning them. TBH most animals for me are known by their latin name, its saves so much trouble.

  • Comment number 2.

    oh yeah, and off south africa some people refer to great whites as dog sharks... nice.. sounds friendly, I'll get the diving gear on. lol.

  • Comment number 3.

    I sympathise with confusion over names. The whale shark is the one that springs to mind. Had a lot of trouble remembering if it was a whale or a shark when I was a child. It was not helped by reading a book that referred to a shark whale, that was a whale that had the attributes of a shark. And made a point of differentiating the two species. To be honest I don't think it exists as I have never heard of the species since and suspect that I read about it in a work of fiction and got confused between fact and reality.

    Although one point about slaters / woodlice and pill bugs / Roley pollies. It has to be pointed out that, that although they belong to the same group of crustaceans, they are separate species. Easily differentiated because pill bugs defensively roll into a ball if disturbed, woodlice don't.

  • Comment number 4.

    There are all sorts of odd anomalies like this with systematic names as well as common names - with entirely unrelated groups sharing the same name. Take the Genus "Ammophila". It is both a genus of grasses (Poaceae, which includes Marram Grass) and a genus of wasps in the family Sphecidae).
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammophila

    There are quite a few examples, but I can't think of them off the top of my head.

  • Comment number 5.

    look up Pieris as a genus in a good gardening book and you may well be confronted with both large white butterflies, (Pieris brassicae) and an ericacious shrub, (Pieris japonica). Confusion.

 

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.