Qision
חורבת קציון (Hebrew) | |
 A decorated lintel in Qision | |
  Shown within Israel | |
| Alternative name | Horvat Qazyon (Heb.) Khirbet Qasyun (Ar.) |
|---|---|
| Location | Sde Eliezer, Northern District, Israel |
| Region | Upper Galilee |
| Coordinates | 33°02′34″N 35°31′46″E / 33.04278°N 35.52944°E |
| Palestine grid | 199/272 |
| Type | Settlement, cultic structure (synagogue?) |
| History | |
| Periods | Roman period (second to third century CE) |
| Associated with | Jews |
| Site notes | |
| Condition | In ruins |
| Public access | Yes |
Qision (Hebrew: קַצִיּוֹן, also spelled Qazion and Qatsion) was an ancient settlement in Upper Galilee, now an archaeological site in northern Israel, featuring the ruins of the settlement, including a public building, possibly an ancient synagogue, alongside an inscription dedicated to the Roman emperor Septimius Severus and his family commissioned by the local Jewish community.[1][2]
The site is known as Ḥorvat Qazyon[2] (Hebrew: חורבת קציון), and in Arabic as Khirbet Qasyun or Khirbet Keisun.[1][3]
Location
[edit]
The site is located in the Upper Galilee, approximately 9 km northeast of Safed[2] and 1 km north of Meroth, a Jewish village dating from the Late Roman and Byzantine periods.[3][4] The hill is covered with large Pistacia atlantica trees.[5]
The ruin and the Qision brook are situated within the Dishon Stream area, constituting a fire zone. As such, access to the site necessitates prior coordination with military authorities.[6]
History
[edit]Twice mentioned in rabbinic literature,[7] particularly in the Jerusalem Talmud, Qision appears in the name of Rabbi Yohanan from Kasion (Hebrew: רִבִּי יוֹחָנָן דְּקַצִיּוֹן),[8][1] elsewhere as Karṣion (Hebrew: רִבִּי יוֹחָנָן דְּקַרְצִיוֹן),[9] a sage from the third century.[7][10] These passages strongly suggest the presence of a Jewish community at the site during the second and third centuries CE.[7] This is further supported by surveys conducted on the site, which revealed a primary period of occupation during the same period.[7]
Archaeologist Zvi Ilan proposed that the name Qision is derived from the Hebrew word קצה, meaning "edge," reflecting its position as one of the northernmost points of Jewish settlement in Galilee.[11]
During the reign of the Roman Severan dynasty, Qision was part of the province of Syria Phoenice.[2] The site experienced another period of occupation during the Mamluk era, particularly the 13th and 14th centuries, when it was possibly occupied by a Muslim group.[7]
In a tradition originating from Safed in the 16th century, Qision is believed to house the tombs of Rabbi Yohanan from Kasion and Rabbi Shimon Ben Lakish.[12]
Qision's ruins were first discovered in 1860 by Ernest Renan.[7] The Arabic term Khirbet Keisun, recorded in the PEF Survey of Palestine, preserves the ancient name.[3][11]
Archaeology
[edit]Monumental structure and complex
[edit]The discovery of a distinctive complex of structures in Qision, comprising a sizable monumental building and a western structure, unparalleled elsewhere, alongside an inscription honoring the Roman emperor (see below), has sparked significant scholarly debate about its intended function. Opinions are split between two interpretations: Jewish synagogue or a Syro-Phoenician Roman temple.[3][4]
Ernest Renan, who discovered the site in 1860, and Victor Guérin, who referenced it in his 1880 book, both identified the structure as a synagogue. However, PEF explorers Conder and Kitchener, following their visit in 1877, proposed identifying it with a Roman temple, dating back to the same period as the Temple at Kedesh.[7]
In the 20th century, E.W.G. Masterman, in his 1909 writing, identified the site as a synagogue. Conversely, in a 1916 study, E. Kohl and C. Watzinger classified it as a temple, drawing parallels to Kedesh and other Roman temples in the region. In 1987, following a survey, A. Bar Oz and Zvi Ilan concluded that it was a public building with pagan characteristics.[7]
In an effort to resolve this dispute, Rachel Hachlili and Ann E. Killebrew undertook three survey seasons at the site in 1992 and 1997.[3] Despite their consensus that it was not a synagogue, they arrived at differing conclusions.[7]
Killebrew proposed that the structure might have functioned as part of a cultic complex for ceremonies or festivals, constructed by local Jews to honor the imperial family of Septimius Severus.[3]
Hachlili interpreted the site as a complex that served as a communal and religious center for priestly families relocating to Galilee after the Jewish–Roman wars, along with the local Jewish communities, serving as a space for the performance and preservation of priestly rituals. According to her analysis, the architectural features and the presence of ritual purification pools and an incense altar suggest its role in maintaining Jewish religious practices following the destruction of the Temple. This includes facilitating rituals like incense burning and the Water Libation Ceremony observed in the Temple during Sukkot.[13]
