Minzu (anthropology)

In China, the word minzu (Chinese: 民族みんぞく; pinyin: mínzú) means a community that inherits culture (文化ぶんか) or consanguinity (血ち缘). Depending on the context, the word has various meanings, such as "nation", "race" and "ethnic group". In modern Chinese languages, minzu has a stronger cultural meaning than racial meaning.

Minzu-based nationalism is associated with nationalism in Northeast Asia and Vietnam, usually in the form of cultural or ethnic nationalism, in contrast to state nationalism.^[1] Minzu-based nationalism in China and Taiwan is close to multi-ethnic nationalism.^[2]

Etymology

In Chinese, the term minzu has several meanings; it can be confused with concepts such as "zhǒngzú" (种族, lit. "race"), "guózú" (国くに族ぞく, lit. "nation"), "zúqún" (族ぞく群ぐん, lit. "ethnic group"). For example, 民族みんぞく主ぬし义 (pinyin: mínzú zhǔyì, lit. "minzu-ism") means "nationalism", but 民族みんぞく学がく (pinyin: mínzú xué, lit. "minzu-study") means "ethnology".

The term "minzu" is found in Xiao Zixian's book 《南みなみ齐书·高だか逸いっ传》 during the Liang dynasty ("今こん诸华士し女おんな, 民族みんぞく弗どる革かわ"), and in the book 《太白たいはく阴经》 during the Tang dynasty ("愚人ぐじん得どく之の, 以倾宗むね社しゃ, 灭民族ぞく"). However, these terms are closer to the meaning of "people" (民みん众) than they are to today.^[3]^[4]

Minzu is a loanword from Japanese.^[5]^: 109 During the Meji period, Japanese translators rendered "nation", "ethnic group", and "Volk" into minzoku (Japanese: 民族みんぞく) when translating European books, which was introduced to China.^[6]

Zhonghua minzu

Before the 1911 Revolution, the members of the Chinese Revolutionary Party were hostile to the Qing dynasty ("Anti-Qing sentiment") and tried to build a nation-state around the Han Chinese; at this time the concept of Zhonghua minzu (中ちゅう华民族ぞく / 中華ちゅうか民族みんぞく, zhōnghuá mínzú, lit. "Chinese nation") was about the same meaning with Han minzu (汉民族ぞく / 漢かん民族みんぞく, hàn mínzú, lit. "Han nation") or Hanzu (汉族 / 漢かん族ぞく, hànzú, "Han ethnic group").

After the 1911 Revolution, the concept of "Five Races Under One Union" was introduced, and later Zhonghua minzu united various ethnic groups in China. Today, Zhonghua minzu is concept is related to multi-ethnic nationalism, and therefore distinct from Han minzu or Hanzu.

Other countries

民族みんぞく is not a word spoken only in China and Japan, and can be used in countries throughout Chinese cultural sphere where Chinese characters are spoken. The "dân tộc" in the Vietnamese language, and "민족" in the Korean language are 民族みんぞく and lexical cognates.

In the modern Japanese language, minzoku (民族みんぞく) is mainly used to express "ethnic group", instead "nation" is translated into kokumin (国民こくみん).

National symbolism

In many Northeast Asian countries, 民族みんぞく is often related to official national symbol as well.

The word appears in People's Republic of China's official national anthem ("March of the Volunteers"), Military Anthem of the People's Liberation Army, and the National Flag Anthem of the Republic of China (Taiwan). In South Korea, the word was used in the Pledge of Allegiance until 2007.

National liberation movements

民族みんぞく, 国民こくみん, and 国こく族ぞく all mean "nation". Among them, 民族みんぞく is often used to describe anti-imperialist left-wing nationalism centered on ethnic identity, especially stateless nationalism; 国民こくみん or 国こく族ぞく, means "nation", which can be established only on the premise of 'state' (国くに/國くに), so in Northeast Asia, when it comes to words like "national self-determination" (民族みんぞく自決じけつ, mínzú zìjué) and "national liberation" (民族みんぞく解放かいほう, mínzú jiěfàng), the word "nation[nal]" translates to the 民族みんぞく, not the 国民こくみん or 国こく族ぞく. Because of this, in Northeast Asia, 'minzu-based nationalism' (民族みんぞく主義しゅぎ) and 'state-based nationalism' (国くに族ぞく主義しゅぎ, 国民こくみん主義しゅぎ or 国家こっか主義しゅぎ) are applied in different contexts.

