「User:Pentium5dot1/Essays/Advice on Wikipedia and NoWikipedia templates」の版 間 の差分
< User:Pentium5dot1 | Essays
ナビゲーションにPentium5dot1 (トーク | (→When {{NoWikipedia}} is likely inappropriate: the first "never" is a bit redundant and/or inaccurate) |
Pentium5dot1 (トーク | (→What about {{tl|Wikipediapar}} and {{tl|NoWikipediapar}}?: conciseness (also to test a user script)) |
||
22 |
22 |
||
== What about {{tl|Wikipediapar}} and {{tl|NoWikipediapar}}? == |
== What about {{tl|Wikipediapar}} and {{tl|NoWikipediapar}}? == |
||
− | * |
+ | *Avoid using {{tl|Wikipediapar}} solely to bypass a Wikipedia redirect. |
*{{tl|NoWikipediapar}} is almost never useful, except in cases of in-jokes or [[wikipedia:WP:NCTR|titles with technical restrictions]]. |
*{{tl|NoWikipediapar}} is almost never useful, except in cases of in-jokes or [[wikipedia:WP:NCTR|titles with technical restrictions]]. |
||
2013年 10月 15日 (火) 17:25時点 における最新 版
This is a work in progress
Obvious rules[編集 | ソースを編集 ]
- Do not use {{Wikipedia}} if the corresponding Wikipedia article does not exist, except in cases of in-jokes.
- Likewise, do not use {{NoWikipedia}} if the corresponding Wikipedia article does exist, unless it is on an unrelated subject with the same title, in which case you should explain the situation on the talk page.
When {{Wikipedia}} is likely appropriate[編集 | ソースを編集 ]
- The Wikipedia article is a featured article.
When {{Wikipedia}} is likely inappropriate[編集 | ソースを編集 ]
- The topic is a very common one (e.g Dog or Cat), and an average reader would probably already know most of the information in the Wikipedia article.
- The template would disrupt the visual flow of the page.
- The Wikipedia article is a frequent target of vandalism and is not yet protected. (Remember, not all Uncyclopedia readers are sufficiently competent to be well-behaved Wikipedia editors.)
When {{NoWikipedia}} is likely appropriate[編集 | ソースを編集 ]
When {{NoWikipedia}} is likely inappropriate[編集 | ソースを編集 ]
- The absence of a Wikipedia article is nothing special, for example when:
- The Uncyclopedia article has a fictitious title that is unlikely to correspond to any real subject.
- The Uncyclopedia article is about an Internet meme which is not mentioned anywhere on Wikipedia and will never be sufficiently notable.
What about {{Wikipediapar}} and {{NoWikipediapar}}?[編集 | ソースを編集 ]
- Avoid using {{Wikipediapar}} solely to bypass a Wikipedia redirect.
- {{NoWikipediapar}} is almost never useful, except in cases of in-jokes or titles with technical restrictions.
General advice[編集 | ソースを編集 ]
- {{Wikipedia}} and {{NoWikipedia}} should be used only when the presence or absence of a Wikipedia article is relevant to the context for understanding the satire.
- Do not edit-war over these templates.
- If the above guidelines leave significant doubt as to whether a template should be added, you probably should not add it.
- If the above guidelines leave significant doubt as to whether a template should be removed, you probably should not remove it.