Showing 1–50 of 278 results for author: Baer, H

Beyond the Standard Model: An overview

Authors: Howard Baer

Abstract: At present, the Standard Model (SM) agrees with almost all collider data. Yet, three finetuning issues -- the Higgs mass problem, the strong CP problem and the cosmological constant problem -- all call for new physics. The most plausible solutions at present are weak scale SUSY, the PQWW axion and the string landscape. A re-evaluation of EW finetuning in SUSY allows for a higgsino-like LSP and nat… ▽ More At present, the Standard Model (SM) agrees with almost all collider data. Yet, three finetuning issues -- the Higgs mass problem, the strong CP problem and the cosmological constant problem -- all call for new physics. The most plausible solutions at present are weak scale SUSY, the PQWW axion and the string landscape. A re-evaluation of EW finetuning in SUSY allows for a higgsino-like LSP and naturalness upper bounds well beyond LHC limits. Rather general arguments from string theory allow for statistical predictions that m_h~ 125 GeV with sparticles beyond present LHC limits. The most lucrative LHC search channel may be for light higgsino pair production. Dark matter turns out to be a SUSY DFSZ axion along with a diminished abundance of higgsino-like WIMPs. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 6 pages with 2 figures; contribution to the 2024 QCD session of the 58th Rencontres de Moriond

Stau pairs from natural SUSY at high luminosity LHC

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Kairui Zhang

Abstract: Natural supersymmetry (SUSY) with light higgsinos is perhaps the most plausible of all weak scale SUSY models while a variety of motivations point to (right) tau sleptons as the lightest of all the sleptons. We examine a SUSY model line with rather light right-staus embedded within natural SUSY. For light stau_1 of a few hundred GeV, then the decays stau_1 -> τたう\tchi_{1,2}^0 and νにゅー_τたう\tchi_1^- occur… ▽ More Natural supersymmetry (SUSY) with light higgsinos is perhaps the most plausible of all weak scale SUSY models while a variety of motivations point to (right) tau sleptons as the lightest of all the sleptons. We examine a SUSY model line with rather light right-staus embedded within natural SUSY. For light stau_1 of a few hundred GeV, then the decays stau_1 -> τたう\tchi_{1,2}^0 and νにゅー_τたう\tchi_1^- occur at comparable rates where the (higgsino-like) \tchi_1^\pm and \tchi_2^0 release only small visible energy: in this case, the expected τたう^+τたう^- +\eslt signature is diminished from usual expectations due to the presence of the nearly invisible decay mode \ttau_1 -> νにゅー_τたう\tchi_1^-. However, once m_{\ttau_1}> ~m(bino), then decays to binos such as \ttau_1 -> τたう\tchi_3^0 open up where \tchi_3^0 decays to higgsinos plus W^\pm, Z^0 and h at comparable rates. For these heavier staus, then stau pair production gives rise to diboson+\eslt events which may contain 0, 1 or 2 additional hard τたうleptons. From these considerations, we examine the potential for future discovery of tau-slepton pair production at high-luminosity LHC. While we do not find a 5σしぐまHL-LHC discovery reach for 3000 fb^{-1}, we do find a 95\% CL exclusion reach, ranging between m_{\ttau_1}:100-450 GeV for m_{\tchi_1^0}~ 100 GeV. This latter reach disappears for m_{\tchi_1^0}>~ 200 GeV. △ Less

Submitted 26 April, 2024; v1 submitted 27 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Comments: 20 pages including 7 .png figures; version 2 should coincide with published version and fixes several typos

Report number: OU-HEP-240328

Weak scale supersymmetry emergent from the string landscape

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dakotah Martinez, Shadman Salam

Abstract: Superstring flux compactifications can stabilize all moduli while leading to an enormous number of vacua solutions, each leading to different $4-d$ laws of physics. While the string landscape provides at present the only plausible explanation for the size of the cosmological constant, it may also predict the form of weak scale supersymmetry which is expected to emerge. Rather general arguments sug… ▽ More Superstring flux compactifications can stabilize all moduli while leading to an enormous number of vacua solutions, each leading to different $4-d$ laws of physics. While the string landscape provides at present the only plausible explanation for the size of the cosmological constant, it may also predict the form of weak scale supersymmetry which is expected to emerge. Rather general arguments suggest a power-law draw to large soft terms, but these are subject to an anthropic selection of not-too-large a value for the weak scale. The combined selection allows one to compute relative probabilities for the emergence of supersymmetric models from the landscape. Models with weak scale naturalness appear most likely to emerge since they have the largest parameter space on the landscape. For finetuned models such as high scale SUSY or split SUSY, the required weak scale finetuning shrinks their parameter space to tiny volumes, making them much less likely to appear compared to natural models. Probability distributions for sparticle and Higgs masses from natural models show a preference for Higgs mass $m_h\sim 125$ GeV with sparticles typically beyond present LHC limits, in accord with data. From these considerations, we briefly describe how natural SUSY is expected to be revealed at future LHC upgrades. This article is a contribution to the Special Edition of the journal {\it Entropy} honoring Paul Frampton on his 80th birthday. △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: 16 pages with 6 .png figures; submitted for 80th birthday volume of Entropy honoring Paul Frampton

Report number: OU-HEP-240301

Supersymmetry with scalar sequestering

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dakotah Martinez

Abstract: Supersymmetric models with a strongly interacting superconformal hidden sector (HS) may drive soft SUSY breaking scalar masses, bilinear soft term Bμみゅーand Higgs combinations m_{H_{u,d}}^2+μみゅー^2 to small values at some intermediate scale, leading to unique sparticle mass spectra along with possibly diminished finetuning in spite of a large superpotential $μみゅー$ parameter. We set up a computer code to calc… ▽ More Supersymmetric models with a strongly interacting superconformal hidden sector (HS) may drive soft SUSY breaking scalar masses, bilinear soft term Bμみゅーand Higgs combinations m_{H_{u,d}}^2+μみゅー^2 to small values at some intermediate scale, leading to unique sparticle mass spectra along with possibly diminished finetuning in spite of a large superpotential $μみゅー$ parameter. We set up a computer code to calculate such spectra, which are then susceptible to a variety of constraints: 1. possible charge-or-color breaking (CCB) minima in the scalar potential, 2. unbounded from below (UFB) scalar potential, 3. improper electroweak symmetry breaking, 4. a charged or sneutrino lightest SUSY particle (LSP), 5. generating m_h~ 125 GeV, 6. consistency with LHC sparticle mass limits, and 7. naturalness. We find this bevy of constraints leaves little or no viable parameter space for the case where hidden sector dynamics dominates MSSM running, even for the case of non-universal gaugino masses. For the case with moderate HS running with comparable MSSM running, and with universal gaugino masses, then the finetuning is ameliorated, but nonetheless remains high. Viable spectra with moderate HS running and with low finetuning and large mu can be found for non-universal gaugino masses. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2024; originally announced January 2024.

Comments: 29 pages including 27 .png frames

Report number: OU-HEP-240130

Natural anomaly-mediation from the landscape with implications for LHC SUSY searches

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Jessica Bolich, Juhi Dutta, Dibyashree Sengupta

Abstract: Supersymmetric models with the anomaly-mediated SUSY breaking (AMSB) arose in two different settings: 1. extra-dimensional models where SUSY breaking occurred in a sequestered sector and 2. 4-d models with dynamical SUSY breaking in a hidden sector where scalars gain masses of order the gravitino mass m_{3/2} but with gauginos and trilinear soft terms of the AMSB form. Both have run into serious c… ▽ More Supersymmetric models with the anomaly-mediated SUSY breaking (AMSB) arose in two different settings: 1. extra-dimensional models where SUSY breaking occurred in a sequestered sector and 2. 4-d models with dynamical SUSY breaking in a hidden sector where scalars gain masses of order the gravitino mass m_{3/2} but with gauginos and trilinear soft terms of the AMSB form. Both have run into serious conflicts with 1. LHC sparticle and Higgs mass constraints, 2. constraints from wino-like WIMP dark matter searches and 3. bounds from naturalness. These conflicts may be avoided by introducing minor changes to the underlying phenomenological models consisting of non-universal bulk scalar Higgs masses and A-terms, providing a setting for {\it natural anomaly-mediation} (nAMSB). In nAMSB, the wino is still expected to be the lightest of the gauginos, but the higgsinos are expected to be the lightest electroweakinos (EWinos) in accord with naturalness. We examine what sort of spectra are expected to emerge when nAMSB arises from a string landscape setting. We explore the LHC phenomenology of nAMSB models via higgsino pair production and wino pair production. We characterize the dominant LHC signatures arising from the remaining patch of parameter space which should be fully testable at high-luminosity LHC via EWino pair production searches. △ Less

Submitted 29 November, 2023; originally announced November 2023.

Comments: 37 pages with 27 .png figures

Report number: OUHEP-231105

Winos from natural SUSY at the high luminosity LHC

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Xerxes Tata, Kairui Zhang

Abstract: In natural supersymmetric models defined by no worse than a part in thirty electroweak fine-tuning, winos and binos are generically expected to be much heavier than higgsinos. Moreover, the splitting between the higgsinos is expected to be small, so that the visible decay products of the heavier higgsinos are soft, rendering the higgsinos quasi-invisible at the LHC. Within the natural SUSY framwor… ▽ More In natural supersymmetric models defined by no worse than a part in thirty electroweak fine-tuning, winos and binos are generically expected to be much heavier than higgsinos. Moreover, the splitting between the higgsinos is expected to be small, so that the visible decay products of the heavier higgsinos are soft, rendering the higgsinos quasi-invisible at the LHC. Within the natural SUSY framwork, heavy electroweak gauginos decay to W, Z or h bosons plus higgsinos in the ratio ~2:1:1, respectively. This is in sharp contrast to models with a bino-like lightest superpartner and very heavy higgsinos, where the charged (neutral) wino essentially always decays to a W (h) boson and an invisible bino. Wino pair production at the LHC, in natural SUSY, thus leads to VV, Vh and hh+MET final states (V=W, Z) where, for TeV scale winos, the vector bosons and h daughters are considerably boosted. We identify eight different channels arising from the leptonic and hadronic decays of the vector bosons and the decay h-> b\bar{b}, each of which offers an avenue for wino discovery at the high luminosity LHC (HL-LHC). By combining the signal in all eight channels we find, assuming \sqrt{s}=14 TeV and an integrated luminosity of 3000 fb^{-1}, that the discovery reach for winos extends to m(wino)~1.1~TeV, while the 95% CL exclusion range extends to a wino mass of almost 1.4~TeV. We also identify ``higgsino specific channels'' which could serve to provide 3σしぐまevidence that winos lighter than 1.2~TeV decay to light higgsinos rather than to a bino-like LSP, should a wino signal appear at the HL-LHC. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2024; v1 submitted 16 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: 36 pages with 19 .png figures; version 2 coincides with published version

Report number: OU-HEP-231104

Top squarks from the landscape at high luminosity LHC

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Juhi Dutta, Dibyashree Sengupta, Kairui Zhang

Abstract: Supersymmetric models with low electroweak finetuning are expected to be more prevalent on the string landscape than finetuned models. We assume a fertile patch of landscape vacua containing the minimal supersymmetric standard model (MSSM) as low energy/weak scale effective field theory (LE-EFT). Then, a statistical pull by the landscape to large soft terms is balanced by the requirement of a deri… ▽ More Supersymmetric models with low electroweak finetuning are expected to be more prevalent on the string landscape than finetuned models. We assume a fertile patch of landscape vacua containing the minimal supersymmetric standard model (MSSM) as low energy/weak scale effective field theory (LE-EFT). Then, a statistical pull by the landscape to large soft terms is balanced by the requirement of a derived value of the weak scale which is not too far from its measured value in our universe. Such models are characterized by light higgsinos in the few hundred GeV range whilst top squarks are in the 1-2.5 TeV range with large trilinear soft terms which helps to push m_h~ 125 GeV. Other sparticles are generally beyond current LHC reach and the BR(b -> sγがんま) branching fraction is nearly equal to its SM value. The light top-squarks decay comparably via \tst_1 -> b\tchi_1^+ and \tst_1 -> t\tchi_{1,2}^0 yielding mixed final states of b\bar{b}+MET, t\bar{b}/\ \bar{t}b + MET and t\bar{t}+ MET. We evaluate prospects for top squark discovery at high-luminosity (HL) LHC for the well-motivated case of natural SUSY from the landscape. We find for HL-LHC a 5σしぐまreach out to m_{\tst_1}~ 1.7 TeV and a 95\% CL exclusion reach to m_{\tst_1} ~ 2 TeV. These reaches cover {\it most} (but not all) of the allowed stringy natural parameter space! △ Less

Submitted 16 July, 2023; originally announced July 2023.