From the 1930s to 1945, the Japanese imperialists proclaimed the idea of "national liberation" (民族みんぞく自決じけつ, minzu jiefang) and "national self-determination" (民族みんぞく解放かいほう, minzu zijue) to encourage the separation of Northeast China and North China from the rest of the country. This is also related to local ethnic nationalism; minzu may mean "nation" but may also mean "ethnic group".^[7]

In Postwar Japan, liberal nationalists like Masao Maruyama emphasized "国民こくみん主義しゅぎ" (kokumin shugi, lit. "state-based nationalism" or "civic nationalism"^[8]) while left-wing nationalists who supported Marxism and anti-imperialism emphasized "民族みんぞく主義しゅぎ" (minzoku shugi, lit. "ethnic nationalism").^[9]

Today, in South Korea, left-liberals tend to value minjok (the Korean race) over the North–South ideological and political divide. In a broader sense, left-liberals embrace "ethnic nationalism" (民族みんぞく主義しゅぎ, Korean: 민족주의); the notion that sharing the same bloodline is superior to temporary national partition. Conservatives on the other hand support "regime-based nationalism" (國民こくみん主義しゅぎ or 國家こっか主義しゅぎ, Korean: 국민주의 or 국가주의), which puts emphasis on being South Korean and stresses the differences in social and political values between the two Koreas.^[10]^[11]

In South Vietnam, which existed in the past, the anti-communist nationalist Vietnamese Nationalist Party defined "nation" as quốc dân (國民こくみん). In contrast, the National Liberation Front of South Vietnam, a dissident communist nationalist guerrilla in South Vietnam, defined "nation" as dân tộc (民族みんぞく).

Hong Kong nationalists reject the concept of "Chinese minzu" (中華ちゅうか民族みんぞく) and define themselves as "HongKonger minzu" (香港ほんこん民族みんぞく). "Hong Kong [ethnic] nationalism" (民族みんぞく主義しゅぎ or 香港ほんこん民族みんぞく主義しゅぎ) is often opposed to Chinese state nationalism (國家こっか主義しゅぎ or 中國ちゅうごく國家こっか主義しゅぎ),^[12] because many Chinese state nationalists support reducing Hong Kong's autonomy.^[13] During Taiwan's KMT one-party dictatorship, the Kuomintang (KMT) defended Chinese state nationalism, in opposition to which liberal/progressives, including the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP), defended Taiwanese-based "liberal [ethnic] nationalism" (自由じゆう民族みんぞく主義しゅぎ); moderate Taiwanese [ethnic] nationalism has an impact on Taiwanese politics even after democratization.^[14]

Racial pride

Some Northeast Asia's nationalists value the 'blood purity' when defining 民族みんぞく, showing racial nationalism.^[15] Yamato nationalism during Empire of Japan, and today's North Korea's Juche are linked to racial nationalism.^[16]

According to some scholars, Northeast Asia's "nationalism" (民族みんぞく主義しゅぎ) has right Hegelians and 19th century notions of blood and soil.^[17]

Three Principles of the People

"Mínzú" (民族みんぞく, nationalism) is a core principle of the Three Principles of the People, along with "Mínquán" (民權みんけん, democracy) and "Mínshēng" (民生みんせい, socialism).

