(Translated by https://www.hiragana.jp/)
Curbing Holiday Weight Gain With Exercise - Readers' Comments - NYTimes.com
The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20111102161420/http://community.nytimes.com/comments/well.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/11/02/curbing-holiday-weight-gain-with-exercise/

Health

readers' Comments

Curbing Holiday Weight Gain With Exercise

Holiday feasting represents a dire threat to most people's waistlines, but exercise can lessen or reverse the unwelcome consequences, new studies suggest.

Share your thoughts.

Back to Blog Post »

1.
New England
November 2nd, 2011
8:54 am
You are missing the elephant in the room: highly processed manufactured food-like products. Measure the intake of those against whole foods (unprocessed/minimally processed).
2.
Alexis Maciel
Potsdam, NY
November 2nd, 2011
8:55 am
Nice article. Very informative, as this blog usual is. But why a picture of runners running in the dark, presumably before heading out to work? Why not a run in a sunny park on the weekend? The unfortunate effect of this picture may be to perpetuate in the minds of some people the idea that exercise is an unpleasant chore. But exercise can be and should be fun! It's just a matter of finding something we enjoy.
3.
norman silverman md
detroit
November 2nd, 2011
8:55 am
as a public health issue, this misses the point. a fringe of endurance walkers/runners can exercise away dietary indiscretion. how do we motivate the rest of the public to start a modest exercise program AND modify their eating habits? bringing coals to newcastle seems a waste of research time, effort and funding, sorry
4.
Larry Eisenberg
New York City
November 2nd, 2011
8:55 am
My int'rest doesn't lie in running,
At my age I focus on sunning,
As to high cal meals,
The scale soon reveals
The weight gain that follows is stunning.
5.
Alex Lickerman, M.D.
Chicago
November 2nd, 2011
8:56 am
No great surprise here that exercise retards weight gain. Though all year round I encourage my patients to exercise, my mantra becomes somewhat different as the holiday season approaches at the end of the year: weight changes aren't correlated to daily caloric intake but rather to caloric intake over time, which means if you overconsume on just one or two days, that by itself won't result in weight gain. Telling yourself you've blown your diet and THEN continuing to overconsume from that point on, however, will (an all-to-common occurrence). Thus the message is that if you fall off the diet wagon during the holidays, don't berate yourself but quickly get back on and you'll likely experience little to no impact (especially if you are exercising).

http://www.happinessinthisworld.com/2009/03/29/the-truth-about-how-to-lo...
6.
The Healthy Librarian
U.S.A.
November 2nd, 2011
8:56 am
I've been exercising--and not the wimpy stuff--since my 20s.

Same for my husband--but he's a lifelong runner--marathons, ultras, that sort of thing.

We're now almost 62--and although we ate a "heart healthy" diet all those years our weight justf slowly increased--though always in the normal BMI range--overweight.

Not anymore!

16 months ago we eliminated added oil, dairy & meat from out diet--and concentrated on lots of vegetables, fruit, beans, legumes, and whole grains.

We switched to a nutritional-dense diet and eat as much as we want--without thinking twice. And the extra squishy weight just fell off.

We both now weigh what we did in our twenties, with the more important bonus of excellent lipids, low blood pressure, & no hypertension. No more meds.

Good health is more than weighing less.

http://www.happyhealthylonglife.com/happy_healthy_long_life/2011/08/15-m...
7.
Pamela
NYC
November 2nd, 2011
8:56 am
Well, duh. More calories in, more calories burned, negate each other.
8.
Mrs Fox
Sydney
November 2nd, 2011
8:56 am
That's good in theory...but I'm full of excuses for not exercising. I've started to list them here as a bit of an exercise confessional...162 and counting... Confession Time: Reasons I didn’t exercise this week - http://bit.ly/oColeE
9.
SamBill
Richmond, CA
November 2nd, 2011
8:56 am
I'm a big fan of exercise but yet believe that one must control the mouth.
http://www.lifestyle-after50.com/nutrition.html
10.
Sara
Texas
November 2nd, 2011
11:43 am
Having someone to exercise with can definitely improve your chances of actually doing it. I know my husband and I always try to run together after dinner and I am much more likely to get it done if I know he's counting on me to come with. Plus, exercising together is always a great way to spend some quality time together, especially around the busy holidays.
www.losingtogether.com
11.
Northern California
November 2nd, 2011
11:44 am
This is a valuable reminder to craft a preemptive strategy to prevent the holiday weight gain before the parties and treats start hitting. Get exercising now and you'll have a reliable routine in place to carry you through it all. Start being mindful of what goes in your mouth now, practice restraint now, decide on limits now and you'll be more likely to stick to them when faced with temptation.