Comments: 26 pages with 16 .png figures

Report number: OU-HEP-230701

Prospects for charged Higgs bosons in natural SUSY models at the high-luminosity LHC

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Xerxes Tata, Kairui Zhang

Abstract: We continue our examination of prospects for discovery of heavy Higgs bosons of natural SUSY (natSUSY) models at the high luminosity LHC (HL-LHC), this time focussing on charged Higgs bosons. In natSUSY, higgsinos are expected at the few hundred GeV scale whilst electroweak gauginos inhabit the TeV scale and the heavy Higgs bosons, H, A and H^\pm could range up tens of TeV without jeopardizing nat… ▽ More We continue our examination of prospects for discovery of heavy Higgs bosons of natural SUSY (natSUSY) models at the high luminosity LHC (HL-LHC), this time focussing on charged Higgs bosons. In natSUSY, higgsinos are expected at the few hundred GeV scale whilst electroweak gauginos inhabit the TeV scale and the heavy Higgs bosons, H, A and H^\pm could range up tens of TeV without jeopardizing naturalness. For TeV-scale heavy SUSY Higgs bosons H, A and H^\pm, as currently required by LHC searches, SUSY decays into gaugino plus higgsino can dominate H^\pm decays provided these decays are kinematically accessible. The visible decay products of higgsinos are soft making them largely invisible, whilst the gauginos decay to W, Z or h plus missing transverse energy (MET). Charged Higgs bosons are dominantly produced at LHC14 via the parton subprocess, gb-> H^\pm t. In this paper, we examine the viability of observing signtures from H^\pm -> τたうνにゅー, H^\pm -> tb and H^\pm -> W, Z, h + MET events produced in association with a top quark at the HL-LHC over large Standard Model (SM) backgrounds from (mainly) t\bar{t}, t\bar{t}V and t\bar{t}h production (where V=W, Z). We find that the greatest reach is found via the SM H^\pm(-> τたうνにゅー) +t channel with a subdominant contribution from the H^\pm(-> tb) +t channel. Unlike for neutral Higgs searches, the SUSY decay modes appear to be unimportant for H^\pm searches at the HL-LHC. We delineate regions of the m_A vs. \tanβべーたplane, mostly around m_A \sim 1-2 TeV, where signals from charged Higgs bosons would serve to confirm signals of a heavy, neutral Higgs boson at the 5σしぐまlevel or, alternatively, to exclude heavy Higgs bosons at the 95% confidence level at the high luminosity LHC. △ Less

Submitted 8 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: 33 pages with 22 .png figures. arXiv admin note: text overlap with arXiv:2212.09198

Report number: OU-HEP-230601

On practical naturalness and its implications for weak scale supersymmetry

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dakotah Martinez, Shadman Salam

Abstract: We revisit the various measures of naturalness for models of weak scale supersymmetry including 1. electroweak (EW) naturalness, 2. naturalness via sensitivity to high scale parameters (EENZ/BG), 3. sensitivity of Higgs soft term due to high scale (HS) radiative corrections and 4. stringy naturalness (SN) from the landscape. The EW measure is most conservative and seems unavoidable; it is also mod… ▽ More We revisit the various measures of naturalness for models of weak scale supersymmetry including 1. electroweak (EW) naturalness, 2. naturalness via sensitivity to high scale parameters (EENZ/BG), 3. sensitivity of Higgs soft term due to high scale (HS) radiative corrections and 4. stringy naturalness (SN) from the landscape. The EW measure is most conservative and seems unavoidable; it is also model independent in that its value is fixed only by the weak scale spectra which ensues, no matter which model is used to generate it. The EENZ/BG measure is ambiguous depending on which ``parameters of ignorance'' one includes in the low energy effective field theory (LE-EFT). For models with calculable soft breaking terms, then the EENZ/BG measure reduces to the tree-level EW measure. The HS measure began life as a figurative expression and probably shouldn't be taken more seriously than that. SN is closely related to EW naturalness via the atomic principle, although it is also sensitive to the distribution of soft terms on the landscape. If the landscape favors large soft terms, as in a power law distribution, then it favors m(h) ~ 125 GeV along with sparticles beyond present LHC reach. In this context, SN appears as a probability measure where more natural models are expected to be more prevalent on the landscape than finetuned models. We evaluate by how much the different measures vary against one another with an eye to determining by how much they may overestimate finetuning; we find overestimates can range up to a factor of over 1000. In contrast to much of the literature, we expect the string landscape to favor EW natural SUSY models over finetuned models so that the landscape is not an alternative to naturalness. △ Less

Submitted 25 May, 2023; originally announced May 2023.

Comments: 48 pages with 33 .png figures

Report number: OU-HEP-230501

Dark matter and dark radiation from the early universe with a modulus coupled to the PQMSSM

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Robert Wiley Deal

Abstract: The supersymmetrized DFSZ axion model is especially compelling in that it contains 1. the SUSY solution to the gauge hierarchy problem, 2. the Peccei-Quinn (PQ) solution to the strong CP problem and 3. the Kim-Nilles solution to the SUSY mu problem. In a string setting, where a discrete R-symmetry ({\bf Z}_{24}^R for example) may emerge from the compactification process, a high-quality accidental… ▽ More The supersymmetrized DFSZ axion model is especially compelling in that it contains 1. the SUSY solution to the gauge hierarchy problem, 2. the Peccei-Quinn (PQ) solution to the strong CP problem and 3. the Kim-Nilles solution to the SUSY mu problem. In a string setting, where a discrete R-symmetry ({\bf Z}_{24}^R for example) may emerge from the compactification process, a high-quality accidental axion (accion) can emerge from the accidental, approximate remnant global U(1)_{PQ} symmetry where the decay constant f_a is linked to the SUSY breaking scale, and is within the cosmological sweet zone. In this setup, one also expects the presence of stringy remnant moduli fields φふぁい_i. Here, we consider the situation of a single light modulus φふぁいcoupled to the PQMSSM in the early universe, with mixed axion plus higgsino-like WIMP dark matter. We evaluate dark matter and dark radiation production via nine coupled Boltzmann equations and assess the severity of the cosmological moduli problem (CMP) along with dark matter and dark radiation production rates. We find that typically the light modulus mass should be m_φふぁい>~ 10^4 TeV to avoid the moduli-induced dark matter overproduction problem. If one is able to (anthropically) tune the modulus field amplitude, we find a value of φふぁい_0 <~ 10^{-7}m_P would be required to solve the overall CMP. △ Less

Submitted 29 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Comments: 40 pages including 29 .png figures

Report number: OU-HEP-230204

Detecting heavy neutral SUSY Higgs bosons decaying to sparticles at the high-luminosity LHC

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Xerxes Tata, Kairui Zhang

Abstract: In supersymmetry (SUSY) models with low electroweak naturalness (natSUSY), which have been suggested to be the most likely version of SUSY to emerge from the string landscape, higgsinos are expected at the few hundred GeV scale whilst electroweak gauginos inhabit the TeV scale. For TeV-scale heavy neutral SUSY Higgs bosons H and A, as currently required by LHC searches, then the dominant decay mod… ▽ More In supersymmetry (SUSY) models with low electroweak naturalness (natSUSY), which have been suggested to be the most likely version of SUSY to emerge from the string landscape, higgsinos are expected at the few hundred GeV scale whilst electroweak gauginos inhabit the TeV scale. For TeV-scale heavy neutral SUSY Higgs bosons H and A, as currently required by LHC searches, then the dominant decay modes of H, A are into gaugino plus higgsino provided these decays are kinematically open. The light higgsinos decay to soft particles so are largely invisible whilst the gauginos decay to W, Z or h plus missing transverse energy (MET). Thus, we examine the viability of H,A-> W+MET, Z+MET and h+MET signatures at the high luminosity LHC (HL-LHC) in light of large Standard Model (SM) backgrounds from (mainly) t\bar{t}, VV and Vh production (where V=W, Z). We also examine whether these signal channels can be enhanced over backgrounds by requiring the presence of an additional soft lepton from the decays of the light higgsinos. We find significant regions in the vicinity of m_A~ 1-2 TeV of the m_A vs. \tanβべーたplane which can be probed at the high luminosity LHC using these dominant signatures by HL-LHC at 5σしぐまand at the 95% confidence level (CL). △ Less

Submitted 18 December, 2022; originally announced December 2022.

Comments: 24 pages with 26 .png figures

Report number: OU-HEP-230101

TF08 Snowmass Report: BSM Model Building

Authors: Patrick J. Fox, Graham D. Kribs, Hitoshi Murayama, Amin Aboubrahim, Prateek Agrawal, Wolfgang Altmannshofer, Howard Baer, Avik Banerjee, Vernon Barger, Brian Batell, Kim V. Berghaus, Asher Berlin, Nikita Blinov, Diogo Buarque Franzosi, Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Cari Cesarotti, Nathaniel Craig, Csaba Csáki, Raffaele Tito D'Agnolo, Jordy De Vries, Aldo Deandrea, Matthew J. Dolan, Patrick Draper, Gilly Elor, JiJi Fan , et al. (31 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: We summarize the state of Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) model building in particle physics for Snowmass 2021, focusing mainly on several whitepaper contributions to BSM model building (TF08) and closely related areas. We summarize the state of Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) model building in particle physics for Snowmass 2021, focusing mainly on several whitepaper contributions to BSM model building (TF08) and closely related areas. △ Less

Submitted 6 October, 2022; originally announced October 2022.