References

^ Hankwon Kim (2022). Cultural and State Nationalism: South Korean and Japanese Relations with China. American University.
^ Gunter Schubert; Jens Damm (2012). Taiwanese Identity in the 21st Century: Domestic, Regional and Global Perspectives. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. p. 270. In the multi-ethnic nationalism approach, the Taiwanese nation is conceptualized as a harmonious, democratic and ...
^ 邸やしき永ひさし君くん. “民族みんぞく”一いち词见于《南みなみ齐书》. 民族みんぞく研究けんきゅう. 2004, (3): 98–99.
^ 茹莹. 汉语"民族みんぞく"一词在我国的最早出现. 世界せかい民族みんぞく. 2001, (6): 1.
^ Qian, Ying (2024). Revolutionary Becomings: Documentary Media in Twentieth-Century China. New York, NY: Columbia University Press. ISBN 9780231204477.
^ Shiyuan Hao (30 November 2015). How the Communist Party of China Manages the Issue of Nationality: An Evolving Topic. Springer Berlin Heidelberg. p. 39. ISBN 978-3-662-48462-3. ... minzu to translate the German word volk and the English words ethnos and nation. After the Japanese philosopher Enryou Inoue founded the magazine Nihonjin in 1888, the term minzu became widely used in Japan and influenced the whole news ...
^ Wei Wang; Lisong Jiang (July 19, 2021). Ethnic Identity of the Kam People in Contemporary China: Government Versus Local Perspectives. Taylor & Francis. p. 4. ISBN 978-1-000-41288-8.
^ Andrea Castiglioni; Carina Roth; Fabio Rambelli (12 November 2020). Defining Shugendo: Critical Studies on Japanese Mountain Religion. Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 978-1-350-17941-7. ... civic nationalism (kokuminshugi 国民こくみん主義しゅぎ) in an attempt to forcibly construct the identity of Japanese society (Hayashi 2010: 34). ...
^ Gayle, Curtis Anderson (2003-08-29). Marxist History and Postwar Japanese Nationalism. Routledge. doi:10.4324/9780203217771. ISBN 978-1-134-43159-5.
^ Cloudy forecast for Moon’s ‘Sunshine Policy 2.0’ Archived 31 October 2023 at the Wayback Machine East Asia Forum (2017. 07. 20). "In South Korean politics, liberal political parties often support a policy of engagement with North Korea. This is because left-wing politicians tend to value miunjok (the Korean race) over the North–South ideological and political divide. In a broader sense, liberals embrace ethno-nationalism; the notion that sharing the same bloodline is superior to temporary national partition. Conservatives on the other hand support regime-based nationalism, which puts emphasis on being South Korean and stresses the differences in social and political values between the two Koreas."
^ Myers, Brian Reynolds (December 28, 2016). "Still the Unloved Republic". Sthele Press. Retrieved June 26, 2019. ... Someone who is asked by a pollster whether he is prouder of the Taehan minguk or of the minjok therefore knows which answer is better, more progressive-sounding. In all likelihood he is not prouder of the republic than of his Koreanness. One should be wary of polls on this issue that were not conducted precisely and clearly.
^ Daniel Cetrà; Coree Brown Swan (2022). State and Majority Nationalism in Plurinational States. Taylor & Francis. p. 135. ... Hong Kong nationalism, or at least opposition to Chinese state nationalism.
^ Chang, Che (1 December 2020). "The Nazi Inspiring China's Communists". The Atlantic.
^ Glenn Drover; Graham Johnson; Julia Lai Po-Wah Tao (2001). Regionalism and Subregionalism in East Asia: The Dynamics of China. Nova Science. p. 101. ISBN 978-1-56072-872-6. In response to the rise of 'liberal ethno-nationalism' and the DPP, it has increasingly promoted the discourse and practices of a 'Taiwanized' KMT.
^ Ko-wu Huang, Max (15 March 2008). The Meaning of Freedom: Yan Fu and Origins of Chinese Liberalism. Chinese University of Hong Kong Press. p. 97. doi:10.2307/j.ctv1x0kc5b. ISBN 978-962-996-278-4. JSTOR j.ctv1x0kc5b. S2CID 261749245. ... racial nationalism (minzu zhuyi 民族みんぞく主義しゅぎ) was characteristic of any race, but he asked: "Will racial nationalism strengthen our race? In my opinion, it definitely will not."...
^ B. R. Myers (2010). The Cleanest Race.
^ Kelly, Robert E. (24 May 2010). "More on Asian Multiculturalism: 5 Masters Theses to be Written". Retrieved 10 February 2024. Northeast Asians (NEA – Chinese, Koreans, Japanese) strike me as quite nationalistic, and nationalism up here is still tied up in right-Hegelian, 19th century notions of blood and soil.

[Hankwon_Kim-1] Hankwon Kim (2022). Cultural and State Nationalism: South Korean and Japanese Relations with China. American University.

[2] Gunter Schubert; Jens Damm (2012). Taiwanese Identity in the 21st Century: Domestic, Regional and Global Perspectives. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. p. 270. In the multi-ethnic nationalism approach, the Taiwanese nation is conceptualized as a harmonious, democratic and ...

[3] 邸やしき永ひさし君くん. “民族みんぞく”一いち词见于《南みなみ齐书》. 民族みんぞく研究けんきゅう. 2004, (3): 98–99.

