「Uncyclopedia:VFH/Youth」の版 間 の差分
ナビゲーションに移動
検索 に移動
2008
imported>DrStrange |
Under user (トーク | |
||
3 |
3 |
||
|nom={{User:The Woodburninator/sig}} 22:34, 18 December 2008 (UTC) |
|nom={{User:The Woodburninator/sig}} 22:34, 18 December 2008 (UTC) |
||
|scoretext= times by 1,000,000 = number of images in this article |
|scoretext= times by 1,000,000 = number of images in this article |
||
− | |fornumber= |
+ | |fornumber=6 |
|for= |
|for= |
||
#'''For''' Good one from {{U|DrStrange}}. Some people may have a problem with how the page looks and the amount of pictures, but I like the set up, and it made me laugh. Gets my vote. {{User:The Woodburninator/sig}} 22:34, 18 December 2008 (UTC) |
#'''For''' Good one from {{U|DrStrange}}. Some people may have a problem with how the page looks and the amount of pictures, but I like the set up, and it made me laugh. Gets my vote. {{User:The Woodburninator/sig}} 22:34, 18 December 2008 (UTC) |
||
10 |
10 |
||
#'''For'''. Like {{U|Nachlader}} I'm a fan of encyclopaedic style articles. I was really not sure how to vote on this one when it was first nominated. Now that {{U|DrStrange}} has made this look a bit more like a article which parodies Wikipedia it's a dam fine Uncyc article. {{User:MrN9000/sig}} <small><small>15:54, Dec 20</small></small> |
#'''For'''. Like {{U|Nachlader}} I'm a fan of encyclopaedic style articles. I was really not sure how to vote on this one when it was first nominated. Now that {{U|DrStrange}} has made this look a bit more like a article which parodies Wikipedia it's a dam fine Uncyc article. {{User:MrN9000/sig}} <small><small>15:54, Dec 20</small></small> |
||
#'''For'''. Situation has changed so I'm the only whore in Uncyclopedia. --[[User:Nachlader|Nachlader]] 16:29, 20 December 2008 (UTC) |
#'''For'''. Situation has changed so I'm the only whore in Uncyclopedia. --[[User:Nachlader|Nachlader]] 16:29, 20 December 2008 (UTC) |
||
+ | #'''For'''. Ah, that's better, I can see the good article that was hiding in there. Good work Doc! --{{User:Under_user/sig3}} <small><font color="navy"><i>20:36, Dec 20</i></font></small> |
||
|againstnumber=2 |
|againstnumber=2 |
||
|against=#<s>'''Against'''. It's too much of an image whore for VFH, in my opinion. Images are always awesome, giving a sight for sore eyes and relinquishes the overwhelming job of having to read a wall of text, maybe three or four for the average article, but you don't need '''twenty-eight''' of the darn things. Moreover, a multitude of images can easily encourage readers to just ignore the text and flip through the pictures instead. I know there are some committed readers who will willingly perform the heavenly delight that is, well, reading, but not all visitors to the site will; my first instinct upon seeing this article, despite my love for literature, was to just look at the pile of images instead. That, and the images lack captions and disrupt the text formation. --[[User:Nachlader|Nachlader]] 22:02, 19 December 2008 (UTC)</s> |
|against=#<s>'''Against'''. It's too much of an image whore for VFH, in my opinion. Images are always awesome, giving a sight for sore eyes and relinquishes the overwhelming job of having to read a wall of text, maybe three or four for the average article, but you don't need '''twenty-eight''' of the darn things. Moreover, a multitude of images can easily encourage readers to just ignore the text and flip through the pictures instead. I know there are some committed readers who will willingly perform the heavenly delight that is, well, reading, but not all visitors to the site will; my first instinct upon seeing this article, despite my love for literature, was to just look at the pile of images instead. That, and the images lack captions and disrupt the text formation. --[[User:Nachlader|Nachlader]] 22:02, 19 December 2008 (UTC)</s> |
||
24 |
25 |
||
**'''I Like''' the cut of your jib, young man......Smithers! Fetch me my laptop, we have editing to do!--[[User:DrStrange|DrStrange]][[image:Retro-groovy.gif|20px]] 14:39, 20 December 2008 (UTC) |
**'''I Like''' the cut of your jib, young man......Smithers! Fetch me my laptop, we have editing to do!--[[User:DrStrange|DrStrange]][[image:Retro-groovy.gif|20px]] 14:39, 20 December 2008 (UTC) |
||
**'''Done'''....gutted...slashed...--[[User:DrStrange|DrStrange]][[image:Retro-groovy.gif|20px]] 15:40, 20 December 2008 (UTC) |
**'''Done'''....gutted...slashed...--[[User:DrStrange|DrStrange]][[image:Retro-groovy.gif|20px]] 15:40, 20 December 2008 (UTC) |
||
+ | ***Vote changed accordingly. We should do this again sometime. --{{User:Under_user/sig3}} <small><font color="navy"><i>20:36, Dec 20</i></font></small> |
||
*'''Comment''', although only to explain my against vote. Anyway, there is ''quite'' the difference between comic books and a Wiki article: the latter usually consisting of a continuous word output that results in a tower of prose, but with comics, unless it's printed by Vertigo, comic books usually lack a wall of text making up the most of even a single page. In fact the only way a Wiki page and a comic book could look alike (aside from uploading an image of an actual comic) is via using only images with a caption denoting any dialogue or Brian Blessed-esque narration that is easily readable, boasting only two or three sentences max most of the time, an effect clearly not attained in this article, so reading [[Youth]] is nothing like reading any comic book I've read. |
*'''Comment''', although only to explain my against vote. Anyway, there is ''quite'' the difference between comic books and a Wiki article: the latter usually consisting of a continuous word output that results in a tower of prose, but with comics, unless it's printed by Vertigo, comic books usually lack a wall of text making up the most of even a single page. In fact the only way a Wiki page and a comic book could look alike (aside from uploading an image of an actual comic) is via using only images with a caption denoting any dialogue or Brian Blessed-esque narration that is easily readable, boasting only two or three sentences max most of the time, an effect clearly not attained in this article, so reading [[Youth]] is nothing like reading any comic book I've read. |
||
2008年 12月20日 (土) 20:36時点 における版
Youth (history, logs)
Article: Youth |
Score: 4 times by 1,000,000 = number of images in this article |
Nominated by: | The Woodburninator (woodtalk) (woodstalk) 22:34, 18 December 2008 (UTC) |
For: 6 |
|
Against: 2 |
|
Comments |
|
VFH