Comments: 44 pages, 1 figure, Submitted to the Proceedings of the US Community Study on the Future of Particle Physics (Snowmass 2021). Topical Group Report for TF08 - BSM Model Building

Report of the Topical Group on Physics Beyond the Standard Model at Energy Frontier for Snowmass 2021

Authors: Tulika Bose, Antonio Boveia, Caterina Doglioni, Simone Pagan Griso, James Hirschauer, Elliot Lipeles, Zhen Liu, Nausheen R. Shah, Lian-Tao Wang, Kaustubh Agashe, Juliette Alimena, Sebastian Baum, Mohamed Berkat, Kevin Black, Gwen Gardner, Tony Gherghetta, Josh Greaves, Maxx Haehn, Phil C. Harris, Robert Harris, Julie Hogan, Suneth Jayawardana, Abraham Kahn, Jan Kalinowski, Simon Knapen , et al. (297 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: This is the Snowmass2021 Energy Frontier (EF) Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) report. It combines the EF topical group reports of EF08 (Model-specific explorations), EF09 (More general explorations), and EF10 (Dark Matter at Colliders). The report includes a general introduction to BSM motivations and the comparative prospects for proposed future experiments for a broad range of potential BSM mode… ▽ More This is the Snowmass2021 Energy Frontier (EF) Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) report. It combines the EF topical group reports of EF08 (Model-specific explorations), EF09 (More general explorations), and EF10 (Dark Matter at Colliders). The report includes a general introduction to BSM motivations and the comparative prospects for proposed future experiments for a broad range of potential BSM models and signatures, including compositeness, SUSY, leptoquarks, more general new bosons and fermions, long-lived particles, dark matter, charged-lepton flavor violation, and anomaly detection. △ Less

Submitted 18 October, 2022; v1 submitted 26 September, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 108 pages + 38 pages references and appendix, 37 figures, Report of the Topical Group on Beyond the Standard Model Physics at Energy Frontier for Snowmass 2021. The first nine authors are the Conveners, with Contributions from the other authors

Prospects for heavy neutral SUSY Higgs scalars in the hMSSM and natural SUSY at LHC upgrades

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Xerxes Tata, Kairui Zhang

Abstract: We examine production and decay of heavy neutral SUSY Higgs bosons pp-> H,\ A -> τたう\barτたう within the hMSSM and compare against a perhaps more plausible natural supersymmetry scenario dubbed m_h^{125}({\rm nat}) which allows for a natural explanation for m_{weak}\simeq m_{W,Z,h}\sim 100 GeV while maintaining m_h\simeq 125 GeV. We evaluate signal against various Standard Model backgrounds from γがんま,Z ->τたう… ▽ More We examine production and decay of heavy neutral SUSY Higgs bosons pp-> H,\ A -> τたう\barτたう within the hMSSM and compare against a perhaps more plausible natural supersymmetry scenario dubbed m_h^{125}({\rm nat}) which allows for a natural explanation for m_{weak}\simeq m_{W,Z,h}\sim 100 GeV while maintaining m_h\simeq 125 GeV. We evaluate signal against various Standard Model backgrounds from γがんま,Z ->τたう\barτたう, t\bar{t} and vector boson pair production VV. We combine the transverse mass method for back-to-back (BtB) taus along with the ditau mass peak m_{τたうτたう} method for acollinear taus as our signal channels. This technique ultimately gives a boost to the signal significance over the standard technique of using just the BtB signal channel. We evaluate both the 95% CL exclusion and 5σしぐまdiscovery reach in the m_A vs. \tanβべーたplane for present LHC with 139 fb^{-1}, Run 3 with 300 fb^{-1} and high luminosity LHC (HL-LHC) with 3000 fb^{-1} of integrated luminosity. For \tanβべーた=10, the exclusion limits range up to m_A\sim 1, 1.1 and 1.4 TeV, respectively. These may be compared to the range of m_A values gleaned from a statistical analysis of the string landscape wherein m_A can range up to ~8 TeV. △ Less

Submitted 31 August, 2022; originally announced September 2022.

Comments: 24 pages with 38 .png figures

Report number: OU-HEP-220731

Fine-tuned vs. natural supersymmetry: what does the string landscape predict?

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dakotah Martinez, Shadman Salam

Abstract: A vast array of (metastable) vacuum solutions arise from string compactifications, each leading to different 4-d laws of physics. The space of these solutions, known as the string landscape, allows for an environmental solution to the cosmological constant problem. We examine the possibility of an environmental solution to the gauge hierarchy problem. We argue that the landscape favors softly brok… ▽ More A vast array of (metastable) vacuum solutions arise from string compactifications, each leading to different 4-d laws of physics. The space of these solutions, known as the string landscape, allows for an environmental solution to the cosmological constant problem. We examine the possibility of an environmental solution to the gauge hierarchy problem. We argue that the landscape favors softly broken supersymmetric models over particle physics models containing quadratic divergences, such as the Standard Model. We present a scheme for computing relative probabilities for supersymmetric models to emerge from the landscape. The probabilities are related to the likelihood that the derived value of the weak scale lies within the Agrawal et al. (ABDS) allowed window of values leading to atoms as we know them. This then favors natural SUSY models over unnatural (SUSY and other) models via a computable probability measure. △ Less

Submitted 5 September, 2022; v1 submitted 29 June, 2022; originally announced June 2022.

Comments: 19 pages with 3 .png figures; version 2 contains added figure and some clarifying text

Report number: OU-HEP-220702

On dark radiation from string moduli decay to ALPs

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Robert Wiley Deal

Abstract: We examine the issue of dark radiation (DR) from string moduli decay into axion-like particles (ALPs). In KKLT-type models of moduli stabilization, the axionlike phases of moduli fields are expected to decouple whilst in LVS-type moduli stabilization some can remain light and may constitute dark radiation. We evaluate modulus decay to Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) particles and dark… ▽ More We examine the issue of dark radiation (DR) from string moduli decay into axion-like particles (ALPs). In KKLT-type models of moduli stabilization, the axionlike phases of moduli fields are expected to decouple whilst in LVS-type moduli stabilization some can remain light and may constitute dark radiation. We evaluate modulus decay to Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) particles and dark radiation for more general compactifications. In spite of tightening error bars on ΔでるたN_{eff}, we find only mild constraints on modulus-ALP couplings due to the somewhat suppressed modulus branching fraction to DR owing to the large number of MSSM decay modes. We anticipate that future CMB experiments with greater precision on ΔでるたN_{eff} may still turn up evidence for DR if the ALP associated with the lightest modulus field is indeed light. △ Less

Submitted 3 April, 2022; originally announced April 2022.

Comments: 18 pages with 9 .png figures

Report number: OU-HEP-220401

The International Linear Collider: Report to Snowmass 2021

Authors: Alexander Aryshev, Ties Behnke, Mikael Berggren, James Brau, Nathaniel Craig, Ayres Freitas, Frank Gaede, Spencer Gessner, Stefania Gori, Christophe Grojean, Sven Heinemeyer, Daniel Jeans, Katja Kruger, Benno List, Jenny List, Zhen Liu, Shinichiro Michizono, David W. Miller, Ian Moult, Hitoshi Murayama, Tatsuya Nakada, Emilio Nanni, Mihoko Nojiri, Hasan Padamsee, Maxim Perelstein , et al. (487 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: The International Linear Collider (ILC) is on the table now as a new global energy-frontier accelerator laboratory taking data in the 2030s. The ILC addresses key questions for our current understanding of particle physics. It is based on a proven accelerator technology. Its experiments will challenge the Standard Model of particle physics and will provide a new window to look beyond it. This docu… ▽ More The International Linear Collider (ILC) is on the table now as a new global energy-frontier accelerator laboratory taking data in the 2030s. The ILC addresses key questions for our current understanding of particle physics. It is based on a proven accelerator technology. Its experiments will challenge the Standard Model of particle physics and will provide a new window to look beyond it. This document brings the story of the ILC up to date, emphasizing its strong physics motivation, its readiness for construction, and the opportunity it presents to the US and the global particle physics community. △ Less

Submitted 16 January, 2023; v1 submitted 14 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 356 pages, Large pdf file (40 MB) submitted to Snowmass 2021; v2 references to Snowmass contributions added, additional authors; v3 references added, some updates, additional authors

Report number: DESY-22-045, IFT--UAM/CSIC--22-028, KEK Preprint 2021-61, PNNL-SA-160884, SLAC-PUB-17662

Angular cuts to reduce the tautaubar+jet background to the higgsino signal at the LHC

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dibyashree Sengupta, Xerxes Tata

Abstract: We re-examine higgsino pair production in association with a hard QCD jet at the LHC. We focus on \ell^+\ell^- +MET +jet events from the production and subsequent decay, \tchi_2^0\to\tchi_1^0\ell^+\ell^-, of the heavier neutral higgsino. The novel feature of our analysis is that we propose angular cuts to reduce the irreducible background from Z(-> τたう\barτたう)+jet events more efficiently than the m_{τたう… ▽ More We re-examine higgsino pair production in association with a hard QCD jet at the LHC. We focus on \ell^+\ell^- +MET +jet events from the production and subsequent decay, \tchi_2^0\to\tchi_1^0\ell^+\ell^-, of the heavier neutral higgsino. The novel feature of our analysis is that we propose angular cuts to reduce the irreducible background from Z(-> τたう\barτたう)+jet events more efficiently than the m_{τたうτたう}^2<0 cut that has been used by the ATLAS and CMS collaborations. Additional cuts, needed to reduce backgrounds from t\bar{t}, WWj and W/Z+\ell\bar{\ell} production, are also delineated. We evaluate the reach of LHC14 for 300 and 3000~fb^{-1} and stress that the dilepton mass distribution would serve to characterize the higgsino signal. △ Less

Submitted 7 March, 2022; originally announced March 2022.

Comments: 17 pages plus 13 .png figures; contribution to Snowmass 2021

Report number: UH-511-1324-22

Mini-review: Expectations for supersymmetry from the string landscape

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Shadman Salam, Dibyashree Sengupta

Abstract: In this mini-review, we summarize a variety of findings pertaining to consequences of the landscape of string theory for supersymmetry (SUSY) phenomenology. The idea is to adopt the MSSM as the most parsimonious 4-d low energy EFT after string compactification but where the scale of SUSY breaking is as yet undetermined. A power-law landscape draw to large soft terms is tempered by the requirement… ▽ More In this mini-review, we summarize a variety of findings pertaining to consequences of the landscape of string theory for supersymmetry (SUSY) phenomenology. The idea is to adopt the MSSM as the most parsimonious 4-d low energy EFT after string compactification but where the scale of SUSY breaking is as yet undetermined. A power-law landscape draw to large soft terms is tempered by the requirement that the derived value of the weak scale lie within the anthropic window of Agrawal {\it et al.} (ABDS). Such a set-up predicts a light Higgs mass m_h~ 125 GeV with sparticles generally beyond LHC bounds. We discuss consequences for LHC searches: light higgsinos, highly mixed TeV-scale top squarks, same-sign diboson events and m_{\tg}~ 2-5 TeV. We expect dark matter to consist of an axion/higgsino-like WIMP admixture. △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2022; v1 submitted 23 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 19 pages plus 14 figures; submitted as contribution to Snowmass 2022 TF01/TF08 groups; version 2 includes improved readability of figures

Report number: OU-HEP-220301

Radiative natural supersymmetry emergent from the string landscape

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dakotah Martinez, Shadman Salam

Abstract: In string theory with flux compactifications, anthropic selection for structure formation from a discretuum of vacuum energy values provides at present our only understanding of the tiny yet positive value of the cosmological constant. We apply similar reasoning to a toy model of the multiverse restricted to vacua with the MSSM as the low energy effective theory. Here, one expects a statistical se… ▽ More In string theory with flux compactifications, anthropic selection for structure formation from a discretuum of vacuum energy values provides at present our only understanding of the tiny yet positive value of the cosmological constant. We apply similar reasoning to a toy model of the multiverse restricted to vacua with the MSSM as the low energy effective theory. Here, one expects a statistical selection favoring large soft SUSY breaking terms leading to a derived value of the weak scale in each pocket universe (with appropriate electroweak symmetry breaking) which differs from the weak scale as measured in our universe. In contrast, the SUSY preserving μみゅーparameter is selected uniformly on a log scale as is consistent with the distribution of SM fermion masses: this favors smaller values of μみゅー. An anthropic selection of the weak scale to within a factor of a few of our measured value -- in order to produce complex nuclei as we know them (atomic principle) -- provides statistical predictions for Higgs and sparticle masses in accord with LHC measurements. The statistical selection then more often leads to (radiatively-driven) {\it natural} SUSY models over the Standard Model or finely-tuned SUSY models such as mSUGRA/CMSSM, split, mini-split, spread, high scale or PeV SUSY. The predicted Higgs and superparticle spectra might be testable at HL-LHC via higgsino pair production but is certainly testable at higher energy hadron colliders with \sqrt{s}~ 30-100 TeV. △ Less

Submitted 13 June, 2022; v1 submitted 14 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Comments: 21 pages with 13 .png figures; version 2 includes corrected Fig. 9

Report number: OU-HEP-220204

The cosmological moduli problem and naturalness

Authors: Kyu Jung Bae, Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Robert Wiley Deal