Next to the northern wall of the monumental structure is a decorated, broken lintel adorned with grapevine branches bearing clusters of grapes, alongside Acanthus syriacus leaves.[6]
Inscription dedicated to the family of Septimius Severus
[edit]A Greek-language inscription was found in Qision, dating to 195/6 CE.[2] Discovered near an ancient building in 1860 by Ernest Renan,[3][14] it was rediscovered in 1984.[2] This inscription, originally part of a lintel, is dedicated to the salvation of Septimius Severus and his family.[2]
The inscription is missing a section from the right corner. On the left side, a wreath with stylized leaves ending in a ribbon bound in a 'Hercules' knot features the name of Julia Domna. A similar wreath on the right side is missing.[2]
The inscription was dedicated by the local Jewish community, as indicated in its text "in accord with the vow of the Jews" ([ἐ
Similar inscriptions have been uncovered in Pannonia and Ostia, while a midrash refers to a synagogue known as "of Severus" in Rome. Scholars interpret the existence of such inscriptions, which uncommonly praise rulers in ancient Jewish contexts, as indicative of the special honor bestowed upon the Severan dynasty by Jewish communities.[12]
Similar inscriptions have been discovered in Pannonia and Ostia, while one midrash references a synagogue known as "of Severus" in Rome. According to one interpretation, this unusual occurrence of mentioning rulers, especially with praise, in ancient Jewish inscriptions suggests that the Jews held the Severan dynasty in special esteem.[12]
Olive oil press and burial caves
[edit]To the west of the public structure lie the remnants of an olive oil press, suggesting that the local inhabitants derived their livelihood from cultivating olive trees and producing olive oil. Several burial caves are situated on the southern slope of the ruin.[6]
See also
[edit]- Alma – a nearby site with the remnants of an ancient synagogue along with Jewish inscriptions
- Kalybe (temple) for cult of the emperor
- Roman imperial cult
References
[edit]- ^ a b c Avi-Yonah, Michael (1976). "Gazetteer of Roman Palestine". Qedem. 5: 89. ISSN 0333-5844. JSTOR 43587090. Archived from the original on 2023-06-29. Retrieved 2024-04-04.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i "XXVII. Qision (mod. Ḥ. Qazyon)", Corpus Inscriptionum Iudaeae/Palaestinae (CIIP): Galilaea and Northern Regions (5876–6924), vol. V/part 1, De Gruyter, pp. 160–62, 2023, doi:10.1515/9783110715774-035, ISBN 978-3-11-071577-4, archived from the original on 4 April 2024, retrieved 4 April 2024
- ^ a b c d e f g Killebrew, Ann E. (2013). "Qazion: A Late Second–Early Third-Century CE Rural Cultic Complex in the Upper Galilee Dedicated to Septimius Severus and His Family". Journal of Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology and Heritage Studies. 1 (2): 113–60. doi:10.5325/jeasmedarcherstu.1.2.0113. ISSN 2166-3556.
- ^ a b Hachlili, Rachel (1 January 2013), "Supplement: Qazion—A Galilean Riddle", Ancient Synagogues – Archaeology and Art: New Discoveries and Current Research, Brill, pp. 617–682, ISBN 978-90-04-25772-6, retrieved 5 April 2024
- ^ Gabay, Mushon, ed. (2001). Upper Galilee and its coast. The New Israel Guide (in Hebrew). Vol. 3. Keter Publishing House. pp. 133–134.
- ^ a b c Gabay, Mushon, ed. (2001). Upper Galilee and its coast. The New Israel Guide (in Hebrew). Vol. 3. Keter Publishing House. pp. 133–34.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i Hachlili, Rachel (1 January 2013), "Supplement: Qazion—A Galilean Riddle", Ancient Synagogues – Archaeology and Art: New Discoveries and Current Research, Brill, pp. 617–82, ISBN 978-90-04-25772-6, retrieved 5 April 2024
- ^ "Jerusalem Talmud Beitzah 5:5:2". Sefaria. Archived from the original on 4 April 2024. Retrieved 4 April 2024.
- ^ "Jerusalem Talmud Berakhot 8:6:4". Sefaria. Archived from the original on 5 April 2024. Retrieved 5 April 2024.
- ^ ברס, צבי; ספראי, שמואל; צפריר, יורם; שטרן, מנחם, eds. (1982). ארץ-ישראל מחורבן בית שני ועד הכיבוש המוסלמי: היסטוריה מדינית, חברתית ותרבותית [Eretz Israel: from the Destruction of the Second Temple to the Muslim Conquest. Vol. 1: Political, Social and Cultural History] (in Hebrew). ירושלים: הוצאת יד יצחק בן-צבי. p. 172. ISBN 965-217-006-2.
- ^ a b עמית, חנה; עמית, דוד, eds. (2004). מראי מקום | לטייל עם המקורות בצפון הארץ [Reference Points | Touring with Hebrew Sources in Northern Israel] (in Hebrew). ירושלים: יד יצחק בן-צבי. p. 173. ISBN 965-217-223-5.
- ^ a b c בן יוסף, ספי, ed. (2001). הגליל העליון וחופו. מדריך ישראל החדש: אנציקלופדיה | מסלולי טיול (in Hebrew). Vol. 3. כתר הוצאה לאור. pp. 95, 358. ISBN 965-07-0894-4.
- ^ Hachlili, Rachel (1 January 2013), "Supplement: Qazion—A Galilean Riddle", Ancient Synagogues – Archaeology and Art: New Discoveries and Current Research, Brill, pp. 617–682, ISBN 978-90-04-25772-6, retrieved 5 April 2024
- ^ Renan, E. (1871) Mission de Phénicie p. 774
 Ancient synagogues (Second Temple and Talmudic periods) | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Land of Israel |
|  | ||||||||
| Asia Minor and Syria | ||||||||||
| Greece and the Balkans | ||||||||||
| Italy, Iberia and North Africa | ||||||||||