Obviously calories in vs. calories out is always important to weight management as mentioned by several comments already. But, the belly fat/bmi endocrine/metabolic piece plays out here big time at the holidays too with all the rich fatty, refined, sugary foods.

In the past I've taken the reactive, 'OMG how did this happen' approach to mopping up the post holiday damage http://www.drbaileyskincare.com/blog/post-holiday-bmi-shocker-gets-me-se...

This year I've already upped my cardio and started having green smoothies for lunch, and I've already dropped some weight in the past 3 weeks. I also cut out sugar and gluten and plan to try to keep that up through the holidays (with occasional exceptions for the really special treats). It will be interesting to see if I can stave off the January regrets. Your post reiterates to me that I want to be deliberate about it.

I think posting on this topic now is brilliant, thanks!
12.
denver
November 2nd, 2011
11:44 am
It's hard to rev up an exercise program in the deep of winter: cold, ice on gound, short sunlight hours. best if you can keep going year-round.
13.
Ozark Homesteader
Arkansas
November 2nd, 2011
11:44 am
I like food. I like running. I like the results of this study.

November 2, 2011
Home Cooking With Jean-Georges

A celebrated chef takes time off and rediscovers the joy of cooking at home.

November 1, 2011
A Thanksgiving Feast, No Turkeys Allowed

A turkey-free Thanksgiving might sound like heresy to traditionalists, but focusing on the bounty of the fall harvest, rather than the bird, can alter your eating habits and inspire your cooking year round.

More From Eat Well »

November 2, 2011
Curbing Holiday Weight Gain With Exercise

Holiday feasting represents a dire threat to most people’s waistlines, but exercise can lessen or reverse the unwelcome consequences, new studies suggest.

October 24, 2011
Midlife Weight Loss Cuts Heart Risk

Being overweight as a teenager carries a greater risk of being an overweight adult, along with an increased risk of dying from heart disease. But overweight adolescents who slim down in middle age may lower their risk, a new study shows.

More From Weigh In »

November 1, 2011
A Few Drinks a Week Raises Breast Cancer Risk

A new study shows that women who routinely have even small amounts of alcohol, as few as three drinks a week, have an elevated risk of breast cancer, but the risk was modest and must be weighed against heart benefits.

October 31, 2011
Steve Jobs’s Cancer Choices

When doctors discovered a tumor on Steve Jobs’s pancreas, he chose nine months of alternative therapies before undergoing surgery. Did he make the right decision?

More From Cancer »

October 31, 2011
Do ‘Nice’ Doctors Make Better Doctors?

Breeding nice doctors is becoming something of a trend, but could selecting future doctors based on their interpersonal skills backfire?

October 27, 2011
Think Like a Doctor: The Right Test Solved!

On Wednesday, we challenged Well readers to really think like a doctor. We asked you to figure out the diagnosis for a complicated patient and to design the testing strategy necessary to reach that diagnosis; to do, in short, what every doctor has to do in order to make a diagnosis.

More From Doctors and Patients »

October 27, 2011
Can Romance Be Reduced to Pronouns?

Can your romantic life be reduced to the pronouns you say (or tweet or post or text)? Sort of.

September 16, 2011
Love, Divorce and Alzheimer’s

Television evangelist Pat Robertson has sparked controversy with his suggestion that a man could divorce his wife with Alzheimer’s once she no longer recognized him.

More From Love Well »

October 26, 2011
A New Breed of Knee Injury in Young Athletes

Increasingly large numbers of children, both boys and girls, are now suffering A.C.L. and knee meniscus tears, injuries that were uncommon 20 years ago, and doctors aren’t sure why.

October 19, 2011
Do We Have a Set Point for Exercise?

The question of whether humans have an innate set point for movement, a so-called activitystat, is of increasing interest and controversy among scientists.

More From Phys Ed »

October 24, 2011
Yoga and Stretching Equally Effective for Back Pain

Weekly yoga classes relieve symptoms of low back pain about as well as intense, regular stretching sessions, a new study shows.