Abstract: The cosmological moduli problem (CMP) comes in three parts: 1. potential violation of BBN constraints from late decaying moduli fields, 2. the moduli-induced gravitino problem wherein gravitinos are overproduced and 3. the moduli-induced lightest SUSY particle (LSP) overproduction problem. We examine the cosmological moduli problem and its connection to electroweak naturalness. We calculate the va… ▽ More The cosmological moduli problem (CMP) comes in three parts: 1. potential violation of BBN constraints from late decaying moduli fields, 2. the moduli-induced gravitino problem wherein gravitinos are overproduced and 3. the moduli-induced lightest SUSY particle (LSP) overproduction problem. We examine the cosmological moduli problem and its connection to electroweak naturalness. We calculate the various two-body decay widths of a light modulus field into MSSM particles and gravitinos within general supersymmetric models. We include both phase space and mixing effects. We examine cases without and with helicity suppression of modulus decays to gravitinos (cases 1 & 2) and/or gauginos (cases A & B). For case B1, we evaluate regions of gravitino mass m_{3/2} vs. modulus mass m_φふぁいparameter space constrained by BBN, by overproduction of gravitinos and by overproduction of neutralino dark matter, along with connections to naturalness. For this case, essentially all of parameter space is excluded unless m_φふぁい>~ 2.5\times 10^3 TeV with m_φふぁい<2m_{3/2}. For a potentially most propitious case B2 with φふぁいdecay to Higgs and matter turned off, then modulus branching fractions to SUSY and to gravitinos become highly suppressed at large m_φふぁい. But since the modulus number density increases faster than the branching fractions decrease, there is still gross overproduction of neutralino dark matter. We also show that in this scenario the thermally produced gravitino problem is fixed by huge entropy dilution, but non-thermal gravitino production from moduli decay remains a huge problem unless it is kinematically suppressed with m_φふぁい< 2m_{3/2}. In a pedagogical appendix, we present detailed calculations of modulus field two-body decay widths. △ Less

Submitted 2 February, 2022; v1 submitted 17 January, 2022; originally announced January 2022.

Comments: 73 pages with 15 .png figures; revised version contains added discussion plus 16th figure and added references

Report number: OU-HEP-211030

Detecting Heavy Higgs Bosons from Natural SUSY at a 100 TeV Hadron Collider

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Rishabh Jain, Chung Kao, Dibyashree Sengupta, Xerxes Tata

Abstract: Supersymmetric models with radiatively-driven naturalness (RNS) enjoy low electroweak fine-tuning whilst respecting LHC search limits on gluinos and top squarks and allowing for $m_h\simeq 125$ GeV. While the heavier Higgs bosons $H,\ A$ may have TeV-scale masses, the SUSY conserving $μみゅー$ parameter must lie in the few hundred GeV range. Thus, in natural SUSY models there should occur large heavy Hi… ▽ More Supersymmetric models with radiatively-driven naturalness (RNS) enjoy low electroweak fine-tuning whilst respecting LHC search limits on gluinos and top squarks and allowing for $m_h\simeq 125$ GeV. While the heavier Higgs bosons $H,\ A$ may have TeV-scale masses, the SUSY conserving $μみゅー$ parameter must lie in the few hundred GeV range. Thus, in natural SUSY models there should occur large heavy Higgs boson branching fractions to electroweakinos, with Higgs boson decays to higgsino plus gaugino dominating when they are kinematically accessible. These SUSY decays can open up new avenues for discovery. We investigate the prospects of discovering heavy neutral Higgs bosons $H$ and $A$ decaying into light plus heavy chargino pairs which can yield a four isolated lepton plus missing transverse energy signature at the LHC and at a future 100 TeV $pp$ collider. We find that discovery of heavy Higgs decay to electroweakinos via its $4\ell$ decay mode is very difficult at HL-LHC. For FCC-hh or SPPC, we study the $H,\ A \to $ SUSY reaction along with dominant physics backgrounds from the Standard Model and devise suitable selection requirements to extract a clean signal for FCC-hh or SPPC with $\sqrt{s}=100$ TeV, assuming an integrated luminosity of 15 $ab^{-1}$. We find that while a conventional cut-and-count analysis yields a signal statistical significance greater than $5σしぐま$ for $m_{A,H}\sim 1.1-1.65$ TeV, a boosted-decision-tree analysis allows for heavy Higgs signal discovery at FCC-hh or SPPC for $m_{A,H}\sim 1-2$ TeV. △ Less

Submitted 4 May, 2022; v1 submitted 3 December, 2021; originally announced December 2021.

Comments: 20 pages, 11 figures Substantial revision in version.2 includes heavy Higgs boson production from bottom quark fusion processes. Results and conclusions are considerably changed from version.1

Report number: OU-HEP-211202

An anthropic solution to the cosmological moduli problem

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Robert Wiley Deal

Abstract: Light moduli fields, gravitationally coupled scalar fields with no classical potential and which are expected to emerge as remnants from string theory compactification, are dangerous to cosmology in that 1. their late-time decays may disrupt successful Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN), 2. they may decay into gravitino pairs which result in violation of BBN constraints or overproduction of lightest S… ▽ More Light moduli fields, gravitationally coupled scalar fields with no classical potential and which are expected to emerge as remnants from string theory compactification, are dangerous to cosmology in that 1. their late-time decays may disrupt successful Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN), 2. they may decay into gravitino pairs which result in violation of BBN constraints or overproduction of lightest SUSY particles (LSPs, assumed to constitute at least a portion of the dark matter in the universe) and 3. they may decay directly into LSPs, resulting in gross DM overproduction. Together, these constitute the cosmological moduli problem (CMP). The combined effects require lightest modulus mass m_φふぁい>~10^4 TeV, and if the lightest modulus mass m_φふぁいis correlated with the SUSY breaking scale m_{3/2}, then the underlying SUSY model would be highly unnatural. We present a solution to the CMP wherein the lightest modulus initial field strength φふぁい_0 is anthropically selected to be φふぁい_0\sim 10^{-7}m_P by the requirement that the dark matter-to-baryonic matter ratio be not-too-far removed from its present value so that sufficient baryons are present in the universe to create observers. In this case, instead of dark matter overproduction via neutralino reannihilation at the modulus decay temperature, the neutralinos inherit the reduced moduli number density, thereby gaining accord with the measured dark matter relic density. △ Less

Submitted 22 December, 2021; v1 submitted 10 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 12 pages plus 5 .png figures; version 2 contains new Fig. 4 with added text

Report number: OU-HEP-211110

Comparison of SUSY spectra generators for natural SUSY and string landscape predictions

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dakotah Martinez

Abstract: Models of natural supersymmetry give rise to a weak scale m_{weak}~m_{W,Z,h}~ 100 GeV without any (implausible) finetuning of independent contributions to the weak scale. These models, which exhibit radiatively driven naturalness (RNS), are expected to arise from statistical analysis of the string landscape wherein large soft terms are favored, but subject to a not-too-large value of the derived w… ▽ More Models of natural supersymmetry give rise to a weak scale m_{weak}~m_{W,Z,h}~ 100 GeV without any (implausible) finetuning of independent contributions to the weak scale. These models, which exhibit radiatively driven naturalness (RNS), are expected to arise from statistical analysis of the string landscape wherein large soft terms are favored, but subject to a not-too-large value of the derived weak scale in each pocket universe of the greater multiverse. The string landscape picture then predicts, using the Isajet SUSY spectra generator Isasugra, a statistical peak at m_h~ 125 GeV with sparticles generally beyond current LHC search limits. In this paper, we investigate how well these conclusions hold up using other popular spectra generators: SOFTSUSY, SPHENO and SUSPECT (SSS). We built a computer code DEW4SLHA which operates on SUSY Les Houches Accord files to calculate the associated electroweak naturalness measure Δでるた_{EW}. The SSS generators tend to yield a Higgs mass peak ~125-127 GeV with a superparticle mass spectra rather similar to that generated by Isasugra. In an Appendix, we include loop corrections to Δでるた_{EW} in a more standard notation. △ Less

Submitted 17 January, 2022; v1 submitted 4 November, 2021; originally announced November 2021.

Comments: 27 pages with 19 .png figures; version 2 includes some 2-loop corrections; version 3 includes some minor text additions to be in accord with published version

Report number: OU-HEP-211130

New angular (and other) cuts to improve the higgsino signal at the LHC

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dibyashree Sengupta, Xerxes Tata

Abstract: Motivated by the fact that naturalness arguments strongly suggest that the SUSY-preserving higgsino mass parameter mu cannot be too far above the weak scale, we re-examine higgsino pair production in association with a hard QCD jet at the HL-LHC. We focus on \ell^+\ell^-+\eslt+j events from the production and subsequent decay, \tchi_2^0\to\tchi_1^0\ell^+\ell^-, of the heavier neutral higgsino. The… ▽ More Motivated by the fact that naturalness arguments strongly suggest that the SUSY-preserving higgsino mass parameter mu cannot be too far above the weak scale, we re-examine higgsino pair production in association with a hard QCD jet at the HL-LHC. We focus on \ell^+\ell^-+\eslt+j events from the production and subsequent decay, \tchi_2^0\to\tchi_1^0\ell^+\ell^-, of the heavier neutral higgsino. The novel feature of our analysis is that we suggest angular cuts to reduce the important background from Z(\to τたうτたう)+j events more efficiently than the m_{τたうτたう}^2<0 cut that has been used by the ATLAS and CMS collaborations. Other cuts, needed to reduce backgrounds from t\bar{t}, WWj and W/Z+\ell\bar{\ell} production, are also delineated. We plot out the reach of LHC14 for 300 and 3000~fb^{-1} and also show distributions that serve to characterize the higgsino signal, noting that higgsinos may well be the only superpartners accessible at LHC14 in a well-motivated class of natural SUSY models. △ Less

Submitted 20 April, 2022; v1 submitted 28 September, 2021; originally announced September 2021.

Comments: 33 pages including 26 .png figures; version 2 has minor typo changes to coincide with published version

Report number: OU-HEP-210330

Anomalous muon magnetic moment, supersymmetry, naturalness, LHC search limits and the landscape

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Hasan Serce

Abstract: The recent measurement of the muon anomalous magnetic moment a_μみゅー\equiv (g-2)_μみゅー/2 by the Fermilab Muon g-2 experiment sharpens an earlier discrepancy between theory and the BNL E821 experiment. We examine the predicted Δでるたa_μみゅー\equiv a_μみゅー(exp)-a_μみゅー(th) in the context of supersymmetry with low electroweak naturalness (restricting to models which give a plausible explanation for the magnitude of the weak s… ▽ More The recent measurement of the muon anomalous magnetic moment a_μみゅー\equiv (g-2)_μみゅー/2 by the Fermilab Muon g-2 experiment sharpens an earlier discrepancy between theory and the BNL E821 experiment. We examine the predicted Δでるたa_μみゅー\equiv a_μみゅー(exp)-a_μみゅー(th) in the context of supersymmetry with low electroweak naturalness (restricting to models which give a plausible explanation for the magnitude of the weak scale). A global analysis including LHC Higgs mass and sparticle search limits points to interpretation within the normal scalar mass hierarchy (NSMH) SUSY model wherein first/second generation matter scalars are much lighter than third generation scalars. We present a benchmark model for a viable NSMH point which is natural, obeys LHC Higgs and sparticle mass constraints and explains the muon magnetic anomaly. Aside from NSMH models, then we find the (g-2)_μみゅーanomaly cannot be explained within the context of natural SUSY, where a variety of data point to decoupled first/second generation scalars. The situation is worse within the string landscape where first/second generation matter scalars are pulled to values in the 10-50 TeV range. An alternative interpretation for SUSY models with decoupled scalar masses is that perhaps the recent lattice evaluation of the hadronic vacuum polarization could be confirmed which leads to a Standard Model theory-experiment agreement in which case there is no anomaly. △ Less