[4] 茹莹. 汉语"民族みんぞく"一词在我国的最早出现. 世界せかい民族みんぞく. 2001, (6): 1.

[:Qian-5] Qian, Ying (2024). Revolutionary Becomings: Documentary Media in Twentieth-Century China. New York, NY: Columbia University Press. ISBN 9780231204477.

[6] Shiyuan Hao (30 November 2015). How the Communist Party of China Manages the Issue of Nationality: An Evolving Topic. Springer Berlin Heidelberg. p. 39. ISBN 978-3-662-48462-3. ... minzu to translate the German word volk and the English words ethnos and nation. After the Japanese philosopher Enryou Inoue founded the magazine Nihonjin in 1888, the term minzu became widely used in Japan and influenced the whole news ...

[7] Wei Wang; Lisong Jiang (July 19, 2021). Ethnic Identity of the Kam People in Contemporary China: Government Versus Local Perspectives. Taylor & Francis. p. 4. ISBN 978-1-000-41288-8.

[8] Andrea Castiglioni; Carina Roth; Fabio Rambelli (12 November 2020). Defining Shugendo: Critical Studies on Japanese Mountain Religion. Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 978-1-350-17941-7. ... civic nationalism (kokuminshugi 国民こくみん主義しゅぎ) in an attempt to forcibly construct the identity of Japanese society (Hayashi 2010: 34). ...

[9] Gayle, Curtis Anderson (2003-08-29). Marxist History and Postwar Japanese Nationalism. Routledge. doi:10.4324/9780203217771. ISBN 978-1-134-43159-5.

[10] Cloudy forecast for Moon’s ‘Sunshine Policy 2.0’ Archived 31 October 2023 at the Wayback Machine East Asia Forum (2017. 07. 20). "In South Korean politics, liberal political parties often support a policy of engagement with North Korea. This is because left-wing politicians tend to value miunjok (the Korean race) over the North–South ideological and political divide. In a broader sense, liberals embrace ethno-nationalism; the notion that sharing the same bloodline is superior to temporary national partition. Conservatives on the other hand support regime-based nationalism, which puts emphasis on being South Korean and stresses the differences in social and political values between the two Koreas."

[stillunloved-11] Myers, Brian Reynolds (December 28, 2016). "Still the Unloved Republic". Sthele Press. Retrieved June 26, 2019. ... Someone who is asked by a pollster whether he is prouder of the Taehan minguk or of the minjok therefore knows which answer is better, more progressive-sounding. In all likelihood he is not prouder of the republic than of his Koreanness. One should be wary of polls on this issue that were not conducted precisely and clearly.

[12] Daniel Cetrà; Coree Brown Swan (2022). State and Majority Nationalism in Plurinational States. Taylor & Francis. p. 135. ... Hong Kong nationalism, or at least opposition to Chinese state nationalism.

[nazi-13] Chang, Che (1 December 2020). "The Nazi Inspiring China's Communists". The Atlantic.

[Taiwan-14] Glenn Drover; Graham Johnson; Julia Lai Po-Wah Tao (2001). Regionalism and Subregionalism in East Asia: The Dynamics of China. Nova Science. p. 101. ISBN 978-1-56072-872-6. In response to the rise of 'liberal ethno-nationalism' and the DPP, it has increasingly promoted the discourse and practices of a 'Taiwanized' KMT.

[Max_Ko-wu_Huang-15] Ko-wu Huang, Max (15 March 2008). The Meaning of Freedom: Yan Fu and Origins of Chinese Liberalism. Chinese University of Hong Kong Press. p. 97. doi:10.2307/j.ctv1x0kc5b. ISBN 978-962-996-278-4. JSTOR j.ctv1x0kc5b. S2CID 261749245. ... racial nationalism (minzu zhuyi 民族みんぞく主義しゅぎ) was characteristic of any race, but he asked: "Will racial nationalism strengthen our race? In my opinion, it definitely will not."...

[16] B. R. Myers (2010). The Cleanest Race.

[Robert_E._Kelly-17] Kelly, Robert E. (24 May 2010). "More on Asian Multiculturalism: 5 Masters Theses to be Written". Retrieved 10 February 2024. Northeast Asians (NEA – Chinese, Koreans, Japanese) strike me as quite nationalistic, and nationalism up here is still tied up in right-Hegelian, 19th century notions of blood and soil.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]

[17]