October 19, 2011
The Doctor’s Remedy: Turmeric for Joint Pain

Patients aren’t the only ones interested in alternative and complementary medicine. In a new occasional series, Well talks to doctors around the country to find out what nontraditional medicines or therapies they sometimes recommend or use themselves.

More From Alternative Medicine »

October 23, 2011
Studying Successful People With Mental Illness

Researchers are studying high-functioning people with schizophrenia to learn how mental health disorders can be managed while people build full, successful lives.

September 26, 2011
Coffee Drinking Linked to Less Depression in Women

Women who regularly drink caffeinated coffee have a 20 percent lower risk of depression than nondrinkers.

More From On Your Mind »

October 18, 2011
Friends Still Let Friends Drive Drunk

There are more than 110 million instances of impaired driving each year in the United States, and 11,000 deaths, despite 30 years of drunk driving advocacy.

October 11, 2011
More Evidence Against Vitamin Use

Two new studies add to the growing body of evidence that high doses of vitamins can do more harm than good.

More From Healthy Consumer »

October 26, 2011
A New Breed of Knee Injury in Young Athletes

Increasingly large numbers of children, both boys and girls, are now suffering A.C.L. and knee meniscus tears, injuries that were uncommon 20 years ago, and doctors aren’t sure why.

October 19, 2011
Do We Have a Set Point for Exercise?

The question of whether humans have an innate set point for movement, a so-called activitystat, is of increasing interest and controversy among scientists.

More From Fitness »

September 28, 2011
Things Every Dog Should Know

What are the essential skills or commands every dog should know? Veteran dog trainers weigh in.

September 21, 2011
The Importance of Pet Tags

Research shows that 80 percent of pet owners believe it’s important that dogs and cats wear personal identification tags, but only one in three pet owners say their pets always wear them.

More From Well Pets »

October 12, 2011
Feeling Ageless Under Water

Vexed by arthritis and other health issues, a 59-year-old woman rebuffs her son’s suggestion to learn how to scuba dive. But several later she discovered that in the water, nothing hurts.

September 15, 2011
The Voices of Sjogren’s Syndrome

Most people probably never heard of Sjogren’s syndrome until Venus Williams announced she suffered from the condition. But an estimated four million Americans have Sjogren’s, making it one of the most prevalent autoimmune disorders.

More From Patient Voices »

June 16, 2011
For Children on Medicaid, the Doctor Is Out

Children with Medicaid are more likely to be turned away by medical specialists compared to those with private insurance, a new study finds.

April 15, 2011
Hypnosis as a Health Option

Today’s Patient Money column looks into the costs and potential benefits of hypnosis for dealing with anxiety, pain management and other health issues.

More From Patient Money »

February 4, 2011
An Author Escapes From Chronic Fatigue Syndrome

Author Laura Hillenbrand transports readers to another time and place with her best-selling books. Her accomplishments are all the more remarkable given that she is largely homebound, debilitated by chronic fatigue syndrome.

January 7, 2011
Nutrition Advice From the China Study

More than 500,000 copies of “The China Study” have been sold, and even former President Bill Clinton is talking about it.

More From Books »

February 4, 2011
An Author Escapes From Chronic Fatigue Syndrome

Author Laura Hillenbrand transports readers to another time and place with her best-selling books. Her accomplishments are all the more remarkable given that she is largely homebound, debilitated by chronic fatigue syndrome.

January 7, 2011
Nutrition Advice From the China Study

More than 500,000 copies of “The China Study” have been sold, and even former President Bill Clinton is talking about it.

More From Books »

About Well

Tara Parker-Pope on HealthHealthy living doesn’t happen at the doctor’s office. The road to better health is paved with the small decisions we make every day. It’s about the choices we make when we buy groceries, drive our cars and hang out with our kids. Join columnist Tara Parker-Pope as she sifts through medical research and expert opinions for practical advice to help readers take control of their health and live well every day.

Special Section
well
Decoding Your Health

A special issue of Science Times looks at the explosion of information about health and medicine and offers some guidelines on how to sort it all out

Special Section
well
Small Steps: A Good Health Guide

Trying to raise a healthy child can feel overwhelming, but it doesn’t have to be.

Special Section
well
A Guided Tour of Your Body

Changes in our health are inevitable as we get older. What do we need to know about staying well as we age?

Archive