Submitted 16 May, 2021; v1 submitted 15 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 20 pages with 4 .png figures; v2, self-energies stabilized, references added

Report number: OU-HEP-210415

Distribution of supersymmetry mu parameter and Peccei-Quinn scale f_a from the landscape

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dibyashree Sengupta, Robert Wiley Deal

Abstract: A scan of soft SUSY breaking parameters within the string theory landscape with the MSSM assumed as the low energy effective field theory -- using a power-law draw to large soft terms coupled with an anthropic selection of a derived weak scale to be within a factor four of our measured value -- predicts a peak probability of m_h~125 GeV with sparticles masses typically beyond the reach of LHC Run… ▽ More A scan of soft SUSY breaking parameters within the string theory landscape with the MSSM assumed as the low energy effective field theory -- using a power-law draw to large soft terms coupled with an anthropic selection of a derived weak scale to be within a factor four of our measured value -- predicts a peak probability of m_h~125 GeV with sparticles masses typically beyond the reach of LHC Run 2. Such multiverse simulations usually assume a fixed value of the SUSY conserving superpotential mu parameter to be within the assumed anthropic range, mu<~ 350 GeV. However, depending on the assumed solution to the SUSY mu problem, the expected mu term distribution can actually be derived. In this paper, we examine two solutions to the SUSY mu problem. The first is the gravity-safe-Peccei-Quinn (GSPQ) model based on an assumed Z_{24}^R discrete R-symmetry which allows a gravity-safe accidental, approximate Peccei-Quinn global symmetry to emerge which also solves the strong CP problem. The second case is the Giudice-Masiero solution wherein the mu term effectively acts as a soft term and has a linear draw to large values. For the first case, we also present the expected landscape distribution for the PQ scale f_a; in this case, weak scale anthropics limits its range to the cosmological sweet zone of around f_a~ 10^{11} GeV. △ Less

Submitted 8 April, 2021; originally announced April 2021.

Comments: 19 pages including 11 .png figures

Report number: OU-HEP-210403

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 104, 015037 (2021)

Sparticle and Higgs boson masses from the landscape: dynamical versus spontaneous supersymmetry breaking

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Shadman Salam, Hasan Serce

Abstract: Perturbative supersymmetry breaking on the landscape of string vacua is expected to favor large soft terms as a power-law or log distribution, but tempered by an anthropic veto of inappropriate vacua or vacua leading to too large a value for the derived weak scale -- a violation of the atomic principle. Indeed, scans of such vacua yield a statistical prediction for light Higgs boson mass m_h~ 125… ▽ More Perturbative supersymmetry breaking on the landscape of string vacua is expected to favor large soft terms as a power-law or log distribution, but tempered by an anthropic veto of inappropriate vacua or vacua leading to too large a value for the derived weak scale -- a violation of the atomic principle. Indeed, scans of such vacua yield a statistical prediction for light Higgs boson mass m_h~ 125 GeV with sparticles (save possibly light higgsinos) typically beyond LHC reach. In contrast, models of dynamical SUSY breaking (DSB) -- with a hidden sector gauge coupling g^2 scanned uniformly -- lead to gaugino condensation and a uniform distribution of soft parameters on a log scale. Then soft terms are expected to be distributed as $m_{\rm soft}^{-1}$ favoring small values. A scan of DSB soft terms generally leads to $m_h\ll 125$ GeV and sparticle masses usually below LHC limits. Thus, the DSB landscape scenario seems excluded from LHC search results. An alternative is that the exponential suppression of the weak scale is set anthropically on the landscape via the atomic principle. △ Less

Submitted 22 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 14 pages, 11 .png figures

Report number: OU-HEP-210322

Landscape Higgs and sparticle mass predictions from a logarithmic soft term distribution

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Shadman Salam, Dibyashree Sengupta

Abstract: Recent work on calculating string theory landscape statistical predictions for the Higgs and sparticle mass spectrum from an assumed power-law soft term distribution yields an expectation for m(h)~ 125 GeV with sparticles (save light higgsinos) somewhat beyond reach of high-luminosity LHC. A recent examination of statistics of SUSY breaking in IIB string models with stabilized moduli suggests a po… ▽ More Recent work on calculating string theory landscape statistical predictions for the Higgs and sparticle mass spectrum from an assumed power-law soft term distribution yields an expectation for m(h)~ 125 GeV with sparticles (save light higgsinos) somewhat beyond reach of high-luminosity LHC. A recent examination of statistics of SUSY breaking in IIB string models with stabilized moduli suggests a power-law for models based on KKLT stabilization and uplifting while models based on large-volume scenario (LVS) instead yield an expected logarithmic soft term distribution. We evaluate statistical distributions for Higgs and sparticle masses from the landscape with a log soft term distribution and find the Higgs mass still peaks around ~125 GeV with sparticles beyond LHC reach, albeit with somewhat softer distributions than those arising from a power-law. △ Less

Submitted 17 February, 2021; v1 submitted 8 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Comments: version 2 contains improved statistics for figures along with some minor text changes; published version in PRD is still version 1; 17 pages plus 16 .png figures

Report number: OU-HEP-201104

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 103, 035031 (2021)

The LHC higgsino discovery plane for present and future SUSY searches

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Shadman Salam, Dibyashree Sengupta, Xerxes Tata

Abstract: Considerations from electroweak naturalness and stringy naturalness imply a little hierarchy in supersymmetric models where the superpotential higgsino mass parameter mu is of order the weak scale whilst the soft SUSY breaking terms may be in the (multi-) TeV range. In such a case, discovery of SUSY at LHC may be most likely in the higgsino pair production channel. Indeed, ATLAS and CMS are perfor… ▽ More Considerations from electroweak naturalness and stringy naturalness imply a little hierarchy in supersymmetric models where the superpotential higgsino mass parameter mu is of order the weak scale whilst the soft SUSY breaking terms may be in the (multi-) TeV range. In such a case, discovery of SUSY at LHC may be most likely in the higgsino pair production channel. Indeed, ATLAS and CMS are performing searches in the higgsino mass discovery plane of m(chi_2^0) vs. Δでるたm^0 = m(chi_2^0)-m(chi_1^0). We examine several theoretical aspects of this discovery plane in both the gravity-mediation NUHM2 model and the general mirage-mediation (GMM') models. These include: the associated chargino mass m(chi_1^+), the expected regions of the bottom-up notion of electroweak naturalness Δでるた_{EW}, and the expected regions of stringy naturalness. While compatibility with electroweak naturalness allows for mass gaps Δでるたm^0~ 4-20 GeV, stringy naturalness exhibits a clear preference for yet smaller mass gaps of 4-10 GeV. For still smaller mass gaps, the plane becomes sharply unnatural since very large gaugino masses are required. This study informs the most promising SUSY search channels and parameter space regions for the upcoming HL-LHC runs and possible HE-LHC option. △ Less

Submitted 12 September, 2020; v1 submitted 17 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Comments: 16 pages + 3 two-part figures; version 2 updated to coincide with journal copy

Report number: OU-HEP-200730

A string landscape guide to soft SUSY breaking terms

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Shadman Salam, Dibyashree Sengupta

Abstract: We examine several issues pertaining to statistical predictivity of the string theory landscape for weak scale supersymmetry (SUSY). We work within a predictive landscape wherein super-renormalizable terms scan while renormalizable terms do not. We require stringy naturalness wherein the likelihood of values for observables is proportional to their frequency within a fertile patch of landscape inc… ▽ More We examine several issues pertaining to statistical predictivity of the string theory landscape for weak scale supersymmetry (SUSY). We work within a predictive landscape wherein super-renormalizable terms scan while renormalizable terms do not. We require stringy naturalness wherein the likelihood of values for observables is proportional to their frequency within a fertile patch of landscape including the MSSM as low energy effective theory with a pocket-universe value for the weak scale nearby to its measured value in our universe. In the string theory landscape, it is reasonable that the soft terms enjoy a statistical power-law draw to large values, subject to the existence of atoms as we know them (atomic principle). We argue that gaugino masses, scalar masses and trilinear soft terms should each scan independently. In addition, the various scalars should scan independently of each other unless protected by some symmetry. The expected non-universality of scalar masses-- once regarded as an undesirable feature-- emerges as an asset within the context of the string landscape picture. In models such as heterotic compactifications on Calabi-Yau manifolds, where the tree-level gauge kinetic function depends only on the dilaton, then gaugino masses may scale mildly, while scalar masses and A-terms, which depend on all the moduli, may scale much more strongly leading to a landscape solution to the SUSY flavor and CP problems in spite of non-diagonal Kähler metrics. We present numerical results for Higgs and sparticle mass predictions from the landscape within the generalized mirage mediation SUSY model and discuss resulting consequences for LHC SUSY and WIMP dark matter searches. △ Less

Submitted 27 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: 27pages with 11 frames of figures

Report number: OU-HEP-200430

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 102, 075012 (2020)

Midi-review: Status of weak scale supersymmetry after LHC Run 2 and ton-scale noble liquid WIMP searches

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Shadman Salam, Dibyashree Sengupta, Kuver Sinha

Abstract: While LHC has discovered a very Standard Model-like Higgs boson of mass m_h~ 125 GeV, no solid signal for physics beyond the Standard Model has emerged so far at LHC or at WIMP seach experiments. For the case of weak scale supersymmetry (SUSY), LHC has found rather generally that gluinos are beyond about 2.2 TeV whilst top squark must lie beyond 1.1 TeV. These limits contradict older simplistic no… ▽ More While LHC has discovered a very Standard Model-like Higgs boson of mass m_h~ 125 GeV, no solid signal for physics beyond the Standard Model has emerged so far at LHC or at WIMP seach experiments. For the case of weak scale supersymmetry (SUSY), LHC has found rather generally that gluinos are beyond about 2.2 TeV whilst top squark must lie beyond 1.1 TeV. These limits contradict older simplistic notions of naturalness that emerged in the 1980s-1990s, leading to the rather pessimistic view that SUSY is now excluded except for perhaps some remaining narrow corners of parameter space. Yet, this picture ignores several important developments in SUSY/string theory that emerged in the 21st century: 1. the emergence of the string theory landscape and its solution to the cosmological constant problem, 2. a more nuanced view of naturalness including the notion of "stringy naturalness", 3. the emergence of anomaly-free discrete R-symmetries and their connection to R-parity, Peccei-Quinn symmetry, the SUSY mu problem and proton decay and 4. the importance of including a solution to the strong CP problem. Rather general considerations from the string theory landscape favor large values of soft terms, subject to the vacuum selection criteria that electroweak symmetry is properly broken (no CCB minima) and the resulting magnitude of the weak scale is not too far from our measured value. Then stringy naturalness predicts a Higgs mass m_h~ 125 GeV whilst sparticle masses are typically lifted beyond present LHC bounds. In light of these refinements in theory perspective confronted by LHC and dark matter search results, we review the most likely LHC, ILC and dark matter signatures that are expected to arise from weak scale SUSY as we understand it today. △ Less

Submitted 10 November, 2020; v1 submitted 7 February, 2020; originally announced February 2020.

Comments: 47 pages; version 2 includes typo fixes and some added discussion; version 3 contains minor re-wording on weak scale limits from Agrawal et al

Report number: OU-HEP-191231

The ILC as a natural SUSY discovery machine and precision microscope: from light higgsinos to tests of unification

Authors: Howard Baer, Mikael Berggren, Keisuke Fujii, Jenny List, Suvi-Leena Lehtinen, Tomohiko Tanabe, Jacqueline Yan

Abstract: The requirement of electroweak naturalness in simple supersymmetric models implies the existence of a cluster of four light higgsinos with mass $\sim 100-300$\,GeV, the lighter the better. While such light compressed spectra may be challenging to observe at LHC, the International Linear $e^+e^-$ Collider (ILC) with $\sqrt{s}>2m_{\rm higgsino}$ would serve as both a SUSY discovery machine and a pre… ▽ More The requirement of electroweak naturalness in simple supersymmetric models implies the existence of a cluster of four light higgsinos with mass $\sim 100-300$\,GeV, the lighter the better. While such light compressed spectra may be challenging to observe at LHC, the International Linear $e^+e^-$ Collider (ILC) with $\sqrt{s}>2m_{\rm higgsino}$ would serve as both a SUSY discovery machine and a precision microscope. We study higgsino pair production signatures at the ILC based on full, \texttt{Geant4-}based simulation of the ILD detector concept. We examine several benchmark scenarios that may be challenging for discovery at HL-LHC due to mass differences between the higgsino states between $20$ and $4$\,GeV. Assuming $\sqrt{s}= 500$\,GeV and 1000\,fb$^{-1}$ of integrated luminosity, the individual higgsino masses can be measured to $1-2\%$ precision in case of the larger mass differences, and at the level of $5\%$ for the smallest mass difference case. The higgsino mass splittings are sensitive to the electroweak gaugino masses and allow extraction of gaugino masses to $\sim 3-20\%$ (depending on the model). Extrapolation of gaugino masses via renormalization group running can test the hypothesis of gaugino mass unification. We also examine a case with natural generalized mirage mediation where the unification of gaugino masses at an intermediate scale apparently gives rise to a natural SUSY spectrum somewhat beyond the reach of HL-LHC. △ Less

Submitted 13 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 43 pages, 33 figures

Report number: ILD-PHYS--2019--001, DESY 19-227, KEK Preprint 2019-53

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 101, 095026 (2020)

Mirage mediation from the landscape

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dibyashree Sengupta

Abstract: Rather general considerations from the string theory landscape suggest a statistical preference within the multiverse for soft SUSY breaking terms as large as possible subject to a pocket universe value for the weak scale not greater than a factor of 2-5 from our measured value. Within the gravity/moduli-mediated SUSY breaking framework, the Higgs mass is pulled to m_h~ 125 GeV while first/second… ▽ More Rather general considerations from the string theory landscape suggest a statistical preference within the multiverse for soft SUSY breaking terms as large as possible subject to a pocket universe value for the weak scale not greater than a factor of 2-5 from our measured value. Within the gravity/moduli-mediated SUSY breaking framework, the Higgs mass is pulled to m_h~ 125 GeV while first/second generation scalars are pulled to tens of TeV scale and gauginos and third generation scalars remain at the few TeV range. In this case, one then expects comparable moduli- and anomaly-mediated contributions to soft terms, leading to mirage mediation. For an assumed stringy natural value of the SUSY mu parameter, we evaluate predicted sparticle mass spectra for mirage mediation from a statistical scan of the string landscape. We then expect a compressed spectrum of gauginos along with a higgsino-like LSP. For a linear (quadratic) statistical draw with gravitino mass m_{3/2}~ 20 TeV, then the most probable mirage scale is predicted to be around μみゅー_{mir}~10^{13} (10^{14}) GeV. SUSY should appear at high-luminosity LHC via higgsino pair production into soft dilepton pairs. Distinguishing mirage mediation from models with unified gaugino masses may have to await construction of an ILC with \sqrt{s}>2m(higgsino). △ Less

Submitted 3 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Comments: 25 pages, 19 figures

Report number: OU-HEP-191104

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 2, 013346 (2020)

A landscape solution to the SUSY flavor and CP problems

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dibyashree Sengupta

Abstract: In a fertile patch of the string landscape which includes the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) as the low energy effective theory, rather general arguments from Douglas suggest a power-law statistical selection of soft breaking terms (m(soft)^n where n=2n_F+n_D-1 with n_F the number of hidden sector F-SUSY breaking fields and n_D the number of D-term SUSY breaking fields). The statisti… ▽ More In a fertile patch of the string landscape which includes the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) as the low energy effective theory, rather general arguments from Douglas suggest a power-law statistical selection of soft breaking terms (m(soft)^n where n=2n_F+n_D-1 with n_F the number of hidden sector F-SUSY breaking fields and n_D the number of D-term SUSY breaking fields). The statistical draw towards large soft terms must be tempered by requiring an appropriate breakdown of electroweak (EW) symmetry with no contributions to the weak scale larger than a factor 2-5 of its measured value, lest one violates the (anthropic) atomic principle. Such a simple picture of stringy naturalness generates a light Higgs boson with mass m_h~ 125 GeV with sparticles (other than higgsinos) typically beyond LHC reach. Then we expect first and second generation matter scalars to be drawn independently to the tens of TeV regime where the upper cutoff arises from two-loop RGE terms which drive third generation soft masses towards tachyonic values. Since the upper bounds on m_0(1,2) are the same for each generation, and flavor independent, then these will be drawn toward quasi-degenerate values. This mechanism leads to a natural mixed decoupling/quasi-degeneracy solution to the SUSY flavor problem and a decoupling solution to the SUSY CP problem. △ Less

Submitted 30 September, 2019; originally announced October 2019.

Comments: 18 pages with 8 .png figures

Report number: OU-HEP-190930

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 1, 033179 (2019)

Lepton flavor violation from SUSY with non-universal scalars

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Hasan Serce

Abstract: Right-handed neutrinos in supersymmetric models can act as the source of lepton flavor violation (LFV). We present experimental implications of lepton flavor-violating processes within a supersymmetric type-I seesaw framework in the three-extra-parameter non-universal Higgs model (NUHM3) for large (PMNS-like) and small (CKM-like) Yukawa mixing scenarios. We highlight LFV predictions for the natura… ▽ More Right-handed neutrinos in supersymmetric models can act as the source of lepton flavor violation (LFV). We present experimental implications of lepton flavor-violating processes within a supersymmetric type-I seesaw framework in the three-extra-parameter non-universal Higgs model (NUHM3) for large (PMNS-like) and small (CKM-like) Yukawa mixing scenarios. We highlight LFV predictions for the natural (low $Δでるた_{\rm EW}$) portion of parameter space. Our numerical analysis includes full 2-loop renormalization group running effects for the three neutrino masses and mass matrices. We show the projected discovery reach of various LFV experiments ($\textit{i.e.}$ Mu2e, Mu3e, MEG-II, Belle-II), and specify regions that have already been excluded by the LHC searches. Our results depend strongly on whether one has a normal sneutrino hierarchy (NSH) or an inverted sneutrino hierarchy (ISH). Natural SUSY with a NSH is already excluded by MEG-2013 results while large portions of ISH have been or will soon be tested. However, LFV processes from natural SUSY with small Yukawa mixing and an ISH seem below any projected sensitivities. A substantial amount of the remaining parameter space of models with large PMNS-like sneutrino mixing will be probed by Mu2e and MEG-II experiments whereas small, CKM-like Yukawa mixing predicts LFV decays which can hide from LFV experiments. △ Less

Submitted 15 July, 2019; originally announced July 2019.

Comments: 18 pages, 9 figures

Report number: OU-HEP-190715

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 1, 033022 (2019)

Naturalness versus stringy naturalness (with implications for collider and dark matter searches)

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Shadman Salam

Abstract: The notion of stringy naturalness-- that an observable O_2 is more natural than O_1 if more (phenomenologically acceptable) vacua solutions lead to O_2 rather than O_1-- is examined within the context of the Standard Model (SM) and various SUSY extensions: CMSSM/mSUGRA, high-scale SUSY and radiatively-driven natural SUSY (RNS). Rather general arguments from string theory suggest a (possibly mild… ▽ More The notion of stringy naturalness-- that an observable O_2 is more natural than O_1 if more (phenomenologically acceptable) vacua solutions lead to O_2 rather than O_1-- is examined within the context of the Standard Model (SM) and various SUSY extensions: CMSSM/mSUGRA, high-scale SUSY and radiatively-driven natural SUSY (RNS). Rather general arguments from string theory suggest a (possibly mild) statistical draw towards vacua with large soft SUSY breaking terms. These vacua must be tempered by an anthropic veto of non-standard vacua or vacua with too large a value of the weak scale m(weak). We argue that the SM, the CMSSM and the various high-scale SUSY models are all expected to be relatively rare occurances within the string theory landscape of vacua. In contrast, models with TeV-scale soft terms but with m(weak)~100 GeV and consequent light higgsinos (SUSY with radiatively-driven naturalness) should be much more common on the landscape. These latter models have a statistical preference for m_h~ 125 GeV and strongly interacting sparticles beyond current LHC reach. Thus, while conventional naturalness favors sparticles close to the weak scale, stringy naturalness favors sparticles so heavy that electroweak symmetry is barely broken and one is living dangerously close to vacua with charge-or-color breaking minima, no electroweak breaking or pocket universe weak scale values too far from our measured value. Expectations for how landscape SUSY would manifest itself at collider and dark matter search experiments are then modified compared to usual notions. △ Less

Submitted 21 July, 2020; v1 submitted 18 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: 25 pages, 9 figures; v2 includes stau coannihilation region in Fig. 8a

Report number: OU-HEP-190617

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Research 1, 023001 (2019)

Is the magnitude of the Peccei-Quinn scale set by the landscape?

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dibyashree Sengupta, Hasan Serce, Kuver Sinha, Robert Wiley Deal

Abstract: Rather general considerations of the string theory landscape imply a mild statistical draw towards large soft SUSY breaking terms tempered by the requirement of proper electroweak symmetry breaking where SUSY contributions to the weak scale are not too far from m(weak)~ 100 GeV. Such a picture leads to the prediction that m_h~ 125 GeV while most sparticles are beyond current LHC reach. Here we exp… ▽ More Rather general considerations of the string theory landscape imply a mild statistical draw towards large soft SUSY breaking terms tempered by the requirement of proper electroweak symmetry breaking where SUSY contributions to the weak scale are not too far from m(weak)~ 100 GeV. Such a picture leads to the prediction that m_h~ 125 GeV while most sparticles are beyond current LHC reach. Here we explore the possibility that the magnitude of the Peccei-Quinn (PQ) scale f_a is also set by string landscape considerations within the framework of a compelling SUSY axion model. First, we examine the case where the PQ symmetry arises as an accidental approximate global symmetry from a more fundamental gravity-safe Z(24)^R symmetry and where the SUSY mu parameter arises from a Kim-Nilles operator. The pull towards large soft terms then also pulls the PQ scale as large as possible. Unless this is tempered by rather severe (unknown) cosmological or anthropic bounds on the density of dark matter, then we would expect a far greater abundance of dark matter than is observed. This conclusion cannot be negated by adopting a tiny axion misalignment angle theta_i because WIMPs are also overproduced at large f_a. Hence, we conclude that setting the PQ scale via anthropics is highly unlikely. Instead, requiring soft SUSY breaking terms of order the gravity-mediation scale m_{3/2}~ 10-100 TeV places the mixed axion-neutralino dark matter abundance into the intermediate scale sweet zone where f_a~ 10^{11}-10^{12} GeV. We compare our analysis to the more general case of a generic SUSY DFSZ axion model with uniform selection on theta_i but leading to the measured dark matter abundance: this approach leads to a preference for f_a~ 10^{12} GeV. △ Less

Submitted 1 May, 2019; originally announced May 2019.

Comments: 24 pages plus 10 figures

Report number: OU-HEP-190501

Revisiting the SUSY mu problem and its solutions in the LHC era

Authors: Kyu Jung Bae, Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dibyashree Sengupta

Abstract: The supersymmetry preserving mu parameter in SUSY theories is naively expected to be of order the Planck scale while phenomenology requires it to be of order the weak scale. This is the famous SUSY mu problem. Its solution involves two steps: 1. first forbid mu, perhaps via some symmetry, and then 2. re-generate it of order the scale of soft SUSY breaking terms. However, present LHC limits suggest… ▽ More The supersymmetry preserving mu parameter in SUSY theories is naively expected to be of order the Planck scale while phenomenology requires it to be of order the weak scale. This is the famous SUSY mu problem. Its solution involves two steps: 1. first forbid mu, perhaps via some symmetry, and then 2. re-generate it of order the scale of soft SUSY breaking terms. However, present LHC limits suggest the soft breaking scale m_{soft} lies in the multi-TeV regime whilst naturalness requires mu~ m_{W,Z,h}~ 100 GeV so that a Little Hierarchy (LH) appears with mu << m_{soft}. We review twenty previously devised solutions to the SUSY mu problem and re-evaluate them in light of whether they are apt to support the LH. We organize the twenty solutions according to: 1. solutions from supergravity/superstring constructions, 2. extended MSSM solutions, 3. solutions from an extra local U(1)' and 4. solutions involving Peccei-Quinn (PQ) symmetry and axions. Early solutions would invoke a global Peccei-Quinn symmetry to forbid the mu term while relating the mu solution to solving the strong CP problem via the axion. We discuss the gravity-safety issue pertaining to global symmetries and the movement instead toward local gauge symmetries or R-symmetries, either continuous or discrete. At present, discrete R-symmetries of order M (Z_M^R) which emerge as remnants of Lorentz symmetry of compact dimensions seem favored. Even so, a wide variety of regenerative mechanisms are possible, some of which relate to other issues such as the strong CP problem or the generation of neutrino masses. We also discuss the issue of experimental verification or falsifiability of various solutions to the mu problem. Almost all solutions seem able to accommodate the LH. △ Less

Submitted 27 February, 2019; originally announced February 2019.

Comments: 40 pages with 9 .png figures

Report number: CTPU-PTC-19-06

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 99, 115027 (2019)

LHC SUSY and WIMP dark matter searches confront the string theory landscape

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Shadman Salam, Hasan Serce, Kuver Sinha

Abstract: The string theory landscape of vacua solutions provides physicists with some understanding as to the magnitude of the cosmological constant. Similar reasoning can be applied to the magnitude of the soft SUSY breaking terms in supersymmetric models of particle physics: there appears to be a statistical draw towards large soft terms which is tempered by the anthropic requirement of the weak scale ly… ▽ More The string theory landscape of vacua solutions provides physicists with some understanding as to the magnitude of the cosmological constant. Similar reasoning can be applied to the magnitude of the soft SUSY breaking terms in supersymmetric models of particle physics: there appears to be a statistical draw towards large soft terms which is tempered by the anthropic requirement of the weak scale lying not too far from ~100 GeV. For a mild statistical draw of m_{soft}^n with n=1 (as expected from SUSY breaking due to a single F term) then the light Higgs mass is preferred at ~125 GeV while sparticles are all pulled beyond LHC bounds. We confront a variety of LHC and WIMP dark matter search limits with the statistical expectations from a fertile patch of string theory landscape. The end result is that LHC and WIMP dark matter detectors see exactly that which is expected from the string theory landscape: a Standard Model-like Higgs boson of mass 125 GeV but as yet no sign of sparticles or WIMP dark matter. SUSY from the n=1 landscape is most likely to emerge at LHC in the soft opposite-sign dilepton plus jet plus MET channel. Multi-ton noble liquid WIMP detectors should be able to completely explore the n=1 landscape parameter space. △ Less

Submitted 30 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Comments: 21 pages plus 15 .png figures

Report number: OU-HEP-190131

Beyond the Standard Model Physics at the HL-LHC and HE-LHC

Authors: X. Cid Vidal, M. D'Onofrio, P. J. Fox, R. Torre, K. A. Ulmer, A. Aboubrahim, A. Albert, J. Alimena, B. C. Allanach, C. Alpigiani, M. Altakach, S. Amoroso, J. K. Anders, J. Y. Araz, A. Arbey, P. Azzi, I. Babounikau, H. Baer, M. J. Baker, D. Barducci, V. Barger, O. Baron, L. Barranco Navarro, M. Battaglia, A. Bay , et al. (272 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: This is the third out of five chapters of the final report [1] of the Workshop on Physics at HL-LHC, and perspectives on HE-LHC [2]. It is devoted to the study of the potential, in the search for Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics, of the High Luminosity (HL) phase of the LHC, defined as $3~\mathrm{ab}^{-1}$ of data taken at a centre-of-mass energy of $14~\mathrm{TeV}$, and of a possible futu… ▽ More This is the third out of five chapters of the final report [1] of the Workshop on Physics at HL-LHC, and perspectives on HE-LHC [2]. It is devoted to the study of the potential, in the search for Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) physics, of the High Luminosity (HL) phase of the LHC, defined as $3~\mathrm{ab}^{-1}$ of data taken at a centre-of-mass energy of $14~\mathrm{TeV}$, and of a possible future upgrade, the High Energy (HE) LHC, defined as $15~\mathrm{ab}^{-1}$ of data at a centre-of-mass energy of $27~\mathrm{TeV}$. We consider a large variety of new physics models, both in a simplified model fashion and in a more model-dependent one. A long list of contributions from the theory and experimental (ATLAS, CMS, LHCb) communities have been collected and merged together to give a complete, wide, and consistent view of future prospects for BSM physics at the considered colliders. On top of the usual standard candles, such as supersymmetric simplified models and resonances, considered for the evaluation of future collider potentials, this report contains results on dark matter and dark sectors, long lived particles, leptoquarks, sterile neutrinos, axion-like particles, heavy scalars, vector-like quarks, and more. Particular attention is placed, especially in the study of the HL-LHC prospects, to the detector upgrades, the assessment of the future systematic uncertainties, and new experimental techniques. The general conclusion is that the HL-LHC, on top of allowing to extend the present LHC mass and coupling reach by $20-50\%$ on most new physics scenarios, will also be able to constrain, and potentially discover, new physics that is presently unconstrained. Moreover, compared to the HL-LHC, the reach in most observables will generally more than double at the HE-LHC, which may represent a good candidate future facility for a final test of TeV-scale new physics. △ Less

Submitted 13 August, 2019; v1 submitted 19 December, 2018; originally announced December 2018.

Comments: Report from Working Group 3 on the Physics of the HL-LHC, and Perspectives at the HE-LHC; v2: final version updated with the latest contributions and summaries; 239 pages + refs; v3: typos and character misprint in Fig. 7.2 fixed; v4: added one missing author

Report number: CERN-LPCC-2018-05

Gravity safe, electroweak natural axionic solution to strong CP and SUSY mu problems

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dibyashree Sengupta

Abstract: Particle physics models with Peccei-Quinn (PQ) symmetry breaking as a consequence of supersymmetry (SUSY) breaking are attractive in that they solve the strong CP problem with a SUSY DFSZ-like axion, link the SUSY breaking and PQ breaking intermediate mass scales and can resolve the SUSY mu problem with a naturalness-required weak scale mu term whilst soft SUSY breaking terms inhabit the multi-TeV… ▽ More Particle physics models with Peccei-Quinn (PQ) symmetry breaking as a consequence of supersymmetry (SUSY) breaking are attractive in that they solve the strong CP problem with a SUSY DFSZ-like axion, link the SUSY breaking and PQ breaking intermediate mass scales and can resolve the SUSY mu problem with a naturalness-required weak scale mu term whilst soft SUSY breaking terms inhabit the multi-TeV regime as required by LHC sparticle mass limits and the Higgs mass measurement. On the negative ledger, models based on global symmetries suffer a generic gravity spoliation problem. We present a model based on the discrete R-symmetry Z_{24}^R-- which may emerge from compactification of 10-d Lorentzian spacetime in string theory-- where the mu term and dangerous proton decay and R-parity violating operators are either suppressed or forbidden while a gravity-safe PQ symmetry emerges as an accidental approximate global symmetry leading to a solution to the strong CP problem and a weak-scale/natural value for the mu term. △ Less

Submitted 8 October, 2018; originally announced October 2018.

Comments: 14 pages including two .png figures

Report number: OU-HEP-180930

LHC luminosity and energy upgrades confront natural supersymmetry models

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, James S. Gainer, Dibyashree Sengupta, Hasan Serce, Xerxes Tata

Abstract: The electroweak fine-tuning measure Delta(EW) allows for correlated SUSY soft terms as are expected in any ultra-violet complete theory. Requiring no less than 3% electroweak fine-tuning implies upper bounds of about 360~GeV on all higgsinos, while top squarks are lighter than ~3 TeV and gluinos are bounded by ~ 6-9 TeV. We examine the reach for SUSY of the planned high luminosity (HL: 3 ab^{-1} a… ▽ More The electroweak fine-tuning measure Delta(EW) allows for correlated SUSY soft terms as are expected in any ultra-violet complete theory. Requiring no less than 3% electroweak fine-tuning implies upper bounds of about 360~GeV on all higgsinos, while top squarks are lighter than ~3 TeV and gluinos are bounded by ~ 6-9 TeV. We examine the reach for SUSY of the planned high luminosity (HL: 3 ab^{-1} at 14 TeV) and the proposed high energy (HE: 15 ab^{-1} at 27 TeV) upgrades of the LHC via four LHC collider search channels relevant for natural SUSY: 1. gluino pair production followed by gluino decay to third generation (s)quarks, 2. top-squark pair production followed by decay to third generation quarks and light higgsinos, 3. neutral higgsino pair production with QCD jet radiation (resulting in monojet events with soft dileptons), and 4. wino pair production followed by decay to light higgsinos leading to same-sign diboson production. We confront our reach results with upper limits on superpartner masses in four natural SUSY models: natural gravity-mediation via the 1. two- and 2. three-extra-parameter non-universal Higgs models, 3. natural mini-landscape models with generalized mirage mediation and 4. natural anomaly-mediation. We find that while the HL-LHC can probe considerable portions of natural SUSY parameter space in all these models, the HE-LHC will decisively cover the entire natural SUSY parameter space with better than 3% fine-tuning. △ Less

Submitted 14 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: 19 pages with 8 .png figures

Report number: OUHEP-180730,UH-511-1296-18

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 98, 075010 (2018)

Is natural higgsino-only dark matter excluded?

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dibyashree Sengupta, Xerxes Tata

Abstract: The requirement of electroweak naturalness in supersymmetric (SUSY) models of particle physics necessitates light higgsinos not too far from the weak scale characterized by m(weak)~ m(W,Z,h)~100 GeV. On the other hand, LHC Higgs mass measurements and sparticle mass limits point to a SUSY breaking scale in the multi-TeV regime. Under such conditions, the lightest SUSY particle is expected to be a m… ▽ More The requirement of electroweak naturalness in supersymmetric (SUSY) models of particle physics necessitates light higgsinos not too far from the weak scale characterized by m(weak)~ m(W,Z,h)~100 GeV. On the other hand, LHC Higgs mass measurements and sparticle mass limits point to a SUSY breaking scale in the multi-TeV regime. Under such conditions, the lightest SUSY particle is expected to be a mainly higgsino-like neutralino with non-negligible gaugino components (required by naturalness). The computed thermal WIMP abundance in natural SUSY models is then found to be typically a factor 5-20 below its measured value. To gain concordance with observations, either an additional DM particle (the axion is a well-motivated possibility) must be present or additional non-thermal mechanisms must augment the neutralino abundance. We compare present direct and indirect WIMP detection limits to three natural SUSY models based on gravity-, anomaly- and mirage-mediation. We show that the case of natural higgsino-only dark matter where non-thermal production mechanisms augment its relic density, is essentially excluded by a combination of direct detection constraints from PandaX-II, LUX and Xenon-1t experiments, and by bounds from Fermi-LAT/MAGIC observations of gamma rays from dwarf spheroidal galaxies. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2018; v1 submitted 29 March, 2018; originally announced March 2018.

Comments: 16 pages with 6 .png figures; some added references for version 2

Report number: OUHEP-180329

Anomaly mediated SUSY breaking model retrofitted for naturalness

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Dibyashree Sengupta

Abstract: Anomaly-mediated supersymmetry breaking (AMSB) models seem to have become increasingly implausible due to 1. difficulty in generating a Higgs mass m(h)~125 GeV, 2. typically unnatural superparticle spectra characterized by a large superpotential mu term and 3. the possibility of a wino-like lightest SUSY particle (LSP) as dark matter now seems to be excluded. In the present paper we propose some m… ▽ More Anomaly-mediated supersymmetry breaking (AMSB) models seem to have become increasingly implausible due to 1. difficulty in generating a Higgs mass m(h)~125 GeV, 2. typically unnatural superparticle spectra characterized by a large superpotential mu term and 3. the possibility of a wino-like lightest SUSY particle (LSP) as dark matter now seems to be excluded. In the present paper we propose some minor modifications to the paradigm model which solve these three issues. Instead of adding a universal bulk scalar mass to avoid tachyonic sleptons, we add distinct Higgs and matter scalar soft masses which then allow for light higgsinos. To gain accord with the measured Higgs mass, we also include a bulk trilinear soft term. The ensuing natural generalized AMSB (nAMSB) model then has a set of light higgsinos with mass nearby the weak scale m(W,Z,h)~100 GeV as required by naturalness while the winos populate the several hundred GeV range and gluinos and squarks occupy the multi-TeV range. For LHC searches, the wino pair production followed by decay to same-sign diboson signature channel offers excellent prospects for discovery at high luminosity LHC along with higgsino pair production leading to soft dileptons plus jet(s)+MET. A linear e^+e^- collider operating above higgsino pair production threshold should be able to distinguish the AMSB gaugino spectra from unified or mirage unified scenarios. Dark matter is expected to occur as a higgsino-like WIMP plus axion admixture. △ Less

Submitted 29 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: 26 pages with 12 .png figures

Report number: OUHEP-180129

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 98, 015039 (2018)

Higgs and superparticle mass predictions from the string theory landscape

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, Hasan Serce, Kuver Sinha

Abstract: Predictions for the scale of SUSY breaking from the string landscape go back at least a decade to the work of Denef and Douglas on the statistics of flux vacua. The assumption that an assortment of SUSY breaking F and D terms are present in the hidden sector, and their values are uniformly distributed in the landscape of D=4, N=1 effective supergravity models, leads to the expectation that the lan… ▽ More Predictions for the scale of SUSY breaking from the string landscape go back at least a decade to the work of Denef and Douglas on the statistics of flux vacua. The assumption that an assortment of SUSY breaking F and D terms are present in the hidden sector, and their values are uniformly distributed in the landscape of D=4, N=1 effective supergravity models, leads to the expectation that the landscape pulls towards large values of soft terms favored by a power law behavior P(m(soft))~ m(soft)^n. On the other hand, similar to Weinberg's prediction of the cosmological constant, one can assume an anthropic selection of weak scales not too far from the measured value characterized by m(W,Z,h)~ 100 GeV. Working within a fertile patch of gravity-mediated low energy effective theories where the superpotential mu term is << m(3/2), as occurs in models such as radiative breaking of Peccei-Quinn symmetry, this biases statistical distributions on the landscape by a cutoff on the parameter Delta(EW), which measures fine-tuning in the m(Z)-mu mass relation. The combined effect of statistical and anthropic pulls turns out to favor low energy phenomenology that is more or less agnostic to UV physics. While a uniform selection n=0 of soft terms produces too low a value for m(h), taking n=1 or 2 produce most probabilistically m(h)~125 GeV for negative trilinear terms. For n>=1, there is a pull towards split generations with m(squarks,sleptons)(1,2)~10-30 TeV whilst m(t1)~ 1-2 TeV. The most probable gluino mass comes in at ~ 3-4 TeV--apparently beyond the reach of HL-LHC (although the required quasi-degenerate higgsinos should still be within reach). We comment on consequences for SUSY collider and dark matter searches. △ Less

Submitted 24 February, 2018; v1 submitted 4 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: 28 pages with 10 figures; updated version includes referee mandated changes and truncated title

Report number: OU-HEP-171104

Aspects of the same-sign diboson signature from wino pair production with light higgsinos at the high luminosity LHC

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, James S. Gainer, Michael Savoy, Dibyashree Sengupta, Xerxes Tata

Abstract: Naturalness arguments applied to simple supersymmetric (SUSY) theories require a set of light higgsinos with mass $\sim |μみゅー|$ not too far from $m_h$. These models have an inverted electroweakino spectrum with $|μみゅー| \ll M_2$ which leads to a rather clean, hadronically quiet, same-sign diboson (SSdB) signature at hadron colliders arising from neutral-plus-charged wino pair production. We improve and e… ▽ More Naturalness arguments applied to simple supersymmetric (SUSY) theories require a set of light higgsinos with mass $\sim |μみゅー|$ not too far from $m_h$. These models have an inverted electroweakino spectrum with $|μみゅー| \ll M_2$ which leads to a rather clean, hadronically quiet, same-sign diboson (SSdB) signature at hadron colliders arising from neutral-plus-charged wino pair production. We improve and expand our earlier studies of this signature for discovering SUSY in natural SUSY models by (i) including backgrounds which were not previously considered and which turn out to be significant, (ii) devising more efficient cuts to successfully contend with these larger backgrounds and determining the discovery reach and exclusion ranges for winos with these cuts, emphasizing projections for the updated integrated luminosity target for HL-LHC of 3 ab$^{-1}$, and (iii) emphasizing the utility of this channel for natural models without gaugino mass unification. We display the kinematic characteristics of the relatively jet-free same sign dilepton+$\not\!\!\!{E_T}$ events (from leptonic decays of both $W$s) and find that these are only weakly sensitive to the parent wino mass. We also examine the charge asymmetry in these events and show that its measurement can be used to check the consistency of the wino origin of the signal. Finally, we show that -- because the wino branching fractions in natural SUSY are essentially independent of details of the underlying model -- a determination of the rate for clean, same-sign dilepton events yields a better than 10% determination of the wino mass over the entire mass range where experiments at the HL-LHC can discover the wino signal. △ Less

Submitted 25 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 26 pages, 9 figures consisting of 13 image files

Report number: UH-511-1285-17

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 97, 035012 (2018)

Naturalness and light Higgsinos: why ILC is the right machine for SUSY discovery

Authors: Suvi-Leena Lehtinen, Howard Baer, Mikael Berggren, Keisuke Fujii, Jenny List, Tomohiko Tanabe, Jacqueline Yan

Abstract: Radiatively-driven natural supersymmetry, a theoretically and experimentally well-motivated framework, centers around the predicted existence of four light, nearly mass-degenerate Higgsinos with mass $\sim 100-200$ GeV (not too far above $m_Z$). The small mass splittings amongst the higgsinos, typically 4-20 GeV, results in very little visible energy arising from decays of the heavier higgsinos. G… ▽ More Radiatively-driven natural supersymmetry, a theoretically and experimentally well-motivated framework, centers around the predicted existence of four light, nearly mass-degenerate Higgsinos with mass $\sim 100-200$ GeV (not too far above $m_Z$). The small mass splittings amongst the higgsinos, typically 4-20 GeV, results in very little visible energy arising from decays of the heavier higgsinos. Given that other SUSY particles are considerably heavy, this makes detection challenging at hadron colliders. On the other hand, the clean environment of an electron-positron collider with $\sqrt{s}>2m_{higgsino}$ would enable a decisive search of these required higgsinos, and thus either the discovery or exclusion of natural SUSY. We present a detailed simulation study of precision measurements of higgsino masses and production cross sections at $\sqrt{s}$ = 500 GeV of the proposed International Linear Collider currently under consideration for construction in Japan. The study is based on a Geant4 simulation of the International Large Detector concept. We examine several benchmark points just beyond the HL-LHC reach, with four light higgsinos directly accessible by the ILC, and the mass differences between the lightest SUSY particle and the heavier states ranging from about 4 to 20 GeV. It can be shown that their masses and production cross sections can be precisely measured to approximately 1\% precision or better. These precise measurements allow for extracting the underlying weak scale SUSY parameters, giving predictions for the masses of heavier SUSY states. These provide motivation for future high-energy colliders. Additionally, dark matter properties may be derived. Evolution of the measured gaugino masses to high energies should allow testing the hypothesis of gaugino mass unification. △ Less

Submitted 6 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures; to appear in the proceedings for EPS-HEP2017, 5-12 July 2017, Venice, Italy

The Reach of the High-Energy LHC for Gluinos and Top Squarks in SUSY Models with Light Higgsinos

Authors: Howard Baer, Vernon Barger, James S. Gainer, Hasan Serce, Xerxes Tata

Abstract: We examine the top squark (stop) and gluino reach of the proposed 33 TeV energy upgrade of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC33) in the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) with light higgsinos and relatively heavy electroweak gauginos. In our analysis, we assume that stops decay to higgsinos via ${\tilde t}_1 \to t {\tilde{Z}}_1$, $\tilde{t}_1 \to t\tilde{Z}_2$ and $\tilde{t}$… ▽ More We examine the top squark (stop) and gluino reach of the proposed 33 TeV energy upgrade of the Large Hadron Collider (LHC33) in the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) with light higgsinos and relatively heavy electroweak gauginos. In our analysis, we assume that stops decay to higgsinos via ${\tilde t}_1 \to t {\tilde{Z}}_1$, $\tilde{t}_1 \to t\tilde{Z}_2$ and $\tilde{t}$$_1 \to b\tilde{W}_1$ with branching fractions in the ratio 1:1:2 (expected if the decay occurs dominantly via the superpotential Yukawa coupling) while gluinos decay via $\tilde{g}\to t\tilde{t}_1$ or via three-body decays to third generation quarks plus higgsinos. These decay patterns are motivated by models of natural supersymmetry where higgsinos are expected to be close in mass to $m_Z$, but gluinos may be as heavy as $5 - 6$ TeV and stops may have masses up to $\sim 3 $ TeV. We devise cuts to optimize the signals from stop and gluino pair production at LHC33. We find that experiments at LHC33 should be able to discover stops with $> 5σしぐま$ significance if $m_{\tilde{t}_1} < 2.3 \ (2.8) \ [3.2]$ TeV for an integrated luminosity of 0.3 (1)[3] ab$^{-1}$. The corresponding reach for gluinos extends to 5 (5.5) [6] TeV. These results imply that experiments at LHC33 should be able to discover at least one of the stop or gluino pair signals even with an integrated luminosity of 0.3 ab$^{-1}$ for natural SUSY models with no worse than 3% electroweak fine-tuning, and quite likely both gluinos and stops for an integrated luminosity of 3 ab$^{-1}$. △ Less

Submitted 29 August, 2017; originally announced August 2017.

Comments: 37 pages, 18 figures

Report number: UH-511-1281-17

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. D 96, 115008 (2017)

US Cosmic Visions: New Ideas in Dark Matter 2017: Community Report

Authors: Marco Battaglieri, Alberto Belloni, Aaron Chou, Priscilla Cushman, Bertrand Echenard, Rouven Essig, Juan Estrada, Jonathan L. Feng, Brenna Flaugher, Patrick J. Fox, Peter Graham, Carter Hall, Roni Harnik, JoAnne Hewett, Joseph Incandela, Eder Izaguirre, Daniel McKinsey, Matthew Pyle, Natalie Roe, Gray Rybka, Pierre Sikivie, Tim M. P. Tait, Natalia Toro, Richard Van De Water, Neal Weiner , et al. (226 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: This white paper summarizes the workshop "U.S. Cosmic Visions: New Ideas in Dark Matter" held at University of Maryland on March 23-25, 2017. This white paper summarizes the workshop "U.S. Cosmic Visions: New Ideas in Dark Matter" held at University of Maryland on March 23-25, 2017. △ Less

Submitted 14 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Comments: 102 pages + references